Expert report review

How do you challenge a handwriting expert?

Federal courts have admitted, limited and excluded handwriting examiners. In 2016 Judge Rakoff excluded an examiner's forgery opinion in Almeciga; in 2002 an Arizona judge barred an examiner from naming the writer, while a Washington judge admitted the full opinion. A challenge works from the record of the specific examination: originals, known writing, the steps of ANSI/ASB Standard 070, the wording of the conclusion and what counsel told the examiner.

A handwriting examiner studies a signature line through a large magnifier under a desk lamp

Is handwriting comparison testimony admissible in federal court?

Courts have admitted it, limited it and excluded it. Under Rule 702 the party offering the examiner must show the court that each opinion more likely than not meets the rule's four conditions.

Rule 702 lets a qualified witness testify to an opinion if the proponent shows the court that the specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The amendment that stated the more-likely-than-not burden in the text took effect on December 1, 2023, under the Supreme Court's order of April 24, 2023.

The Advisory Committee note to the 2000 amendment cites United States v. Jones, 107 F.3d 1147 (6th Cir. 1997), which found "no abuse of discretion in admitting the testimony of a handwriting examiner who had years of practical experience and extensive training, and who explained his methodology in detail." In United States v. Prime, decided September 20, 2002, Judge Lasnik of the Western District of Washington admitted an examiner's testimony, conclusions included. He wrote that the Kam studies "indicate that handwriting identification is not error-free," yet in those studies lay persons "made far more types of errors than professional examiners." He found the field "sufficiently tested by its long-established use and the research that already has been conducted" and acknowledged that under extensive scientific testing standards "forensic document examination would come up short at the present time."

On November 6, 2002, Judge Martone of the District of Arizona ruled differently in United States v. Hidalgo. He held that "the principle of uniqueness of handwriting or handprinting fails to satisfy a Daubert/Kumho analysis" and barred the examiner from testifying that the maker of a known document is the maker of the questioned one. The examiner could still describe handwriting mechanics, the methodology and the similarities and differences, and the jury would make the finding of identity.

Why did the court exclude the examiner in Almeciga?

Judge Rakoff found no studies testing the techniques examiners use to determine authorship, error rates too high for the task, a subjective method, a skipped verification step and an examiner told by counsel that the release was forged.

In Almeciga v. Center for Investigative Reporting, Inc., 185 F. Supp. 3d 401 (S.D.N.Y.), decided May 6, 2016, the plaintiff's examiner concluded that the signature on a release was a forgery. After a Daubert hearing on December 4, 2015, Judge Jed S. Rakoff granted the defendant's motion to exclude her testimony.

The court wrote that "no studies have evaluated the reliability or relevance of the specific techniques, methods, and markers" that examiners use to determine authorship, and that "the available error rates for handwriting experts are unacceptably high" for the task in the case, which was telling disguised writing from natural writing. The examiner's report was "a series of subjective observations." She applied the ACE-V sequence without its verification step, saying she "didn't feel it was necessary in this matter." The court also cited the 2009 National Academy of Sciences report: "[t]he scientific basis for handwriting comparisons needs to be strengthened."

Plaintiff's counsel had written to the examiner that "[t]he questioned document was a Release that Defendant CIR forged." The court found that counsel "sought to bias" the examiner "from the start." The amended complaint was dismissed with prejudice, and the court found that the plaintiff had fabricated the critical allegations and imposed nonmonetary sanctions.

What does ANSI/ASB Standard 070 require of the examiner?

Standard 070 (2022) has the examiner check whether writing is original, assess distortion and signs of simulation or tracing, judge comparability with the known writing, weigh features in combination, consider alternative interpretations and record limitations.

ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items, first edition 2022, covers comparisons of questioned and known handwritten items and the evaluation of whether the material is sufficient. It sets the steps a reviewer can check one by one against the opposing report and the examiner's notes.

For the questioned writing, the examiner determines whether it is original (6.3.2), looks for signs of slow writing such as "lifts, stops, and hesitations of the writing instrument," patching and unvaried pressure (6.3.6), checks for distortion, which "can be attributable to internal or external factors and can be intentional" (6.3.7), and looks for guide lines, slow execution and unnatural similarity among several questioned items that point to simulation or tracing (6.3.8). The note to 6.3.8 warns that some simulations and tracings do not show significant signs of slow execution.

For the comparison, the examiner evaluates similarities and differences "individually and in combination" (6.5.5), considers alternative interpretations during review (6.7) and bases no conclusion on any single characteristic (6.8.1). The examiner documents the work contemporaneously (6.1), and the documentation records the bases and reasons for each conclusion and any limitations (6.6). Under 6.8.3, conclusion phrases come from professional document examination organizations and published standards. A report that gives a conclusion without the steps, or notes made after the fact, falls short of these requirements.

Did the examiner work from originals?

Standard 070 tells the examiner to request the original when the questioned writing is a reproduction and to stop if the copy is not clear enough. Copies can hide guide lines, pressure, stroke sequence and erasures.

Section 6.3.2 reads: "If it is not original writing, request the original." If no original is submitted, the examiner judges whether the reproduction is clear enough for analysis and, if it is not, discontinues and reports. The note to the section says "examination of the original writing is preferable" because reproductions can conceal guide lines, pressure, stroke sequence and erasures, the same features that separate a traced or simulated signature from a natural one.

The Florida Department of Law Enforcement tells submitters the same thing in practical terms: "Ideally, the original will be the BEST evidence," the laboratory can examine machine copies of questioned or known documents, and "when originals can be obtained, they should be submitted." A report written from a copy should say so and limit its conclusion.

Federal Rule of Evidence 1003 admits a duplicate "to the same extent as the original unless a genuine question is raised about the original's authenticity or the circumstances make it unfair to admit the duplicate." A signature dispute is that kind of question, so the party challenging the examiner asks for the original to be produced and examined.

Was the known writing sufficient and comparable?

The reviewer checks how many known samples the examiner used, who collected them, whether they date from about the same period as the questioned item and whether they are the same type of writing.

Standard 070 lists features that limit comparability: the type of writing, writings that are not contemporaneous, text content, capture methods, writing instruments and surfaces (6.5.2.1). The note to that section says "A lack of contemporaneous writings can hamper the assessment of characteristic dissimilarities." Known specimens may be written in the normal course of business or written at request for comparison, and specimens collected solely by a stakeholder may not show the writer's full range of variation (6.4.3(c)).

Section 6.5.5 defines a dissimilarity as a feature absent from all the known specimens; a feature that appears in even one specimen is within the writer's range. With a small set of known signatures, a feature can look foreign that a larger set would show as normal variation. In its submission FAQ the Florida Department of Law Enforcement suggests "25+ of the questioned signature with strong hand, 1 weak hand" as the amount of known writing for a questioned signature. In Almeciga the court noted that the field had no objective standard for how many exemplars or similarities are needed.

The known writing must itself be proved. Rule 901(b)(3) permits "a comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact," and 28 U.S.C. § 1731 makes "the admitted or proved handwriting of any person" admissible for comparison to determine the genuineness of other handwriting attributed to that person. If the origin of a known sample is disputed, every opinion that uses it inherits the dispute.

How strong is the examiner's conclusion, and is it worded within limits?

SWGDOC terminology uses nine levels between identification and elimination, with no conclusion in the middle. The 2023 note to Rule 702 says forensic experts should avoid claims of absolute certainty when the method is subjective.

SWGDOC published standard terminology for document examiners with nine levels: identification, strong probability, probable, indications, no conclusion, indications did not, probably did not, strong probability did not, and elimination. "Probable" means the evidence points rather strongly toward the same writer but falls short of virtual certainty. The terminology rejects "possible" and "could have" because they say nothing about probability. The court in Prime described the same nine-point scale.

The 2023 committee note to Rule 702 sets two limits. Forensic experts "should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty," or of certainty "to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty," "if the methodology is subjective and thus potentially subject to error." Expert testimony on the weight of feature comparison evidence "must be limited to those inferences that can reasonably be drawn from a reliable application of the principles and methods."

A reviewer compares the stated level with the limitations the examiner recorded. An identification from a photocopy, from a handful of non-contemporaneous signatures or from a short signature with few features is a level the record may not support, and the reviewer explains which limitation caps it.

Did the examiner know what the client wanted to hear?

In Almeciga the court treated counsel's statement that the release was forged as a source of bias. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), facts, data and assumptions that counsel gave a reporting expert can be discovered.

Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects communications between a party's attorney and a reporting expert, with three exceptions. Communications are discoverable if they relate to compensation, if they "identify facts or data that the party's attorney provided" and the expert considered, or if they "identify assumptions that the party's attorney provided" and the expert relied on.

For a handwriting examiner, the cover letter that sent the documents, the list of known samples and who chose them, and any description of the case fall within those exceptions when the examiner considered or relied on them. A deposition under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) can follow once the report is served, and the party seeking it pays the examiner a reasonable fee for the time spent under Rule 26(b)(4)(E)(i), unless manifest injustice would result.

Standard 070 requires the examiner to consider alternative interpretations during review (6.7). A report that never mentions an alternative, such as natural variation, disguise by the writer or a different writer with similar letter forms, gives the challenger a specific point to raise.

Can a lay witness or the jury compare the handwriting instead?

Yes, within limits. Rule 901(b)(2) permits a lay opinion based on familiarity not acquired for the litigation, and Rule 901(b)(3) lets the expert or the trier of fact compare the writing with an authenticated specimen.

Rule 901(a) requires the proponent of an item to produce "evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is." For handwriting, Rule 901(b)(2) accepts "a nonexpert's opinion that handwriting is genuine, based on a familiarity with it that was not acquired for the current litigation." A spouse, a business partner or a bank officer who has seen the person sign for years can testify on that basis.

Under Rule 901(b)(3) the jury itself may compare the questioned writing with an authenticated specimen. Hidalgo used that route: the examiner described the similarities and differences, and the court left "the ultimate finding of identity or non-identity" to the jury.

A challenge to the examiner therefore does not end the handwriting question. The side that wins an exclusion still faces lay witnesses and the jury's own comparison, and prepares its known samples for that.

When is a rebuttal report on handwriting due?

Absent a stipulation or court order, within 30 days after the other side's expert disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii). A rebuttal report from a retained examiner contains the six items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B).

The six items are a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years, a list of cases in which the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition in the previous 4 years, and the compensation to be paid.

The 30-day route covers evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject. An affirmative opinion of one's own, for example that a different person signed, falls under the general deadline of Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(i): at least 90 days before the date set for trial or for the case to be ready for trial, unless the court sets another date.

A Rule 702 motion follows the schedule the court sets. The review supplies its content: each objection tied to subdivision (b), (c) or (d) of Rule 702, to a section of Standard 070 and to a page of the opposing report.

What does IAE do when a party needs a review of a handwriting examiner's report?

IAE prepares reviews of the opposing handwriting examiner's report and expert reports on questioned signatures and entries for federal and state cases. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

On the handwriting and signatures page the review checks whether the report states each opinion with its basis and the facts or data considered, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires, and whether the examiner followed Standard 070 on originals, comparability, distortion and alternative explanations. For a report on your own questions, the examiner compares the questioned signature or entry with known writing under Standard 070 and checks it for slow writing, guide lines and unnatural similarity between questioned signatures.

The client sends the questioned document or its best copy, the known writing and the opposing report, and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report or review is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member