Expert report review

The opposing examiner calls the document a forgery: may a document examiner decide that?

A document examiner may testify that a signature is not the writing of the person named, that a page was replaced or that an entry was added. Whether the document is a forgery is a different question that includes intent and legal effect. Rule 704 lets an expert address an ultimate issue but not tell the jury what result to reach, and in a criminal case it bars opinions on the defendant's intent.

A wooden gavel rests beside a loupe and a signature page turned away from the light

Can a document examiner testify that a document is forged?

An examiner may give an opinion on genuineness: who wrote a signature, whether a page was replaced, whether an entry was added. Calling the document a forgery adds intent and a legal label that the examination does not establish.

Courts have long admitted opinions on genuineness. In United States v. Starzecpyzel, 880 F. Supp. 1027 (S.D.N.Y., April 3, 1995), Judge McKenna allowed forensic document examiners to state opinions on whether signatures were genuine, noting that Rule 702 permits qualified experts to offer their opinions.

Calling a document a forgery adds a claim about why it was made and what it is worth in law. The reasons for making a document are not visible in the strokes. An examiner observes letter forms, line quality, ink, paper and printing, and reports what they show about authorship and alteration; what the writer meant to achieve is evidence of another kind.

The review therefore reads each conclusion and sorts it: a statement about the document, which the method can support, or a statement about a person's purpose or the legal character of the document, which it cannot.

What does Rule 704 allow an expert to say?

An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue. But opinions must help the trier of fact, and the advisory committee says opinions that would merely tell the jury what result to reach are excluded.

Rule 704(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence states: "An opinion is not objectionable just because it embraces an ultimate issue." The 1972 advisory committee note says the so-called ultimate issue rule "is specifically abolished", and then sets the limit: under Rules 701 and 702 opinions must be helpful to the trier of fact, and these provisions guard against "opinions which would merely tell the jury what result to reach."

The note gives an example that fits document cases. The question "Did T have capacity to make a will?" would be excluded, while the question whether T had sufficient mental capacity to know the nature and extent of his property, the natural objects of his bounty and a rational scheme of distribution would be allowed. The first asks for a legal conclusion; the second asks for facts measured against the legal standard.

Applied to a questioned document, "the signature on page 4 was not written by the person named" is an opinion on a fact in issue. "The guaranty is a forgery and void" is the legal result, and the note's reasoning places it with the court and the jury.

Can the examiner say that the writer intended to deceive?

Not in a federal criminal case. Rule 704(b) bars an expert from stating an opinion on whether the defendant had a mental state that is an element of the crime or a defense.

Rule 704(b) states: "In a criminal case, an expert witness must not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense. Those matters are for the trier of fact alone."

In a forgery or fraud prosecution, intent to defraud is the element the rule protects. The examiner may describe a simulated signature, a traced line or a disguised hand; the jury decides why it was made.

Civil cases have no equivalent of Rule 704(b), but the same 1972 note applies: an opinion that merely tells the jury what result to reach does not help it. A civil report that says the defendant "knowingly fabricated" a document has left the examiner's field.

What did the court decide about document examiner testimony in Starzecpyzel?

That the testimony was admissible as practical, skilled expertise, that examiners are not scientists, and that the jury had to be told so before hearing them. The court also doubted the nine-level certainty scale.

Judge McKenna wrote that the expertise of forensic document examiners "is not properly characterized as scientific, but as practical in character", and that examiners "are not scientists." The testimony was admitted under Rule 702 as nonscientific or skilled testimony.

The court found that such testimony "does suffer from a substantial problem of prejudice" under Rule 403 and dealt with it by safeguards: before any examiner testified, the jury was to be told that examiners offer practical rather than scientific expertise. The draft instruction in the appendix described them as more like artisans, skilled craftsmen. The court also said it might exclude testimony about the nine-level certainty scale, finding no showing that examiners can reach conclusions such as would justify a nine-level scale.

For the question here, the opinion fixes what the court admitted: opinions on genuineness, presented as practical expertise, with the strength of the conclusion open to limits.

What wording does a reviewer expect in a document examiner's conclusion?

Conclusions framed as propositions about the document: who wrote it, whether it was altered, whether inks differ. The standards supply this vocabulary, and none of it is the vocabulary of fraud.

ANSI/ASB Standard 070 frames handwriting work as a set of hypotheses. The note to section 6.2.4 lists that the questioned writing was written by the writer of the known material, by another specified writer, by a random writer from a relevant population, or by the writer of the known material in a distorted manner. Section 6.3.8 speaks of indicia of simulation and tracing, and section 6.8.1 requires a conclusion based on a combination of characteristics.

The SWGDOC ink comparison standard gives the wording for ink in section 4.8.1, "inability to distinguish the ink samples at this level of analysis", and forbids calling two samples identical (9.3.3). Recommendation 2.3 of NIST IR 8282r1 bars reporting that handwriting was written by an individual to the exclusion of all others.

A conclusion written in these terms leaves the legal step to the fact finder. A conclusion that the document is "fraudulent", "falsified to deceive the court" or "a forgery by the plaintiff" combines a technical finding with a legal one, and the review separates them.

How is a legal conclusion in the report challenged?

By a specific objection or a motion in limine aimed at the sentences that state the legal result, not at the examiner in general. A general objection to qualifications may leave the method and the wording unchallenged on appeal.

In the estate of Marie Laveck (Michigan Court of Appeals, December 20, 1996), a graphologist who did not apply forgery indicia testified about a will signature, and the probate court admitted the will. The objection at trial was to his qualifications. The Court of Appeals noted that no specific objection was registered as to technique or methodology and that the issue could have been raised by a motion in limine or a timely and specific objection; because it was not, the issue was not preserved.

The same lesson applies to wording. A motion that quotes the sentences of the report that state a legal conclusion and asks the court to bar them, while leaving the technical findings, gives the court something it can grant. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) requires the report to state the basis and reasons for each opinion, so a legal label without a stated basis in the examination is also a gap in the report itself.

What does a reviewer check when a report calls a document forged?

Whether each conclusion is a finding about the document, what observations support it, whether intent or legal effect is asserted, and whether the wording stays within the standards the examiner cites.

The review goes through the conclusions one by one.

  • Which sentences state a finding about authorship, alteration, ink or printing, and which state that the document is forged, false or fraudulent?
  • For each finding, which observations and images does the report rely on?
  • Does the report say anything about the intent or purpose of a person, and on what basis?
  • Does the conclusion use the terms of the standard the examiner cites, or terms of its own?
  • Were alternative explanations considered, such as natural variation, distortion by the genuine writer or an innocent later addition?
  • In a criminal case, does any part of the report or the expected testimony reach the defendant's mental state?

What does IAE do when the opposing report calls a document a forgery?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing questioned document report for federal and state cases, with each point tied to a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule, in up to 5 business days.

The IAE review page for questioned documents is written for attorneys facing the other side's report on alterations, substituted pages, ink or dating. The reviewer reads the report and the produced file against ANSI/ASB Standards 011 and 035, the SWGDOC ink comparison standard and Rule 26(a)(2)(B), and each point of the review cites a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Send the opposing report and the produced file through the form on the contact page; you approve the reviewer and the CV before work starts. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D) a consulting expert's opinions are ordinarily not discoverable, so counsel can read the review before deciding whether to disclose the reviewer.

Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The reviewer confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member