Expert report review

How does a reviewer check the child interview in a custody evaluation?

A reviewing psychologist checks the child interview in a custody evaluation in the evaluator's notes and recordings as well as in the report. The review asks how each question was put, who was present, how many times the child was asked and whether the report keeps the child's words apart from a parent's. The 2022 APA custody guidelines, research on question types and a court ruling on suggestive interviews supply the measures.

A low table holds toy blocks and a dark voice recorder beside a child's empty chair

What do the APA custody guidelines ask of an evaluator who interviews a child?

Guideline 13 asks evaluators to select and use developmentally appropriate, empirically supported techniques with children. Its commentary says interviewing children requires specific knowledge and skills and an approach fitted to each child's age, language ability and development.

The American Psychological Association adopted its Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings as association policy in February 2022. Guideline 13 covers the evaluation of children. Its rationale calls for "a developmentally appropriate, multimethod approach to assessment," and its application lists methods that include observation of the child, observation of parent-child interactions under Guideline 18 and developmentally appropriate interviewing.

The commentary states that "interviewing children requires specific knowledge and skills" and that psychologists "strive to utilize approaches consistent with each child's age, language ability, and developmental level." It asks them to avoid adding to a child's distress during the process and to stay alert to any inadvertent harm the evaluation itself may cause. Psychological tests with children "may not be necessary or appropriate" when they do not shed light on the child's best interests.

Collateral sources fall under the same guideline. Psychologists "seek to identify and interview collateral sources who can best help them understand the child's needs" and focus on "the collateral source's direct observations and the factual basis for any opinions expressed." A teacher who watched the child at school pickup and a relative who repeats what one parent told her supply different kinds of data, and the reviewer checks whether the report weighs them differently.

Which kinds of questions make a child's answers less reliable?

Questions that offer the answer or assume facts the child has not mentioned. Research on the NICHD interview protocol found answers to open-ended invitations more accurate and three to five times more informative than answers to focused prompts.

Michael Lamb and four co-authors reviewed the research on the NICHD Investigative Interview Protocol in Child Abuse & Neglect in 2007 (volume 31, pages 1201-1231). The review sorts interviewer utterances into four types. An invitation is "an open-ended request that the child recall information about the incident." A directive is a cued-recall prompt that focuses the child's attention on information already mentioned. An option-posing prompt focuses on details "not previously mentioned" and asks the child to confirm, deny or choose an option the interviewer offers. A suggestive utterance "assumes information not disclosed by the child."

The findings come with numbers. The authors report that responses to individual free-recall prompts are "three to five times more informative" than responses to focused prompts, and that responses to open-ended questions "are more likely to be accurate." Recognition questions were "even riskier when addressed to children aged 6 and under." Children as young as 4 gave substantial information in response to free-recall prompts, and on average almost half of the information children provided came from such prompts, regardless of age.

Interviewers trained on the protocol used at least three times more open-ended prompts and about half as many option-posing and suggestive prompts as comparison interviewers. Even so, details elicited by option-posing and suggestive prompts made up about a quarter of the total under the protocol.

The protocol was written for investigative interviews about abuse, and the APA custody guidelines do not adopt it by name. Its four categories still give the reviewer a fixed way to code the evaluator's questions. The reviewer applies them to each topic of the interview: which parent the child prefers, events in the other home, any allegation against a parent.

What have courts said about suggestive interviews of children?

In State v. Michaels (1994) the New Jersey Supreme Court listed practices that make an interview suggestive or coercive and required a pretrial hearing on whether the children's statements remained reliable.

State v. Michaels was decided on June 23, 1994, in an opinion by Justice Handler. The case was a criminal prosecution built on young children's statements. The court held that, if the State retried the case, "a pretrial hearing must be held in which the State must prove by clear and convincing evidence" that the statements and testimony kept sufficient reliability. The defendant first had to show "some evidence" that the statements came from suggestive or coercive interviewing.

The opinion named the practices it examined: "a lack of investigatory independence," "the pursuit by the interviewer of a preconceived notion of what has happened to the child," "the use of leading questions" and "a lack of control for outside influences on the child's statements." It added that "The use of incessantly repeated questions also adds a manipulative element to an interview" and listed the vilification of the accused, "mild threats, praise, cajoling, bribes and rewards," peer pressure and "the failure to videotape or otherwise document the initial interview sessions."

Michaels is a criminal decision of one state court, and its taint hearing was built for a criminal trial. Its list still works as a checklist for a custody file: who spoke with the child first, whether the evaluator began with a hypothesis taken from one parent's account, whether questions were repeated after the child had answered, and whether the early sessions were recorded.

What does the reviewer need from the evaluator's file?

The interview notes, any recordings, the schedule of sessions and the correspondence. Guideline 20 lists test data, interview notes, interview recordings and correspondence among the records, and the report's summary is checked against them.

Guideline 20 asks psychologists to create, maintain, convey and dispose of records in line with their legal, regulatory, institutional and ethical obligations. The commentary notes that "the documentation created during the evaluation process may be used as evidence in legal proceedings" and that records may include "test data, interview notes, interview recordings, correspondence." Release of the file follows the legal obligations and restrictions that apply in the case, and counsel requests it through the court's procedures.

With the file the reviewer reconstructs each contact with the child: the date, the length, the place, who brought the child, who was in the room or the waiting area, and what came right before, such as a session with one parent. A child seen once, straight after an hour with the parent who brought him, leaves a different record than a child seen twice, once after each parent's visit.

The notes are then read for the wording of the questions. If the notes record only the child's answers, the reviewer cannot tell an invitation from an option-posing question, and the review states that limit for each answer the report relies on. Michaels counted the failure to document the initial sessions among the problems, and Guideline 13 itself names "repeated questioning or subtle suggestibility" as concerns.

How does the reviewer read a child's stated preference?

As one piece of data with its context. California courts weigh the wishes of a child of sufficient age and capacity, and no child has to state a preference, so the reviewer checks how the preference reached the report.

California Family Code section 3042(a) provides that if a child "is of sufficient age and capacity to reason so as to form an intelligent preference as to custody or visitation," the court "shall consider, and give due weight to, the wishes of the child" in making or modifying a custody or visitation order. Subdivision (i) adds that the section "does not require the child to express to the court a preference." Guideline 1 of the APA custody guidelines notes that "considerations of the children's wishes are often regulated by law."

The reviewer separates three things a report may merge: what the child said, the reasons the child gave and the evaluator's interpretation. A preference quoted with no question attached cannot be checked. A preference given in answer to a question that named one parent's home first is an answer to an option-posing prompt in Lamb's categories. A preference stated in the same words as a parent's interview goes into the review with both passages side by side.

Age enters the same way. In Lamb's review recognition questions carried more risk for children 6 and under, and Guideline 13 ties methods to each child's developmental level. A report that gives a five-year-old's choice of parent the same weight as a twelve-year-old's reasoned account, with no discussion of development, becomes a point of the review.

What if the child wants to talk to the judge?

In California a child 14 or older who wishes to address the court may do so unless the court finds otherwise, and the evaluator tells the judge about that wish and about any later change.

Section 3042(c) lets a child 14 or older who wishes to address the court about custody or visitation do so, "unless the court determines that doing so is not in the child's best interest," and the court then states its reasons on the record. Under subdivision (d) a younger child may address the court when the court finds that appropriate. If the court precludes calling the child as a witness, subdivision (e) requires "alternative means of obtaining input from the child and other information regarding the child's preferences."

Subdivision (f) keeps the parents out of the room: the court "shall not permit a child addressing the court regarding custody or visitation to do so in the presence of the parties," unless it finds for stated reasons that their presence is in the child's best interest. Subdivision (g) puts a duty on the professionals: minor's counsel, "an evaluator, an investigator, or a child custody recommending counselor" shall indicate to the judge that the child wishes to address the court. Under subdivision (h), if the child later changes that choice, the evaluator tells the judge, the parties or their attorneys and the other professionals on the case "as soon as feasible."

The reviewer checks the report and the file for both steps. If the notes show that the child asked to speak to the judge, or withdrew the request, and the report is silent, the review records the dates. When the child did speak to the judge, the reviewer compares what the child said there, and with whom present, with the evaluator's account of the child's views.

How does the reviewer test whether a parent shaped the child's account?

By comparing the child's words with each parent's interview and with the timeline of contacts, and by checking whether the evaluator tested more than one explanation. Guideline 5 asks evaluators to evaluate hypotheses when a child resists a parent.

Guideline 5 concerns resistance and refusal of contact: "Psychologists strive to evaluate hypotheses when assessing a case of resistance-refusal." Its commentary lists factors that can align a child with one parent, among them "having been abused, neglected, or poorly parented by the rejected parent" and "having a preexisting preference for one parent over the other." The guideline names causes that lie with the rejected parent and with the child, so a report that tests only the other parent's influence has tested one hypothesis.

Guideline 11 warns that "cognitive, confirmatory, implicit, or other biases may compromise a custody evaluation" and asks psychologists to be skeptical of their own objectivity. Michaels described the same risk in interviewing terms: an interviewer pursuing "a preconceived notion of what has happened to the child." In a file it appears as questions that carry the first parent's account into the child's interview.

The reviewer builds a side-by-side table: the phrase in the child's interview, the same or a similar phrase in a parent's interview or pleadings, the dates of both, and whether the child stayed with that parent between them. Adult wording in a young child's account that matches a parent's complaint word for word is recorded with page references. Whether it came from coaching is a question the evaluator had to test, and the review asks where that test appears in the report.

Should the reviewing psychologist interview the child again?

No. A reviewer works from the evaluator's file and examines no one, and another interview adds the repeated questioning that Guideline 13 warns about. Whether a new evaluation is needed is for the court.

Guideline 13 asks psychologists to "be aware of the concerns that may be engendered by such factors as repeated questioning or subtle suggestibility that may influence children's responses" and to avoid adding to a child's distress. Every new interview about the same events is one more round of questions about them, and each round becomes part of the history any later evaluator has to account for.

A reviewer who has examined no one also has no data on the child's present views. The review states its limits: it addresses how the evaluator obtained the child's statements, how they were recorded and how the report used them. Requests for a new evaluation, for the child to address the court or for minor's counsel go to the court through counsel.

Where the interview record is missing, the request that follows from the review is for the record itself: the notes, the recordings and the schedule of sessions under Guideline 20. A further interview of the child would add a session to a record that is already incomplete.

What does IAE do when a party needs the child interview in a custody evaluation reviewed?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review of the evaluation or a review of the opposing psychologist's report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The custody evaluation review page lists the child interview among the reviewer's checks: Guideline 13 asks for developmentally appropriate methods and warns that repeated questioning or subtle suggestibility may influence a child's answers. The reviewer measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The reviewer reads the report and the underlying data, does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.

IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The client sends the evaluation, the court order and the materials of the case and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV. The draft is checked for facts, and the signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, verifiable by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member