Expert report review

Construction defect extrapolation: how does a reviewer test the opposing expert's sample?

A construction expert who tests a few walls or windows and prices repairs for a whole project is extrapolating, and a reviewer checks how that sample was chosen. In a 2018 Florida condominium case, about 200 feet of stucco testing supported replacing 220,000 square feet, and the jury found $9.6 million in damages. The Fifth Circuit has required a randomly selected sample of sufficient size before trial results are extrapolated.

An engineer on scaffolding chalks one cladding panel, a sampling diagram on a tablet beside her

What is extrapolation in a construction defect case?

An expert tests or opens part of a project and applies the result to parts nobody examined. The Nevada Supreme Court described it as the statistical use by an expert of a valid and reliable representative sample.

The condominium project in D.R. Horton, Inc.-Jacksonville v. Heron's Landing Condominium Association of Jacksonville, Inc. had 240 residential units in twenty buildings. At trial the association's expert was asked whether all 220,000 square feet of stucco needed to be replaced based on "200 something feet of testing." He answered: "That is accurate...." A contractor then testified to an "all in" bid of $9,157,690 to correct the issues.

In D.R. Horton, Inc. v. Eighth Judicial District Court, decided on October 11, 2007, the Nevada Supreme Court wrote that "Extrapolation encompasses the statistical use by an expert witness of a valid and reliable representative sample." The case concerned the pre-litigation notice of a homeowners association, and the court held that "an extrapolated notice is valid only if it identifies the subset or characteristics of the subset to which it applies."

A reviewer reads the opposing report for three facts: the population the expert claims to describe, the way the tested locations were picked and the number of locations tested. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires a retained expert's report to list "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them," meaning the opinions. The test log, the location plan and the photographs belong in that list, and item (iii) adds "any exhibits that will be used to summarize or support them."

Is extrapolation evidence admissible under Rule 702?

It can be. The Supreme Court treats a sample like other evidence: its use depends on how reliably it proves the claim. Rule 702 then asks whether the opinion rests on sufficient data and a reliable method reliably applied.

In Tyson Foods, Inc. v. Bouaphakeo, decided on March 22, 2016 by a 6-2 vote, Justice Kennedy wrote for the Court: "A representative or statistical sample, like all evidence, is a means to establish or defend against liability." Its permissibility turns "on the degree to which the evidence is reliable in proving or disproving the elements of the relevant cause of action," and the Court cited Federal Rules of Evidence 401, 403 and 702. The Court also wrote that the case presented "no occasion for adoption of broad and categorical rules" on representative and statistical evidence in class actions.

The Court compared the case with Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes. The experiences of the Wal-Mart employees "bore little relationship to one another," while in Tyson "each employee worked in the same facility, did similar work, and was paid under the same policy." For a building the parallel questions are whether the units were built to the same plans, by the same trades and with the same products.

Rule 702, as amended effective December 1, 2023, lets a qualified expert testify if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case. A sample offered to prove defects in units nobody tested raises the second and the fourth conditions: was the sample large enough, and was the step to the untested units reliable?

What makes a sample of units or test locations representative?

Selection by chance from a complete list of the units, and enough of them to support the confidence claimed. The Fifth Circuit barred using the results of thirty selected trials for the remaining plaintiffs in the case.

In re Chevron U.S.A., Inc., No. 97-20042, was decided by the Fifth Circuit on March 26, 1997, in an opinion by Judge Robert M. Parker. The district court had planned a trial of thirty plaintiffs whose results would be used for the others. The appeals court described the plan this way: "It is simply a trial of fifteen (15) of the 'best' and fifteen (15) of the 'worst' cases."

The court wrote that in a bellwether trial "the sample must be a randomly selected one of sufficient size," and that "Without a sufficient level of confidence in the sample results, no inferences may be drawn from such results." The trial court "must, prior to any extrapolation, find that the cases tried are representative," and the finding must rest on "competent, scientific, statistical evidence that identifies the variables involved and that provides a sample of sufficient size." The Fifth Circuit granted the petition as to using the results of the thirty trials for the untried cases.

The Reference Guide on Statistics by David H. Kaye and David A. Freedman, published by the Federal Judicial Center in the third edition of the Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence (2011), describes the same requirement. With probability methods "a sampling frame (i.e., an explicit list of units in the population) must be created," and units are "selected by an objective, well-defined chance procedure" (p. 224). "Probability methods are designed to avoid selection bias" (p. 225). When a survey does not meet these criteria, "additional arguments are needed to justify the inferences" (p. 227).

On a construction project the frame is the list of units, elevations, windows or wall panels. The guide's example of a convenience sample is a pollster who interviews shoppers in a mall, and it warns that such samples "may be biased by the interviewer's discretion in deciding whom to approach." Test locations chosen because an owner complained or a stain was visible are picked the same way, by a person's discretion.

How did a Florida court treat about 200 feet of testing for 220,000 square feet of stucco?

It affirmed. In 2018 Florida's First District Court of Appeal found no error in admitting the extrapolation, because the trial court had found the method peer-reviewed, accepted and the industry standard.

D.R. Horton, Inc.-Jacksonville v. Heron's Landing Condominium Association of Jacksonville, Inc., 266 So. 3d 1201, was decided by Florida's First District Court of Appeal in 2018, after the Florida Supreme Court's DeLisle decision of October 15, 2018, which the opinion discusses. The association alleged that the developer violated the Florida Building Code, breached warranties and was negligent in its construction of the project. The developer's motion in limine targeted defect testimony "relating to windows and sliding glass doors, stucco, or asphalt," and the stucco was the main subject at trial.

The trial court found that the methodology of the association's experts "was scientifically reliable, had been peer-reviewed," "had been developed by people in the industry, and was generally accepted in the scientific community." On appeal the court noted that the Legislature amended Florida's expert statute in 2013 to adopt the Daubert standard, and that the Florida Supreme Court had since reaffirmed Frye, which "applies only when experts render an opinion that is based upon new or novel scientific principles." The court wrote: "We accept Appellee's argument that no Frye analysis is necessary in this case." The jury found total damages of $9,600,000, and the judgment was affirmed.

The expert named three bases for full replacement: the testing, "A lot of visual observation, a lot of indications of problematic conditions with the stucco," and problems "that we have seen many times on other projects." A reviewer separates such bases. Measured results, visual observations on site and experience from other buildings are different kinds of data, and each one either covers the untested units or does not.

When does an extrapolation become an analytical gap?

When the conclusion reaches further than the tested data. The committee note to Rule 702 names unjustified extrapolation as a reliability factor, and Joiner lets a court exclude an opinion too far removed from its data.

The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 lists questions courts have used to test reliability. One is whether the expert "has unjustifiably extrapolated" an accepted premise into an unfounded conclusion, citing General Electric Co. v. Joiner, 522 U.S. 136, 146 (1997). Others are whether the expert "has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations" and whether the expert "is being as careful as he would be in his regular professional work."

In Joiner, decided on December 15, 1997, the Supreme Court wrote: "A court may conclude that there is simply too great an analytical gap between the data and the opinion proffered." The experts had relied on studies in which infant mice received "massive doses of PCBs injected directly into their peritoneums," and the Court held that "The studies were so dissimilar to the facts presented in this litigation" that the district court did not abuse its discretion in rejecting them. A test of one wall assembly offered to prove the condition of a different assembly raises the same question of fit.

The 2023 committee note adds that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology." It also says that many courts had treated the sufficiency of an expert's basis as a question of weight, and "These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)." In federal court the size and selection of a sample are therefore part of the judge's admissibility decision under the more likely than not standard.

Can a sample prove defects in units nobody inspected?

Only if the untested units share what caused the defects in the tested ones. Tyson Foods asks whether each claimant could have relied on the sample alone, and Nevada required the expert to name the subset.

In Tyson Foods the Supreme Court asked whether "each class member could have relied on that sample to establish liability if he or she had brought an individual action." In a condominium case the owner of an untested unit is in that position. If his unit was built in a later phase, with another window model or another wall assembly, the sample from the first phase says little about it.

The Nevada Supreme Court in D.R. Horton set a "reasonable threshold test" that "every pre-litigation notice must satisfy, but only if challenged by the contractor." It wrote that "adequate extrapolated pre-litigation notice must have a reasonable statistical basis." To reach "the minimum statistical basis that the reasonable threshold test requires," the court suggested that the expert test "the existence of the alleged defect in at least one of the homes in each subset."

A reviewer applies the same idea to a trial report. Which subsets exist on the project: phases, building types, window models, wall assemblies, roofing systems? Is each subset represented among the tested locations? Does the report say which tested location belongs to which subset, and does the defect rate change between them?

How did Nevada change notices based on a representative sample?

In 2015 the Legislature deleted the provisions that let an expert's representative sample give notice for similar homes. The statute now asks for reasonable detail for each residence and a signed statement from each named owner.

The version of NRS 40.645 discussed in D.R. Horton in 2007 allowed a notice based on an expert opinion "which is based on a valid and reliable representative sample of the components of the residences," and a separate subsection dealt with similarly situated residences in one development.

Assembly Bill 125, chapter 2 of the Statutes of Nevada 2015, was approved on February 24, 2015. Its section 8 amended NRS 40.645 and removed former subsections 3, 4 and 5, including the representative sample provision and the provision for similarly situated owners.

The current text requires the notice to "Specify in reasonable detail the defects or any damages or injuries to each residence or appurtenance that is the subject of the claim" and to "Include a signed statement, by each named owner of a residence or appurtenance in the notice" verifying that each defect exists in that residence. The change concerns the notice that starts the pre-litigation process. A sample presented by an expert at trial is tested under the rules of evidence.

Which parts of the opposing expert's sample does a reviewer test?

The list of units the opinion covers, how test locations were chosen, how many were tested in each subset, what error margin is claimed, and whether the repair estimate prices only what the sample supports.

The first item is the frame. The reviewer compares the units, elevations or components named in the opinion with an explicit list built from the plans. If the report gives no list, the reviewer reconstructs it and marks where the opinion goes beyond the tested group.

The second is selection. The reviewer asks who picked the locations, when and why, and whether a chance procedure was used. In Chevron the Fifth Circuit refused to let the results of the "best" and the "worst" cases decide the untried ones. A location plan and the field log are exhibits under Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(iii), and the reviewer requests them if they are missing.

The third is size. The reviewer counts tested locations per subset and computes the defect rate for each. If the report states no confidence level or margin of error, the inference to the whole project rests on what the Federal Judicial Center guide calls additional arguments, and the reviewer lists which ones the report offers.

The fourth is the estimate. Each line of the repair estimate is traced to a tested location, a visual observation or an extrapolated quantity. The extrapolated quantities are totaled separately, so the court can see how much of the claimed cost rests on locations nobody opened. A rebuttal report limited to the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), unless a stipulation or court order sets another date.

What does IAE do when the opposing construction expert extrapolates?

IAE reviews the opposing construction expert's report for US cases and prepares expert reports on the client's own questions. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The review tests each opinion against the data behind it, with the measure the Supreme Court set in General Electric Co. v. Joiner. For cost, the repair is priced line by line, each damaged element is listed, quantities are measured on site or from photos, and defect repair is kept apart from upgrades.

Every review answers six questions: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at every stage; whether all objects, materials and questions were examined; whether the conclusions follow from the examination; whether the expert's education, specialty and experience match the subject; whether the report meets the form and procedure of the jurisdiction; and whether it can be relied on.

The client sends the opposing report, its exhibits and the case materials and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Specialists are members of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Each confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member