Attorneys

For attorneys: how do you order an expert letter and vet the author?

Before an expert letter goes into an EB-1A, EB-2 NIW or O-1 petition, the attorney or paralegal checks the author's qualifications, the author's independence from the beneficiary and every fact in the letter. The USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to weigh the author's relationship with the beneficiary and expects corroboration by documents. Under 8 CFR 292.3 and 8 CFR 1003.102, the grounds for disciplining a practitioner before DHS include offering false evidence knowingly or with reckless disregard.

A lawyer of about 50 with a graying beard, in a vest and no jacket, checks a printed letter against a CV in a small office beside a case folder

What does USCIS look for in an expert letter?

Four things: the author's relationship with the beneficiary, the basis of the author's knowledge, specific statements and documents that corroborate them. For O-1, affidavits must state facts, the author's expertise and how the author got the information.

One sentence in the passage on letters of support in the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 concerns the author: "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements." On content the passage says that "the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record. The letters should explain in specific terms why the witnesses believe the beneficiary to be of the caliber of a person with extraordinary ability." Letters that "merely reiterate USCIS' definitions" or make "general and expansive statements" about the beneficiary "are generally not persuasive."

The basis of the author's knowledge appears in the criterion on original contributions of major significance: "Submitted letters should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field and should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." For a leading or critical role, letters "from persons with personal knowledge of the significance of the person's leading or critical role can be particularly helpful to officers" if they contain "detailed and probative information."

For O-1 petitions, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(2)(iii)(B) says that affidavits written by present or former employers or recognized experts "shall specifically describe the alien's recognition and ability or achievement in factual terms and set forth the expertise of the affiant and the manner in which the affiant acquired such information."

How Matter of Caron International treats a letter as an advisory opinion, and how the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) weighed expert letters in the NIW precedent Matter of Dhanasar, is covered in the guide How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?

How did the AAO treat letters without specific facts in 2024?

On December 16, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an integration architect who relied on four recommendation letters. The letters lacked specific, detailed information, and the AAO wrote that USCIS need not accept primarily conclusory statements.

The petitioner, "an integration architect," sought classification "as an individual of extraordinary ability in energy efficiency" (In Re: 35163329). The Director of the Nebraska Service Center denied the petition. On appeal he claimed original contributions of major significance under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v) "based on four recommendation letters."

One letter, quoted in the decision, said that his work on a notification framework "has resulted in annual saving of over a million USD." The AAO found that the letters limited the relevance of his contributions to his employers and did not establish their significance in the field. It concluded: "In this case, the letters lack specific, detailed information explaining how the Petitioner has made original contributions of major significance in the field. USCIS need not accept primarily conclusory statements." The appeal was dismissed.

For an attorney reading a draft, a figure like that saving is the first statement to trace: which exhibit records it, who made the record and for which year.

How do you check the author's qualifications before filing?

Match the author's degrees, positions and publications with the beneficiary's specialty and with the criterion the letter addresses. Then confirm each credential in a source the author does not control, and note the date of the check.

The Policy Manual asks for "the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise," and the O-1 regulation asks for "the expertise of the affiant." In the file, that expertise rests on the CV attached to the letter. The check takes five steps.

  • Compare the author's specialty with the beneficiary's specialty, using the titles of degrees, positions and publications in the CV.
  • Open the website of the university, company or agency named as the current employer and find the author's position there.
  • Find several of the author's publications or patents in a public database and compare titles, years and co-authors with the CV.
  • Confirm memberships, editorial roles and review work with the organization that granted them.
  • Read the letter for the criterion it addresses and check that the author's experience covers that criterion, such as the state of the field for original contributions or the organization for a leading role.

How do you check that the author is independent of the beneficiary?

Compare the author's CV with the beneficiary's CV and exhibits for shared employers, joint papers, grants and money ties. Then get a declaration signed by the author, and ask that the letter say how the author learned of the work.

The Policy Manual makes the relationship a factor in weighing the statements, and for a leading or critical role it values letters from persons with personal knowledge of the role. A tie that the officer finds in the exhibits and the letter leaves out puts the letter in conflict with the record. Which facts each kind of author can confirm is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?

A search for ties takes five steps.

  • Search the beneficiary's publications and patents for the author's name as a co-author or co-inventor.
  • Compare employers, laboratories and dates in both CVs and look for overlapping periods and for supervision in either direction.
  • Compare grants, projects and conference committees named in both CVs.
  • Ask the author about money: shares or options in the beneficiary's company, paid consulting for the beneficiary, and any fee that depends on the outcome of the petition.
  • Ask the author to state in the letter how and when the author learned of the beneficiary's work.

What should a declaration of independence say?

It names the kinds of ties the author denies, for example personal, financial and professional, and carries the author's signature and date. Read it against the search results. A declaration that denies professional ties while both CVs list the same laboratory for the same years contradicts the exhibits, and the officer reads both.

What should you request from the letter provider?

The author's CV, a signed declaration of independence, a status record you can check without the provider, the list of documents the author reviewed and the draft before signing. Ask also who prepared the draft.

The requests below apply to any provider, including IAE. Each item gives the attorney something to file or to keep in the case file with the date it arrived.

  • Request the author's CV before work starts, with degrees, positions, dates, publications and memberships.
  • Request a declaration of independence signed by the author that names the ties it covers.
  • Request a status record that you can open without the provider's help, such as a public registry entry found by number or QR code.
  • Request the list of the beneficiary's documents the author reviewed, so that each statement in the letter points to an exhibit.
  • Ask in writing who prepared the draft and how the author reviewed it.
  • Request the draft before signing, with a set time for factual corrections.
  • For a package of several letters, request the names of all authors, so that no author signs two letters for the same petition.

What do 8 CFR 292.3 and 8 CFR 1003.102 say about facts in evidence?

8 CFR 292.3 applies the grounds of 8 CFR 1003.102 to practitioners before DHS. The grounds include a false statement of material fact made knowingly or with reckless disregard, offering false evidence and failure to provide competent representation.

Under 8 CFR 292.3(a)(1), "It will be in the public interest to impose disciplinary sanctions against a practitioner who is authorized to practice before DHS when such person has engaged in criminal, unethical, or unprofessional conduct, or in frivolous behavior, as set forth in 8 CFR 1003.102." The sanctions listed there include suspension and expulsion from practice before DHS. Paragraph (b) applies them to any practitioner "who falls within one or more of the categories enumerated in 8 CFR 1003.102."

8 CFR 1003.102(c) covers a practitioner who "Knowingly or with reckless disregard makes a false statement of material fact or law" concerning "any material and relevant matter relating to a case, including knowingly or with reckless disregard offering false evidence." The same paragraph says: "If a practitioner has offered material evidence and comes to know of its falsity, the practitioner shall take appropriate remedial measures."

Paragraph (o) covers a failure "to provide competent representation to a client" and says that "Competent handling of a particular matter includes inquiry into and analysis of the factual and legal elements of the problem."

An expert letter carries facts about the beneficiary: dates, job titles, figures, names of organizations. Each of them can be traced to an exhibit before filing. IAE is not a law firm and does not interpret these rules for a particular case; the text above is quoted from eCFR.

How do you check the facts in a draft letter?

Mark every factual statement in the draft, find the exhibit behind it and compare dates, titles, figures and names. Send all corrections before the author signs and take out statements that no exhibit supports.

The check of one draft takes seven steps.

  • Number the factual statements in the draft: each date, job title, figure, name of an organization and description of the beneficiary's role.
  • Write the exhibit number next to each statement, and send a statement without an exhibit back to the provider with a question.
  • Compare each figure with its source, including the unit, the year and who measured it.
  • Compare the beneficiary's job titles and dates with the CV and the employer letters.
  • Check that every document the author lists as reviewed is in the exhibit list.
  • Take out sentences that only repeat USCIS definitions: the Policy Manual calls letters that merely reiterate them generally not persuasive.
  • Send all corrections to the provider in one round before the author signs.

What if a mistake is found after signing?

Ask the provider for a corrected letter signed again by the same author, and keep both versions with the dates in the case file.

How does an attorney order an expert letter from IAE?

Send IAE the petition category, the beneficiary's field, the deadline, the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition or the RFE. Within one business day the Secretariat replies with the expert, the cost and the deadline.

The order goes through the page for attorneys. The attorney or paralegal sends the petition category, the beneficiary's field and the filing or RFE response deadline, with the beneficiary's CV and the draft petition or the RFE. Within one business day the Secretariat replies which letters make sense for the case, who the expert from the Expert Registry in the beneficiary's field is, the cost and the deadline.

Before the invoice is issued, the attorney receives the expert's CV, degree, memberships and publications and a link to the expert's registry record, and may decline the candidate. The invoice carries the case number. The deadline runs in business days from payment and receipt of the full file and is fixed in the invoice: 10 business days for a letter, 5 in rush mode.

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the beneficiary's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The draft goes to the attorney and the beneficiary. One round of edits covers facts and wording, and the expert's conclusions remain the expert's own. Before delivery the letter passes the IAE checklist: facts, dates and quotations are checked against the beneficiary's documents, and text from earlier letters is not reused except section headings. The attorney receives the signed letter, the expert's CV and the declaration of independence in PDF.

In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the beneficiary. If there is one, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition, and a package of three letters is signed by three different experts. The rules are set out in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002).

How do you verify an IAE expert?

The public Expert Registry lists everyone who writes letters on IAE orders, members of the Association and experts who are not members. The Secretariat checks the CV and identity of a non-member expert, and a member's were checked on admission to IAE. An expert receives orders only after signing the expert agreement with IAE.

The expert number is printed on the expert certificate and in the letter. The QR code on the certificate opens the expert's registry record on iaexperts.com, and a search by number on the registry page finds the same record. If the name, number or fields on the certificate and in the record differ, write to the Secretariat at info@iaexperts.com. The expert's email, phone and address are not published, and the order goes through the Secretariat.

What if the letter is already written?

An IAE expert letter review checks an existing letter against the IAE checklist and gives a written verdict: file, revise or redo. It takes 3 business days. For an RFE or NOID, IAE prepares the expert's answer to each point of the request in 5 business days, 3 in rush mode; the structure of such a letter is covered in the guide Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point.

Is an IAE letter a legal service?

No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice. The attorney is responsible for the case strategy. IAE does not promise that a letter will meet any criterion: USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence and decides the petition.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree