Examinations
Capacity to make a will: what can an expert establish after the person has died?
When a will is contested after death, the person who signed it cannot be interviewed or tested. A psychologist or psychiatrist reconstructs the person's mental functioning at the signing from medical records, witnesses and documents, then compares it with the state's legal test. California sets that test in Probate Code § 6100.5 and requires evidence of a deficit in a specific mental function rather than a diagnosis alone.

What does the law ask about a person's capacity to make a will?
In California, whether at signing the person could understand the act of making a will, understand and recall his or her property, and remember relatives affected by it, or had delusions or hallucinations that changed the gifts.
California Probate Code § 6100.5(a)(1) says an individual is not mentally competent to make a will if, at the time of making it, the individual lacks sufficient mental capacity to understand the nature of the act, to understand and recollect the nature and situation of his or her property, or to "remember and understand the individual's relations to living descendants, spouse, and parents," and to those whose interests the will affects. Under § 6100.5(a)(2) the individual is also not competent if a mental health disorder with symptoms including "delusions or hallucinations" led him or her to leave property in a way that, without those symptoms, he or she would not have chosen.
Section 810(a) creates a rebuttable presumption, affecting the burden of proof, that all persons have the capacity to make decisions and to be responsible for their acts. Section 810(b) adds that a person with a mental or physical disorder may still be capable of acts such as executing wills or trusts. Under § 810(c) a court's finding that a person lacked capacity for a specific act should rest on evidence of a deficit in mental functions "rather than on a diagnosis of a person's mental or physical disorder."
In a will contest, § 8252(a) places on the contestants the burden of proving lack of intent or capacity. Thomas G. Gutheil, writing in the Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law in December 2007, described the criteria as lying "at a low level, perhaps the lowest level, of demands on the subject" and noted that the person "enjoys the presumption of competence until proven otherwise."
Which mental functions does the expert examine?
California Probate Code § 811 lists four groups: alertness and attention, information processing, thought processes, and mood and affect. A deficit counts only if it significantly impairs the ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of the decision at issue.
Section 811(a) requires evidence of a deficit in at least one of these functions and evidence linking the deficit to the decision. Alertness and attention cover the level of consciousness, orientation to time, place, person and situation, and the ability to concentrate. Information processing covers memory, understanding and communicating, recognizing familiar people and objects, understanding quantities, reasoning, and planning and carrying out actions in one's own rational self-interest. Thought processes can be shown by severely disorganized thinking, hallucinations, delusions or uncontrollable, repetitive or intrusive thoughts. The fourth group is a pervasive and persistent mood, such as anger, anxiety or depression, that is "inappropriate in degree to the individual's circumstances."
Under § 811(b) a deficit counts only if, alone or with others, it significantly impairs the person's ability to understand and appreciate the consequences of his or her actions for the type of decision in question. Under § 811(c) the court may consider how often, how severely and for how long the impairment occurs. Section 811(d) closes the list: "The mere diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder shall not be sufficient" to support a finding of incapacity.
Gutheil made the same point in clinical terms. He wrote that capacity to make a will "is fundamentally a matter of functional ability and is thus largely independent of diagnosis alone," and that regardless of diagnosis, if the evidence indicates the testator met the criteria, the requirements are met. One of his examples was a woman with schizophrenia who had listed her assets and prepared a will with an attorney. He also noted that the criteria apply "at the time of the execution of the will (which may include a lucid interval in a chronic disorder)."
How can an expert evaluate a person who has already died?
Through records and the accounts of people who saw the person around the signing. Gutheil wrote that a postmortem evaluator relies almost totally on collateral data, and forensic psychology guidelines require stating the limits of such an opinion.
In a postmortem evaluation, Gutheil wrote, the examiner must "rely almost totally on collateral data," and that data may come from "highly biased and far-from-disinterested observers."
The Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology adopted by the American Psychological Association address opinions about people the psychologist has not examined. Guideline 9.03 says forensic practitioners provide evidence about the psychological characteristics of particular individuals only "when they have sufficient information or data to form an adequate foundation for those opinions." When an examination is not possible or feasible, practitioners "strive to make clear the impact of such limitations on the reliability and validity of their professional products." When they rely on records alone, they "seek to identify the sources of information on which they are basing their opinions and recommendations."
Guideline 9.02 adds that forensic practitioners "ordinarily avoid relying solely on one source of data" and "corroborate important data whenever feasible." For a deceased person this means checking one witness's account against the chart, the chart against the pharmacy and nursing records, and both against what the person wrote.
Bennett Blum, M.D., writing in Psychiatric Times in October 2015, distinguished a contemporaneous evaluation, which "is usually optimal," from a historical reconstruction, used when the person is not available for interview, and wrote that "historical reconstruction is difficult to do properly under the best of circumstances."
Which records does a retrospective evaluation use?
Medical records and test results, caregiver notes, the person's own notes, diaries, emails and texts, reports of adult protective services or police, affidavits and depositions. Records made at the time count for more than later recollection.
Blum listed among the sources for a historical reconstruction "personal notes and diaries, adult protective services reports, police reports, and email or text communications," together with medical records, psychological test results, affidavits and depositions; in one of his case examples he also lists "caregiver notes." He wrote that "contemporaneous documentation of relevant behavior or situations is usually more reliable than later recall" and advised looking for "comparable descriptions of behavior and/or circumstances from multiple, independent sources."
Blum also wrote that information supplied by litigants "should be considered suspect" and is more believable when independent evidence corroborates it or it goes against the litigant's own interest. He advised asking the retaining attorney which legal standard of capacity applies in the case.
Access to the medical chart runs through the estate. Guidance from the Department of Health and Human Services describes the personal representative of a deceased individual as "an executor, administrator, or other person who has authority under applicable State or other law to act on behalf of the decedent," who can exercise the person's rights under the HIPAA Privacy Rule. The same guidance says the information stays protected "for 50 years following the date of death" and lets a provider disclose relevant information to family members involved in the person's care unless that conflicts with a preference the decedent expressed.
Can the expert tell the court that the person lacked capacity?
Federal Rule of Evidence 704(a) does not bar an opinion on an ultimate issue. The advisory committee note still excludes the bare question whether the person had capacity and accepts a question framed in the legal elements.
Rule 704(a) reads: "An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue." The advisory committee note gives the example of a will. The question "Did T have capacity to make a will?" would be excluded. The question "Did T have sufficient mental capacity to know the nature and extent of his property and the natural objects of his bounty and to formulate a rational scheme of distribution?" would be allowed.
The difference is that the second question asks about the functions the law names, and the expert can answer it from clinical data. The legal conclusion stays with the court or jury.
Rule 702, as amended effective December 1, 2023, requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony "is based on sufficient facts or data." The committee note says that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application" of the expert's basis and methodology. For a retrospective opinion the bounds are set by what the records say about the person on and around the day of signing. Probate cases are heard in state courts, which apply their own evidence rules.
Does a diagnosis of dementia mean the person could not make a will?
No. California Probate Code § 811(d) says a diagnosis alone is not enough, and Gutheil wrote that capacity turns on functional ability. A low score on a cognitive test does not answer the legal questions by itself either.
Section 810(b) states that a person with a mental or physical disorder may still be capable of executing a will, and § 811(d) bars a finding of incapacity based on the mere diagnosis. The expert has to connect a specific deficit, such as memory loss or delusions, to one of the elements in § 6100.5.
Gutheil listed among the common pitfalls "confusing impairments on standardized tests with failure to meet the relevant criteria." In one of his examples, test findings "did not bear or shed light on the capacity criteria." A test score records performance on that test on that day; the legal question asks whether the person knew the property, the family and the plan of the will at the signing.
Delusions matter only through their effect on the will. Section 6100.5(a)(2) asks whether delusions or hallucinations led to gifts the person would not otherwise have made. Gutheil wrote that "experts may fail to grasp that general delusions in other areas are not relevant" and described a woman whose "delusion about the daughter-in-law did not impinge on her knowing that he was her son."
A chronic disorder also does not exclude a lucid interval at the signing. The expert therefore looks for records from the day of signing and the days around it: nursing notes, medication records and the observations of the attorney and the witnesses.
How does capacity differ from undue influence?
Capacity asks whether the person could understand the will. Undue influence asks whether someone else overrode the person's free will. California defines it in Welfare and Institutions Code § 15610.70, and the person's vulnerability is one of four factors.
Probate Code § 86 says that undue influence "has the same meaning as defined in Section 15610.70 of the Welfare and Institutions Code" and supplements the common law meaning. Section 15610.70(a) defines undue influence as excessive persuasion that causes a person to act or refrain from acting by overcoming that person's free will and results in inequity.
The court weighs four groups of facts. The first is the vulnerability of the victim: incapacity, illness, disability, injury, age, education, impaired cognitive function, emotional distress, isolation or dependency, and whether the influencer knew or should have known of it. The second is the influencer's apparent authority, for example as a family member, caregiver, fiduciary or health care professional. The third is the influencer's actions or tactics, such as controlling the person's necessities, medication, contact with others, access to information or sleep, using affection, intimidation or coercion, or initiating changes in haste or secrecy. The fourth is the equity of the result.
Section 15610.70(b) adds: "Evidence of an inequitable result, without more, is not sufficient to prove undue influence." A psychologist's findings on cognitive function, emotional state and dependency bear on the first factor. Whether influence was exerted and whether it overcame the person's will is decided by the court on all the evidence.
Can capacity be documented while the person is alive?
Yes, and it gives a stronger record than a reconstruction after death. Blum called a contemporaneous evaluation usually optimal, and Gutheil wrote that under the presumption of competence the will should stand unless there is clear evidence of incapacity.
Gutheil described premortem examinations, carried out near the time the will is signed. He wrote: "Under the presumption of competence, the will should stand, barring clear evidence of incapacity." An evaluation made at that point records the person's answers about property, family and the plan of the will in the person's own words.
Blum's article contrasted such an evaluation with a historical reconstruction made after death, which depends on collateral information. A contemporaneous evaluation gives the later court a record made by an examiner who saw the person, together with test results from the period in question.
What does IAE do when capacity to make a will is disputed?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes an expert report on your questions about the person's decision-making capacity, based on the records you provide. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The forensic psychological evaluation page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. For capacity the page cites California Probate Code § 811: a finding of incapacity needs evidence of a deficit in a mental function linked to the decision at issue, and a diagnosis alone is not enough. The questions are framed from the pleadings and the records.
The client sends the will, the medical records, witness statements and other documents of the period and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the psychologist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- California Probate Code § 6100.5, Mental competence to make a will (California Public Law)
- California Probate Code § 810, Presumption of capacity (Justia, 2025)
- California Probate Code § 811, Deficits in mental functions (FindLaw)
- California Probate Code § 8252, Burden of proof in a will contest (California Public Law)
- California Probate Code § 86, Undue influence (California Public Law)
- California Welfare and Institutions Code § 15610.70, Undue influence (California Public Law)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 704, Opinion on an Ultimate Issue, with advisory committee notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with committee notes (U.S. Code, GovInfo)
- American Psychological Association, Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology
- American Psychology-Law Society, Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, section 9, Methods and procedures
- Gutheil T. G. Common Pitfalls in the Evaluation of Testamentary Capacity. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, December 2007, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 514-517
- Blum B. Forensic Evaluations: Testamentary Capacity. Psychiatric Times, October 30, 2015 (modified November 16, 2020)
- HHS, Health Information of Deceased Individuals (HIPAA Privacy Rule guidance)
Read also
All articles
Undue influence expert witness: what can a psychologist assess in a will, trust or contract dispute?
In California a will, or a part of one, is ineffective to the extent undue influence procured it, and that claim is separate from a claim that
Capacity evaluation for guardianship: who examines the person, and what must the report contain?
Before a court appoints a guardian for an adult, professionals examine the person and report on which rights he or she can still exercise. Florida
Supervised visitation: when does a court order it, and what does a psychologist assess?
A court orders supervised visitation when contact with a parent is in the child's interest but carries a risk that a neutral third person can manageExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

