Expert report review
Challenging a custody evaluation's admissibility: what do courts examine?
A custody evaluation reaches the judge through a stipulation, a court order or the evaluator's testimony, and each route sets what the other parent can challenge. New York's highest court reversed a custody order in 1962 because the trial judge relied on psychiatric and psychological reports the parties had never agreed to. In 2004 a New York family court rejected an evaluator's recommendation after a rebuttal psychologist testified about the tests and the missing data.

Is a custody evaluation automatically evidence in the case?
No. In Kesseler v. Kesseler the New York Court of Appeals held that reports the parties had not stipulated to could not be used, and that without consent the experts had to testify subject to cross-examination.
A custody evaluation is a document written by a professional the court appointed or one of the parties hired. How it becomes evidence depends on the law of the state and on what the parties agreed. The question of admissibility therefore starts with paperwork: the order appointing the evaluator, any stipulation about the report, and the rule of court or statute that governs evaluations in that state.
Kesseler v. Kesseler, 10 N.Y.2d 445, was decided by the New York Court of Appeals on January 11, 1962. The trial court had relied on three reports in a custody modification: a family counsellor's report, a psychiatrist's report and a psychologist's report. The parties had stipulated only to the family counsellor's investigation and report.
The Court of Appeals held that considering the psychiatric and psychological reports was error. Without consent, such experts had to testify: "either party could have called those expert witnesses," subject to "cross-examination by the other party under common-law evidence rules." The orders were reversed and the matter was remanded for a hearing de novo.
For a parent who disagrees with an evaluation, the first task is to find out on what basis the report is before the court. A review that starts with the substance of the evaluation and never asks this question can miss the strongest objection in the case.
What went wrong in Kesseler?
The trial court kept three reports confidential, the parties' attorneys never saw them, and the court also considered a hospital psychiatrist's letter that was disclosed to the mother's counsel only after the decision.
The facts of Kesseler explain the holding. The parties had agreed to an investigation and report by a family counsellor. They struck from their agreement a clause that would have allowed psychiatric and psychological examinations. The trial court nonetheless received psychiatric and psychological reports and kept all three reports confidential. The parties' attorneys never saw them.
The court also considered a letter from a hospital psychiatrist. That letter was not disclosed to the mother's counsel until after the decision. A party cannot answer a document it has not seen, and it cannot cross-examine an author who never testified.
Chief Judge Desmond dissented. He would have affirmed, arguing that the mother had waived any objection through her conduct and that the decision rested on sound evidence regardless of the reports. The majority did not accept that view and sent the case back for a new hearing.
A modern review asks the Kesseler questions about every document the evaluator relied on. Was each one provided to both parties? Was each author available to testify? Did the parties agree to anything beyond the evaluation itself? The answers are in the court file and in the evaluator's list of sources, and they decide whether a later objection has a basis.
Can the parties agree that the court may read a report without testimony?
Yes. In Kesseler the stipulation to the family counsellor's report let the court consider it confidentially, and the Court of Appeals did not hold that parties could not stipulate to confidential reports.
The Court of Appeals treated the stipulation to the family counsellor's investigation as an agreement to suspend common-law evidence rules for that investigation. Because the parties had stipulated to it, the court could consider the report confidentially, even though counsel never saw it.
The court was careful about the limits of its ruling. It did not hold that parties "could not stipulate that such reports could be made confidentially to the court," and it noted that parties may waive appellate review by stipulation. The error lay in going beyond what the parties had agreed.
This makes the stipulation the first document a reviewer reads. If the parties agreed to a psychological evaluation and to the court's use of the report, the challenge is about weight rather than admissibility. If the stipulation covered only part of what the evaluator did, for example an interview-based report without psychological testing, the parts outside it may need a witness.
The order appointing the evaluator plays the same role where no stipulation exists. In California, rule 5.220 of the Rules of Court governs court-ordered evaluations, and the scope of the order sets what the evaluator was asked to do. Work outside the order is one of the defects a review lists.
What if the evaluator relied on documents the parent never saw?
Kesseler treats that as error when the documents fall outside the parties' agreement. The review lists every source in the report, marks which were disclosed and identifies authors who would have to testify.
In Kesseler the trial court considered a letter from a hospital psychiatrist that the mother's counsel saw only after the decision, along with two expert reports the parties had not agreed to. The Court of Appeals held that the court could not rely on the reports outside the stipulation, and that either party could have called those experts, subject to cross-examination.
A custody evaluation often relies on documents of the same kind: letters from therapists, school counselors' notes, a pediatrician's records, reports of earlier evaluations. A review builds a table of every source the report cites, with three columns: whether the parent has a copy, whether the source is in the evaluator's file, and whether its author is available as a witness. Sources in the report and absent from the file are the first item in the request to the evaluator. Sources whose authors cannot be examined are the first item in the objection.
What standard do courts apply to the evaluator's reasoning?
In Linda W. v. Frank T. (2004) a New York family court wrote that it "must demand that the expert's reasoning is scientifically valid," and it declined to rely on an evaluator whose reasoning failed that test.
Linda W. v. Frank T., 2004 NY Slip Op 51657(U), was decided by Judge Ettore A. Simeone of the Family Court, Suffolk County, on July 19, 2004 (Docket V-13130-03A). The forensic evaluator, identified as Dr. X, concluded that it would be in the child's best interest to live with his father. The court did not follow the recommendation.
The court weighed the reliability of the evaluator's opinion in deciding custody, and the standard it stated was demanding: "The Court must demand that the expert's reasoning is scientifically valid." It concluded that it "cannot rely on the scientific validity of the reasoning of the expert, nor agree with his ultimate conclusion."
The court drew on two secondary sources: an article by Shuman in the Family Law Quarterly (2002) on relying on experts without testing their methods, and the article by Tippins and Wittman "Empirical and Ethical Problems with Custody Recommendations: A Call for Clinical Humility and Judicial Vigilance." It wrote that "it clearly becomes the responsibility of this court to keep unscientific opinions out of the process entirely," and that "The best interest standard is a legal and socio-moral construct, not a psychological construct."
The opinion cites no Daubert or Frye decision. Its reasoning is still the reasoning of an admissibility analysis: the court looked at the methods, the data and the fit between them and the conclusion, and it found the opinion could not carry the weight the evaluator put on it.
What did the rebuttal psychologist show in Linda W.?
That the tests used had never achieved acceptability for custody cases, that results were misinterpreted, that a key finding had no supporting data, and that the evaluator had not observed the mother with the child.
The rebuttal expert, identified as Dr. Y, testified that the tests the evaluator used "have never achieved acceptability for use in custody cases." The opinion does not name the tests. It reports their results: the mother's showed "emotional overreacting, histrionic," and the father's showed "narcissism." Dr. Y also said that Dr. X "routinely misinterpreted and misrepresented aspects of the testing."
Dr. Y then went to the data. Dr. X had reported that the child felt closer to his father, and Dr. Y said Dr. X "failed to support this with any data." Dr. X had "failed to observe the mother and child together." He had "only observed the stepfather for an hour." Dr. Y described the approach as a "self confirming bias."
These points have a common structure. Each names a step of the evaluation, says what the step should have produced and points to its absence in the report. None of them requires the rebuttal psychologist to evaluate the family. They come from reading the report, the test data and the evaluator's notes.
That is the structure a work product review follows. For each conclusion in the evaluation it asks what data the conclusion rests on, where the data appear in the file, which methods produced them and whether those methods are accepted for the use made of them.
What did the court rely on instead of the evaluator's recommendation?
Its own findings on the statutory considerations: the child's equal bond with both parents, stability of home and school, the sibling relationship and each parent's conduct.
Rejecting a recommendation does not leave the court without a basis. In Linda W. the court found that "the love and respect Matthew has for one parent equals that for the other," so each parent was a good parent. It awarded custody to the mother to keep the child's wish for the status quo and to avoid "another move for Matthew and another school."
The court found "no 'overwhelming need'" to separate the child from his brother. It found the father "inflexible with his schedule more to spite the petitioner than in the best interests of Matthew," and noted that he disregarded the mother's input on therapy, doctor visits and the holiday schedule. It also criticized the "tit for tat" behavior of both parents, including the father's move without notice to the mother and the mother's two days' notice of her own move.
These findings rest on testimony and records that were in the case independently of the evaluation. A party challenging an evaluation therefore prepares two things: the critique of the evaluator's reasoning, and the evidence on which the court can decide without it. A review supplies the first. The attorney assembles the second.
The opinion also shows what the court did with the evaluator's findings on the child's relationships. The evaluator had reported that the child felt closer to his father. The court, after hearing that this finding had no supporting data, found an equal bond. A review that identifies an unsupported finding of this kind gives the attorney a specific point on which to offer the court other evidence: school records, testimony of people who see the child with each parent, the child's own statements in the form the court accepts.
Can a second evaluator testify if the other parent refused to take part?
In an unpublished 2016 Idaho decision, the trial court barred such an evaluator from giving a custody recommendation but let him comment on the court-appointed evaluator's methodology, and the appeals court affirmed.
Orndorff v. Padlo, Docket No. 43836, was decided by the Idaho Court of Appeals on September 7, 2016, as Unpublished Opinion No. 672. The opinion states that it "shall not be cited as authority," so it is described here as an example of how a trial court handled the problem, not as precedent.
Dr. Ward, the court-appointed evaluator, recommended primary physical custody for the mother. The father's expert, Dr. Watts, conducted a second evaluation in which the mother did not take part. The magistrate barred Dr. Watts from giving a best-interests or custody recommendation, but allowed him to comment on Dr. Ward's methodology "from a general perspective." The magistrate also excluded as irrelevant emails about the mother's refusal to participate in Dr. Watts's evaluation.
The Court of Appeals affirmed. It reasoned that "absent a court order, Stephanie was not required to participate," so excluding the custody opinion of an evaluator who had seen only one side was not an abuse of discretion, and the father offered no authority requiring its admission.
The distinction the magistrate drew is the one a reviewing psychologist works within. An opinion on custody needs an evaluation of both parents. An opinion on how another evaluator did the work needs only the work.
Does the evaluator have to interview everyone in the household?
Not under the Idaho statute and rule discussed in Orndorff. The court found that observing both parents and considering attachment and the home environment supported compliance with the evaluation rule.
In Orndorff the father objected to Dr. Ward's testimony and report for not complying with Rule 719 of the Idaho Rules of Family Law Procedure. At trial he made a foundational objection, arguing that Dr. Ward did not address the factors of Idaho Code section 32-717, particularly the child's relationship with the children of the father's partner, who lived in his home.
The magistrate sustained the foundational objection and let the mother lay more foundation. Dr. Ward then gave his custody opinion without further objection. On appeal, the court held that the statute and the rule do not require an evaluator to interview or observe every person living in a parent's home. The record showed that Dr. Ward observed both parents and considered attachment and the home environment.
The court also wrote that "the purpose of an evaluation is to guide the trial court in making a custody determination," and that "the Idaho Rules of Evidence do not exclude the report from consideration." The objection worked as a procedural tool: it forced the proponent to lay a foundation for the opinion in front of the court.
For a reviewer the lesson is practical. An objection that the evaluator skipped a person or a factor succeeds when the rule requires that step. Where the rule does not, the omission goes to the weight of the opinion, and the review explains why the missing information matters for the specific conclusion.
What do California's rules say about the evaluator's report and cross-examination?
Rule 5.220 sets the evaluation procedures, bars recommendations about a party not evaluated directly or with another neutral professional, and requires each local court to develop procedures for cross-examining evaluators.
Rule 5.220(e)(2) of the California Rules of Court lists the procedures: reviewing "pertinent documents related to custody, including local police records"; observing parent-child interaction unless contraindicated to protect the child; interviewing the parents and assessing, among other things, the "History of child abuse, domestic violence, substance abuse, and psychiatric illness"; and interviewing the child and parents together or separately unless contraindicated.
Rule 5.220(j)(3) directs the evaluator to "Not offer any recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional." Rule 5.220(d)(2)(A) has the evaluator "Consider the health, safety, welfare, and best interest of the child within the scope and purpose of the evaluation," which ties the evaluation to the order that defined its scope.
On testimony, rule 5.220(k) provides: "Each local court must develop procedures for expeditious and cost-effective cross-examination of evaluators." The procedures to consider include videoconferences, telephone conferences, audio or video examination and the scheduling of appearances.
These provisions give a review its checklist in a California case. Did the evaluator follow each listed procedure or explain why it was contraindicated? Does the report recommend anything about a person the evaluator never saw? And which local procedure will govern the cross-examination, so that the questions from the review are ready in the form the court will use?
What should a party obtain from the evaluator before the hearing?
The evaluator's file: notes, test data, collateral contacts and every document relied on. The AFCC Model Standards foreword says evaluators should form opinions only on information in their records that is available for inspection.
The Reporter's Foreword to the Model Standards of Practice for Child Custody Evaluation of the Association of Family and Conciliation Courts was printed in Family Court Review in January 2007. It says that forensic mental health professionals should "formulate opinions only on the basis of information that is in their records and is available for inspection." It also says that "Cross-examining attorneys must be able to present evaluators with items from their files," and the same sentence goes on to questions about how those items were used in forming the opinions.
The same foreword addresses the evaluator's status. It states that the work product of a court-appointed custody evaluator "should be subjected to no less scrutiny than the work product of a retained expert." A court appointment does not exempt the evaluation from review.
Kesseler shows the consequence of the opposite practice. Reports the parties never saw, and a letter disclosed after the decision, led to reversal. A party preparing to challenge an evaluation asks for the full file early, through the procedure the court has set, and gives it to the reviewing psychologist with the report.
The reviewer reads the file against the report. Each test score cited in the report should appear in the test data. Each statement attributed to a collateral source should appear in the notes of that contact. Each observation should appear in the observation notes with its date and length. Where the report says more than the file contains, the review lists the gap.
How does a review address the psychological tests in the evaluation?
By asking which tests were used, for what purpose, whether they are accepted for that purpose in custody cases, how the scores were interpreted and whether the conclusion depends on them.
In Linda W. the rebuttal testimony on testing had two parts: the tests "have never achieved acceptability for use in custody cases," and the evaluator "routinely misinterpreted and misrepresented aspects of the testing." The first is a point about the method. The second is a point about its application. A review keeps them apart.
On the method, the reviewer identifies each instrument, the question it was designed to answer and whether the evaluation used it for that question. If an instrument was built for clinical assessment, the review asks how the evaluator linked its scores to the parenting questions in the order, and whether the report states that link or passes directly between a score and a recommendation about where the child should live.
On the application, the reviewer compares the scores in the test data with the descriptions in the report. Labels such as "histrionic" or "narcissistic" should trace to specific scales and specific elevations. If the report uses the label and the data do not show the elevation, or show it with a validity problem the report does not mention, the review says so with the page and scale.
The reviewer also checks the weight the report puts on the tests. If the custody recommendation would stand on the interviews and observations alone, a testing error matters less. If the recommendation rests on the test results, the error goes to the core of the opinion.
What can a reviewing psychologist not do at the hearing?
Recommend custody. The reviewer has evaluated no one, and California rule 5.220(j)(3) bars recommendations about a party not evaluated directly. In Orndorff the second evaluator was limited to methodology.
A reviewing psychologist reads documents and does not meet the family. Under rule 5.220(j)(3) an evaluator may not offer recommendations about a party who was not evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional, and a reviewer who has evaluated no party has no basis for any recommendation.
Orndorff shows a court drawing the same line for an evaluator who had seen only one parent: the custody opinion was excluded, and testimony on the court-appointed evaluator's methodology was allowed. A reviewer who stays within methodology offers the court the kind of testimony that survived there.
The reviewer also does not decide disputed facts. Whether an incident happened, whether a parent's account is true, what the child wants: these are for the court. The review says whether the evaluation gathered the information needed to address them and whether its conclusions follow from what it gathered.
Within those limits the reviewer can say a good deal. The review can state that a conclusion has no data behind it, that a test was used for a question it was not designed to answer, that an observation lasted an hour, that a parent was never observed with the child, that a document was relied on but never produced. In Linda W. points of exactly this kind came from the rebuttal psychologist, and the court relied on them.
Will the court exclude the evaluation or only give it less weight?
Both outcomes appear in the cases. Kesseler reversed for reliance on reports outside the stipulation, Linda W. weighed and rejected a recommendation, and Orndorff kept the court-appointed report in evidence.
The three decisions show the range. In Kesseler the problem was the route by which reports reached the court, and the remedy was reversal and a new hearing. In Linda W. the report was in evidence, and the court declined to rely on it after hearing the rebuttal psychologist. In Orndorff the court-appointed report stayed in, and the challenge produced only a requirement that the proponent lay a better foundation.
A party rarely controls which outcome it gets. What it controls is the record. A procedural objection needs the order, the stipulation and proof of what was disclosed. A reliability challenge needs a qualified witness who can explain to the court what is wrong with the methods and data. A weight argument needs both, plus the independent evidence on which the court can decide.
A review prepared early serves all three. It identifies procedural gaps for the objection, gives the attorney the questions for cross-examining the evaluator under the local procedure, and, if the reviewing psychologist testifies, becomes the basis of that testimony.
Timing matters as well. An objection to the route by which a report reached the court is made before the court relies on it, as the mother's counsel in Kesseler could not do with a letter disclosed after the decision. A foundational objection is made when the evaluator testifies, as the father did in Orndorff. A reliability critique needs the rebuttal witness ready at the hearing, as Dr. Y was in Linda W. The review is scheduled backward from the first of these dates.
What does IAE do when a party challenges a custody evaluation?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review that measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.
IAE describes the review for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. A psychologist from the IAE registry measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines and writes the work product review. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.
IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
The specialist confirms in the document that they have no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- Kesseler v. Kesseler, 10 N.Y.2d 445 (N.Y. 1962)
- Linda W. v. Frank T., 2004 NY Slip Op 51657(U) (Fam. Ct., Suffolk County, July 19, 2004) (New York Official Reports)
- Orndorff v. Padlo, Idaho Court of Appeals, Docket No. 43836, Unpublished Opinion No. 672 (Sept. 7, 2016)
- California Rules of Court, rule 5.220, Court-ordered child custody evaluations
- Association of Family and Conciliation Courts, Reporter's Foreword to the Model Standards of Practice for Child Custody Evaluation (2007)
Read also
All articles
Capacity to sign a contract or deed: how is the opposing expert's opinion on mental capacity reviewed?
An expert opinion that a person lacked the mental capacity to sign a contract or deed is written after the signing, in some cases years later
Sexual abuse allegations in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?
When a parent alleges that a child was sexually abused, a California custody evaluation must follow Family Code section 3118: the evaluator consults
Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?
In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme CourtExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

