Expert report review
The opposing examiner says the pages came from different printers: how is that opinion reviewed?
Opinions that a page was printed on a different machine than the rest of a contract often decide substitution claims. The SWGDOC standards for toner and liquid ink jet documents set the steps behind such an opinion: the printing process, the known material, the individual defects and one of four permitted conclusions. A reviewer checks each step against the report and the examiner's notes.

What does a printer identification opinion claim?
One of three things under the SWGDOC standards: that documents came from the same device, that a particular device produced a document, or the make or model of the device. Each claim needs different evidence.
Section 4.1 of the SWGDOC Standard for Examination of Documents Produced with Toner Technology and the matching section of the liquid ink jet standard describe those three questions. The toner standard covers "photocopiers, printers, facsimile devices, and multifunction devices using toner technology," and the ink jet standard covers the same range of machines that use ink jet.
In litigation the question usually comes from a contract or a set of minutes where one page is alleged to have been replaced. The opposing report says the disputed page shows features that the other pages lack, and concludes that it came from another machine or another printing session. The review asks whether the features the examiner relied on can carry that conclusion.
Did the examiner first establish the printing process?
The standards require it as the first technical step: section 7.3 of the toner standard and section 7.4 of the ink jet standard require confirming the process before any comparison. A comparison of toner pages with ink jet criteria fails.
After the process is confirmed, the examiner decides the type of comparison: questioned against known, questioned against questioned, or another examination. The report should say which one was done. A conclusion that two pages of the same contract came from different machines is a questioned-against-questioned comparison and rests only on the pages themselves.
Class characteristics are compared next. Section 7.11.5 of the toner standard lists paper type, paper supply system, toner type, marks caused by mechanics and color capability, and section 7.11.4 deals with the typestyle. The same section gives the rule for differences at this level: "If significant unexplainable differences exist, discontinue and report accordingly." The reviewer checks that a difference treated as significant was in fact unexplained, and what the examiner did to rule out the explanations.
Do differences between pages prove that a different printer was used?
No. Settings, file format, printing mode and the toner or ink supply change the appearance of output from one machine. A study presented at AAFS in 2019 found that differences between laser printouts do not necessarily mean different printers.
Jasna Galekovic of the Forensic Science Centre Ivan Vucetic in Zagreb printed more than 200 samples on five color laser printers, varying the settings and the file type, and examined them with video-spectral and stereomicroscopic methods. Changing printer parameters and file format "causes significant differences in print quality"; the same text saved as a highly compressed PDF and as plain text showed "a significant difference in letter size and the shape of the same letters and numbers."
The study concluded that such differences "do not necessarily mean that they are manufactured on different laser printers" and that "other available test methods are needed to provide more reliable conclusions."
The SWGDOC standards list the same sources of variation. Section 5.3 of the toner standard notes that multifunction devices "can operate in either printing or copying mode, at different resolutions," and section 5.2 states that "some toner supply units are interchangeable between different brands or models of machines" and may be refilled with non-original toner. Sections 5.5 and 5.6 of the ink jet standard say the same of ink supplies and printing modes. A report that infers a different machine from a difference in letter shape without addressing these variables leaves a gap the reviewer records.
What known material did the examiner compare the page with?
The report should name the known documents or the device, state how their suitability was checked, record the device's condition and settings, and say whether service records were requested and exemplars prepared.
Section 7.7 of the toner standard requires a suitability check of known documents. Section 7.9 requires the examiner to record the device's condition, capabilities and settings and says "service records should be requested and pertinent information noted and recorded." Section 7.10 deals with preparing exemplars from the device. Under section 7.16 of the ink jet standard, if no suitable exemplars can be obtained, the examiner stops and reports.
Service records matter because a machine changes. A part replaced between the date on the document and the date of the exemplars takes its defects with it, and section 7.10.1 of the toner standard mentions damage to the fuser rollers or the imaging drum. Exemplars printed on the questioned machine months after the disputed date may not show the machine as it was. The reviewer checks whether the examiner knew what was serviced between the date on the document and the date of the exemplars.
Which features can tie a page to one machine?
Reproducible individual defects: wear and damage marks, misalignments, repeating marks and voids for toner devices, and misalignments, reproducible marks and banding for ink jet. Repeating marks usually sit in the same position relative to the sheet edges.
Section 7.11.6 of the toner standard lists "wear and damage defects, misalignments, reproducible marks, voids." Section 7.11.6.1 notes that trash marks and defects often repeat in the same position relative to the sheet edges, and Note 4 adds that doubled patterns can indicate several generations of copying. Section 7.24 of the ink jet standard lists misalignments, reproducible marks and banding.
Section 7.25 of the ink jet standard requires the examiner to consider whether a feature comes from the source file or from the device model. A line spacing or font difference created in the word processor says nothing about which printer was used. The reviewer checks that every feature the conclusion relies on is a device feature and that the report shows it on enlarged images with a scale.
Did the examiner work from the original?
The standards allow the best available reproduction only if it shows the significant details with sufficient clarity. They also warn that manipulation and duplication by computer can produce toner-like or ink jet-like items.
Section 7.8 of the toner standard requires that a reproduction used in place of a missing original show significant details "with sufficient clarity for comparison purposes." Section 5.2 tells examiners to consider that "various forms of manipulation and duplication of toner-produced items can be generated by computer or other means," and section 5.4 of the ink jet standard has the same warning.
A scan or a photocopy carries the defects of the scanner or the copier on top of those of the printer. When the report compares a copy of the disputed page with original exemplars, the reviewer checks whether the examiner separated the two sets of features or treated them as one. Both standards also call for the document examination to come before latent print or other chemical processing.
Does the conclusion match one of the four the standards permit?
The standards permit identification, elimination, a qualified opinion with an explanation of the limiting factors, or no conclusion. An identification requires agreement in significant individualizing characteristics and no significant differences.
Section 8.3 of the toner standard permits an identification where there are no significant differences and significant individualizing characteristics agree, and adds that "there may be limitations." Section 8.4 permits elimination when significant differences are found at any level. Section 8.5 provides for a qualified opinion and "requires explanation of the limiting factors," and section 8.6 provides for no conclusion where significant limiting factors exist. The ink jet standard uses the same four conclusions in sections 8.3 to 8.6.
Under section 8.2 the bases and reasons for the conclusion belong in the examiner's documentation. A report that says pages "were printed on different devices" on the strength of class differences alone, without individual defects and without explaining the variables in section 5, states an elimination that the documentation may not support. The reviewer quotes the conclusion, sets it against the section that governs it, and lists the missing elements.
Which records should the reviewer ask for?
The bench notes, the images of the questioned and known pages, the list of known items and exemplars, the device settings and service records consulted, and the documented reasons for any limited procedure.
Section 7.1 of the toner standard states that "examinations performed, relevant observations, and results shall be documented," and section 7.2 requires the reasons for discontinuing or limiting a procedure to be documented. Those records exist if the examiner followed the standard.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a retained expert's report to contain the basis and reasons for each opinion and "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them," together with any exhibits. Counsel requests the notes and images on that basis. A review based only on the narrative report can point out what is missing; a review based on the file can test whether the features the report describes appear on the images.
How does the review reach the court?
As a rebuttal report within 30 days of the other side's disclosure, as the basis for a deposition outline, or as support for a Rule 702 motion. The reviewer may also stay a consulting expert.
Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets 30 days after the other party's disclosure for evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject, unless the court orders otherwise. Under Rule 702 as amended in 2023, the proponent of the printer opinion must show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the expert applied those methods reliably to the facts of the case.
Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D) the facts known and opinions held by a consulting expert who will not testify are ordinarily not discoverable. Counsel can read the review first and then decide whether the reviewer will be disclosed as a rebuttal witness.
What does IAE do when the opposing report ties a page to a different printer?
IAE prepares a review of the opposing questioned document report for federal and state cases, with each point tied to a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE review page for questioned documents is written for attorneys facing the other side's report on alterations, substituted pages, ink or dating. The reviewer reads the report and the produced file against the applicable standards and Rule 26(a)(2)(B), and each point of the review cites a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Send the opposing report, the produced file and, if known, the model of the printer and the dates of any service through the form on the contact page; you approve the reviewer and the CV before work starts.
Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The reviewer confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- SWGDOC Standard for Examination of Documents Produced with Toner Technology (E05-13), version 2013-1
- SWGDOC Standard for Examination of Documents Produced with Liquid Ink Jet Technology (E06-13), version 2013-1
- Galekovic J. An Examination of the Influence of Various Parameters on the Quality of Laser Printer Printouts. AAFS Proceedings 2019, J33
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
The government's forensic report says your document is counterfeit: how is it reviewed and rebutted in immigration proceedings?
An asylum file or a benefit application can turn on one sheet of paper: a birth certificate, a church letter, a party card. When a government
The opposing examiner calls the document a forgery: may a document examiner decide that?
A document examiner may testify that a signature is not the writing of the person named, that a page was replaced or that an entry was added. Whether
Artificially aged document: how is the opposing examiner's finding of heat or light aging reviewed?
A report that calls a document artificially aged makes one of two claims: that someone treated the paper or ink to make it look older, or thatExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

