RFE
An RFE says your letters are not independent: how should you respond?
When an RFE says the letters are not independent, the officer may be questioning the authors' ties to the applicant, missing documents behind the letters, text repeated across letters or no account of how each author knows the work. The USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to consider the writer's relationship with the applicant. The response can add new letters and documents about facts that existed on the filing date, and the filed letters stay as filed.

What does the officer question when the RFE says the letters are not independent?
One of four things, or several at once: the authors' ties to the applicant, the missing documents behind the letters, general or repeated text, or no statement of how each author knows the work.
The passage on letters of support sits in the EB-1A chapter of the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2. One sentence in it concerns the author: "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements." How USCIS weighs a colleague's letter against an independent one, and how to split the authors before filing, is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?
The same passage holds the other grounds an officer may cite. The statements made by the witnesses "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record." Letters that "merely reiterate USCIS' definitions relating to this classification or make general and expansive statements regarding the beneficiary and the beneficiary's accomplishments are generally not persuasive." On original contributions of major significance, the chapter adds that submitted letters "should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."
Before the response is planned, the attorney copies every sentence of the RFE that mentions letters and marks which ground it names. Each ground has a different answer.
- The officer names a tie, such as joint papers, a shared employer or supervision. The answer is letters from authors outside that circle and an open list of every tie.
- The officer writes that the statements are not corroborated. The answer is documents: citation records, licenses, contracts and reports of use by other organizations.
- The officer writes that the letters are general, repeat the regulation or share the same wording. The answer is letters in which each author describes what that author read or saw, with dates.
- The officer writes that a letter does not say how the author knows the work. The answer is a signed statement of when and how the author learned of it and which documents the author read.
What did the AAO decide when the record rested on letters?
In 2019 the AAO dismissed an appeal that relied on letters from people who had worked directly with the applicant. In 2025 it dismissed one where the Director had asked for corroborating evidence and received more letters.
The non-precedent decision In Re: 5808571 of November 21, 2019 concerned a materials science engineer whose work dealt with rare-earth free magnets. The Director of the Texas Service Center found the criteria for judging the work of others and for scholarly articles met and denied the EB-1A petition. On original contributions of major significance, the AAO recorded what the RFE had asked for: "In a request for evidence, the Director provided a list of suggested objective evidence the Petitioner could provide in support of this criterion, such as additional support letters from experts, evidence that her work has been widely cited and discussed in the field, or evidence that it has been implemented by others."
The AAO then wrote: "However, the Petitioner seeks to meet this criterion based solely on letters from persons with whom she has directly worked." The AAO accepted the colleagues' letters for one purpose: "As discussed, while we find that the submitted letters from colleagues are effective in describing the Petitioner's original contributions, we disagree with the Petitioner's claim that they 'describe' the present impact of those contributions. The letters that do make such a claim do so in general terms, do not provide specific details, and are not accompanied by independent evidence of that impact." In this decision the word "independent" applied to the evidence of impact. The appeal was dismissed.
In Re: 34878316, decided on February 3, 2025, concerned a business consultant and executive who had been general director of a beauty supply distributorship in 2015-2018. The Director of the Texas Service Center found two criteria met, published material and a leading or critical role. The AAO wrote: "The Petitioner has relied heavily on various letters. While those letters have some weight, they should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record." And then: "When the Director specifically and directly requested such corroborating evidence, the Petitioner responded with more letters and with unsupported claims."
On high salary, the applicant relied on a letter from a former employer. "That letter identified no source to support the claim that the Petitioner's salary was five times higher than the average." The appeal was dismissed.
What can the response add?
Letters from authors who have no tie with the applicant, a dated statement from each author on how the author knows the work, the documents the letters rely on and an open list of every tie.
A new author knows the work from its publications, its citations or its use at another organization, and shares no paper, grant, employer or financial interest with the applicant. The letter says when and how the author first read or used the work and lists the exhibits the author reviewed, with their dates. For NIW, the Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 says under the second prong: "Letters may be persuasive when they are from experts in the person's field who have first-hand knowledge of the person's achievements, describe those achievements, provide specific examples of how the person is well positioned to advance the person's endeavor, and are supported by other independent evidence."
The author's qualifications go with the letter. A footnote in the same chapter reads: "Petitioners may submit evidence related to the credentials of experts who support a petition for officers to consider when assigning weight to the letter." For O-1B petitions in the arts and in motion pictures or television, the O-1 chapter of the Policy Manual requires testimonials in a form that "clearly indicates the author's authority, expertise, and knowledge of the beneficiary's achievements."
A finding on corroboration is answered with documents. A statement about citations points to a citation report with the database and the search date. A statement that other organizations use the method points to a license, a contract or a paper by another group that names the method. Each document records an event before the filing date.
An author whose letter was already filed can sign a new statement, dated on the day of signing, that says how the author knows the work and what tie exists with the applicant. The filed letter stays in the record unchanged.
Every tie goes into the response in writing: joint papers with their years, a shared employer, supervision, a shared grant. In Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791, 795 (Comm'r 1988), the Commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service wrote that "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence." A letter that calls its author independent while the applicant's publication list shows a joint paper with that author is not in accord with the record.
What cannot be done in the response?
The filed letters cannot be swapped for edited versions under the old date, a colleague cannot be presented as independent, and facts that arose after the filing date do not establish eligibility under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1).
USCIS already holds the letters filed with the petition. An edited version of a filed letter with the old date puts two different texts under one date and one signature into the record, and the officer reads both. A new letter carries the date on which the author signed it.
An author who co-wrote papers with the applicant, supervised the applicant or worked at the same organization writes as a colleague. If the joint work ended years ago, the letter gives the years and the officer weighs the tie. The publication list and the CV are already exhibits, so a co-authorship is visible to the officer whether or not the letter mentions it.
Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), an applicant or petitioner "must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request." A new letter is signed after the filing date, and the facts it describes date from before it. A citation, an award or an adoption by another company that came after the filing date does not count toward eligibility on that date. The rule and the cases on it are covered in Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point.
Which finding calls for which filing?
Each finding has its own answer: outside authors for ties, documents for missing corroboration, the author's own account for general text and for a missing basis of knowledge, a CV for expertise.
A finding left without an answer stays in the record as the officer wrote it. Each row below pairs a type of finding with what goes into the response.
The authors are co-authors, supervisors or colleagues
File letters from authors who know the work through published papers or through its use at other organizations, together with a table of every author's ties and their years. The colleagues' letters stay in the record for facts known from inside the project, such as the applicant's share of a joint paper.
The statements are not corroborated
File the documents behind each statement: citation reports with the database and the date, licenses, contracts, reports of use by other groups. The new letters cite these exhibits by number.
The letters are general or repeat each other
File letters in which each author describes, with dates and examples, what that author read or saw. A letter does not restate the regulatory criteria and does not say that a criterion is met, because the officer decides that.
The letter does not say how the author knows the work
File a new signed statement from the author on when and how the author learned of the work, which documents the author read and what tie exists with the applicant.
The author's expertise is not shown
File the author's CV with positions and publications in the field, and add to the new letter a paragraph on the author's own work in that field.
The letters claim impact in general terms
File records of impact that existed on the filing date: papers by other groups that build on the work, products or methods adopted by companies, licenses with their dates. In the 2019 decision the AAO looked for "independent evidence of that impact," and the Director's list named citations and implementation by others.
In what order is the response prepared?
Start from the text of the RFE, then list the filed letters and their authors' ties, then collect documents and choose new authors. The attorney's brief ties each finding to the exhibits.
The order below assumes an RFE. A NOID gives at most thirty days under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), so with a NOID the documents and the new authors are sought at the same time. How the two notices differ is covered in RFE or NOID: what is the difference and how do you answer each?
- The attorney copies every sentence of the RFE that mentions letters, numbers them and marks the ground each names: ties, documents, general text, basis of knowledge or impact.
- A table lists each filed letter with the author's position and organization, every tie with the applicant and its years, and the facts the letter confirms.
- For each criterion or Dhanasar prong in question, the attorney and the applicant list the facts that need confirmation from outside the applicant's circle.
- For each such fact the applicant collects documents that record events before the filing date shown on the receipt notice.
- Each candidate author is checked for joint papers, shared grants, a shared employer and financial interest, and confirms in writing that there is none.
- Each new author receives the RFE, the petition as filed and the exhibits, and the letter states when and how the author learned of the work and which exhibits the author reviewed.
- Dates and job titles in the new letters and statements are checked against the CV and the exhibits before signing.
- The package goes to USCIS at one time before the date in the notice, because under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) additional time to respond may not be granted.
How does IAE prepare a letter for this kind of RFE?
A registry expert with no tie to the applicant answers the findings within the expert's field, points each statement to an exhibit and signs a declaration of independence attached to the letter.
Before the order is assigned, the expert confirms in writing that there is no personal, financial or professional relationship with the applicant, the client's attorney or the client's employer. If a relationship exists, the Secretariat assigns another expert. One expert signs one letter for one petition, and a package of several letters is signed by experts from different organizations. The rules are set out in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002).
An RFE or NOID response letter runs up to 15 pages, with one section per finding and references to the case file. The expert knows the work from the documents listed in the letter, and the letter names them with their dates. The Secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents, and the expert checks every statement, removes what the expert does not consider supported and signs. The standard term is 5 business days, or 3 in rush mode, counted from payment and receipt of all materials. If the findings need two fields, a second expert joins at the assessment stage.
The expert's CV and the declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked in the public Expert Registry by QR code or by the number in the letter. If the attorney decides to file a new petition, an expert opinion letter is prepared under the same rules before filing.
Is an IAE letter legal advice?
No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice; the strategy of the response belongs to a licensed immigration attorney. IAE does not promise any result of the RFE. USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence and decides the petition.
Sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, O-1 Beneficiaries
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (eCFR)
- Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988), Interim Decision 3085
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 5808571, November 21, 2019
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 34878316, February 3, 2025
Read also
All guides
Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point
An RFE tells the petitioner what evidence USCIS requires and sets a deadline of no more than twelve weeks under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv). The response
Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?
The USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to consider the relationship or affiliation between the applicant and the author of a letter when they weigh
How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
USCIS treats an expert letter as one piece of evidence. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use such a letter as an advisory opinionGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

