Expert witnesses
Vocational expert in a personal injury case: how loss of earning capacity is proved and tested
A vocational expert in a personal injury case compares the work and earnings open to the injured person before the injury with what is open after it. An economist then turns that difference into a dollar figure. Courts test both opinions. In Elcock v. Kmart (3d Cir. 2000) the court sent a vocational opinion back for a Daubert hearing and threw out an economic model built on figures that were not in the record.

What does a vocational expert do in a personal injury case?
The expert compares the jobs and earnings available to the injured person before and after the injury and states the loss of earning capacity. An economist then converts that loss into money for the damages claim.
In Elcock v. Kmart Corp., 233 F.3d 734 (3d Cir. 2000), the plaintiff's vocational expert, Dr. Chester Copemann, testified that she was 50-60% vocationally disabled and that the disability was permanent. He described his starting point as the Fields method, which the court summarized as "comparing the difference between 'preinjury access to the labor market' and 'post injury access.'"
His testing included IQ and achievement tests and an aptitude analysis under the Dictionary of Occupational Titles. Then he departed from the numbers: "I use Fields analysis as a starting point and then I revert to Gamboa to depart from Fields." The Gamboa approach, in his words, means looking at "all the factors involved in the client's analysis." The Third Circuit describes both methods only through Copemann's testimony and notes that Kmart did not dispute that the Fields and Gamboa methods are accepted. The descriptions here follow the opinion.
The economist came next. Dr. Bernard Pettingill built the model of economic damages that the jury heard. In Elcock the work divided this way: the vocational expert stated what the plaintiff could still do, and the economist stated what that was worth over the rest of her working life.
How is loss of earning capacity different from lost earnings?
Lost earnings are wages the person actually lost. Loss of earning capacity is the lost ability to earn money, and under California's jury instruction it can be awarded without a work history or proof of actual lost earnings.
California's civil jury instruction CACI No. 3903D, in the text marked revised April 2004, names the item of damage as "[t]he loss of [name of plaintiff]'s ability to earn money." The plaintiff proves the earnings he or she would have been reasonably certain to receive had the injury not happened, and the instruction adds: "It is not necessary that [he/she] have a work history."
The sources listed with the instruction draw the line. Heiner v. Kmart Corp. (2000): "Damages may be awarded for lost earning capacity without any proof of actual loss of earnings." Connelly v. Pre-Mixed Concrete Co. (1957): loss of earning power "is an element of general damages" that can be inferred from the injury "without proof of actual earnings or income either before or after the injury."
The claim still needs a basis. Bellman v. San Francisco High School Dist. (1938), also cited with the instruction, requires that future consequences have "such a degree of probability of their occurring" that they amount to a reasonable certainty. The vocational expert supplies that basis by showing which occupations the person could fill before the injury and which remain after it.
What occupational data does a vocational expert work with?
The O*NET database of the U.S. Department of Labor describes over 900 occupations by tasks, knowledge, skills, abilities and work activities. It uses the 2018 Standard Occupational Classification and is updated quarterly.
The O*NET overview calls O*NET "the nation's primary source of occupational information." It is "developed under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Labor/Employment and Training Administration" through a grant to the North Carolina Department of Commerce. The database holds "over 900 occupation profiles." The taxonomy lists 1,016 occupational titles, of which 923 are data-level occupations, and was "Updated in 2019 to align with the 2018 Standard Occupational Classification (SOC)."
Each occupation is described through "knowledges, skills, abilities, activities, and tasks." O*NET OnLine, "developed for the U.S. Department of Labor by the National Center for O*NET Development," gives the public the same database. Its reports cover "occupation requirements, worker characteristics," and "available training, education, and job opportunities." O*NET OnLine also publishes crosswalks to the Standard Occupational Classification, the Occupational Outlook Handbook and the Dictionary of Occupational Titles.
The crosswalk to the Dictionary of Occupational Titles matters in older records. In Elcock the expert ran an aptitude analysis under the Dictionary, and vocational files and earlier reports in a case may use its codes. The expert who works with O*NET today can link those codes to current occupations through the crosswalk.
Where do the wage figures come from, and what do they leave out?
Often from the Bureau of Labor Statistics OEWS program, which estimates employment and wages for about 830 occupations by area. OEWS wages include base pay, commissions and tips but exclude overtime, nonproduction bonuses, shift differentials and benefits.
The Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) program of the Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes employment and wage estimates for "approximately 830 occupations" for the nation, each state, and metropolitan and nonmetropolitan areas, with national figures by industry. OEWS is a "semi-annual mail survey of non-farm establishments." The estimates combine six semiannual panels over three years, a sample of "1.1 million establishments and about 57 percent of the employment in the United States."
The wage definition is narrow. OEWS counts straight-time gross pay, including base rates, commissions and tips. It excludes overtime pay, nonproduction bonuses and shift differentials, and the estimates "do not include nonproduction bonuses or employer costs of nonwage benefits, such as health insurance." A worker whose pay before the injury included regular overtime or a shift premium earned more than the OEWS figure for the same occupation, and that difference has to be accounted for separately.
BLS also warns about one use: "The Bureau of Labor Statistics does not encourage the use of OEWS data for time-series analysis." The three-year pooled sample and changes in classifications and methods make year-to-year comparisons difficult. An opinion that projects wage growth from changes between two OEWS releases rests on a use the agency itself does not encourage.
What happened in Elcock v. Kmart?
A 51-year-old self-employed saleswoman slipped at a Kmart in the U.S. Virgin Islands in 1995. Kmart conceded liability, and the jury awarded $650,000, including $350,000 for economic loss built on vocational and economic testimony.
Carmelita Elcock sold Mary Kay products on her own account. In August 1995 she slipped on a waxy substance at a Kmart store in Frederiksted, U.S. Virgin Islands. Kmart conceded liability, and the trial was about damages: back and leg injuries, depression and lost earning capacity. The jury awarded $650,000, of which $350,000 was economic loss and $300,000 pain and suffering.
Dr. Copemann, the vocational witness, was a psychologist with a Ph.D. who had also treated Ms. Elcock. He had no formal training in vocational rehabilitation. The district court admitted his testimony and the economist's testimony without a Daubert hearing. Kmart appealed.
Chief Judge Becker wrote for the Third Circuit panel with Judges Scirica and Garth. The opinion was filed on October 10, 2000 and amended on November 20, 2000. In footnote 11 Judge Garth wrote that he did not agree with the majority on the limits placed on Copemann's cross-examination.
Why did the Third Circuit question the vocational method?
The court found the hybrid of the Fields and Gamboa methods subjective, untested and unreproducible, held that a Daubert hearing was required, and vacated the admission of the testimony. It affirmed his qualification as an expert.
On qualifications the court wrote that "Copemann's qualifications as a vocational rehabilitationist are thin," but added that "[t]his court has had, for some time, a generally liberal standard of qualifying experts." It wrote that Copemann "seems but marginally qualified" and still affirmed the district court's decision to qualify him as an expert, which the district court itself had called a close call.
The method fared worse. The court looked at factors such as "whether a method consists of a testable hypothesis" and "the qualifications of the expert witness testifying based on the methodology." It found the combined approach "subjective and unreproducible" and wrote that "it would have been nearly impossible for Kmart's experts to repeat Copemann's apparently subjective methods." Kmart did not dispute that the Fields and Gamboa methods are accepted, but Elcock offered no evidence that Copemann's combination was used by other experts or referenced in the literature. The court called it "nothing more than a hodgepodge of the Fields and Gamboa approaches."
The numbers did not agree with the method. Applying the Fields analysis as Copemann described it, the court arrived at a 100% loss of jobs, yet the expert reported 50-60%. The court wrote: "the discord is so stark that we factor it into our Daubert calculus." Its conclusion: "we conclude that there should have been a Daubert hearing prior to the receipt of Copemann's testimony." The admission was vacated and the question remanded without a view on the result of that hearing.
What went wrong with the economist's model in Elcock?
It rested on assumptions without support in the record: 100% disability, a wage more than double her actual earnings, no account of her later earnings, and average life and retirement figures not adjusted for her diabetes.
Dr. Pettingill had the vocational report that put Ms. Elcock at 50 to 60 percent disabled, yet "Pettingill assumed that Elcock was 100 percent disabled when arriving at his opinion." He assumed earnings of $6 an hour for 40 hours a week, about $12,480 a year. In 1995 she had earned less than $6,000. He ignored the $1,070 she earned in 1996 and used average life and retirement expectations without adjusting for her diabetes.
The court held that "his economic model relied on assumptions wholly without foundation in the record" and should have been excluded. An expert's model "must be based upon the proper factual foundation" and "must be accompanied by a sufficient factual foundation before it can be submitted to the jury."
The economic and non-economic awards could not be cleanly separated, so the court ordered that "a new trial must be had on all aspects of the damage award." Liability, which Kmart had conceded, was not retried. The economist's disability figure, wage and work-life had to match the vocational opinion and the earnings record, and the court cited each mismatch.
Does a plaintiff always need a vocational expert to claim lost earning capacity?
Not always. The sources to California's CACI No. 3903D cite Gargir v. B'Nei Akiva (1998): it is not necessary to produce expert testimony on future earning ability. Elcock shows the risk when an expert figure lacks a factual basis.
The sources listed with CACI No. 3903D quote Gargir v. B'Nei Akiva (1998): "it is not necessary for a party to produce expert testimony on future earning ability." The same sources cite Fein v. Permanente Medical Group (1985) for the rule that a plaintiff with permanent injuries may base recovery on prospective earnings for the life expectancy, "undiminished by any shortening of that expectancy."
Without an expert the jury works from the injury itself and the plaintiff's own evidence. With an expert, the opinion has to meet the court's reliability test, and in federal court the retained expert serves a written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The report states the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the expert's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases with testimony in the previous 4 years and the compensation.
The rule also governs how the vocational report reaches the economist. The facts or data considered must be listed, so the economist's report that relies on the vocational opinion and the vocational report itself are read side by side by the other side, as they were in Elcock.
What records should the vocational expert and the economist share?
The same earnings history, the same medical restrictions and the same disability figure. In Elcock the economist used 100% disability while the vocational expert reported 50-60%, and the court cited that gap.
The list below follows the points on which the Third Circuit faulted the expert testimony in Elcock. Each item is a fact that the vocational expert and the economist take from the same record.
- Earnings before the injury for each year, from tax returns or business records, and earnings after the injury, including small amounts such as the $1,070 that Ms. Elcock earned in 1996.
- One disability or loss-of-access figure used by both experts, with the vocational method that produced it described so that the other side can repeat it.
- The physicians' restrictions and prognosis on which the vocational opinion rests, including conditions such as diabetes that bear on work-life and life expectancy.
- The occupations considered before and after the injury, with their O*NET codes and the OEWS wage estimates for the area and year used.
- Any adjustment for overtime, bonuses, shift pay or benefits, which OEWS wage estimates do not include.
How does IAE find a vocational expert for a personal injury case?
In the request choose the case type Personal injury and name vocational assessment, and an economist if needed, in the field. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The personal injury expert witness page lists eight personal injury specialties, among them life care planning, vocational assessment and economic damages. Its "Damages and falls" group names vocational assessment with the O*NET database and economists on lost earnings, and the "Medicine" group names orthopedic surgeons, neurologists and neurosurgeons on cause of injury, treatment and prognosis.
The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years.
The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Elcock v. Kmart Corp., 233 F.3d 734 (3d Cir. 2000) (Justia)
- O*NET OnLine Help, O*NET Overview (U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration)
- O*NET OnLine Help, OnLine Overview (National Center for O*NET Development)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, frequently asked questions
- Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions, CACI No. 3903D, Lost Earning Capacity (Economic Damage), revised April 2004 (Justia copy)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Dram shop expert witness: what can a toxicologist prove about visible intoxication, and what do courts require of the opinion?
A dram shop claim asks a court to hold a bar or restaurant liable for what an intoxicated patron did after leaving. The crash is usually undisputed
Construction accident expert witness: which safety rules does the expert apply, and when do they decide the case?
A fall from a scaffold, a collapsed trench or a ladder that kicked out ends up in court as a question about safety rules. The construction safety
Traumatic brain injury expert witness: what can a neuropsychologist and brain imaging prove in court?
A mild traumatic brain injury often leaves nothing a standard scan can show, so the case turns on experts: the treating physiciansExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

