Expert opinion letters
Who can write an expert opinion letter for an EB-1A, NIW or O-1 petition?
No regulation lists who may sign an expert opinion letter for an EB-1A, NIW or O-1 petition. 8 CFR 204.5 sets the writer's details only for letters from employers, which must give the writer's name, address and title. For opinion letters the USCIS Policy Manual asks that the letter set out the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise, and the officer weighs the writer's relationship with the applicant.

Who can write an expert opinion letter for an EB-1A petition?
Any specialist whose letter explains what the applicant did, why it matters to the field and how the writer knows. 8 CFR 204.5 requires no title, degree or U.S. citizenship; the officer weighs expertise, relationship and corroboration.
The EB-1A regulation, 8 CFR 204.5(h), lists ten criteria, and none of them mentions letters. The only letters named in paragraph (h) are in (h)(5), where evidence that the applicant will continue work in the field "may include letter(s) from prospective employer(s)," evidence of prearranged commitments such as contracts, or a statement in which the applicant describes plans to continue the work in the United States. The phrase "recognized national or international experts" in (h)(3)(ii) describes the people who judge the achievements required for membership in an association, not letter writers.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 addresses letters in a section titled "Letters of Support." It begins: "Many petitions to classify a person with extraordinary ability contain letters of support." Such letters are "not without weight," but the Manual states that they should not be the main basis of a successful claim, and the writers' statements "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record."
For the author, the Manual names two things. In the discussion of original contributions it says letters "should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." In the section on letters of support it says that "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness" is a factor the officer should consider. The author's job title, degrees and country of residence are evidence the officer can weigh. None of them is a condition in the regulation.
Does 8 CFR 204.5 set any requirements for the person who signs?
Only for letters that prove experience. Letters from current or former employers must include the writer's name, address and title and a specific description of the duties. Opinion letters have no such rule.
Paragraph (g)(1) of 8 CFR 204.5 states that "Evidence relating to qualifying experience or training shall be in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s)" and "shall include the name, address, and title of the writer" and "a specific description of the duties performed by the alien." If such evidence is unavailable, "other documentation relating to the alien's experience or training will be considered."
The same form appears twice more. For outstanding professors and researchers (EB-1B), paragraph (i)(3)(iii) requires evidence of at least three years of teaching or research experience "in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s)" with the name, address and title of the writer. For exceptional ability (EB-2), paragraph (k)(3)(ii)(B) accepts letters from current or former employers showing at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation.
An employer letter proves a fact: dates and duties. An expert opinion letter gives a judgment about significance, and 204.5 does not say who may give it. The regulation section contains no citizenship, degree or title requirement for the author of an expert or recommendation letter.
Which author fits which EB-1A criterion?
For original contributions, the Manual expects experts in the field who explain the contribution and its significance. For a leading or critical role, it points to persons with personal knowledge of the role.
On original contributions of major significance, the Policy Manual lists among useful evidence "Detailed letters from experts in the field explaining the nature and significance of the person's contribution." It adds that "Submitted letters should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field" and set out the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise. Such letters carry more weight "particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance." For a pending patent the Manual mentions evidence such as detailed reference letters.
On a leading or critical role for an organization, the Manual describes letters from "persons with personal knowledge of the significance of the person's leading or critical role" containing "detailed and probative information that specifically addresses how the person's role" was leading or critical. A chief technology officer or a board member who saw the work fits that description better than an outside professor who did not.
The same file can therefore need different authors: an outside specialist for the contribution to the field, and a person inside the organization for the role. For both, the Manual expects documents in the record that corroborate what the letter says.
Does the author have to be independent of the applicant?
No rule requires it. The Manual makes the relationship a factor and expects acclaim to reach beyond the applicant's personal and professional acquaintances, and an author with no tie to the applicant speaks to that wider recognition.
The Policy Manual states: "It is generally expected that one whose accomplishments have garnered sustained national or international acclaim would have received recognition for their accomplishments well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances." A supervisor or coauthor describes the work as an insider. A letter from an author who has no tie with the applicant is evidence that the work is known outside that circle.
The Manual also describes the letter that adds little: "In some cases, letters from others in the beneficiary's field may merely make general assertions about the beneficiary, and at most, indicate that the beneficiary is a competent, respected figure within the field of endeavor, but the record lacks sufficient, concrete evidence supporting such statements." Letters that "merely reiterate USCIS' definitions relating to this classification" are "generally not persuasive."
In a decision of September 9, 2021 on an EB-1A petition from a researcher with a Ph.D. in neurobiology, the AAO noted that the applicant's doctoral advisor, an editorial board member for "13 professional journals," had signed several of the applicant's invitations to review manuscripts. The AAO wrote that this "appears to have direct and significant consequences" for how the applicant became a reviewer. The Director had denied the petition, finding that the reference letters were not "preexisting, independent, and objective evidence." The AAO disagreed "to some extent," found the original contributions criterion met, withdrew the denial and remanded the case for a final merits determination. The way IAE splits authors between collaborators and independent experts is described in the guide on independent and collaborator letters.
Who can write a letter for an EB-2 NIW petition?
Experts in the applicant's field, U.S. government agencies and quasi-governmental entities, and for entrepreneurs also outside investors, established business associations and other third-party reviewers with knowledge of the work.
The Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 lists evidence for the second Dhanasar prong, that the person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. One item is "Letters from experts in the person's field, describing the person's past achievements and providing specific examples of how the person is well positioned to advance the person's endeavor." The Manual adds that "This list is not meant to be a checklist."
Letters from U.S. government agencies or quasi-governmental entities are "not required," but the Manual states that they "could prove favorable for purposes of the first prong," that detailed letters of government interest "are valuable for purposes of assessing the second prong," and that such an entity can help explain how the waiver may outweigh the labor certification process under the third prong.
For entrepreneurs the Manual names more authors. "Letters may be from, for example, relevant government entities, outside investors, or established business associations" with knowledge of the research, products or services developed by the petitioner or the petitioner's entity, or of the petitioner's knowledge, skills or experience that would advance the endeavor. It explains that entrepreneurs may operate in industries "that have their own industry or technology experts that provide various forms of peer review," and that statements from "relevant third-party reviewers" may have probative value for the first and second prongs.
Footnote 77 of the chapter speaks to the author's credentials: "Petitioners may submit evidence related to the credentials of experts who support a petition for officers to consider when assigning weight to the letter."
Who can confirm recognition for EB-2 exceptional ability?
Paragraph (k)(3)(ii)(F) names peers, governmental entities and professional or business organizations. The Manual calls claims that witness letters are comparable evidence unpersuasive and weighs letters written for the petition below recognition given earlier.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii) an exceptional ability petition "must be accompanied by at least three of the following" six types of evidence. One of them, in 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii)(F), is "Evidence of recognition for achievements and significant contributions to the industry or field by peers, governmental entities, or professional or business organizations." The regulation names the source of recognition and does not mention letters.
Chapter 5 of the Policy Manual adds two limits. On comparable evidence it states that "claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive." In the final merits determination, formal recognition given at the time of the achievement "may have more weight than letters prepared for the petition recognizing the beneficiary's achievements."
An award, a citation in an industry report or a government commendation dated before the petition was filed comes from the same peers and organizations the regulation names, without being written for the case. A letter written for the petition can explain such records, and the Manual weighs it below them.
Who can write a testimonial for an O-1B artist?
Organizations, critics, government agencies or other recognized experts in the field. The Policy Manual requires the testimonial to clearly indicate the author's authority, expertise and knowledge of the beneficiary's achievements.
Chapter 4 of Volume 2, Part M of the Policy Manual lists, as one of the O-1B criteria in the arts, "Evidence that the beneficiary has received significant recognition for achievements from organizations, critics, government agencies, or other recognized experts in the field in which the beneficiary is engaged." It continues: "Such testimonials must be in a form which clearly indicates the author's authority, expertise, and knowledge of the beneficiary's achievements." The O-1B criteria for motion pictures and television set the same requirement for testimonials.
The three words describe different things. Authority is the author's position, for example a festival director, a critic at a publication or an official of an arts agency. Expertise is the author's own record in the field. Knowledge is how the author learned of the beneficiary's achievements, for example by reviewing a performance or selecting the work for an exhibition. A letter that names all three lets the officer check each against the record.
Another O-1B criterion accepts testimonials alongside press: achievements and recognition "as evidenced by articles in newspapers, trade journals, publications, or testimonials." For O-1A, the chapter's section on comparable evidence states that "a statement alone can be sufficient if it is detailed, specific, and credible," in the context of explaining why a criterion does not readily apply to the occupation.
How does an officer check the author's expertise?
From what the letter and the record show: the writer's position and work, the basis of the writer's knowledge, and documents that corroborate the claims. Conclusory statements and questionable opinions get less weight or none.
The rule comes from Matter of Caron International, decided by the Commissioner on October 28, 1988. The Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources" submitted as expert testimony. But "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence." Caron was an H-1 petition for a vice-president of manufacturing at a yarn manufacturer. The letters came from three universities and a yarn spinners' association, and the Commissioner read them for what they actually said about the job.
In an EB-1A decision of December 16, 2024 (Matter ID 35163329), concerning an integration architect in energy efficiency, the AAO quoted the Policy Manual that letters "should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise" and added that "USCIS need not accept primarily conclusory statements," citing 1756, Inc. v. U.S. Attorney General (D.D.C. 1990). The appeal was dismissed.
A CV attached to the letter, a list of the author's publications, or a link to the author's faculty or company page is the material footnote 77 of the NIW chapter describes: evidence of the credentials of experts who support a petition, for the officer to consider when assigning weight.
Must the author know the applicant's work, or only the field?
Both, and the letter must say how. In a 2021 EB-1A decision the AAO noted that a professor who said he had followed the writer's work for ten years did not identify the works.
In a decision of July 15, 2021 the applicant was a writer of fiction and non-fiction, with two novels, a former magazine editor and a university fellow. An associate professor who had translated his work wrote that he had "been following [the Petitioner's] work for more than ten years." The AAO observed that the professor "does not identify or submit these works."
The AAO noted that the petition "relies heavily on letters" written for it and wrote of the claims in them: "These claims may be true, but they have minimal weight without corroborating evidence." It withdrew the denial because the Director's discussion did not suffice as a final merits determination, and remanded the case with an instruction to issue a request that would let the applicant produce documents from before 2015.
An author who knows the field but has not read the applicant's work can still write, but the letter then rests on what the author was given to read, and the letter should name those documents. An author who knows the work names the papers, products, performances or projects, with dates.
What happens if the author's letter conflicts with the rest of the record?
The officer can discount the letter and reassess other evidence. In a 2023 EB-1A appeal, letters described plans the applicant later disowned, and new letters on appeal did not cure the inconsistency.
In a decision of December 1, 2023 (Matter ID 25693008), the applicant was a professor of English. His earlier recommendation letters said he would teach "trauma studies" in the United States, and the Director found his area of expertise to be psychoanalysis. On appeal he argued that his doctorate was in English, that the authors had written without knowing his future plans and knew only "his inclination [] towards psychology," and he submitted new letters stating he would teach English language and literature.
The AAO found the record still contradictory. His May 2022 cover letter spoke of continuing research in "trauma studies and psychoanalysis," and a book printout said he had earned a doctorate in Trauma Studies in 2018. Citing Matter of Ho (BIA 1988), the AAO wrote that "A petitioner must resolve inconsistencies in the record" with independent, objective evidence, and that unresolved material inconsistencies may lead it to reevaluate the reliability and sufficiency of other evidence. The appeal was dismissed.
The authors in that case wrote about plans they had not checked with the applicant. Before signing, an author reads the applicant's CV, the petition's description of the endeavor and the documents the letter refers to, and states facts in the same terms as those documents.
Who signs an IAE expert opinion letter?
An expert from the public IAE registry in the applicant's field. You approve the expert and the CV before work starts, and the expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached to the letter.
Send the applicant's CV and the petition category through the expert opinion letters page. Within one business day the secretariat confirms the expert, the cost and the timeline. The cost depends on the category and the volume of materials. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with analysis under the criteria of the category, for EB-1A, EB-1B, EB-2 NIW, O-1, H-1B or L-1B. The expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code and Member ID.
Under the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002), before an order is assigned the expert confirms in writing that he or she has no personal, financial or professional relationship with the applicant, the client's attorney or the client's employer. If a relationship exists, the secretariat assigns another expert. One expert signs one letter for one petition, and a package of several letters is signed by experts from different organizations. The author is paid a flat fee that does not depend on the content of the letter or on the outcome of the petition and is not told the price paid by the client.
The secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents. The expert checks every statement, corrects or removes anything the expert does not consider supported, and signs only a text that states the expert's own professional opinion. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, with one round of factual edits included. Every letter is checked for overlap with letters issued earlier, and a draft with more than 10 percent of matching sentences goes back to the author.
The standard term is 10 business days and the rush term 5, counted from payment and receipt of all materials. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the expert influences the decision: USCIS weighs the letter together with the rest of the record.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (LII)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, O-1 Beneficiaries
- Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988)
- AAO non-precedent decision, Matter ID 35163329 (December 16, 2024)
- AAO non-precedent decision, extraordinary ability, writer (July 15, 2021)
- AAO non-precedent decision, extraordinary ability, neurobiology researcher (September 9, 2021)
- AAO non-precedent decision, Matter ID 25693008 (December 1, 2023)
Read also
All articles
Does USCIS verify recommendation letters, and what happens when an author does not confirm a letter?
No rule says that every recommendation letter is checked, and no rule says that letters are taken on trust. The statute makes approval depend
EB-1A for athletes and coaches: which criteria fit a sports career, and what should expert letters say?
Athletics is one of the five fields named in the EB-1A definition, and the regulation lists athletic contributions among its criteria. AAO decisions
Comparable evidence in EB-1A and O-1A: what must a letter explain when a criterion does not fit?
When an EB-1A or O-1A criterion does not readily apply to an occupation, the rules allow comparable evidence in its place. USCIS first asksExpert opinion letters
Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?
Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

