Expert report review

How do you challenge a child custody evaluation, and what does a reviewing psychologist check?

A custody evaluation is evidence that the court weighs, and a parent who disagrees with it can question the evaluator, call a second expert and file a written review of the report. In California, Rule 5.220 of the Rules of Court sets how a court-ordered evaluator gathers data and presents findings. A reviewing psychologist reads the report against that rule and the custody guidelines that the American Psychological Association adopted in February 2022.

A reviewing psychologist reads a report, a child's pencil drawing resting at the edge of the desk

Can a custody evaluation be challenged in court?

Yes. In California any party may call and examine an evaluator whom the court appointed under Evidence Code section 730, and section 733 lets a party present other expert evidence on the same matter.

Rule 5.220 of the California Rules of Court governs child custody evaluations ordered by a court. Under subdivision (b), the court orders an evaluation to assist it in assessing the child's health, safety, welfare and best interest when custody or visitation is disputed. The rule covers court-connected evaluators and private ones.

Evidence Code section 730 lets the court, on its own motion or on motion of any party, appoint one or more experts to investigate, report and testify on a matter that requires expert evidence. Under section 732, such an expert "may be called and examined by the court or by any party to the action." When the court examines the expert, the parties keep the right to cross-examine and to object that Evidence Code section 775 gives them.

Section 733 keeps a second opinion available. Nothing in the article on court-appointed experts prevents a party "from producing other expert evidence on the same fact or matter mentioned in Section 730." The party that calls such an expert pays the fee, and only ordinary witness fees are taxed as costs.

Other states have their own court rules and evidence codes. The examples below come from California because its rule lists each requirement for the evaluator by subdivision.

Which rules and guidelines does the evaluator have to follow?

In California, Rule 5.220 on how the evaluation is run and reported and Rule 5.225 on the evaluator's training. Psychologists also follow the APA Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings of February 2022.

Rule 5.220(i) ties the evaluator's qualifications to Family Code sections 1815, 1816 and 3111 and to Rules 5.225 and 5.230. Rule 5.225(c) names who may serve: a physician who is a board-certified psychiatrist or has completed a psychiatry residency, a psychologist, a marriage and family therapist, a clinical social worker, a professional clinical counselor qualified to assess couples and families, or a court-connected evaluator certified by the court. Each must complete 40 hours of education and training, later 8 hours of update training on the same subjects, and the domestic violence training of Rule 5.230. A private evaluator files a declaration on form FL-326 no later than 10 days after notice of each appointment.

The American Psychological Association adopted its Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings as association policy in February 2022. The document has 23 guidelines and is scheduled to expire 10 years from that date. The APA list of practice guidelines carries it together with the Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology.

The earlier custody guidelines, approved on February 21, 2009, had 14 guidelines. APA keeps them on a page marked as archived and no longer updated. The reviewer records which edition, if any, the report cites.

What does a reviewer check in the data the evaluator collected?

Whether both parents were observed and interviewed in comparable ways, whether each was observed with the child, which records and corroborating sources were used, and which findings rest on one person's account.

Rule 5.220(e)(2) requires data collection that will "allow the evaluator to observe and consider each party in comparable ways." The same paragraph lists the methods: reviewing pertinent documents related to custody, including local police records; observing parent-child interaction unless that is contraindicated to protect the child's best interest; interviewing the parents conjointly, individually or both; and collecting relevant corroborating information or documents as permitted by law.

The APA custody guidelines ask for the same. Guideline 8 asks psychologists to identify, request and review relevant records. Guideline 10 asks for "an evidence-based, multimethod, and multitrait assessment format," and Guideline 18 asks them to include an observation of parent-child interactions.

Under Guideline 9.02 of the Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology, which the APA Council of Representatives adopted on August 3, 2011, forensic practitioners "ordinarily avoid relying solely on one source of data" and corroborate important data whenever feasible.

The reviewer counts the interviews, home visits, observations and hours for each parent from the report's own list of procedures and sets them side by side. Then the reviewer lists every finding that rests on one parent's account alone and checks whether the report says so.

How are the psychological tests in the report checked?

Against the purpose and norms of each instrument. APA asks for standardized administration and instruments with established validity and reliability, and Rule 5.220 asks the evaluator to explain what role the test results play.

Rule 5.220(e)(1)(B) requires the written explanation of the evaluation process to state, "if psychological tests will be used, the role of the results in confirming or questioning other information." A test score in a custody report is one source among several, and the evaluator has to say how it fits with the interviews and records.

APA Guideline 17 asks psychologists to use assessment measures "administered in a standardized and methodologically sound fashion." Guideline 10.02 of the forensic specialty guidelines asks practitioners to use instruments "whose validity and reliability have been established." When they have not been established, practitioners "consider and describe the strengths and limitations of their findings."

For each test the reviewer checks four points: whether it was given under standard conditions, whether its norms fit the person tested, whether the report gives the scores or only the conclusions, and whether the interpretation stays within what the test measures. A conclusion about parenting drawn from a personality scale alone goes into the review with the page where it appears.

Can an evaluator make recommendations about a parent who was not evaluated?

Not under California's rule. Rule 5.220 bars recommendations about a party who was not evaluated directly, and the APA guidelines ask psychologists not to compare parents when only one of them is evaluated.

Rule 5.220(f)(3) says the evaluator may "only make a custody or visitation recommendation for a party who has been evaluated." The ethics subdivision says it again: under (j)(3) the evaluator must "not offer any recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly." Under (j)(1) the evaluator must maintain objectivity, gather balanced information for both parties and control for bias.

The commentary to APA Guideline 19 covers cases in which a psychologist is asked to evaluate only one parent or only the children. In such cases psychologists "endeavor to refrain from comparing the parents and offering recommendations on decision-making." Guideline 9.03 of the forensic specialty guidelines covers people the psychologist did not examine. When an examination is not possible or feasible, forensic practitioners "strive to make clear the impact of such limitations."

A report that compares an interviewed mother with a father who was never contacted gives counsel an objection under (f)(3) and (j)(3) that needs no expert testimony to state.

What must the evaluator's report disclose?

Its procedures, sources and time spent, the information that does not support its conclusions, and the limits caused by information the evaluator could not obtain. Rule 5.220(f) lists these items for California evaluations.

Under Rule 5.220(f), the evaluator must "summarize the data-gathering procedures, information sources, and time spent," present relevant information "including information that does not support the conclusions reached," and "describe any limitations in the evaluation that result from unobtainable information." Recommendations must be clear and detailed. Findings may be presented orally or in writing.

Written reports under Family Code section 3111 are confidential. Rule 5.220(g) requires them to be filed and served with form FL-328 attached as the first page. A report under Family Code section 3118, on allegations of child sexual abuse, goes on form FL-329 and must contain a full analysis of the allegations.

APA Guideline 23 asks psychologists to convey findings "in a manner that is clear, concise, accurate, and objective," and its commentary asks them to "acknowledge significant limitations to the available data." Guideline 11.04 of the forensic specialty guidelines asks for "a complete statement of all relevant opinions." The reviewer compares the list of sources with the facts that the report relies on and marks every fact without a source.

How do you get the evaluator's file and test data?

Through a subpoena or a court order. The forensic specialty guidelines ask psychologists to document all data they consider and, under proper subpoenas or court orders, to make that documentation available.

Guideline 10.06 of the Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology encourages practitioners to document all data they consider "with enough detail and quality to allow for reasonable judicial scrutiny and adequate discovery by all parties." Under Guideline 10.07, "pursuant to proper subpoenas or court orders," they seek to make that documentation available, together with financial records related to the matter and other records that might reasonably be related to the opinions to be expressed.

APA custody Guideline 20 asks psychologists to create, keep and dispose of records under "legal, regulatory, institutional, and ethical obligations," and the commentary reminds them of the legal limits on releasing records. Counsel requests the file well before the hearing, so that the reviewer works from the evaluator's notes, scoring sheets and collateral records.

With the report alone, a reviewer can check its logic, its sources and its compliance with Rule 5.220(f). Rescoring a test or comparing a quoted interview with the notes needs the file.

Can you cross-examine the custody evaluator?

Yes. Evidence Code section 732 lets any party call and examine a court-appointed expert, and Rule 5.220(k) requires each California court to set procedures for cross-examining evaluators quickly and at reasonable cost.

Rule 5.220(k) reads: "Each local court must develop procedures for expeditious and cost-effective cross-examination of evaluators." It names videoconferencing, telephone conferences, audio or video examination and scheduling among the means.

The review supplies the questions. Each point cites a page of the report and the subdivision or guideline it departs from: a different number of interviews for each parent, a test interpreted outside its norms, a recommendation about a parent who was not seen, a source the report quotes but does not list.

Rule 5.220(d) also requires each court to adopt local rules on peremptory challenges to evaluators, on evaluator withdrawal and on complaints. The local rule decides whether a peremptory challenge to a court-appointed evaluator is allowed and when it must be exercised.

When does a party need its own psychologist?

When the dispute turns on the evaluator's method, tests or data. Evidence Code section 733 lets the party present its own expert on the same matter, and that party pays the expert's fee.

The second psychologist can work in two roles. As a reviewer, he or she reads the report and the file and writes a critique that counsel uses for cross-examination or files with the court. As a testifying expert, he or she gives opinions at the hearing and is examined by the other side.

A review of the evaluator's work product is an opinion about method and data. The reviewer did not examine the family, and Guideline 9.03 of the forensic specialty guidelines asks a psychologist who gives opinions about people not examined to have sufficient information or data to form an adequate foundation and to state the limits that follow. So the review answers whether the report meets Rule 5.220 and the APA guidelines and does not recommend which parent should have custody.

If the court orders a new evaluation, the order again sets its scope. Under Rule 5.220(c), a partial evaluation is one "limited by court order in either time or scope."

What does IAE do when a party disagrees with a custody evaluation?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a review of the opposing evaluation or an expert report on the client's questions. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The forensic psychological evaluation and review page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. The review checks the opposing report against the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02), and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03).

IAE frames the questions from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirms them with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix. The Member ID from the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status on the status check page or by QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case.

Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member