Expert report review

Reviewing the opposing solvency analysis in a fraudulent transfer case: what does the reviewer check?

A trustee who sues to avoid a transfer as constructively fraudulent under 11 U.S.C. 548 has to prove the debtor's financial condition on the transfer date. When that proof is an accountant's solvency analysis, the defense answers it with a review: the reviewer rebuilds the expert's balance sheet for each transfer date, line by line, from the record. Federal courts have excluded or discounted such analyses for zero values given to missing data and for hindsight.

Hands compare two financial printouts turned away beside a quiet calculator

What does a review of the opposing solvency analysis check?

Four things: the legal test the expert applied, the date of each transfer, the value assigned to each asset and liability, and whether any input relied on information that did not exist on the transfer date.

Section 548(a)(1)(B) of the Bankruptcy Code lets a trustee avoid a transfer made within 2 years before the petition if the debtor "received less than a reasonably equivalent value" and one of four conditions existed. Three of them are financial. The debtor "was insolvent on the date that such transfer was made" or "became insolvent as a result" of it; the property left with the debtor was "an unreasonably small capital" for its business; or the debtor intended to incur, or believed it would incur, debts "beyond the debtor's ability to pay as such debts matured". The fourth condition covers transfers to insiders under employment contracts outside the ordinary course of business.

An accountant retained by the trustee or a creditor answers the financial questions with numbers. In Weinman v. Crowley (In re Blair), decided by the Bankruptcy Court for the District of Colorado on August 2, 2018, the trustee's expert offered a fair value balance sheet and a separate cash flow analysis. Judge Thomas B. McNamara excluded both under Federal Rule of Evidence 702. The decision goes through the expert's balance sheet line by line.

A review follows the same order. The reviewer lists every challenged transfer and its date, rebuilds the expert's balance sheet for each date from the documents in the record, marks each figure that has no source or a source dated after the transfer, and records each departure from the method the report announces. The findings go into a rebuttal report, deposition questions and, where a defect goes to method or data, a Rule 702 motion.

Which insolvency test does the law prescribe?

A balance sheet test: under 11 U.S.C. 101(32)(A) an entity is insolvent when its debts exceed all its property "at a fair valuation", leaving out property transferred to defraud creditors and exempt property.

The definition in section 101(32)(A) applies to entities other than partnerships and municipalities. It compares "the sum of such entity's debts" with "all of such entity's property, at a fair valuation", excluding property "transferred, concealed, or removed with intent to hinder, delay, or defraud" the entity's creditors and property that may be exempted under section 522. For a partnership, subparagraph (B) adds the excess of each general partner's nonpartnership property over that partner's nonpartnership debts. For a municipality, subparagraph (C) uses a cash test instead: whether it is generally not paying its debts as they become due or is unable to pay them.

State voidable transfer statutes carry their own definitions. In Weinman v. Crowley the court read the Colorado statute, C.R.S. 38-8-103(1), and section 101(32)(A) as both requiring a fair valuation balance sheet test. It also noted that under C.R.S. 38-8-103(2) a presumption of insolvency arises when a debtor is generally not paying its debts.

The reviewer also checks which presumptions the report invokes. Section 547(f) presumes the debtor insolvent "on and during the 90 days immediately preceding the date of the filing of the petition", but the subsection opens with "For the purposes of this section", and section 547 governs preferences. Under section 547(g) the trustee carries the burden of proving the elements of a preference, one of which is a transfer "made while the debtor was insolvent". Section 548 has no presumption of its own, so a constructive fraudulent transfer report has to prove insolvency on the transfer date with figures.

Does the analysis measure solvency on the date of each transfer?

It has to. Section 548 asks about the debtor's condition on the date each transfer was made and as a result of it, so a report built on one year-end balance sheet leaves the other transfer dates unmeasured.

In Weinman v. Crowley the question was whether the debtor, Peter H. Blair, Sr., was insolvent on May 7, 2011, the date of at least one challenged transfer. A complaint that attacks several transfers within the 2-year look-back period puts several dates in issue. The alternative in the statute, that the debtor "became insolvent as a result of such transfer", calls for a second balance sheet on each date, one that books the transfer itself.

The reviewer's first table pairs each transfer date with the balance sheet the expert used for it and with the date of every source document behind that balance sheet. Where the expert rolled a statement forward or back to reach a transfer date, the review lists the adjustments made for the period in between and checks whether the report discloses them.

Preference claims use different windows. Under section 547(b)(4) the transfer must fall within 90 days before the petition, or between 90 days and one year before it if the creditor was an insider. A report written for a combined complaint should separate the preference dates from the fraudulent transfer dates, because only the first group carries the statutory presumption.

Did the expert value the assets at fair value or carry them at book value?

Fair value is the test. In Weinman v. Crowley the court excluded a balance sheet that started from book values, wrote a business interest down to zero for past losses and valued accounts without data at zero.

The trustee's expert, Mark Dennis, described his approach as a going-concern asset approach at fair market value rather than GAAP, and the court accepted that method as appropriate and reliable in general. The exclusion turned on how he applied it. The court had admitted his qualifications "just barely": his background lay mainly in tax and general accounting, with no record of prior solvency opinions or solvency testimony.

Five of the debtor's cash accounts showed "No data available" in the expert's materials, and he valued each at $0. The court's comment took one sentence: "This was rank speculation." For the debtor's interest in Blair Oil Investments, LLC, the expert began with book values and then assumed a value of zero because the company had a history of losses. "So, he altered the methodology," the court wrote. For an interest in BPI Partners he used the debtor's own 2015 valuation of $156,164, prepared about four years after the valuation date.

The reviewer applies the same questions to every line of the opposing balance sheet. Each asset needs a value as of the transfer date, a source for that value and a method that matches the one the report announces. A zero needs a reason other than missing data. A figure taken from a later appraisal needs an account of what was known on the transfer date. The court in Weinman v. Crowley put its conclusion in one line: "Bottom line: the entire Expert Report and proffered balance sheet for the Debtor are unreliable."

How should contingent and disputed liabilities be counted?

At their expected value on the transfer date. In Harden v. Stephenson the court described it as the expected cost of the liability times the estimated chance of it ever occurring; neither face value nor zero meets that standard.

The Code's definition of "claim" in section 101(5) covers a right to payment whether it is "contingent", "unliquidated" or "disputed". A lawsuit pending against the debtor on the transfer date belongs on the liability side of the balance sheet, but its amount has to be estimated as of that date.

In Harden v. Stephenson (In re Stephenson), decided by the Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina on October 1, 2012, the debtors' schedules listed assets of $148,896.12 and liabilities of $704,229.31, of which $635,685.06 was a jury award. Without the award, liabilities came to $68,544.25. The court held that the award "should not be used at face value in calculating the debtors' solvency" and described the measure as "the expected cost of the liability times the estimated chance of it ever occurring". A zero value, it wrote, is "the equivalent of saying that there was no chance whatsoever any liability will be incurred". The debtors had viewed an adverse judgment as remote when they made the transfer; "in hindsight", the court said, that view "was badly mistaken". It denied the trustee summary judgment: whether the debtors were insolvent depended on the value of that liability, and that value "turns on disputed facts".

In Weinman v. Crowley the expert made the opposite error. He entered $2,298,346, the principal of a judgment entered on March 27, 2015, as a liability on May 7, 2011, although the lawsuit was filed only in 2012. He conceded that the liability was contingent in 2011 and that he did not have sufficient information to estimate it, and he did not discount it. The court wrote that contingent liabilities "must be discounted by the probability of the contingency's becoming non-contingent" and called the figure "an improper hindsight assumption". The expert testified that he had asked the trustee's counsel whether to make the assumption and counsel "confirmed yes"; the court wrote that counsel "just decided it would be a helpful assumption for their case".

The reviewer lists every lawsuit, guarantee and disputed claim open on each transfer date, with what the parties knew about it then: pleadings, settlement offers, insurance coverage and any assessments produced in discovery. The report under review should give a probability and an amount for each item, or explain why it left the item out.

Did the expert rely on facts that were not known on the transfer date?

A solvency opinion speaks as of the transfer date. In VFB v. Campbell Soup the Third Circuit affirmed a ruling that discounted the plaintiff's experts for assumptions the informed public markets did not share at the time.

Campbell Soup spun off Vlasic Foods International (VFI) on March 30, 1998, and VFI paid Campbell $500 million for the business with bank debt. VFB LLC later sued, arguing that the spin was a fraudulent transfer. The district court chose not to rely on VFI's market capitalization at the time of the spin, which Campbell's accounting practices had inflated, and used the market value after the manipulation became known. VFI's market capitalization never dropped below $1.1 billion until January 1999. The court held that VFI had been solvent at the time of the spin.

The district court rejected the plaintiff's three valuation experts largely for hindsight bias, citing "their use of assumptions about VFI that were not shared by the informed public markets at the time of and after the spin." The Third Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Cudahy decided on March 30, 2007 and reported at 482 F.3d 624, affirmed. Quoting the Seventh Circuit's 1996 decision in In re Prince, it wrote that, absent some reason to distrust it, the market price is "a more reliable measure of the stock's value than the subjective estimates of one or two expert witnesses", and it upheld the finding that VFI received reasonably equivalent value in the spin.

For a reviewer the question is concrete. For each projection, appraisal or judgment the opposing report uses, what is its date, and could management, lenders or the market have known it on the transfer date? Where the debtor's shares or bonds traded, the reviewer sets the report's equity value beside the market's figure for the same date and asks the expert to explain the gap.

Is the cash flow test supported by the bank records?

Only if it covers the debtor's accounts and follows a stated method. In Weinman v. Crowley the court rejected a cash flow insolvency analysis built on one bank account and on deposits subtracted without a basis.

Section 548(a)(1)(B)(ii)(III) asks whether the debtor intended to incur, or believed it would incur, debts beyond its ability to pay as they matured. The trustee's expert in Weinman v. Crowley offered a cash flow insolvency analysis for 2011. He examined one of the debtor's bank accounts and conceded that, counting both exempt and non-exempt assets, the debtor had been able to pay its debts as they came due in 2011. He then subtracted certain deposits and reached the opposite result. The court found no methodological basis for the analysis and wrote: "Obviously, such an approach is inadmissible and unreliable."

The reviewer asks for the list of all the debtor's accounts for the period, the statements for each, and the expert's workpapers. Each subtraction or reclassification in the cash flow model needs a document and a reason. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) an expert report must contain "the facts or data considered by the witness" in forming the opinions, so the accounts the expert left out appear on the face of the disclosure.

Do arithmetic errors get a solvency report excluded?

In Weinman v. Crowley they did not. The defendants pointed to mathematical errors, including a $1 million liability counted twice; the court left them to cross-examination and based the exclusion on method, data and hindsight.

In footnote 12 the court wrote that it "does not consider mathematical errors or the like as a basis for exclusion" and that such errors are "more appropriately addressed in cross-examination". The exclusion rested on the expert's departures from his own method, on inputs without support and on the hindsight treatment of the 2015 judgment.

Rule 702 as amended in 2023 lets an expert testify only if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The Advisory Committee's note on the amendment says that rulings treating the sufficiency of an expert's basis as a question of weight rather than admissibility "are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)", and that each opinion "must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology."

A review sorts its findings the same way. Arithmetic errors go into a table of corrected figures and into deposition questions. Departures from the stated method, missing data and inputs dated after the transfer go into the rebuttal report and, if counsel decides to file one, into a Rule 702 motion.

When is a rebuttal to a solvency report due, and what can it cover?

Absent a stipulation or court order, within 30 days after the other side's disclosure under FRCP 26(a)(2)(D)(ii). The rebuttal is limited to contradicting or rebutting evidence on the same subject matter as the opposing report.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the 30-day period for evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter" identified by another party. A rebuttal by a retained expert has the same contents as any report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B): all opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, the witness's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases in which the witness testified in the previous 4 years and the compensation.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and under Rule 26(b)(4)(E)(i) the party seeking that discovery pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent responding. A reviewer who works only as a consultant and will not testify falls under Rule 26(b)(4)(D): ordinarily the other side may not discover that expert's facts or opinions. Under Rule 26(e)(2) the duty to supplement a testifying expert's report extends to information given at the deposition.

In Weinman v. Crowley the court measured the trustee's expert against the method his own report announced, page by page. A review that cites the opposing report's pages and workpapers gives counsel the same material for the deposition and the motion.

What does IAE do when a party faces a solvency analysis?

A forensic accountant from the IAE registry writes a review of the opposing expert's report or an expert report on the party's questions, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE forensic accounting page lists solvency among the questions the expert answers: the expert measures value received against value given and tests solvency on each transfer date, as 11 U.S.C. 548 asks for transfers within 2 years before the petition. The same page covers lost profits and other damages, and the tracing of funds between accounts through bank statements and ledgers, in commercial, bankruptcy and partnership disputes.

The client sends the opposing report or the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's collegial attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's status. A review is evidence that the court weighs together with the other materials. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member