Examinations

Sold "as is": can the buyer still claim a defect, and what does the goods expert check?

Under UCC 2-316(3)(a) the words "as is" or "with all faults" exclude the implied warranties in a sale of goods, unless the circumstances indicate otherwise. The clause does not reach express warranties, it fails against a supplier that gave a written warranty, and federal and state rules limit it for used cars and consumer goods. Courts in New Jersey and Florida have refused to let an "as is" clause end the buyer's case.

A buyer's hands turn a small toaster to show a hairline crack

What does "as is" mean in a sale of goods?

That the buyer takes the goods without the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness. UCC 2-316(3)(a) excludes all implied warranties by expressions like "as is" or "with all faults" unless the circumstances indicate otherwise.

Section 2-316 of the Uniform Commercial Code governs the exclusion or modification of warranties in sales of goods. Subsection (3)(a) provides that "unless the circumstances indicate otherwise, all implied warranties are excluded" by expressions like "as is" or "with all faults" or other language that in common understanding calls the buyer's attention to the exclusion and makes plain that there is no implied warranty. Each state enacts the Code in its own statute; Connecticut, for example, carries the same words in section 42a-2-316 of its General Statutes.

The implied warranties at stake are two. Merchantability, under 2-314, is the promise that goods are fit for the ordinary purposes for which such goods are used. Fitness for a particular purpose, under 2-315, is the second. An effective "as is" clause removes both.

The words "unless the circumstances indicate otherwise" matter in litigation. They let a court look past the label to the deal: whether the goods were new or used, what else the contract said, how the parties dealt with each other before, and what the trade understands. The two court decisions discussed below turned on those circumstances.

The clause also does not change what happened to the goods. A defect that existed at delivery still existed; the question is only who bears the risk of it. That is why the goods expert's work in an "as is" dispute starts in the same place as in any warranty dispute: what the defect is, when it arose and whether a reasonable examination would have revealed it.

Which warranties and claims survive an "as is" clause?

Express warranties, warranties from course of dealing or trade usage that the clause does not plainly exclude, and tort claims: a Florida court let a negligence claim go forward. The clause speaks only to implied warranties under 2-316(3).

Subsection 2-316(1) deals with express warranties. Words or conduct creating an express warranty and words or conduct tending to negate it "shall be construed wherever reasonable as consistent with each other." A seller who tells the buyer that a machine was rebuilt last month, and then writes "as is" on the invoice, has made an express statement that the general clause does not erase.

Subsection 2-316(2) sets the rule for excluding merchantability without the "as is" route: "the language must mention merchantability and in case of a writing must be conspicuous," and to exclude fitness "the exclusion must be by a writing and conspicuous." Subsection (3)(c) adds that an implied warranty can also be excluded or modified "by course of dealing or course of performance or usage of trade." The same sources can create obligations the clause fails to reach.

Tort claims run on a separate track. In Knipp v. Weinbaum, decided by Florida's Third District Court of Appeal on November 1, 1977, the court held that summary judgment on the buyer's negligence claim was improper even though the bill of sale said "as is." It wrote that the absence of warranties does not necessarily bar a negligence claim and that the "as is" term bears on the questions of duty and reasonable care. The court also held that the buyer should have been allowed to add a strict liability count.

For the expert, each surviving claim asks a different question about the goods. An express warranty claim asks whether the goods matched the statement. A course of dealing claim asks what the seller used to fix. A negligence or strict liability claim asks what caused the failure and whether the cause was a defect.

When does an "as is" clause fail to exclude the implied warranty?

When the circumstances point the other way. In Gindy v. Cardinale Trucking (N.J. 1970) an inconspicuous "as is" clause in a sale of 25 new trailers did not exclude merchantability, and the buyer's defect counterclaim went forward.

Gindy Manufacturing Corp. sold twenty-five new 1967 semi-trailers to Cardinale Trucking Corp. under a one-page installment contract of about $141,756, finance charges included. After the buyer missed payments between May and August 1968, the seller repossessed and resold the trailers and sued for a deficiency of $13,052.37. The buyer counterclaimed that faulty radius rods caused premature tire wear and loss of use. Paragraph H of the contract said that the vehicles were sold "as is" and that no warranties arose beyond the writing.

In a decision of July 27, 1970, Judge Botter of the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law Division, denied the seller's motion for summary judgment. On the merchantability disclaimer under 2-316(2) he wrote: "The word 'merchantability' is not used and the exclusion is not conspicuous." The heading WARRANTIES over the paragraph suggested to a reader that warranties were being given rather than taken away.

On the "as is" route under 2-316(3)(a), the court read the words "unless the circumstances indicate otherwise" against the seller. The contract also said "Buyer accepts delivery in good condition," the form was used for both new and used vehicles, and given the usage of the trade and the parties' dealings the clause was not sufficient to make plain that no implied warranty was intended. The court held that "the 'as is' clause in this contract is not effective to disclaim an implied warranty of merchantability," and observed that a buyer of new vehicles could readily say that "as is" means new and in good mechanical condition. The clause also did not exclude warranties arising from the parties' prior dealings: the buyer said the seller had always paid for manufacturing defects and had agreed to replace the radius rods in this deal.

The court did not decide whether the radius rods made the trailers unmerchantable. That was left for proof, and proof of that kind comes from an engineer who examines the rods, the tire wear pattern and the trailers' use.

Does "as is" end the case for used goods?

Not automatically. In Knipp v. Weinbaum (Fla. App. 1977) a used motorcycle sold "as is" failed at a rear axle weld hours later, and the court held that what the parties understood by the phrase was a fact question.

The buyer in Knipp bought a three-wheeled motorcycle from Allan Weinbaum, who did business as Homestead Cycle Shop. A hobbyist had built the trike at home about two years earlier, and it had passed through three private owners before reaching the shop. The bill of sale carried the notation "CYCLE SOLD AS IS." Hours after the purchase, the buyer was severely injured on a major highway when a weld on the rear axle allegedly failed. He sued for breach of express and implied warranties and for negligence, and the trial court granted summary judgment for the defendants.

The Third District reversed. Judge Nathan wrote that the statute excludes implied warranties "unless the circumstances indicate otherwise," that "a disclaimer, to be effective, must be a part of the basis of the bargain between the parties," and that "a seller may disclaim warranties as long as the buyer reasonably understands this is being done." The depositions conflicted on what the parties understood "as is" to mean, so summary judgment on the implied warranty claim was improper.

The express warranty claim survived too. An employee had made statements about the trike's dependability, and the court held that "these diverse contentions create a jury question as to the facts at issue." The negligence claim survived, and the court allowed the buyer to add a strict liability count.

The facts of Knipp show where an expert enters an "as is" case for used goods. The weld on a home-built axle was the alleged defect. An engineer would examine the weld for lack of fusion, porosity or cracking that existed at sale, against a failure caused by the ride itself, and would answer whether a dealer's ordinary inspection would have found it.

Can a seller sell "as is" and give a written warranty at the same time?

Not for consumer products. Under 15 U.S.C. 2308 a supplier that gives a written warranty, or a service contract within 90 days of sale, may not disclaim implied warranties, and a violating disclaimer is ineffective.

Section 2308 of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act provides in subsection (a) that "No supplier may disclaim or modify" an implied warranty to a consumer if "such supplier makes any written warranty to the consumer" with respect to the product or, at the time of sale or "within 90 days thereafter," enters into a service contract with the consumer that applies to the product.

Subsection (b) permits one narrower step: "implied warranties may be limited in duration to the duration of a written warranty of reasonable duration," but only "if such limitation is conscionable and is set forth in clear and unmistakable language" and "prominently displayed on the face of the warranty." Subsection (c) states the consequence of a violation: the disclaimer, modification or limitation "shall be ineffective for purposes of this chapter and State law."

In practice the conflict appears on the paperwork. A sales slip stamps "as is" while the box contains a 90-day limited warranty card, or the dealer sells an extended service plan with a used appliance. A review of an "as is" defense therefore starts by collecting every document that came with the product, because one warranty card can defeat the clause on the invoice.

What rules apply to used cars sold "as is"?

The FTC Used Car Rule. The dealer displays a Buyers Guide showing "As Is - No Dealer Warranty", implied warranties only or a warranty, the guide is part of the contract, and stricter state law prevails.

The Used Motor Vehicle Trade Regulation Rule is part 455 of title 16 of the Code of Federal Regulations. Under section 455.1(a) it is a deceptive act for a used vehicle dealer to "misrepresent the mechanical condition of a used vehicle" or to "represent that a used vehicle is sold with a warranty when the vehicle is sold without any warranty." A dealer, under section 455.1(d)(3), is a person or business that sells or offers for sale a used vehicle "after selling or offering for sale five (5) or more used vehicles in the previous twelve months."

Before offering a used vehicle, the dealer prepares and displays the Buyers Guide on that vehicle under section 455.2(a). The guide carries the warranty choice, with boxes headed "As Is - No Dealer Warranty" and "Implied Warranties Only." The text the rule prescribes for the guide states: "If your State law limits or prohibits 'as is' sales of vehicles, that State law overrides this part."

Section 455.3(b) ties the guide to the sale. Each consumer contract must state: "The information you see on the window form for this vehicle is part of this contract. Information on the window form overrides any contrary provisions in the contract of sale." If the guide on the window shows a dealer warranty and the contract says "as is," the guide controls.

For an expert examining a used car after an "as is" sale, the Buyers Guide and the dealer's statements become the reference points. The examination asks whether a defect existed at sale, whether it is the kind of mechanical condition the dealer described or concealed, and whether the dealer's own inspection records mention it.

Do some states restrict "as is" sales of consumer goods?

Yes. California requires a conspicuous writing attached to consumer goods before an "as is" sale, in simple language stating three things about the risk; without it the implied warranty is not disclaimed.

Section 1792.4 of the California Civil Code, part of the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, provides that a sale of covered consumer goods on an "as is" or "with all faults" basis does not disclaim the implied warranty of merchantability, or of fitness where it applies, unless a conspicuous writing is attached to the goods before the sale. The writing must use simple and concise language and state that "The goods are being sold on an 'as is' or 'with all faults' basis," that "The entire risk as to the quality and performance of the goods is with the buyer," and that should the goods prove defective after purchase, the buyer and not the manufacturer, distributor or retailer "assumes the entire cost" of all necessary servicing or repair.

For goods sold through a mail order catalog, the statute requires the catalog itself to contain the writing for each item offered, in place of the notice attached to the goods.

The California text shows how far state law can move the starting point. A clause that would pass under 2-316(3)(a) in another state can fail in California because it was printed on the receipt instead of attached to the goods before the sale. Counsel checks the governing state's version of 2-316 and any consumer statute before assuming the clause is effective.

What about defects the buyer could have found by inspecting the goods?

UCC 2-316(3)(b) removes the implied warranty for defects that an examination ought to have revealed, when the buyer examined the goods or refused to examine them before contracting. Latent defects stay outside that rule.

Subsection 2-316(3)(b) provides that when the buyer before entering into the contract has examined the goods, or the sample or model, as fully as he desired or has refused to examine them, "there is no implied warranty with regard to defects which an examination ought in the circumstances to have revealed to him." The Connecticut text uses the same words, including "defects which an examination ought in the circumstances to have revealed to him."

The rule works with "as is" sales of used goods, where buyers often inspect before buying. Its reach depends on two facts the expert can address: what examination the buyer actually made or was offered, and whether the defect was the kind that such an examination would reveal. A dent, a missing part or a visible crack in a casting is in one category. Internal corrosion, a weld defect under paint or an intermittent electrical fault is in the other.

An expert report in such a case describes the defect, where it sits, whether it was visible or detectable without disassembly or test equipment at the time of sale, and what an ordinary buyer's inspection, or a professional buyer's inspection in the trade, would have shown. The report states the limits of the conclusion when the goods changed after the sale.

What does the goods expert examine in an "as is" dispute?

The defect and its cause, whether it existed at delivery, whether it matches what the seller disclosed or stated, whether a pre-sale examination would have revealed it, and the documents that define what the goods were supposed to be.

The first task is the same as in any warranty case: identify the defect, its cause and whether it existed when the goods were delivered. The expert reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks to tell a manufacturing flaw from misuse, and documents the condition of the item before any test that could change it, following ASTM E860-22 for testing that alters evidence.

The second task is specific to "as is" sales: compare the defect with what the seller disclosed or stated. A defect that matches a disclosed condition sits within the risk the buyer accepted. A defect that contradicts an express statement, a Buyers Guide entry or a description in the listing supports a claim the clause does not reach. The expert lists each statement and the finding that confirms or contradicts it.

The third task is the examination question under 2-316(3)(b): whether the defect was patent or latent at the time of sale. The fourth, when damages are claimed, is value: under UCC 2-714(2) the difference between the value of the goods as accepted and their value as warranted, which in an "as is" sale depends on which warranty survived.

The report separates these findings from the legal questions. Whether the clause was conspicuous, whether the circumstances indicated otherwise and whether a state statute applies are for the court. The expert supplies the facts about the goods that those questions turn on.

Which documents decide what the buyer was promised?

Every document that came with the sale: the contract or invoice, the listing or description, warranty cards and service contracts, a Buyers Guide for a used car, and the seller's messages about condition.

An "as is" dispute is often decided by a document that nobody read closely at the time of sale. In Gindy the same contract that said "as is" also said "Buyer accepts delivery in good condition," and the court read the two together. In Knipp the bill of sale said "as is" while an employee had spoken about the trike's dependability. Under 15 U.S.C. 2308 a single written warranty card defeats a disclaimer of implied warranties, and under 16 CFR 455.3(b) the Buyers Guide on the window overrides a contrary provision in the contract.

The expert therefore asks for the full sale file before the examination: the contract and any attachments, the invoice and the receipt, the advertisement, listing or catalog page as it read on the date of sale, warranty cards, service or extended protection contracts, the Buyers Guide for a vehicle, emails and messages about the goods' condition, and any pre-sale inspection report. Each statement about condition becomes a test item, and the report says for each whether the goods matched it.

For goods sold between businesses, the list adds the purchase order, the seller's terms and conditions, prior orders between the same parties and records of how earlier complaints were handled. Those records are the course of dealing that the Gindy court relied on when it held that the "as is" clause did not exclude warranties from the parties' prior practice.

How is the loss measured when goods sold "as is" prove defective?

Under UCC 2-714(2), as the difference between the value of the goods as accepted and their value as warranted. In an "as is" sale the warranted value depends on which warranty survived the clause.

When a warranty survives, the damages rule is the same as in any accepted-goods case. The expert sets the value of the goods as accepted, with the defect, and their value as warranted, at the time and place of acceptance, and the difference is the measure under UCC 2-714(2).

The "as warranted" value is where an "as is" case differs. If the clause failed entirely, as in Gindy, the comparison is with merchantable goods; for new trailers the court said a buyer could readily read "as is" as new and in good mechanical condition. If only an express statement survived, the comparison is with goods that match the statement and nothing more. A used machine described as having a rebuilt engine is valued as a used machine with a rebuilt engine, not as a new one.

The expert's report states which warranty the valuation assumes and gives the value under each alternative when the court has not yet decided the warranty question. That lets counsel use the same report whichever way the clause is resolved.

What does IAE do when goods were sold "as is" and turned out defective?

IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing expert's report. The format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day, and the signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.

On the product defect page the expert's questions are whether the goods were defective when delivered, whether the failure came from manufacturing or from misuse, and what the goods were worth as accepted. The expert tests the item against the merchantability rule of UCC 2-314 and the contract description, reads fracture surfaces, wear and repair marks, and sets values under UCC 2-714(2) at the time and place of acceptance.

The client sends the request and describes the goods and the dispute: what was sold, what the "as is" clause and any other statements said, whether a warranty card, a service contract or a Buyers Guide came with the goods, and what is attached, such as the contract or invoice, the listing or description, photographs, inspection records, notice letters and any report from the other side. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The questions are confirmed with the client before work starts.

The specialist prepares the report, and the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, depending on the volume of materials. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether the clause is effective and which claim to bring are questions for the client's attorney. An expert report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member