Examinations
Can you sue for a bad review, and which words in it can be defamation?
A business can sue over a negative review only for statements that a reader would take as facts and that can be proved false; opinion about the service stays protected. In Wong v. Jing (2010) a California appeals court let a dentist's libel claim over a Yelp review go forward because the review implied facts a jury could find false. Federal law bars contract clauses against reviews and shields the review site.

Can a business sue a customer over a negative review?
Yes, for defamation, but only over statements that can be read as facts and proved false. Complaints about quality, taste or service expressed as opinion are not actionable.
In Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., decided on June 21, 1990, the Supreme Court held that "a statement on matters of public concern must be provable as false before there can be liability under state defamation law," at least where a media defendant is involved. Statements that cannot reasonably be interpreted as stating actual facts about a person are protected.
A review often mixes both. In Wong v. Jing, discussed below, the reviewer wrote that he was "really, really angry", and he also made statements about nitrous oxide, mercury in fillings and the seven cavities found by a new dentist, which Wong's account of the treatment could confirm or refute. A defamation claim has to identify the statements of the second kind and show that they are false.
The claim belongs to state law, so the elements, the defenses and the procedure depend on the state where the case is filed. The cases below come from California and from the Supreme Court.
Which parts of a review count as opinion?
Statements that cannot be proved true or false: judgments, impressions and exaggeration. A label attached to a specific event, such as calling someone a liar about a stated transaction, can imply a fact.
Milkovich gives the test with two sentences about a mayor. "In my opinion Mayor Jones is a liar" can be actionable because it implies knowledge of facts showing that Jones told an untruth. "In my opinion Mayor Jones shows his abysmal ignorance by accepting the teachings of Marx and Lenin" cannot, because it states a judgment about ideas.
The opinion collected earlier cases in which words that named crimes were read as rhetorical hyperbole: "blackmail" about a developer's negotiating position in Greenbelt Cooperative Publishing Assn. v. Bresler, and "traitor" in a literary definition of a union scab in Letter Carriers v. Austin.
The prefix "in my opinion" does not change the analysis. Milkovich's own example puts those words in front of an actionable statement: if the statement implies a provably false fact, the label does not protect it.
When can a review be defamatory? What happened in Wong v. Jing?
When it implies false facts about the business. In Wong v. Jing (2010) the California Court of Appeal held that a jury could find a Yelp review falsely implied that a dentist failed to warn about her treatment.
Wong v. Jing, 189 Cal. App. 4th 1354, No. H034059, was decided on November 9, 2010, in an opinion by Presiding Justice Rushing, with Justices Premo and Elia concurring. Yvonne Wong, a pediatric dentist, sued Tai Jing, his wife Jia Ma and Yelp over a Yelp review about the treatment of the couple's young son.
The review said that the boy was "light headed for several hours" after the filling, which the reviewer blamed on nitrous oxide, that silver amalgam fillings contain mercury, that Wong was "really, really fast" and that a new dentist found seven cavities. Wong said that she had disclosed the mercury content of the amalgam, obtained consent and used nitrous oxide as an analgesic, not as a general anesthetic. The family later moved to another dentist.
The court held that Wong showed a probability of prevailing on libel against Jing. It wrote that "the review falsely implies that Wong failed to warn and advise" and that "a jury reasonably could find that the review falsely implied that Wong had failed to warn and advise." On the passage about her speed and the cavities, which the court read as implying that she had misdiagnosed the boy's teeth: "If believed, Wong's statement would refute the implied assertion that she worked so fast." On nitrous oxide, a jury reasonably could find false the implied assertion that she used general anesthesia.
None of those statements used the words "liar" or "fraud". The defamatory meaning came from what the review implied about facts of the treatment, and Wong answered each implication with her own account of what she did.
Is a review on a public site speech on a public issue?
In Wong v. Jing, yes. The court held that the review concerned an issue of public interest, which brought the case under California's anti-SLAPP procedure and required the dentist to show a probability of winning.
The defendants moved to strike the complaint under California's anti-SLAPP procedure. The trial court denied the motion, and the Court of Appeal reversed in part. The court found that the posting "went beyond parochial issues concerning a private dispute about particular dental appointments" and was part of "a public discussion and dissemination of information on issues of public interest."
After that finding, the court asked whether Wong had shown a probability of prevailing on each claim. Her libel claim against Jing met that burden. Her claims against Ma did not: the court wrote that "Wong failed to show probable success on any cause of action against Ma", because Wong offered no evidence against Ma. Jing stated in a declaration that he had written and posted the review without her knowledge.
Wong had to make that showing on the motion to strike, before trial. Her evidence was her own account of the warnings, the consent and the drug she used, set against what the review implied.
Can a business owner add a claim for emotional distress?
In Wong v. Jing that did not work. The court held that being criticized in a Yelp review was not severe or serious distress and that the distress claims were redundant of the libel claim.
The court found Wong's showing insufficient for intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress. Her reaction to "being professionally criticized in a Yelp review" did not reach the level of severe or serious distress, and the court noted that Jing later modified the review on Yelp to delete the allegedly defamatory remarks.
It added: "In light of her libel claim, Wong's alternative claims for infliction of emotional distress are redundant." The case went forward on one claim against one defendant: libel against Jing.
For the reviewer the deletion did not end the case either. The libel claim against Jing survived the motion, although the remarks were no longer on the site.
Can a contract forbid customers to post negative reviews?
Not in a form contract. The Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016, 15 U.S.C. 45b, voids provisions that restrict reviews, impose a penalty or fee for them or take the reviewer's rights in the content.
Section 45b was enacted by Public Law 114-258 on December 14, 2016. It applies to a form contract: standardized terms used in selling or leasing goods or services and imposed without a meaningful opportunity to negotiate. Employer-employee and independent contractor contracts are excluded.
Under 45b(b)(1) a provision is void from the inception of the contract if it restricts a party's ability to engage in a covered communication, imposes a penalty or fee for it, or requires the party to transfer intellectual property rights in the review content, other than a non-exclusive license to use it. A covered communication includes "a written, oral, or pictorial review, performance assessment of, or other similar analysis of" the seller's goods, services or conduct.
The act keeps defamation law in place. Under 45b(b)(2) the voiding rule does not affect duties of confidentiality, civil claims for defamation, or a party's right to remove or refuse to display content on its own website, including content that is clearly false or misleading or unrelated to its goods or services. Offering a form contract with a void provision is unlawful under 45b(c), the Federal Trade Commission enforces the section as an unfair or deceptive act or practice, and a state attorney general may sue as parens patriae.
Can a business sue Yelp or Google over a customer's review?
Generally no. Under 47 U.S.C. 230(c)(1) a provider or user of an interactive computer service is not treated as the publisher or speaker of information provided by another information content provider.
Section 230(c)(1) states: "No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider." An information content provider is "any person or entity that is responsible, in whole or in part, for the creation or development of information" provided through the Internet.
Section 230(e)(3) adds that no cause of action may be brought and no liability may be imposed under any state or local law that is inconsistent with the section. The protection covers information provided by another information content provider; the reviewer who wrote the text is the information content provider for that text.
In Wong v. Jing the dentist named Yelp as a defendant and voluntarily dismissed it before the hearing on the anti-SLAPP motion. The case continued against the reviewer and his wife.
What does a linguist check in a disputed review?
Which sentences state facts and which state evaluations, what facts the wording implies, how the sentences relate to each other and what the whole review says to an ordinary reader. The court decides liability.
Wong v. Jing turned on implication. The review did not state in so many words that Wong failed to warn the parents; it described the fillings and the boy's reaction in a way that, in the court's reading, implied a failure to warn. A linguist describes how such implications arise in the text: which statements are presented as the writer's experience, which as general facts, and which connections between them a reader is invited to draw.
The analysis covers the whole post, the replies and any edits, because the meaning of a sentence depends on what surrounds it. Milkovich asked whether a statement could reasonably be read as stating actual facts; that question is asked about the review as readers saw it.
In a federal case the linguist's written report follows Rule 26(a)(2)(B): a complete statement of all opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, testimony from the previous 4 years and compensation. Whether the review is defamatory remains a question for the court and the jury.
What does IAE prepare when a review is disputed as defamation?
An IAE linguist prepares a report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing linguist's report for a federal or state case, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic linguistics page starts with this question: whether a post states a fact or an opinion. For defamation the linguist separates statements that can be checked against facts from evaluations, reading each sentence in the context of the whole article, post or message thread. IAE puts questions to the linguist about the language of the text and leaves legal conclusions to the court, and the questions are confirmed with the client before work starts.
The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to sue the reviewer is a question for the client's attorney.
Sources
- Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., 497 U.S. 1 (1990) (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Wong v. Jing, 189 Cal. App. 4th 1354, No. H034059 (Cal. Ct. App. Nov. 9, 2010) (Hall Approved)
- 15 U.S.C. 45b, Consumer review protection (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 47 U.S.C. 230, Protection for private blocking and screening of offensive material (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Puffery or false advertising: where is the line, and what does a linguist examine in the claim?
"Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." was puffery, and so was "America's Favorite Pasta." "50% Less Mowing" was a statement of fact. The line between
What is a true threat, when is an angry message a crime, and what does a linguist examine in the words?
A true threat is a serious expression of an intent to commit unlawful violence against a particular person or group. The First Amendment does not
Is satire or parody defamation, how do courts read a joke about a real person, and what does a linguist examine?
Satire about a real person is not defamation if a reasonable reader could not take it as stating actual facts. That is the test the D.C. CircuitExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

