Expert report review
Window leak expert report: what does a reviewer check in the opposing water test?
A window leak report rests on a water test, and the test decides whether the opinion survives. In 2016 a federal court excluded all window-testing opinions of three engineers in the Pella litigation: the tests did not reproduce the conditions under which leaks had been seen, did not rule out installation and condensation, and covered almost only the named plaintiffs' windows. A reviewer checks the same points in any opposing window report.

What does the opposing window expert claim, and what does a reviewer test?
The report blames the window unit, its installation or the wall around it. The reviewer tests the method behind that choice: which test, at what pressure, under what conditions, on which windows.
A window leak report answers two questions: where the water enters and whose work is at fault. The candidates are the window product itself (frame corners, glazing, sash seals), the installation (flashing, sealant joints, the connection to the water-resistive barrier), the wall around the opening and condensation on the inside surface. The report picks one and supports the pick with tests.
A review does not need its own theory to test that pick. It takes each opinion and asks which data and which test stand behind it, whether the test fits the question, and whether the alternatives were excluded. The standard of comparison is Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence and the test standards the expert cites.
The 2016 Pella decision gives the checklist a court applied. The sections below follow it.
Was the test a field test of the installed window or a laboratory rating test?
The reviewer identifies the standard. ASTM E331 and E547 are laboratory water penetration tests under static and cyclic pressure; ASTM E1105 is the field test for installed units. Results from one do not answer questions written for the other.
A 2023 report prepared by the University of Florida for the Florida Building Commission describes the test family. ASTM E331 covers water penetration of exterior windows, skylights, doors and curtain walls under uniform static air pressure difference. ASTM E547 covers the same under cyclic static air pressure difference. ASTM E1105 is the field test for water penetration of installed units under uniform or cyclic static pressure.
A laboratory test rates a product mounted in a test chamber. A field test measures the installed unit with its flashing, its sealant joints and the wall around it. A report that cites the product's laboratory rating to prove the installation leaks, or a field failure to prove the product is defective, has to explain the link.
The reviewer asks for the test record: the standard and edition, the pressure, the water rate, the duration, which parts of the assembly were masked or isolated, and where water first appeared. Without that record the test cannot be repeated or checked.
Was the test pressure tied to the product rating or to the weather at the site?
In Pella the court faulted pressures derived from the manufacturer's rating rather than local weather. The reviewer checks how the expert chose the pressure and whether the leak observed by the owner occurred under comparable conditions.
In Pella the plaintiffs' experts ran spray rack tests that sprayed water on the outside of the windows at 5 gallons per square foot per hour while applying air pressure at zero, one-third, two-thirds and the full standard test pressure derived from the manufacturer's rating. They tested 45 windows from 13 homes and reported leakage in 67 percent.
Judge David C. Norton noted that the pressures were derived from the manufacturer's performance standards and that "there is no evidence they were tailored to any actual weather conditions." A window can leak at its full rated pressure without having leaked in service, and the question in the case was why the windows had leaked in service.
The reviewer therefore compares the test pressure with the conditions of the reported leaks: the storms, the wind exposure of the elevation, the height of the window. A report that reached leakage only at pressures the house never saw proves a capacity, not a cause.
Did the test reproduce the conditions under which the leak was seen?
ASTM E2128 asks the investigator to simulate the actual conditions under which leakage has been observed. In Pella the court held that the tests did not, and that the diagnostic standard AAMA 511 was clearly applicable and ignored.
The Pella court read ASTM E2128, the standard guide for evaluating water leakage of building walls, as requiring tests that "simulate the actual conditions under which leakage has been observed." The plaintiffs' experts had cited E2128 to support their method, and the court wrote: "The court cannot permit the plaintiffs to invoke ASTM E2128 as both a sword and a shield."
The court also found that AAMA 511, the diagnostic standard that ASTM E2128 references, was clearly applicable and had been ignored. A report that names a diagnostic standard has to follow it, and a reviewer lists each step of the cited standard against what the expert did.
The conditions include more than pressure: the water rate, the direction of spray, the duration and the state of the window (closed, latched, with screens and trim in place). Each departure from the observed conditions is a reason the test may show something other than the cause of the leak.
What is wrong with a nozzle test aimed at a joint?
Nothing, if it isolates a path after a realistic test found a leak. In Pella the nozzle tests used far more water than the spray rack and did not replicate real weather, so their 91 percent leak rate proved little.
The Pella experts also ran nozzle tests: a narrow stream of water at pressures the order gives as less than 1 and 2 psi, aimed at window jambs and at gaps in the sash rain strip. They tested 53 windows from 11 homes and reported leakage in 91 percent.
The court found that the nozzle delivered a volume of water far above the spray rack rate and did not replicate real weather. A concentrated stream on a joint can push water through a path that rain never reaches. In the court's words, the tests showed that leakage was possible, not probable: "This demands a showing of probability, not possibility."
A reviewer treats two uses of a nozzle differently: a diagnostic test that locates a path once a realistic test has produced a leak, and a test offered as proof that a leak occurs in service. The second use needs a link to service conditions that the report has to supply.
Did the expert separate a window defect from an installation defect or condensation?
The 2000 note to Rule 702 asks whether the expert accounted for obvious alternative explanations. In Pella the tests did little to raise the defect theory above installation errors, construction defects and condensation.
The committee note to the 2000 amendment of Rule 702 lists as a factor whether the expert "has adequately accounted for obvious alternative explanations." For a wet window those are the installation (flashing, sill pan, sealant), the wall around the opening, and condensation on cold glass or frames.
In Pella the manufacturer pointed to installation errors, construction defects and condensation as other causes of the leaks. The court wrote that the spray rack tests "do very little to elevate the SGH Experts' defect-related leakage theory above other potential causes."
The reviewer asks what the expert did to exclude each alternative: whether the interior trim was removed to see where water appeared, whether the flashing and sill were inspected, whether surface temperatures and indoor humidity were measured. Each step not taken leaves an alternative open.
How many windows were tested, and how were they chosen?
The sample has to represent the windows the opinion covers. In Pella the experts tested mostly the named plaintiffs' windows, and the court found that plaintiffs had not shown the sample was representative.
The court found that the Pella experts' inspections and testing "focused almost exclusively on Windows owned by the named plaintiffs," and held that the plaintiffs had not shown that the sample represented the roughly 7.5 million windows at issue: "Plaintiffs have failed to show that this was done here."
The same question arises in a single building. An expert who tested the five windows the owner pointed to, all on the elevation that faces the storms, can speak about those five. An opinion about every window in the building needs a sample chosen to represent them, and the report should say how it was chosen.
The reviewer asks for the list of windows inspected and tested, their locations and elevations, the selection method and the results for each, including the windows that did not leak.
Does a window that passed its rating test prove there is no defect?
No. In the 2023 study for the Florida Building Commission, every specimen that passed ASTM E331 and E547 at 15 percent of design pressure still let some water in during sine sweep or hurricane simulations.
The University of Florida report of June 8, 2023 tested off-the-shelf window and door products in a laboratory chamber. It found that every specimen that passed ASTM E331 and E547 at 15 percent of design pressure still had some water ingress during sine sweep or hurricane simulations, that there was no clear correlation between passing the current pass/fail standards and performance in hurricane passage testing, and that nearly half of the water-ingress-rated specimens failed the ASTM standard tests.
The report states that "Passing the ASTM tests does not appear to predict the performance" of a specimen and recommends moving away from binary pass/fail ratings. It also lists its limits: a small number of products and no statistically significant sample.
For a review this cuts both ways. A builder's expert who argues that a rated window cannot leak has to deal with this study, and a homeowner's expert who treats any leak in a severe test as a defect has to deal with the same finding that rated products let some water in under severe loading.
How does the review reach the court?
As a rebuttal report, deposition questions and the basis for a Rule 702 motion. A rebuttal report on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure unless the court orders otherwise.
Under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject is disclosed within 30 days after the other party's disclosure, absent a stipulation or court order. The rebuttal report follows Rule 26(a)(2)(B): opinions with basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony and compensation.
Under Rule 702 as amended on December 1, 2023, the party offering the expert must show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and a reliable application of reliable methods. In Pella the court granted the motion to exclude the SGH experts' opinions in full, including the wood treatment opinions: it found the lead expert qualified to identify wood deterioration but not to apply the IS-4 standard.
The review gives counsel the material for each route: the departures from the cited standards, the missing alternatives, the sampling, and the data the other side has not produced.
What does IAE do when the other side relies on a window water test?
IAE prepares reviews of the opposing construction expert's report and rebuttal reports for US cases, each point tied to a rule or standard, in up to 5 business days after format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE page on reviews of construction expert reports is written for attorneys facing the other side's construction expert on a leak, defective work or a repair estimate. The reviewer reads the opposing report with its exhibits and the data the expert considered, tests each opinion against the data behind it and writes a rebuttal report; deposition questions are part of the service. One of the page's checks is whether other sources such as roofing, plumbing and condensation were screened before the wall was blamed, as ASTM E2128-26 requires.
The client sends the opposing report with its exhibits, the test records and photographs disclosed, the window product data and installation instructions, and the deadlines, and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. IAE then confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- In re Pella Corp. Architect & Designer Series Windows Marketing, Sales Practices & Products Liability Litigation, 214 F. Supp. 3d 478 (D.S.C. Dec. 12, 2016), opinion text (hallapproved.com)
- Final Report: Assessing the Need to Modernize Water Penetration Resistance Test Procedures, University of Florida for the Florida Building Commission, June 8, 2023 (floridabuilding.org)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, with committee notes (uscode.house.gov)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Sinkhole claim denied in Florida: how does a reviewer test the insurer's engineering report?
When a Florida insurer denies a sinkhole claim after testing, the denial rests on the report of the engineer or geologist it hired. Sections 627.706
Cast iron pipe claim: what does a reviewer check in the opposing plumbing or engineering expert's report?
In a cast iron pipe dispute the expert's words about cause and duration decide coverage. In State Farm Florida Insurance Co. v. Feltes (Fla. 6th DCA
Concrete moisture testing in a flooring failure dispute: what does a reviewer check in the opposing expert's report?
When glue-down flooring lifts, bubbles or cups, the other side's expert may blame moisture in the concrete slab. ASTM F2170 measures relativeExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

