For employers

Skills-based hiring without a degree requirement: is it legal to drop the degree, and how does an employer test skills instead?

A private employer in the United States may require a degree, and it may drop one. Under Title VII the requirement becomes a legal risk when it screens out a protected group and the employer cannot show that it is job related and consistent with business necessity. In Griggs v. Duke Power Co. in 1971 the Supreme Court struck down a high school diploma requirement on that ground. Since 2020 federal agencies may not assess candidates by education alone.

Hands assemble a small mechanical sample while a closed diploma lies unused to the side

What is skills-based hiring?

Selecting candidates by the skills the job needs, checked by a test, a work exercise or a structured interview, instead of by a degree used as a stand-in for those skills.

No federal statute defines skills-based hiring for private employers. The closest legal text is Executive Order 13932 of June 26, 2020, which governs the federal competitive service. Section 2(b) states that position descriptions and job postings for positions within the competitive service "should be based on the specific skills and competencies required to perform those jobs."

In private hiring the term describes the same move. The employer lists what the job requires, for example writing a SQL query, reading a balance sheet or planning a project budget, and checks those skills directly. The degree stops being the filter at the first step, and the candidate who has the skills without the diploma reaches the test.

The change does not make the hiring process free of rules. The test that replaces the degree is itself a selection procedure, and the same anti-discrimination law covers it.

What did the Supreme Court decide about diplomas in Griggs v. Duke Power?

On March 8, 1971 the Court held that Duke Power could not require a high school diploma or a general intelligence test without showing that either bore a demonstrable relationship to successful job performance.

Duke Power adopted a high school education requirement in 1955 for initial assignment to any department except Labor. On July 2, 1965 it added aptitude tests for new hires. A footnote in the opinion gives the 1960 census figures for North Carolina: 34% of white males had completed high school, and only 12% of Negro males had done so.

Chief Justice Burger wrote the opinion. "The touchstone is business necessity." The Court found that neither the high school completion requirement nor the general intelligence test was shown to bear a demonstrable relationship to successful performance of the jobs. It noted that "employees who have not completed high school or taken the tests have continued to perform satisfactorily."

The Court did not forbid diplomas or tests. It wrote: "Diplomas and tests are useful servants." It also wrote: "History is filled with examples of men and women who rendered highly effective performance without the conventional badges of accomplishment." Section 2000e-2(k) of Title VII now states the disparate impact test in the words quoted in the previous section.

The tests themselves came under the same rule, which the IAE article on whether pre-employment testing is legal sets out in detail.

Is a degree requirement a selection procedure under the Uniform Guidelines?

Yes. The Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (1978) define selection procedures to include educational and work experience requirements, so a degree screen is analyzed for adverse impact like a test.

The definition reads: "Selection procedure. Any measure, combination of measures, or procedure used as a basis for any employment decision. Selection procedures include the full range of assessment techniques from traditional paper and pencil tests, performance tests, training programs, or probationary periods and physical, educational, and work experience requirements through informal or casual interviews and unscored application forms." The text quoted here is the copy of the Guidelines that the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs publishes at 41 CFR 60-3.16.

Two consequences follow. An employer that keeps a degree requirement compares the selection rates of groups at that step, using the method described in the IAE article on the four-fifths rule. If the requirement has adverse impact, the employer needs evidence that it is job related, which the Guidelines call validation and which the IAE article on test validation describes.

In Griggs the record had no evidence that linked the diploma to the work. A test built on the duties of the job can carry that link, because a content validity study ties each task of the test to a duty of the job.

What did Executive Order 13932 change in federal hiring?

For the federal competitive service it allowed a minimum educational requirement only when one is legally required for the duties, and it told agencies to assess candidates without relying solely on educational attainment or on self-evaluations.

The order, published at 85 FR 39457, states in section 2(a)(i): "An agency may prescribe a minimum educational requirement for employment in the Federal competitive service only when a minimum educational qualification is legally required to perform the duties of the position in the State or locality where those duties are to be performed." Outside that case, section 2(a)(ii) lets education count toward a qualification only where it matches the competencies the qualification requires.

Section 3(a) requires agencies to assess candidates "in a manner that does not rely solely on educational attainment." Section 3(b) adds that "agencies shall not rely solely on candidates' self-evaluations of their stated abilities." The order set 120 days for publishing the revised standards and 180 days for the new assessment practices.

The order binds federal agencies only. A private company is not covered. Its two limits carry over to private hiring as working rules: education is not the only measure, and a candidate's own rating of his skills does not replace a test.

What does the Chance to Compete Act require?

Approved on December 23, 2024, it amended 5 U.S.C. 3304 for federal hiring: a technical assessment is a position-specific tool that does not principally rely on self-assessment, and subject matter experts may develop and administer it.

Public Law 118-188 defines a technical assessment in 5 U.S.C. 3304(a)(9) as "a position-specific tool that is relevant to the position for which the tool is developed." The tool "does not solely include or principally rely upon a self-assessment from an automated examination." Among the forms an assessment may include, the Act lists "a structured interview" and "a work-related exercise."

The Act lets a person "determined by an examining agency to be a subject matter expert in the subject and job field" take part in developing and administering assessments. The Act thus brings people who know the work into building and giving the test.

The Act applies to federal hiring. For a private employer the definition reads as a checklist: the assessment is tied to one position, built by people who do that work and scored on what the candidate does, not on what the candidate says about himself.

Which assessments can replace a degree screen?

Tests of the job's own tasks: written exams on cases from the field, work samples, structured interviews with the same questions and scoring for everyone. Self-rating questionnaires alone do not measure skills.

The Uniform Guidelines list the range of procedures they cover, among them paper and pencil tests, performance tests, training programs, probationary periods and interviews. The Chance to Compete Act names structured interviews and work-related exercises. Each of these can replace the degree as the first filter, if it is built on the duties of the job.

A structured interview asks every candidate the same questions and scores the answers on a fixed scale. A work sample gives the candidate a task from the job, such as a report, a calculation or a piece of code. A written exam combines short questions with cases that carry the figures of a real task.

Remote testing adds a check of who is answering. The IAE article on fake candidates in remote hiring describes how employers check identity before a test.

Every result is kept. The IAE article on record retention sets out how long the law requires employers to keep test records and which records count.

How does an employer drop a degree requirement from a job posting?

It starts with a job analysis, lists the skills and knowledge the duties require, replaces the degree with a skills requirement or an equivalent-experience clause and names the assessment that checks those skills.

A job analysis lists the duties, how often each is performed and what knowledge each requires. The posting is written from that list. Section 2(b) of Executive Order 13932 sets the same basis for federal job postings: the specific skills and competencies required to perform the job.

Where the employer wants to keep education as one route, the posting can name the degree or a number of years of experience in the same work, or a passed skills exam. The candidate then has more than one way to meet the requirement, and the test decides between candidates on the same scale.

The posting says which assessment follows the application and what it covers, for example a two-hour written exam with cases from the field. Candidates then know before they apply which skills will be checked and how.

Does dropping the degree requirement remove the legal risk?

No. The skills test that replaces the degree is a selection procedure too. It is checked for adverse impact, and if it screens out a group, the employer must show that it is job related.

Section 2000e-2(k) speaks of "a particular employment practice," and the Uniform Guidelines cover "any measure, combination of measures, or procedure used as a basis for any employment decision." A written exam, a work sample and a scored interview all fall within those words.

What changes is the evidence the employer holds. A test built on the duties of the job can be linked to them task by task. The records of who took it, who passed and on what scores give the employer the numbers for an adverse impact check. A degree requirement offers neither the task link nor the scores.

The employer also keeps the decision. The test result is one input; the interview and the hiring decision remain with the company.

How does the IAE written exam work as a skills check before the interview?

The candidate takes an online written exam of up to 2 hours in the job's field: 8 tasks, each with its own timer. An examiner with no ties to the company approves the result within 5 business days.

On the employer page the company registers and receives a link to its cabinet by email within one business day. In the cabinet it adds a person with a name, email and exam field, and the person receives a link to the questionnaire. The candidate chooses the exam day within 14 days. Before the exam the candidate uploads a photo of an ID document and takes a snapshot, and the IAE Secretariat checks them manually.

The exam runs in one sitting of up to 2 hours: 5 questions of 10 minutes, 2 cases of 25 minutes and a 10-minute question about the candidate's own project. Pasting is disabled, the system logs how each answer was typed and how many times the candidate left the tab, and each candidate gets different figures in the cases. If the log shows a doubtful answer, the candidate receives one more written question with 5 minutes to answer. The tasks are standard IAE tasks from the program of the field, the same for everyone, and the candidate does no work for the company.

Answers are scored against the field rubric, and an examiner with no ties to the candidate or the company approves the result within 5 business days. The company sees the status, the total score out of 100, the score on each rubric criterion (correctness, reasoning, risks, clarity) in each task and the certificate PDF if the exam is passed. It does not see the questionnaire, the CV, education and experience, the answers or the reason for refusal.

Registration, invitations, the exam and the results run on the website and by email, with no calls or meetings. The pilot is free for up to 5 people per company that registers by December 31, 2026. The company decides on the interview and on hiring.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Pilot until December 31, 2026

Register your company

Free for up to 5 people. A link to the company cabinet arrives by email within one business day.

Company registration

Received

Cabinet link within one business day

Employees5
FieldSoftware and data
Pilotuntil Dec 31, 2026