Expert witnesses

Certificate of merit for claims against architects and engineers: does it still apply in federal court after Berk v. Choy?

Several states screen malpractice suits by requiring an affidavit from a professional that the claim has merit, and Texas calls its version for certain professionals a certificate of merit. On January 20, 2026, the Supreme Court held in Berk v. Choy that Delaware's affidavit law does not apply in federal court, because Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8 sets what a complaint must contain. The decision does not reach state courts.

An architect from behind signs a short affidavit beside rolled plans and a stamp

What is a certificate of merit in a claim against an architect or engineer?

It is a screening document filed at the start of a professional negligence suit. Texas requires a certificate of merit under section 150.002 of its Civil Practice and Remedies Code, and subsection (e) provides for dismissal.

The Supreme Court described the medical form of the device in the first lines of Berk v. Choy: "The cost of malpractice insurance for doctors and hospitals has significantly increased in some areas of the country. In response, several States have imposed a screening mechanism on malpractice suits, requiring plaintiffs to submit an affidavit from a medical professional attesting to the suit's merit."

In Texas the requirement is in chapter 150 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. In Sharp Engineering v. Luis, decided on August 10, 2010, by the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston, the appellants were an engineering firm, Sharp Engineering, and Pradeep Shah. Justice Sullivan wrote a concurrence "to note my concerns about the operation and efficacy of this statute" and gave its ostensible purpose as "to provide a mechanism for the threshold elimination of meritless claims."

He also noted where the statute sits. Chapter 150 is in Title 6 of the code, "Miscellaneous Provisions", and not in Title 4, "Liability in Tort", which makes it hard to find. He compared it with Georgia's statute, which in his description covers twenty-six categories of licensed professionals and lets a claimant revive a dismissed action after limitations has run if the failure resulted from mistake or inadvertence.

The question the Supreme Court agreed to decide in Berk was written in general terms. The question presented reads: "Whether a state law providing that a complaint must be dismissed unless it is accompanied by an expert affidavit may be applied in federal court." The Court answered it for one statute, Delaware's affidavit-of-merit law for medical malpractice.

What did the Supreme Court decide in Berk v. Choy?

That Delaware's affidavit-of-merit law does not apply in federal court. Justice Barrett wrote for eight justices, Justice Jackson concurred in the judgment, and the Court reversed the Third Circuit and remanded the case.

The opinion sets out the facts. During a trip to Delaware, Harold Berk fell out of bed and was taken by ambulance to a hospital owned by Beebe Medical Center, where an X-ray showed a fractured ankle. Dr. Wilson Choy recommended a protective boot. Hospital employees forced Berk's leg into the boot and twisted the fractured ankle, and Dr. Choy did not immediately order another X-ray. At the follow-up two weeks later, the second X-ray showed the ankle severely deformed, and it needed surgery.

Berk sued Beebe Medical Center and Dr. Choy for malpractice under Delaware law in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware on November 18, 2022. He immediately moved for an extension of time to file an affidavit, but the clock ran out, and he filed his medical records under seal instead. The defendants asked the District Court to review his submissions in camera. The District Court dismissed the suit on April 4, 2023, for failure to comply with the affidavit law. On July 25, 2024, the Third Circuit affirmed in case No. 23-1620. It held that the Federal Rules are silent on whether an affidavit must accompany the complaint and that, where the Rules are silent, state law applies if it is substantive.

According to the Supreme Court docket, the case was argued on October 6, 2025, and decided on January 20, 2026; the judgment was issued on February 23, 2026. Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Thomas, Alito, Sotomayor, Kagan, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh joined Justice Barrett's opinion. The majority opinion runs 11 pages. Justice Jackson's opinion concurring in the judgment runs 13.

What did Delaware's affidavit law require?

An affidavit of merit signed by a medical professional and filed with the complaint, stating reasonable grounds to believe that each defendant committed health-care medical negligence. Without it or a timely extension motion, the clerk refuses to file the complaint.

Section 6853 of title 18 of the Delaware Code bars a medical malpractice suit "unless the complaint is accompanied by" an affidavit of merit, under section 6853(a)(1). The affidavit must state "reasonable grounds to believe that there has been health-care medical negligence committed by each defendant." Under section 6853(c), a medical professional signs it.

A plaintiff with good cause may obtain a single 60-day extension, but the motion has to be filed before or when the complaint is filed, under section 6853(a)(2). If neither the affidavit nor a timely motion accompanies the complaint, the clerk must "refuse to file the complaint and it shall not be docketed." Defendants need not act until 20 days after the affidavit of merit is filed.

On the defendants' motion, the court decides in camera whether the affidavit meets the statutory requirements, under section 6853(d). Justice Jackson added two details. By statute the affidavit is filed in its own sealed envelope, alongside but apart from the complaint, and its content is neither discoverable nor admissible.

Why does Rule 8 keep the affidavit requirement out of federal court?

Rule 8 already answers what a complaint must contain: a short and plain statement of the claim. The Court found that Delaware demands evidence at the pleading stage, where Rule 8 requires only factual allegations.

The Court used a two-step test. "We first ask whether the Federal Rule 'answers the question in dispute.'" If a Federal Rule answers it, the Rule governs unless it "exceeds statutory authorization or Congress's rulemaking power." Justice Barrett added that "a valid Rule of Civil Procedure displaces contrary state law even if the state law would qualify as substantive."

The majority framed the question in dispute as whether the suit may be dismissed for lack of an affidavit. "Rule 8 gives the answer." Rule 8(a)(2) requires only "a short and plain statement of the claim" showing that the plaintiff is entitled to relief.

The central sentence of the opinion reads: "Unless the Federal Rules single out a claim for special treatment, see, e.g., Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. 9, Rule 8 sets a ceiling on the information that plaintiffs can be required to provide about the merits of their claims." In the Court's reading, Rule 8 establishes "implicitly, but with unmistakable clarity" that evidence of the claim is not required. Delaware asked for more: "Under Rule 8, factual allegations are sufficient, but under the Delaware law, the plaintiff needs evidence too."

The defendants pointed out that an affidavit of merit is a separate document from the complaint. The Court agreed that it is "a document separate from the 'pleading'" and still held that "Rule 8 excludes the possibility of requiring even more information on the same topic."

Does it matter that a state calls the requirement substantive or a precondition to suit?

No. The Court held that a valid Federal Rule displaces contrary state law even when the state law is substantive, and that calling the affidavit a precondition to proceeding does not remove the conflict with Rule 8.

The Third Circuit had applied a two-part test: whether the state law is outcome determinative and whether failing to apply it in federal court would promote forum shopping and the inequitable administration of the law. The Supreme Court did not apply that test, because it found a Federal Rule that answered the question.

The defendants argued that a Rule's validity depends on whether the state law it displaces is substantive. The Court answered: "We rejected that approach eight decades ago and decline to reconsider it now." The reference is to Sibbach v. Wilson & Co., 312 U.S. 1 (1941). In the Court's words, "the substantive nature of [a state] law, or its substantive purpose, makes no difference."

The last argument relied on Cohen v. Beneficial Industrial Loan Corp., 337 U.S. 541 (1949). There a state law required a shareholder suing derivatively to post a bond, and the Court found no conflict, because the state law and Rule 23 addressed different issues. The defendants in Berk read Cohen to protect all state "preconditions to proceeding." The majority said they "substantially overread Cohen" and wrote that describing the affidavit requirement as a "preconditio[n] to proceeding" "does not magically dispel the conflict."

Does Rule 11 leave room for an affidavit requirement?

Not for an affidavit from a third party. Rule 11(a) excuses affidavits with a pleading unless a rule or statute specifically states otherwise, and the Court held that this sentence does not cover third-party affidavits.

Rule 11(a) provides: "Unless a rule or statute specifically states otherwise, a pleading need not be verified or accompanied by an affidavit." The defendants argued that section 6853 is a statute that specifically states otherwise.

The majority rejected the argument: "Even if Rule 11 incorporates some state affidavit laws, it does not incorporate this one." Then: "The sentence has nothing to do with affidavits from third parties. Accordingly, Rule 11 does not shield Delaware's law from displacement by Rule 8."

What did Justice Jackson's concurrence say?

She agreed that Delaware's law does not apply in federal court but found the conflict in Rules 3 and 12(d), not in Rule 8. Under Rule 3, a civil action is commenced by filing a complaint with the court.

Rule 3 states: "A civil action is commenced by filing a complaint with the court." Justice Jackson read it to mean that a federal suit begins when the complaint, and only the complaint, is filed. She wrote that Rule 3 "uses the uncompromising, declarative phrase 'is commenced.'"

Her second ground was Rule 12(d). "Rule 12(d), however, forbids such extraneous considerations," she wrote, and the Delaware affidavit is, "by all accounts," a "matte[r] outside the pleadings."

Justice Jackson called Delaware's requirement "plainly procedural in scope." Quoting Gasperini v. Center for Humanities, Inc., 518 U.S. 415 (1996), she warned against reading the Federal Rules at the expense of "important state interests and regulatory policies." In footnote 6 she listed four decisions of the Fourth, Sixth and Seventh Circuits, decided between 2019 and 2022, that had held state affidavit laws inapplicable in federal court on the basis of Rule 8, and she wrote that these courts, "like the majority, got there by manipulating the relevant question." In her view the conflict lay with Rule 3 and Rule 12 instead.

Does Berk v. Choy change anything in state court?

No. The holding is limited to federal court: "We consider whether Delaware's affidavit requirement applies in federal court and hold that it does not." The opinion does not address suits in state courts.

The majority opinion opens with the federal question and closes with it. On page 11 it states that to decide whether a Rule is valid under the Rules Enabling Act, "the only question is whether it 'really regulates procedure,'" and concludes: "Rule 8 does, so it governs, and Delaware's affidavit law does not apply in federal court." Justice Jackson limited her conclusion to federal court as well.

Berk decided Delaware's medical statute. A federal court asked to apply a state's certificate statute for design professionals starts from the first question the Court set: whether a Federal Rule "answers the question in dispute."

State law still governs other parts of a case in federal court. Justice Jackson recalled Walker v. Armco Steel Corp., 446 U.S. 740 (1980), where the Court held that a federal court hearing a diversity case must apply an Oklahoma law that deemed an action commenced upon service of the summons for purposes of the state limitations period. Rule 3 governs the date from which the timing requirements of the Federal Rules run but does not affect state statutes of limitations.

What problems did Texas courts find in the certificate of merit statute?

In 2010 a justice of the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston listed seven questions raised by recent cases, among them the factual basis the certificate needs and whether a defendant must move to dismiss by any deadline.

Justice Sullivan's concurrence in Sharp Engineering cites the statute as it stood in the 2009 supplement of Vernon's Texas Codes and describes the case law as of August 2010. He wrote that recent cases had raised "some significant issues of statutory construction" and listed them:

  • What counts as an adequate "factual basis" for the certificate under section 150.002(b)?
  • Must the certificate refer to the standard of care? One Houston decision held that it need not recite the standard, while a Beaumont court wrote that the certificate "must necessarily address the applicable standard of care."
  • Must the statements in the certificate meet the standards for admissible evidence?
  • Is a certificate required for claims against a professional that do not sound in negligence?
  • How far does the limited good-cause exception for extending the filing deadline in section 150.002(c) reach?
  • Does the statute reach professionals who do not reside in Texas?
  • Must a defendant move for dismissal by any deadline?

What happens when the certificate is missing or late in a Texas case?

Section 150.002(e) provides for dismissal, which may be without prejudice. In 2010, as Justice Sullivan noted, the statute set no deadline for the defendant's motion, so a defendant could wait until limitations had run.

On the deadline for the motion, Justice Sullivan quoted a Dallas appellate decision: the statute "does not contain any deadline for requesting dismissal." In footnote 9 he wrote that the omission may let a defendant wait for limitations to run, "thus rendering illusory the statute's option of dismissal without prejudice."

In Sharp Engineering, defense counsel did not contend at oral argument that the plaintiff's claim was meritless and argued only that the statute is strict in this context. Justice Sullivan wrote that the drafting had produced "a statute that is a trap for the unwary rather than a screen for meritless claims." In footnote 10 he wrote that the statute "offers no quarter even for an attorney's inadvertence" and gives no meaningful opportunity to cure. In his description, chapter 150 covers only certificates of merit and liability during a disaster, while chapter 74 governs "both substance and procedure of medical-liability suits."

The header of the filed opinion records the result: "Reversed and Remanded, and Majority and Concurring Opinions filed August 10, 2010." The concurrence closed with a hope that other states' statutes "can provide a roadmap to a revised Texas statute" in which "purpose and application more closely align."

How can a defendant in federal court test a claim filed without a certificate?

By a motion for summary judgment under Rule 56. The Court said the Federal Rules already prescribe that mechanism for putting a plaintiff to his proof, after the plaintiff has had adequate time for discovery.

The defendants in Berk conceded that a missing affidavit is not a ground for dismissal under Rule 12(b)(6), for "failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted." The majority then named the rule that tests evidence: "the Federal Rules already prescribe a mechanism for putting a plaintiff to his proof: a motion for summary judgment." Before ruling on that motion, the court must give the nonmoving party "adequate time for discovery."

Justice Barrett wrote that, by design, the federal system of pleading "makes it relatively easy for plaintiffs to subject defendants to discovery," even on claims likely to fail.

How does IAE find an engineer or architect for a certificate of merit or a design case?

Choose the case type Construction and describe the claim, the state, the court and the deadline. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

The construction expert witness page lists seven specialties: structural engineering, geotechnical engineering, architecture, building envelope, MEP systems, cost estimating and scheduling. Among the points a court checks, the page names Texas section 150.002: a claimant suing an architect or engineer for damages over professional services files with the complaint an affidavit of a Texas-licensed professional with the defendant's license and area of practice, or the suit is dismissed.

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel for the conflict check. When a certificate has to be filed with the complaint, give the planned filing date and the defendant's license and practice area in the short description. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years.

Candidate names and CVs come after the search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case