Expert witnesses

Texas medical malpractice expert report: what does the 120-day rule in section 74.351 require?

In a Texas health care liability claim, the claimant serves an expert report and the expert's CV within 120 days after each defendant files its original answer. Section 74.351 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code sets that deadline. If no report arrives in time, the court, on that defendant's motion, dismisses the claim against it with prejudice and awards its attorney's fees. A report that arrives on time but falls short can get one 30-day extension.

A physician from behind slides a thin report into a court envelope beside a stethoscope

When is the expert report due in a Texas malpractice case?

Not later than the 120th day after each defendant's original answer is filed. The claimant serves the report and each expert's CV on every party or its attorney, and the parties may extend the date in writing.

Section 74.351(a) of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code applies to every health care liability claim. The claimant serves one or more expert reports, with a curriculum vitae of each expert listed in the report, for each physician or health care provider against whom a liability claim is asserted. The deadline is the 120th day after the date each defendant's original answer is filed, unless section 74.353 sets a later date. The affected parties may extend the date by written agreement.

Each defendant has its own clock. When defendants answer on different dates, their reports fall due on different dates, and for a defendant joined later the count starts with that defendant's own answer.

The trigger has changed since 2003, when the 78th Legislature added the section. The original text counted from the filing of the claim. In 2005, House Bill 2645 changed that to the date the original petition was filed. The text in force today counts from each defendant's original answer. The section was amended again in 2013, 2021 and 2023, the last time with effect from September 1, 2023.

How are the 120 days counted when the last day falls on a weekend?

Under Rule 4 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. In University of Texas Medical Branch v. Callas (2016), day 120 fell on a Saturday, and the court of appeals held that the report was due on the following Monday.

The University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston filed its original answer on October 3, 2014. Day 120 was Saturday, January 31, 2015. At 6:27 p.m. that Saturday, a paralegal for the plaintiffs emailed the hospital's counsel the expert report, the expert's CV, the death certificate, radiology records and billing records. A second email with the hospital's own medical records bounced because of its size. More records went out on February 3 and February 12.

The hospital moved to dismiss under section 74.351(b). It argued that a report filed electronically had to be served through the electronic filing manager, and that service was incomplete until the medical records arrived on February 12. The trial court denied the motion, and the hospital took an interlocutory appeal.

On May 17, 2016, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston affirmed in No. 14-15-00449-CV, an opinion by Justice J. Brett Busby. Rule 4 applied to the 120-day period and did not conflict with the statute, so the deadline was Monday, February 2, 2015. Email service was permitted under Rule 21a(a)(2), because the report had not been "filed electronically under Rule 21." The first email held a complete report, and the court noted that medical records are not expert reports.

What must the expert report say?

A fair summary of the expert's opinions on three points: the applicable standards of care, how the care given failed to meet them, and the causal relationship between that failure and the injury claimed.

Section 74.351(r)(6) defines an expert report as "a written report by an expert that provides a fair summary of the expert's opinions as of the date of the report" regarding the applicable standards of care, the manner in which the care rendered by the physician or health care provider failed to meet those standards, and the causal relationship between that failure and the injury, harm or damages claimed. The CV of each expert listed in the report is served with it.

The report covers liability and causation. Under section 74.351(j), no report is required on any other issue, so the amount of damages is not part of it.

The Supreme Court of Texas described the causation part in Columbia Valley Healthcare System, L.P. v. Zamarripa (No. 15-0909, decided June 9, 2017). Chief Justice Nathan L. Hecht wrote for the Court that an expert "must explain, based on facts set out in the report, how and why" the breach caused the injury. "A bare expert opinion that the breach caused the injury will not suffice." The report does not have to use words such as "proximate cause", but conclusory statements are not enough: the expert has to link the conclusions to the facts.

Why did the reports in Zamarripa fall short?

They did not explain how the hospital caused a transfer that a physician had ordered. The nurse could not address causation, and the physician expert stated the causal link without facts about the hospital's part in the decision.

Yolanda Iris Flores, 36, was taken by ambulance to the labor and delivery emergency room of Valley Regional Medical Center in Brownsville, Texas, in the middle of the third trimester of her third pregnancy. An MRI showed placenta accreta. Dr. Patrick Ellis ordered her transferred to Corpus Christi Medical Center Bay Area, 159 miles away. During the ambulance ride she began bleeding; the crew was told to continue, and in heavy traffic she went into cardiac arrest. She arrived after 4:00 p.m., had an emergency cesarean section and a hysterectomy, and died at 11:02 p.m. Her baby girl was stillborn.

The guardian of her two minor children sued the physicians, both hospitals, the ambulance service and others. Two reports were served on Valley Regional. Grace Spears, a nurse with labor and delivery and emergency room experience, wrote that the nurses breached the standard of care by not advocating for the patient to remain at Valley Regional and by "allowing [Flores] to be transferred to another facility many miles away." Dr. Frederick Harlass, an obstetrician-gynecologist, attributed the death to the hospital's "permitting and facilitating" of the transfer.

The trial court denied the hospital's motion to dismiss, and the court of appeals affirmed. The Supreme Court reversed. Only a physician may give the causation opinion under section 74.351(r)(5)(C), so the nurse's report could not supply it. Dr. Harlass did not explain how Valley Regional permitted or facilitated a transfer that Dr. Ellis ordered, or whether the hospital had any say in it.

The Court did not order dismissal. The nurse's report suggested that the nurses could have given Dr. Ellis information that might have changed his decision, so the Court could not say that the deficiency was impossible to cure. It remanded the case so that the trial court could consider one 30-day extension.

Who can sign the expert report?

On a physician's standard of care, a physician qualified under section 74.401; on another provider's, an expert under section 74.402. On causation, only a physician qualified under the Texas Rules of Evidence.

Section 74.351(r)(5) defines who counts as an expert for the report, by reference to sections 74.401 and 74.402 for the standard of care, with separate rules for dentists, podiatrists and chiropractors. Section 74.401(a) lets a person testify on whether a physician departed from accepted standards of medical care only if the person is a physician who is practicing medicine when the testimony is given or was practicing when the claim arose, knows the accepted standards for the illness, injury or condition involved, and is qualified by training or experience to give an opinion on those standards.

Practicing medicine includes training residents or students at an accredited school of medicine or osteopathy and serving as a consulting physician to physicians who provide direct patient care, at their request (section 74.401(b)). In weighing training and experience, the court considers whether the witness is board certified or has other substantial training or experience in an area of medical practice relevant to the claim, and whether the witness is actively practicing medicine in rendering care relevant to the claim (section 74.401(c)). The court may depart from these criteria if there is a good reason to admit the testimony, and it states the reason on the record (section 74.401(d)).

For this purpose a physician is a person licensed to practice medicine in one or more states of the United States (section 74.401(g)), so a Texas license is not required.

Causation is narrower. Under section 74.403(a), a person may testify on the causal relationship between the injury and the care rendered only if the person is a physician otherwise qualified under the Texas Rules of Evidence. In Zamarripa the nurse's report addressed the standard of care, and the physician's report had to carry causation.

What is the objective good-faith effort standard?

Under section 74.351(l), a court may grant a motion challenging the adequacy of a report only if, after a hearing, the report does not represent an objective good-faith effort to meet the statutory definition of an expert report.

The test is written into the statute. The court holds a hearing and compares the report with the three elements of section 74.351(r)(6): the standard of care, the breach and causation. A report that leaves out one element, or states it as a conclusion, fails that comparison.

In Zamarripa the Court said that the report "must make a good-faith effort to explain, factually, how proximate cause is going to be proven." It cited its earlier decision in Rodriguez-Escobar v. Goss for the two components of proximate cause: foreseeability and cause in fact.

In Zamarripa the Court looked in Dr. Harlass's report for facts about the hospital's part in the transfer decision and found none: the physician who ordered the transfer was Dr. Ellis, and the report did not say what the hospital could have done to stop him.

Does one report have to cover every defendant and every theory?

Every defendant needs a report that addresses its conduct, but not every pleaded theory. In Certified EMS, Inc. v. Potts (2013), the Supreme Court of Texas held that a report adequately addressing one pleaded liability theory is enough.

In Certified EMS, Inc. v. Potts, 392 S.W.3d 625 (Tex. 2013), the plaintiff alleged that a health care provider was directly and vicariously liable for "an assault committed by its nurse." The expert reports did not address the direct liability theories, and the defendant sought dismissal because the reports did not specify how it was directly negligent.

The trial court denied the motion, and the Supreme Court of Texas affirmed. It held that "No provision of the [TMLA] requires an expert report to address each alleged liability theory" and that "an expert report that adequately addresses at least one pleaded liability theory satisfies the statutory requirements." The Thirteenth Court of Appeals of Texas quoted both passages, with page references to Potts, in Christus Spohn Health System Corp. v. Johnston (No. 13-12-00778-CV, May 23, 2013).

Section 74.351(i) lets the claimant use separate reports by different experts for different physicians or health care providers, or for different issues, such as liability and causation. A case against a hospital, a staffing company and a physician can therefore rest on three reports, as long as each defendant's conduct is addressed in at least one of them.

What happens if no report is served on time?

On the affected defendant's motion, the court enters an order that awards that defendant reasonable attorney's fees and costs and dismisses the claim against it with prejudice. Section 74.351(b) uses the word shall.

Section 74.351(b) applies when an expert report has not been served within the period in subsection (a). On the motion of the affected physician or health care provider, the court shall enter an order that awards that defendant reasonable attorney's fees and costs and dismisses the claim with respect to it, with prejudice.

The statute names the ways to move the date: a written agreement of the affected parties under subsection (a), a later date under section 74.353, and one 30-day extension under subsection (c) when a served report is found deficient.

The order under subsection (b) concerns the claim against the physician or provider that filed the motion. Each defendant's deadline is counted from its own answer, so the question of a missed deadline is decided for each defendant separately.

When can the court grant a 30-day extension?

When a report was served but elements of it are found deficient. Section 74.351(c) permits one 30-day extension to cure the deficiency. When no report at all was served, subsection (b) governs instead.

Section 74.351(c) reads that if a report has not been served within the period because elements of it are found deficient, the court may grant one 30-day extension to the claimant in order to cure the deficiency. The extension is a single one, and it attaches to a report that exists.

In Zamarripa, the Supreme Court relied on its 2011 decision in Scoresby v. Santillan when it sent the case back for the trial court to consider an extension. The deciding fact was that the Court could not say the deficiency was impossible to cure: the nurse's report pointed to information that might have changed the physician's decision.

The extension gives the claimant 30 days to supply the missing element. Section 74.351(i) permits separate reports by different experts on different issues, such as liability and causation.

When must the defendant object to the report?

By the later of the 21st day after the report is served and the 21st day after its own answer, or its objections to sufficiency are waived. Section 74.401(e) separately governs objections to qualifications.

Under section 74.351(a), each defendant physician or health care provider whose conduct is implicated in a report files and serves any objection to its sufficiency not later than the later of the 21st day after the report is served or the 21st day after the defendant's answer is filed. If it does not, all objections are waived.

Section 74.401(e) sets a pretrial deadline for objections to a witness's qualifications: within 21 days after the objecting party receives the witness's CV, or within 21 days after the witness's deposition, whichever is later. The court may allow a late objection for circumstances that could not reasonably have been anticipated. It holds a hearing on qualifications as soon as practicable, and before trial if possible.

Orders on these motions can reach a court of appeals before trial. In Callas and in Zamarripa, the hospitals took interlocutory appeals against the orders that denied their motions to dismiss, and in Zamarripa the Supreme Court confirmed that a motion to dismiss based on a timely but deficient report can be reviewed that way.

What discovery is allowed before the report is served?

Until the report and CV are served, discovery is stayed, except that the claimant may obtain the patient's health care information by written discovery, depositions on written questions and discovery from nonparties. Claimants may take at most two depositions.

Section 74.351(s) stays discovery in a health care liability claim until the claimant serves the report and the CV. The claimant may still obtain the patient's health care information through written discovery, depositions on written questions and discovery from nonparties.

Section 74.351(u) caps oral testimony at this stage: after the claim is filed, all claimants together may take no more than two depositions before the report is served. Before the report is served, the expert's material is the records obtained this way and the testimony from those two depositions, if they were taken.

Can the expert report be used at trial?

Not as a rule. Section 74.351(k) makes a served report inadmissible and bars its use in depositions, trial or other proceedings, but the bar is waived if the claimant uses the report for any other purpose.

Subject to subsection (t), a report served under section 74.351 is not admissible in evidence by any party, may not be used in a deposition, trial or other proceeding, and may not be referred to by any party for any purpose (section 74.351(k)).

Subsection (t) works in one direction. If the claimant uses the report for any purpose other than meeting the service requirement, the restrictions in subsection (k) are waived.

What if it is unclear whether the claim is a health care liability claim?

Since September 1, 2021, the claimant may ask the court for a preliminary determination under section 74.353, by a motion filed within 30 days after each defendant's original answer. The report deadline then moves to the latest of three dates.

Section 74.353 was added by Senate Bill 232 of the 87th Legislature. On a claimant's motion filed within 30 days after each defendant's original answer, the court may decide whether the claim is a health care liability claim. If the court has not ruled by the 91st day after the motion, it issues a preliminary determination that the claim is one.

If the claim is a health care liability claim, the report is due on the latest of three dates: 120 days after each defendant's original answer, 60 days after the preliminary determination, or a date the affected parties agree to in writing. Either side may take an interlocutory appeal from the determination. If an appellate court reverses a ruling that the claim is not a health care liability claim, the report is due 120 days after the appellate opinion issues. The determination decides only whether a report is required under section 74.351.

How does IAE find an expert for a Texas expert report?

In the request choose the case type Medical malpractice and write Texas and the court in the State and court field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

The medical malpractice expert witness page names surgeons, obstetricians, anesthesiologists, emergency physicians, nurses and geriatricians among six medical malpractice specialties, and IAE matches the expert to the defendant's specialty and the state's requirements. Its answer on the first expert opinion reads: in Texas, the expert report and CV are due by the 120th day after each defendant's original answer, or the court on motion dismisses the claim with prejudice.

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties with their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. For a Texas claim, the deadline field can carry day 120 for the defendant that answered first, and the description can say whether the report must cover the standard of care, causation or both, since causation needs a physician. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.

The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour, which credits the search fee to the first invoice. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case