Examinations

Can a notarized signature be challenged as forged, and what does the handwriting examiner have to show?

A notary's stamp does not make a signature unchallengeable, but it changes the proof. In New York a certificate of acknowledgment raises a presumption of due execution that falls only to evidence so clear and convincing as to amount to a moral certainty. In Kanterakis v. Minos Realty (2017) a forgery judgment was reversed, and the expert's testimony was set aside because the known signatures had never been authenticated. New York decisions state what an examiner's opinion needs.

A blank brass embosser sits by a turned-away signature page and a loupe under a warm lamp

Does a notary's certificate prove that the signature is genuine?

It is evidence of genuineness, not conclusive proof. Under New York CPLR 4538 a certified acknowledgment is prima facie evidence that the writing was executed by the person who purported to do so, and the presumption can be rebutted.

Rule 4538 of the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules says that certification of the acknowledgment or proof of a writing, except a will, in the manner prescribed for a conveyance of real property within the state, "is prima facie evidence that it was executed by the person who purported to do so." The Appellate Division put it this way in Moffett v. Gerardi (2010): a certificate of acknowledgment attached to an instrument such as a deed raises a presumption of due execution.

Federal courts start one step earlier, at admissibility. Under Rule 902(8) of the Federal Rules of Evidence a document accompanied by a certificate of acknowledgment that is lawfully executed by a notary public is self-authenticating and requires no extrinsic evidence of authenticity to be admitted. The advisory committee's note explains the reason: in virtually every state, acknowledged title documents are receivable in evidence without further proof.

Neither rule decides who signed. Admission and a presumption put the document in front of the court with a head start, and the party who denies the signature then has to produce evidence against it. How much evidence depends on the state.

What proof overcomes the presumption?

In New York, proof so clear and convincing as to amount to a moral certainty. A bare denial by the person named, or affidavits of interested relatives, does not rebut a certificate of acknowledgment.

The Second Department applied the standard after a full trial in Kanterakis v. Minos Realty I, LLC, 151 A.D.3d 950 (June 21, 2017). The plaintiff sued to void a power of attorney dated August 7, 2002 in favor of his wife. Acting under it, she obtained a bank loan secured by commercial property and in 2005 deeded the property to a company. In 2007, as the company's managing member, she obtained a $1.375 million loan secured by a mortgage on the property. After a nonjury trial the court found the power of attorney forged. The Appellate Division reversed and directed a judgment dismissing the complaint and declaring that the power of attorney is not null and void. A certificate of acknowledgment, it wrote, "should not be overthrown upon evidence of a doubtful character," but only on proof so clear and convincing as to amount to a moral certainty.

The plaintiff's own denial, the testimony of a family member and a set of emails were not enough. The emails lacked a proper foundation and contained no express admission of forgery. The court repeated the rule that something more than a bald assertion of forgery is required to create an issue of fact.

Oro v. Figeroa, 208 A.D.3d 1338 (2d Dep't Sept. 28, 2022) shows the same rule applied to old documents. Defendants claimed that signatures on 1950 probate documents and a 1952 deed in the plaintiff's chain of title were forged. They offered affidavits of interested parties, two documents said to carry genuine signatures and a third on which the handwriting was not shown to be a signature. The comparison signatures were barely visible because of poor copy quality and, where visible, resembled the challenged ones. The court held that the defendants had failed to raise a triable issue of fact and reversed the denial of summary judgment to the plaintiff.

What does the handwriting examiner have to show?

An opinion stated with reasonable professional certainty that the signature is not authentic, resting on known signatures that have themselves been authenticated and are comparable with the questioned one. Without authenticated known writing the opinion is not considered.

New York courts use a fixed phrase: if an expert opinion is offered, the expert must "state with reasonable professional certainty that the signature at issue is not authentic." In Bank of New York Mellon Trust Co. v. Pruitt, 2026 NY Slip Op 04271 (2d Dep't July 8, 2026), a mortgage foreclosure, the borrower counterclaimed that her signatures on the note and the mortgage were forged. Her handwriting expert compared the disputed signatures with known writing samples and stated that the signatures on the loan documents were not written by her. That affidavit, together with her other submissions, raised a triable issue, and the forgery counterclaim survived summary judgment.

Kanterakis shows the other outcome. The plaintiff's examiner had relied on exemplar signatures that were never authenticated, and the Appellate Division held that the expert's testimony should not have been considered at all. The rule behind that holding is general. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 901(b)(3) a comparison is made "with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact." Each known signature therefore needs its own proof of who wrote it, for example the testimony of a witness with knowledge under Rule 901(b)(1).

The examination standard adds requirements of its own. ANSI/ASB Standard 070 (2022) tells the examiner who receives a copy to request the original and notes that examination of the original writing is preferable, because reproductions can hide guide lines, the type of writing instrument, stroke direction, pressure and erasures. It lists non-contemporaneous writing among the factors that limit comparability and warns that known specimens collected solely by a stakeholder may not show a writer's full range of variation. The examiner shall consider alternative interpretations, and a conclusion is not based solely upon any one characteristic.

For a notarized document this has a practical consequence. When a recorded deed or mortgage reaches the examiner as a copy, the request for the original goes out first, and the report states what was examined.

What can the notary's testimony add?

The notary can describe how the acknowledgment was taken and whether it followed his or her usual practice. Testimony that it did not can rebut the presumption together with the signer's sworn denial.

In Moffett v. Gerardi, 75 A.D.3d 496 (2d Dep't July 6, 2010), a deed dated January 16, 1998 transferred the plaintiff's entire interest in a property to his brother-in-law. The plaintiff said his signature was forged. The defendant produced the notarized deed with its certificate of acknowledgment and moved for summary judgment. The notary testified at a deposition that the deed was not notarized in his usual manner and that he would not testify that the signature belonged to the plaintiff. That transcript and the plaintiff's affidavit rebutted the presumption and raised a triable issue of fact, and the Appellate Division reinstated the denial of summary judgment.

In Kanterakis the notary's testimony gave the challenger nothing. The notary who took the acknowledgment had no independent recollection of it, and a coworker had no personal knowledge of the execution and acknowledgment. The court held that this testimony did not help the plaintiff.

The questions for the notary's deposition follow from Moffett and concern practice: how identity was checked, whether the signer appeared in person, what records the notary kept and whether they still exist. If the notary kept a record of the act with the signature of the person who appeared, that entry is known writing made on the same day as the questioned signature.

What other evidence do courts weigh besides handwriting?

Credible testimony, contemporaneous documents that contradict the instrument and the absence of any record of the underlying transaction. In Kupperstock v. Kupperstock that evidence rebutted the presumption against an expert who called the signature genuine.

Kupperstock v. Kupperstock, 163 A.D.3d 940 (2d Dep't July 25, 2018) began with a 1997 divorce stipulation that gave a house to the wife. Weeks later an $840,000 mortgage in favor of Zvi Kupperstock, dated 1994 and payable in 2017, was recorded against the property. Zvi Kupperstock had died in 1996, and her former husband administered his estate. The wife swore that she had never borrowed money from him and had never knowingly signed the mortgage or the note.

The estate relied on the acknowledgment and on a handwriting expert's affidavit attesting that the signature was genuine. That made a prima facie showing, but the wife's sworn denial and contemporaneous documents that contradicted the mortgage raised a triable issue. After trial the court found her credible and held that she had rebutted the presumption. The mortgage was cancelled and discharged, and the Appellate Division affirmed, noting the lack of documentary support for the mortgage and the note.

An expert affidavit of genuineness did not decide the case. The trial court found the wife's testimony consistent and credible and noted that no documents supported the mortgage or the note.

When is the forgery question decided, and what must the expert's papers contain?

A sworn expert affidavit with other evidence can carry the claim past summary judgment, and the heightened standard is applied to the whole record at trial. An unsworn report or unauthenticated known writing may not be counted.

The cases sort by stage. In Pruitt and Moffett the challenger only had to raise a triable issue, and a sworn expert affidavit or the notary's testimony was enough for that. In Moffett the plaintiff had also submitted an unsworn handwriting expert report, and the court's reasoning rested on the notary's testimony and the plaintiff's affidavit instead. In Kanterakis and Kupperstock the question was decided after trial on the full record, under the moral certainty standard.

In federal court the form of the expert's work is set by rule. A retained examiner's report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure contains a complete statement of all opinions with the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the witness's qualifications and a statement of compensation. For a signature case the facts or data are the questioned document, each known signature with its source and date, and a note on whether originals were examined.

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion is based on sufficient facts or data and is the product of reliable principles and methods reliably applied to the facts of the case. Kanterakis and Standard 070 name two weak points in the data behind a comparison: known signatures that were never authenticated and known writing that is not contemporaneous with the questioned signature.

What does IAE do when a notarized signature is disputed?

A handwriting examiner prepares a report on the questioned signature or a review of the opposing examiner's report for a federal or state case, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The handwriting and signature examination page states the questions: whether the person named on a will, contract or check signed it, and whether the signature shows signs of simulation or tracing. Under ANSI/ASB Standard 070 the examiner checks whether questioned and known writing are originals and comparable, then weighs similarities and differences together. Section 6.3.8 of the standard has the examiner look for slow writing, guide lines and unnatural similarity between multiple questioned items.

A review of the opposing report checks whether it states each opinion with its basis and the facts or data considered, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires, and whether the examiner followed Standard 070 on originals, comparability and alternative explanations. Absent a stipulation or court order, a rebuttal report is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii).

The client sends the questioned document, or the best available copy with a note on where the original is, the known signatures with their sources and dates, the certificate of acknowledgment, any testimony of the notary and the questions. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist chosen in its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. The report is evidence the court weighs with the other materials. Neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member