Expert report review

Two ink dating experts disagree: why do the results differ, and what does the court do?

Two ink dating examinations of one document disagree when the examiners used different methods, tested different entries or read the effect of heat and light differently. In Ceglia v. Zuckerberg a defense chemist dated a handwritten interlineation to the two years before testing, while an ink specialist retained by counsel for the plaintiff took ten vials of ink and gave no dating opinion. A reviewer traces each answer to the test behind it.

Two closed report folders sit on either side of a document under a stereo microscope

Why do two ink dating examinations of one document reach different results?

Ink dating is a group of methods. A comparison with a reference collection, a relative aging comparison between entries and a heating test answer different questions, and each depends on the ink formulation and on the document's history.

Gerald M. LaPorte, then with the National Institute of Justice, summarized the field in an abstract for the 2011 meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. He described two approaches. The static approach compares an ink with a standard reference collection of inks to determine the first date of production of its formulation. The dynamic approach measures properties that change as ink ages, a process that involves the "evaporation of solvents and complex interactions." The abstract states that "there still exists significant controversy about the accuracy, reliability, and validity of the dynamic procedures."

Within the dynamic approach, Larry F. Stewart and Susan L. Fortunato separated two techniques in a 1996 paper in the International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners. Relative ink age determination compares "two or more ink entries of the same formula on the same paper" to find the order in which they were made. Accelerated aging works "without known, dated comparison entries" and compares samples of the questioned entry before and after heating. The authors wrote that the two should be kept as "two separate techniques" until the basis of the accelerated technique "has been independently evaluated and reproduced," and that "The accelerated aging technique is still in its infancy."

Two reports can therefore both carry the title of ink dating and rest on different questions. One examiner compares the questioned entry with other entries of the same ink. Another heats a plug of the questioned ink and measures what the heat drove out. A third identifies the formulation and checks when it entered the market. The reports contradict each other only if they tested the same entry for the same purpose.

Even one method reads differently on different inks. In his deposition of July 26, 2012 in Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, LaPorte testified that the chart of 2-phenoxyethanol loss in his report represents "how phenoxyethanol decreases over time" in "arbitrary units." Asked whether the solvent dries quickly in some inks and more slowly in others, he answered: "Absolutely. We characterize those as slow-aging inks and fast-aging inks." The same percentage of solvent loss can therefore stand for a different age in another formulation.

What happened when two ink specialists examined the Ceglia contract?

A defense chemist reported it highly probable that a handwritten interlineation was made within 24 months before August 28, 2011. A specialist retained by counsel for the plaintiff sampled the same document and gave no dating opinion.

Paul D. Ceglia sued Mark Elliot Zuckerberg and Facebook, Inc. in the Western District of New York, No. 1:10-cv-00569, on a work for hire document. Page 1 carries a handwritten interlineation, "Providing web designer is finished by May 24, 2003," and the initials PC and MZ; page 2 carries the two signatures.

LaPorte's report of March 25, 2012, filed as Exhibit B (Doc. 326), describes circular plugs of ink and paper 0.5 to 1.0 millimeter in diameter removed for thin layer chromatography and gas chromatography with mass spectrometry. The dating test measured the solvent 2-phenoxyethanol (PE) in heated and unheated samples; the heated samples were held at 70 degrees Celsius. The report states the rule it applied: "a significant decrease in the level of PE by more than 25% after the questioned sample is heated indicates that the ink is less than two (2) years old." Two runs on the interlineation lost 66% and 62% of the solvent, an average of 64%.

The conclusion reads: "It is highly probable that the interlineation was produced within 24 months prior to August 28, 2011," the date of testing, and the ink "was not placed on the document on April 28, 2003." A footnote ties the phrase highly probable to the terminology standard ASTM E1658-08. The same report says that thin layer chromatography "was rendered practically ineffective due to the condition of the ink" and that LaPorte was "unable to identify the manufacturer of any of the inks." The dating opinion did not rest on an identified formulation.

Speckin, the ink specialist on the plaintiff's side, was deposed on September 24, 2012 (Doc. 593). His transcript records that Larry Stewart first contacted him in July 2011, that he was retained "By counsel for the plaintiff" under a retainer agreement with Jeff Lake, an attorney from San Diego, and that he examined the document in Chicago on July 25, 2011. He took "ten vials of ink, four vials of paper." He had planned ink dating and did not perform it: "The degradation of the ink I didn't feel would allow for any conclusive opinions at all." He had not prepared a report.

The two records do not set one date against another. One is a dating opinion with a stated threshold. The other is a second specialist's decision that the ink did not permit a conclusion. A reviewer reads the second specialist's reasons for declining as closely as the first examiner's measurements.

Could heat, light or storage explain the difference between two dating results?

Yes. Heat drives solvent out of ink faster than natural aging, and light can fade dyes in a way that resembles a later writing. Each report should say where the document was kept and whether those effects were considered.

Speckin testified in Ceglia that GC analysis can show "if a document has been subjected to heat and artificially aged." If heat greater than "human survivable conditions" is applied, "you're going to drive off more phenoxyethanol than natural aging ever would, so you get a number that's zero or so close to zero, you can barely detect it." In his words, "Heat is the only thing that I've seen to be an effective means that you would detect it through the volatile solvents." A document exposed to such heat loses more solvent than natural aging would remove.

Stewart and Fortunato raised the same concern about the accelerated technique itself. They wrote that "it is doubtful to these authors if papers and inks age consistently" and that "it has not been established whether inks chemically degrade at temperatures of less than or equal to 100°C." They also noted that the published procedure "does not state what is meant by 'significant'" and that "The origin of the time/temperature combinations currently being used are unclear." They cited a 1988 scaling factor by Cantu under which "90 days of natural aging at 25°C is equivalent to 4 minutes of artificial aging at 100°C," at least for one ink on one paper.

Light raises a different problem. In a 2025 case report in the Journal of the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, Valery N. Aginsky described a dispute over a three-page will dated 1999. The plaintiff's expert concluded that the will "was not prepared in 1999 as indicated, but at multiple occasions more recently, [namely after] July of 2017," relying in part on differences in ink between pages 1 and 2. Aginsky, retained by the defendant, found that the signatures on both pages were likely made with the same blue ballpoint formulation and attributed the color shift on page 1 to light exposure, through partial decomposition of triarylmethane dyes by N-demethylation. He also found that the printed toner matched a black toner common in the late 1990s. His report title states the point: "Natural Aging of Ink and Ink Fading Are Different Physical and Chemical Processes."

When two reports differ, the reviewer reads both for the document's history: who held it, where it was stored, whether it sat in light, and whether any comparison entries on undisputed documents were kept the same way. A report that is silent on storage leaves heat and light unexamined as explanations.

What if the first examination used up the ink a second examiner needs?

Then a second dating test may have nothing left to sample. How many plugs each side removed, under what agreement or order, and what remains of each entry are part of the record the reviewer checks.

Ceglia shows how quickly an entry runs out. LaPorte's report states that plaintiff's counsel permitted "only a minimal number of ink plugs" at the July 16 examination. The plaintiff "objected to the removal of additional ink plugs and the Court later resolved this issue, ordering the extraction of additional samples." LaPorte returned "on August 27, 2011, as authorized by the Court order." For the initials, the report notes that there was "not enough ink available" for further dating.

Speckin recalled the same episode from the other side: "I recall an agreement and a disagreement as well," and the dispute "wasn't resolved that day." He testified that he did not take more samples and that Patty Giebink of his office ran thin layer chromatography on the plugs. The remaining ink samples were never provided to Stewart: "If they're not discarded, then they are still in Michigan," and "they're probably discarded after a year."

Speckin also explained why old extracts do not settle a later dispute: "After a year of sitting out of the document in a vial, any value would be very minimized." Comparison might still be possible, but ink dating "either by solvents or dyes after sitting in a vial for a year, I would think would be very questionable." A second examiner who arrives after the first test may find the entry cut and the first side's extracts too old to retest.

For that reason a reviewer asks for the sampling record before comparing results: the number and location of plugs taken by each examiner, the dates, the images of each entry before and after, the agreement or order that set the terms, and what happened to every extract.

Can both dating opinions pass Rule 702?

Yes. The 2000 committee note says that a ruling that one expert is reliable does not make contradictory testimony unreliable. Each opinion must still meet the preponderance standard and stay within what its method can support.

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 as amended in 2023, a qualified expert may testify if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the knowledge will help the trier of fact, that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," that "the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case.

The 2000 committee note addresses two experts who disagree. "When a trial court, applying this amendment, rules that an expert's testimony is reliable, this does not necessarily mean that contradictory expert testimony is unreliable." The note continues that the amendment "is broad enough to permit testimony that is the product of competing principles or methods in the same field of expertise." Among its factors is "Whether the expert has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations." For a solvent loss result, heat, light and a different formulation are the obvious alternative explanations that this factor asks the examiner to account for.

The 2023 note tightened the gatekeeping step. It records that many courts had held that the sufficiency of an expert's basis and the application of the methodology "are questions of weight and not admissibility," and states: "These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)." It adds that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded" from the expert's basis and methodology, and that forensic experts "should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty" where the method is subjective.

Applied to dating, the court asks of each report whether the threshold, the temperature and the reference date support the stated interval. A report that converts a percentage of solvent loss into a calendar date that its method cannot produce is exposed under the 2023 note; a report that declines to give a date because the ink was degraded is not a contrary opinion on the date at all.

What happens at trial when both dating opinions are admitted?

Both go to the trier of fact, and each side attacks the other's opinion with cross-examination and contrary evidence. Once the court finds the admissibility requirements met, the 2023 note says any further attack goes only to weight.

The 2000 note repeats the Supreme Court's words in Daubert: "Vigorous cross-examination, presentation of contrary evidence, and careful instruction on the burden of proof are the traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but admissible evidence." The same note observes that "the rejection of expert testimony is the exception rather than the rule."

The 2023 note draws the line at the admissibility ruling: "once the court has found it more likely than not that the admissibility requirement has been met, any attack by the opponent will go only to the weight of the evidence." In a dating dispute that means the jury, or the judge in a bench trial, hears both chemists, and each side's questions decide how much the threshold, the storage history and the sampling record count.

The review becomes the outline for those questions. It lists, for each report, the entry tested, the method, the numbers obtained, the reference date, what the examiner said about heat and light, and how much ink was left for the other side.

What does a reviewer compare in two ink dating reports?

The entries sampled, the method and its threshold, whether the formulation was identified, the reference date, the storage and light history, the plugs removed and the wording of each conclusion. Differences in any of these explain most conflicts.

The reviewer sets the two reports side by side and checks seven points before deciding whether they conflict at all.

  • Both reports name the page, the entry and the location of each plug, so it is clear whether they tested the same writing.
  • Each report states its method: comparison with a reference collection, relative aging between entries of the same ink, or heating of the questioned ink against an unheated sample.
  • Each report says whether the ink formulation was identified, because relative aging compares only entries of the same formula.
  • Each report gives its numbers and the threshold it applied, such as the 25% decrease used in the Ceglia report, and the source of that threshold.
  • Each report names the reference date for its interval, such as the date of testing, and the date the samples were taken.
  • Each report says where the document was kept and whether heat or light exposure was considered.
  • Each report records how many plugs were removed, by whom and under what agreement or order, and what remained for the other examiner.

What does IAE do when two ink dating opinions conflict?

A document examiner from the IAE registry reviews the opposing dating report and the produced file and states where the two opinions differ in method, sample and wording. The document is issued in up to 5 business days.

The IAE page for reviews of questioned document reports is addressed to attorneys facing the other side's report on alterations, substituted pages, ink or dating. The reviewer reads the report and the produced file against ANSI/ASB Standards 011 and 035, the SWGDOC ink comparison standard and Rule 26(a)(2)(B). The page answers the question of what an ink match means: under the SWGDOC standard the inks could not be distinguished at the level of analysis used, which does not rule out different batches or pens.

The client sends the opposing report, the produced file and what is available of the document, and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member