Expert report review

Surrebuttal expert report: when may your expert answer the other side's rebuttal?

The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure give a party 30 days to rebut the other side's expert disclosure and say nothing about a reply to the rebuttal. Federal courts treat a surrebuttal expert report as a matter for leave: they allow it when the rebuttal raised new matter, as in J.R. Simplot v. McCain Foods, and refuse it when the request is late or the reply goes beyond that matter, as in Cason-Merenda v. Detroit Medical Center.

A hand places a thin third report onto two thicker ones beside a blank court order

What is a surrebuttal expert report?

A report in which the party that served the first expert disclosure answers the other side's rebuttal report. Rule 26 names the initial disclosure and the rebuttal, not a third round, so a surrebuttal needs a court order or leave.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D) provides that a party must make expert disclosures "at the times and in the sequence that the court orders." Absent a stipulation or a court order, disclosures are due at least 90 days before trial, or, "if the evidence is intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) or (C), within 30 days after the other party's disclosure." The rule stops there.

Courts use several names for the next step: surrebuttal, sur-rebuttal, sur-reply and reply report. The Middle District of Louisiana explained the position in Louisiana Health Care Self Insurance Fund v. United States on July 25, 2014. Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) does not give a party a right to serve sur-rebuttal reports, but "the Court also does not read Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) to prohibit the filing of sur-rebuttal reports." Its conclusion: "a party wishing to provide a sur-rebuttal must first seek leave of Court."

The court's scheduling order is the first place to look. In Louisiana Health Care the magistrate judge noted that "the Court's Scheduling Order only addresses the submission of expert reports." In other cases the scheduling order or a stipulated order sets a procedure for reply reports, and that procedure then governs the request.

When do courts allow a surrebuttal report?

When the rebuttal raised new matter that the first expert had no fair chance to answer. In J.R. Simplot v. McCain Foods the District of Idaho allowed a sur-reply in 2021 because the rebuttal greatly expanded the theories it presented.

The order in J.R. Simplot Co. v. McCain Foods USA, Inc., No. 1:16-cv-00449-DCN, also carried the captions of a related action and of Simplot's third-party claims against Elea. Elea moved for leave to serve a reply expert report of Dr. Wolfgang Ernst in answer to the second rebuttal report of Professor Pfeiffer on German law. Chief Judge David C. Nye decided the motion on October 20, 2021.

The court stated that leave "should only be granted 'where a valid reason for such additional briefing exists, such as the movant raises new arguments in its reply brief.'" It noted that when "an expert report raised issues for the first time in the rebuttal phase," courts in the district had allowed expert sur-replies.

The analysis was specific. Professor Pfeiffer's assumption, for the sake of argument, that German law applied was not a new theory. But some of his detailed opinions did "bring up new (albeit related) theories and/or explanations." The court added that "some 'new' material is to be expected" in any rebuttal, and found that what little harm, if any, the sur-reply caused would not materially affect the trajectory of the case.

The ruling: "while the opinions in Prof. Pfeiffer's second rebuttal report are not entirely new, there are greatly expounded upon theories contained therein. In fairness, the Court will allow Elea to serve Prof. Ernst's sur-reply in this case."

Why are surrebuttals disfavored?

Because, in the words of the Idaho court, they usually are a strategic effort to have the last word. Each new round also moves the schedule and invites another reply, and courts weigh that cost against the new matter.

The same Simplot decision that granted leave stated that sur-replies "are highly disfavored, as they usually are a strategic effort by the nonmoving party to have the last word on a matter." Leave was granted only after the court found the expanded theories in the rebuttal.

In Cason-Merenda v. Detroit Medical Center the Eastern District of Michigan measured a reply against the size of the new matter. The defendants argued that an errata sheet to the report of a plaintiffs' expert opened a new round, but their proposed 18-page sur-rebuttal report addressed the errata in just over one page: "The Court declines to permit a very small tail to wag a fairly large dog."

The Middle District of Louisiana went further after allowing one sur-rebuttal: "any future rebuttal reports will not be permitted from experts, unless under extreme circumstances." A party that asks for leave should expect the court to look at how many rounds the case has already had.

When do courts refuse a surrebuttal?

When the request is late or the report goes beyond the new issues. In Cason-Merenda v. Detroit Medical Center the court denied leave in 2010: the motion came after the 30-day period and the report substantially exceeded its limited function.

Cason-Merenda v. Detroit Medical Center, No. 06-15601, was decided by Chief Judge Gerald E. Rosen of the Eastern District of Michigan on March 31, 2010. A stipulated order of April 15, 2008 allowed the defendants to seek leave to submit a sur-rebuttal report addressing new issues raised in the plaintiffs' rebuttal reports. The same order provided that the "Plaintiffs' rebuttal expert reports shall not raise any new issues."

The court applied the 30-day period for rebuttal evidence, which it cited as Rule 26(a)(2)(C)(ii), the number the provision had at the time. The defendants filed their motion on April 24, 2009, five days after that period ran. The court did not read the stipulated order as extending the deadline. It allowed that an errata sheet served on April 16, 2009 might count as a second rebuttal, but held that a sur-rebuttal to it would be limited to the errata's new points.

The court also examined the content. A reply is meant to address matter that "is intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party," and the court found: "Defendants' proposed submission substantially exceeds this limited function." It found that the submission raised "legitimate and non-trivial concerns of trial (or, more accurately, dispositive motion practice) by ambush" and held that the plaintiffs' "rebuttal reports do not provide a basis for granting Defendants leave to submit" the report.

The motion was denied, and the proposed report was excluded from consideration of the pending dispositive, class certification and Daubert motions. The court relied on two separate grounds, timing and scope.

What happens if a party serves a surrebuttal without leave?

The court may keep it if the prejudice can be cured. In TQ Delta v. 2Wire the court applied Rule 37(c)(1), kept the report and allowed a reply to it; in Louisiana Health Care the court refused to strike.

In TQ Delta, LLC v. 2Wire, Inc., No. 13-1835-RGA, the District of Delaware addressed a surreply expert report served "without asking for leave of the Court, as required by the Final Scheduling Order." The court decided the question on August 11, 2021 under Rule 37(c)(1), which bars a party from using information not disclosed as Rule 26(a) or (e) requires "unless the failure was substantially justified or is harmless."

The court weighed the five Pennypack factors and treated exclusion as an "'extreme' sanction, not normally to be imposed absent a showing of willful deception," quoting Konstantopoulos. Prejudice weighed slightly toward exclusion but could be cured. The defendant had received the report before the expert's deposition, and the plaintiff offered two more hours of deposition. On bad faith the court wrote: "I do not find that Plaintiff acted in bad faith or willfully withheld information." The opinions mattered to the plaintiff's validity defense.

The cure went to the other side: "I will grant Defendant the opportunity to serve a sur-surreply expert report on invalidity." In Louisiana Health Care the magistrate judge also kept a sur-rebuttal served without leave: "Although Defendant should have obtained the Court's leave before providing its sur-rebuttal expert report," the plaintiff showed no prejudice, did not object to the substance and had deposed the expert about it.

Neither decision makes leave optional. Both turned on prejudice that was absent or could be cured, and in both the court noted that leave was required first.

What may a surrebuttal report contain?

Answers to matter that first appeared in the rebuttal. Opinions that belonged in the opening report, or that add a new theory of the party's own, are the parts courts exclude or limit.

The cases draw the same line from opposite sides. In Simplot the court allowed a reply because the rebuttal had "greatly expounded upon theories." In Cason-Merenda the court refused one because the reply "substantially exceeds" the function of answering new issues. The test in both is the relation between the surrebuttal and the new matter in the rebuttal.

A surrebuttal that repeats the opening report, adds data that was available when the opening report was served, or advances a new affirmative theory gives the court reasons to refuse it. A surrebuttal that answers a new test, a new data set or a new theory introduced in the rebuttal, paragraph by paragraph, gives the court a reason to allow it.

Rule 26(e)(2) is a separate channel. For an expert who must give a report, the duty to supplement extends to information in the report and to information given at deposition, and additions or changes must be disclosed by the time pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due. Under Rule 37(c)(1), a failure to supplement as Rule 26(e) requires carries the same exclusion risk as a failure to disclose.

The party opposing leave works on the same question. It cites the pages of the opening report or the opening expert's deposition where the supposedly new matter already appeared, and it explains what it would have to do, and how long it would take, to answer a surrebuttal. In TQ Delta those were the facts the court weighed under the prejudice and cure factors.

How does a reviewer prepare a surrebuttal or a motion for leave?

By mapping the rebuttal against the opening report, marking each item that is new, checking the dates in the scheduling order, and drafting answers limited to the new items, with a short list the motion can quote.

Before any surrebuttal is drafted, the reviewer maps the rebuttal against the opening report. Courts in Simplot and Cason-Merenda asked the same question, what is new, and a party that answers it item by item gives the court what it needs to decide.

  • Compare the rebuttal with the opening report and the opening expert's deposition, section by section.
  • Mark each new test, data set, source or theory in the rebuttal, with page references.
  • Separate genuinely new matter from criticism of the opening report, which the opening expert can answer at trial.
  • Check the scheduling order and any stipulated order for a reply procedure and deadline.
  • Draft the answers to the new items only, and estimate the time the other side would need to respond.
  • Consider whether a further deposition of the rebuttal expert would cure the problem without a new report.

Is a deposition an alternative to a surrebuttal report?

Courts treat it as a cure for prejudice. In TQ Delta the plaintiff offered two more hours of deposition and the court allowed a sur-surreply; in Louisiana Health Care the plaintiff had already deposed the expert about the sur-rebuttal.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, after the report is provided. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E), unless manifest injustice would result, the party seeking the discovery pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent responding.

A deposition does not add a report to the record, but it can expose what is new in the rebuttal and fix the rebuttal expert's position before trial. When the new matter is narrow, a party may prefer the deposition and an objection at trial to a motion for leave that the court may refuse.

When the new matter is substantial, the deposition is the place where the record for the motion is built: the rebuttal expert's own answers about when he performed the new analysis and why it was not in an earlier report.

What does IAE do when the other side's rebuttal needs an answer?

An IAE specialist reviews the rebuttal report against the opening report and the record, identifies new matter and prepares deposition questions. Format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed within one business day.

The client sends the rebuttal report, the opening report and the case materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its public registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts.

The review answers six questions about the report: method, completeness, soundness of the conclusions, the expert's competence, form and procedure, and whether the report can be relied on. Deposition questions for the rebuttal expert can be ordered with it.

The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and a 48-hour rush is available when the court's schedule leaves little time. The specialist confirms that he has no interest in the outcome and can be verified in the IAE registry by Member ID or QR code. IAE is not a law firm; whether to seek leave for a surrebuttal is a decision for the client's attorney, and a review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member