Examinations
Cost of repair or diminution in value: how are construction defect damages measured?
Courts measure construction defect damages in two ways: by what it costs to repair the work, or by how much the defect reduced the property's market value. The Supreme Court of Georgia called them alternative measures in 2008, and a plaintiff may present either or both. Diminution in value takes over when repair would mean unreasonable destruction of the work or a cost out of proportion to the injury, and each measure is proved by a different expert.

What are the two measures of damages for defective construction?
The cost of repairing or restoring the defective work, and the diminution in the property's value caused by the defect. Georgia's Supreme Court called them alternative, although oftentimes interchangeable, and let the plaintiff use either or both.
The Supreme Court of Georgia set out both measures in John Thurmond & Associates, Inc. v. Kennedy, docket No. S07G1776, decided on October 27, 2008. Writing for the majority, Justice Thompson stated: "As a general rule, damages for defective construction... are determined by measuring the cost of repairing or restoring the damage." Courts have also measured damages by "the diminution in value of the property after the injury occurred."
The court called the two measures "alternative, although oftentimes interchangeable," and added: "An injured party may choose to present his case using either or both methods."
The cost of repair answers the question what it takes to put the building into the condition the contract or the code required. Diminution in value answers a different question: how much less the property is worth on the market with the defect than without it. The first is proved by an engineer or a cost estimator who defines the repair scope and prices it. The second is proved by an appraiser who values the property twice, with the defect and without it.
Which measure do courts start with?
The cost of repair. In Thurmond the Georgia court called it the general rule, and an Illinois appellate court in Arch of Illinois described the measure as generally the cost of correcting the defective condition.
In Arch of Illinois, Inc. v. S.K. George Painting Contractors, Inc., an Illinois appellate panel wrote that the measure of damages for defective work "is generally the cost of correcting the defective condition." The exception is "the amount by which the defects have reduced the value of the property as a whole."
The contract in Arch of Illinois was for $59,000: one coat of primer and one coat of enamel on Arch's preparation plant in Percy, Illinois. The paint peeled. Arch's bids to sandblast, prime and repaint the plant came in between $120,000 and $248,000. Sherwin-Williams, which S.K. George blamed for defective paint and which Arch later added as a defendant, moved in limine to bar evidence of repair costs, and the circuit court of Perry County granted the motion and certified a question for review.
The appellate court reversed and held that the evidence of repair costs should not have been excluded. It expressed no opinion on which measure the facts supported and left that question to the jury.
When does diminution in value replace the cost of repair?
When the repair would involve unreasonable destruction of the contractor's work, or when its cost is unreasonably disproportionate to the benefit. Under Thurmond the cost of repair must be reasonable and bear some proportion to the injury.
The Illinois court in Arch of Illinois named two triggers. One is cost "unreasonably disproportionate to the benefit to the purchaser." The other is destruction of the work: "Only when correcting the defects would involve the 'unreasonable destruction' of a contractor's work" does the diminution standard apply. The court added: "It is not merely the destruction of the original work that must be considered."
The Georgia court stated the limit as a rule of reasonableness: "The cost of repair must be reasonable and bear some proportion to the injury sustained." It treated fair market value as evidence on that question. Fair market value "is one factor the fact finder may use to measure the reasonableness and proportionality of claimed damages."
The New Jersey Appellate Division put the same test in its own words in St. Louis, L.L.C. v. Final Touch Glass & Mirror, Inc. Repair costs are recoverable "unless that cost is clearly disproportionate to the property's probable loss of value." The court distinguished earlier New Jersey cases in which repair costs had been rejected because the award would have produced an economic windfall.
Does the owner have to prove market value to recover the cost of repair?
Not in Georgia. In Thurmond the Supreme Court of Georgia held that the fair market value of the improved property is not a necessary element of a claim for repair costs, and affirmed the reversal of a directed verdict.
David Kennedy's home was substantially damaged by fire. John Thurmond & Associates, a residential restoration and construction company, agreed to repair it for $311,156. Kennedy found construction problems and sued for breach of contract, breach of warranty, negligent construction and negligence. At trial he presented evidence that the repairs would cost about $751,632.
The trial court directed a verdict for the contractor because Kennedy had not proved the fair market value of the home after the repairs. The Court of Appeals reversed. The Supreme Court affirmed: "Evidence of the fair market value of the improved property is not a necessary element of his claim for damages" when the plaintiff seeks the cost of repair. It disapproved an earlier decision, Ryland, to the extent it "suggests fair market value is the only method." Because Kennedy presented some evidence of repair costs and the trial court had not found that measure inappropriate, the directed verdict was improper.
Justice Carley dissented: "Regardless of the measure of damages, however, the fair market value of the property must be proven." In his view, repairs of $751,631 to a house rebuilt for $311,156 were unreasonable, so Kennedy had to prove the loss in market value instead. The two opinions give the repair figure one dollar apart.
Who has to prove that the repair cost is out of proportion?
The defendant. Thurmond cites Corbin for the rule that the contractor bears the burden of proving economic waste, and in St. Louis the New Jersey court held that the defendant had to challenge the repair valuation.
In Thurmond the Georgia court relied on Corbin on Contracts for the point that the contractor bears the burden of proving that a repair award would constitute economic waste. The defendant may contest the reasonableness of the repair costs with contrary evidence.
In St. Louis the New Jersey court stated the same allocation after the plaintiff had made its case: once the plaintiff presented sufficient repair-cost evidence to reach the jury, "it became defendant's burden to challenge the valuation." The defendant's expert valued the unimpaired house at $2.8 million, which implied a diminution of $300,000. The jury was free to accept the repair-cost evidence instead, and the court held that the repair estimate supported the verdict.
For the defendant this means its own expert evidence: an appraisal of the property with and without the defect, and a critique of the plaintiff's repair scope. A defendant that offers neither leaves the jury with only the plaintiff's numbers.
Can an owner who sold the property still recover the cost of repair?
In New Jersey, yes. In St. Louis (2006) the Appellate Division held that selling the damaged house did not bar recovery of repair costs, and that a plaintiff need not spend the award on actual repairs.
St. Louis, L.L.C., formed by John Boulton and his wife, had a glass-walled house built in Franklin Township for about $8.5 million. Final Touch Glass & Mirror installed the glass panels, and its screws punctured nearly all the drain pipes, vent pipes and electrical raceways inside the steel columns.
After the lawsuit was filed, the Boultons tried to sell the house. A public auction drew no bids at a $3 million minimum, and the house sold for $2.5 million. The plaintiff's cost estimator put the repairs at $774,653, plus $200,000 if the roof had to be replaced. The jury returned a verdict of $737,500 and allocated 40 percent of the negligence to Final Touch and 60 percent to Wolf, the construction manager.
Final Touch argued that the plaintiff could prove damages only by a decrease in market value. The Appellate Division called that position "unduly rigid," declined to follow a 1975 District of Columbia decision, Wentworth v. Air Line Pilots Ass'n, and noted that the award "is not in excess of the value of the property." It affirmed the judgment on June 12, 2006, reported at 386 N.J. Super. 177.
Can a plaintiff recover both the cost of repair and the loss in value?
Sometimes. The Georgia court in Thurmond called a combined award unusual but appropriate to make the injured party whole when a loss in value remains after the remedial work.
Footnote 2 of the Thurmond majority opinion describes a combined award as "unusual" and says it may be appropriate "to make the injured party whole" when a diminution in value remains after the remedial work is done. In the main text the plaintiff may present the case "using either or both methods."
The dissent in Thurmond stated the limit from the other side, quoting Ryland: "the plaintiff is entitled only to the benefit of the bargain or to be made whole and not to recover a windfall."
A combined claim needs two pieces of expert evidence that fit together. The repair scope has to describe what the repair restores, and the appraisal has to describe what the repair leaves unrestored, such as a reduced market value after repair. If the two overlap, the defendant can argue that the same loss is counted twice.
Who decides which measure applies, the judge or the jury?
It depends on the state and the question. The Illinois court in Arch of Illinois called the choice usually a question for the jury, while the Georgia court in Thurmond said it is ordinarily determined by the trial court.
In Arch of Illinois the appellate court wrote: "The determination of which measure of damages to apply is usually a question for the jury." It added: "The jury should be permitted to hear evidence on both the cost of repairs and the diminution in value." Excluding the repair evidence before trial took that choice away from the jury, and the court reversed.
In Thurmond the Georgia court said that whether a repair or a diminution measure applies is "ordinarily determined by the trial court," and that "Juries, therefore, are given wide latitude" in setting the amount.
Arch of Illinois let the jury hear evidence on both measures, and Thurmond let the plaintiff present either or both. A party that comes to trial with only one measure has no fallback if the court or the jury finds that measure inappropriate.
What expert evidence does each measure require?
Cost of repair needs an engineer or estimator who defines the repair scope and prices it. Diminution in value needs an appraiser who values the property with and without the defect. St. Louis had both.
In St. Louis the plaintiff's cost estimator priced the repair at $774,653 and added $200,000 for a roof replacement if one proved necessary. The defendant's expert valued the house without the defect at $2.8 million. With the sale price of $2.5 million, that valuation implied a loss in value of $300,000, less than half of the repair estimate. The Appellate Division held that the repair estimate supported the jury's verdict of $737,500.
A repair estimate that will carry a verdict starts with the defect: what is wrong, where, and why. It then describes the repair that corrects that defect and nothing more, lists the quantities and prices each line. Work that would improve the building beyond the contract or the code is listed apart from the defect repair.
An appraisal for diminution in value compares two values at the same date: the property as it is, with the defect, and the property as it should have been. The appraiser explains how the defect reduces the price a buyer would pay, and the engineer supplies the description of the defect the appraiser relies on.
What does IAE do when a construction case turns on the repair cost?
IAE prepares an expert report on the questions agreed with the client about defects and code, repair scope and cost, or a review of the opposing construction expert's report, in up to 5 business days.
On the construction defects page the expert answers three groups of questions. Water intrusion: under ASTM E2128-26 the expert first checks whether the water came from the roof, plumbing or condensation, then tests the wall. Defects and code: the expert documents cracks, deflection, settlement and failed finishes and compares the work with the plans, the specifications and the code edition in force at permit. Scope and cost: the expert lists each damaged element, measures quantities on site or from photos and prices the repair line by line, with defect repair kept apart from upgrades.
The expert works from the documents, the photos and the site inspection record, and IAE confirms the questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- John Thurmond & Associates, Inc. v. Kennedy, No. S07G1776 (Ga. Oct. 27, 2008) (FindLaw Caselaw)
- St. Louis, L.L.C. v. Final Touch Glass & Mirror, Inc., 386 N.J. Super. 177 (App. Div. June 12, 2006), published parts of the opinion (Hall Approved)
- Arch of Illinois, Inc. v. S.K. George Painting Contractors, Inc., 288 Ill. App. 3d 1080 (Caselaw Access Project)
Read also
All articles
A neighbor's grading or paving sends water onto my property: who is responsible, and how does an expert prove the drainage change?
Whether a neighbor answers for water that runs onto your land depends on the surface water rule of the state. California asks whether each owner
Roof leaking after a roof replacement: how does an expert prove that the roofer's work caused it?
A roof that leaks a few weeks after it was replaced does not prove by itself that the roofer did bad work. The owner has to show where the water
Construction next door damaged my house: how does an expert tie the cracks to the neighboring work?
When excavation, pile driving or underpinning next door is followed by new cracks, tilting floors or sticking doors, the owner has to prove thatExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

