Expert report review
Which errors does a reviewing psychologist find in child custody evaluations?
A reviewing psychologist checks a custody evaluation against the court order, the court rule for evaluators and the 23 custody guidelines the American Psychological Association adopted in February 2022. The defects the reviewer looks for have names in those texts: a prior therapy relationship with a family member, unmanaged bias, suggestive questioning of the child, missing screening for family violence, test results read without context, findings outside the order and disputed allegations reported as fact.

Can a family member's therapist serve as the custody evaluator?
The APA guidelines treat it as a conflict. Guideline 12 asks psychologists to avoid conflicts of interest and multiple relationships, and its commentary names evaluating one's current or prior psychotherapy clients among them.
Guideline 12 of the APA Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings states: "Psychologists aspire to avoid conflicts of interest and multiple relationships." The commentary gives examples, among them "Conducting child custody evaluations with one's current or prior psychotherapy clients/patients."
The commentary also covers the move between roles after the evaluation. According to the commentary, a psychologist who served as the custody evaluator and then becomes the family's parenting coordinator may also face a conflict of interest.
A reviewer looks for these relationships in the report and the file: earlier treatment notes in the evaluator's own name, a referral history, a prior role in the same family's case.
The same question arises for the reviewer. A psychologist who treated the child or a parent is not a neutral reviewer of another psychologist's evaluation, and the review states that the reviewer has no prior relationship with the family.
How does confirmatory bias show up in a custody report?
As an early hypothesis that the report never tests, as one parent's data set out in detail and the other's only briefly, and as contrary facts left out. Guideline 11 and California Rule 5.220(j) require evaluators to control for bias.
APA Guideline 11 states: "Psychologists strive to function as fair and impartial evaluators." Its commentary warns that "cognitive, confirmatory, implicit, or other biases may compromise a custody evaluation" and adds that "Psychologists are encouraged to be skeptical of their own objectivity." Guideline 21 asks psychologists "to manage their own biases when integrating and analyzing evaluation data."
California Rule of Court 5.220(j) puts the duty in legal form. The evaluator must "Maintain objectivity, provide and gather balanced information for both parties, and control for bias." Rule 5.220(f) requires the evaluator to present information that does not support the conclusions reached.
The reviewer measures balance in the text. How many pages describe each parent's interviews? Whose collateral sources were contacted? Which concerns raised by the parent the evaluator later criticized were followed up? An evaluation that records one parent's account as background and the other parent's account as a claim to be tested has applied two standards.
The reviewer also checks the order of events. If the report's first interview already states the conclusion that appears in the summary, and later data that point the other way receive no discussion, the review marks the point where the hypothesis stopped being tested.
What errors occur in interviewing the child?
Repeated or leading questions, techniques not suited to the child's age, and no record of how the questions were asked. APA Guideline 13 asks for developmentally appropriate, empirically supported methods and warns about subtle suggestibility.
Guideline 13 concerns the evaluation of children. Psychologists aim to use developmentally appropriate techniques with empirical support and to interpret the results in light of the child's best interests. The commentary names the risk directly: "repeated questioning or subtle suggestibility that may influence children's responses."
The reviewer reads the interview notes as well as the report's summary of them. A note that records the questions in the evaluator's words lets the reviewer see whether a question suggested its answer, whether the child was asked the same thing several times, and who was present or brought the child to the session.
A report that quotes a young child's statement as a finding about a parent, with no description of how the statement was obtained, gives the reader no way to judge its weight. The review lists each such quotation with the page and the missing information.
Age matters for the methods as well. A technique designed for adolescents applied to a six-year-old, or a drawing task interpreted without a stated basis for the interpretation, goes into the review with a reference to Guideline 13.
Is it an error to skip screening for family violence or substance use?
Under the APA guidelines, yes. Guideline 15 asks psychologists to screen for family violence and child maltreatment in all types of cases and throughout the evaluation, and Guideline 16 asks them to screen examinees for substance use.
Guideline 15 asks psychologists to screen thoroughly for family violence, child maltreatment, intimate partner violence and the trauma that follows from them. The commentary says: "Psychologists strive to implement screening across all types of cases," and "Screening is ideally an ongoing process throughout the custody evaluation, rather than a one-time event."
Guideline 16 states: "Psychologists endeavor to screen examinees for substance use."
The reviewer looks for the screening in the procedures section and in the interview notes. A report that never mentions how violence or substance use was asked about, or that screened once at intake and never returned to the subject after new allegations arose, departs from both guidelines.
Screening is a question of method, separate from the findings. The review does not decide whether violence occurred. It states whether the evaluation looked for it in the way the guidelines describe and whether the conclusions take the results into account.
Can test results be produced by the stress of the custody dispute itself?
Yes. APA Guideline 21 asks evaluators to analyze data in context, and its commentary notes that the circumstances of the evaluation may produce results that show temporary states tied to the situation rather than lasting traits.
Guideline 21 asks psychologists to analyze evaluation data within its context, grounded in psychological science and the referral questions. The commentary notes that the circumstances of a custody dispute may lead to assessment results that show temporary, situationally determined states.
A parent tested in the weeks after a separation, a police call or a removal of the children may score high on scales of anxiety, anger or suspicion. A report that treats those scores as stable personality traits, and draws parenting conclusions from them, has skipped the step the guideline describes.
Guideline 2 adds a limit on what a personality test can carry. It states that "The evaluation focuses upon parenting abilities, the children's needs, and the resulting fit," and its commentary says that "Comparatively little weight may be afforded to evaluations that are limited to a general personality assessment."
The reviewer checks three things for each test conclusion: when the test was given and what had happened in the family shortly before, whether the report discusses situational explanations, and whether the conclusion speaks to parenting or only to personality.
What if the evaluator goes beyond the court order?
Findings outside the order are a defect in their own right. Guideline 3 asks evaluators to clarify the purpose, use and scope of the evaluation before accepting it, and Rule 5.220(e)(1) requires a written explanation of the process.
APA Guideline 3 asks psychologists, before they accept a referral, to clarify the stated purpose of the evaluation, its intended use, its scope and the agreed timeline. California Rule 5.220(e)(1) requires "A written explanation of the process that clearly describes the" purpose, the procedures and the time required, the scope and distribution of the report, the limits of confidentiality and the cost.
In his April 2011 column on custody evaluations, Timothy M. Tippins discussed the New York case L.R. v. T.R. and wrote that evaluators must stay within their appointment orders, some of which bar custody recommendations. In his view, a violation of the order should make the court view the whole report with suspicion.
The reviewer sets the order next to the table of contents of the report. A recommendation the order did not request, an opinion about a parent's new partner who was not part of the referral, or a discussion of financial matters outside the questions are marked with the page and the paragraph of the order they exceed.
APA Guideline 22 notes that courts and retaining counsel may or may not ask the evaluator for recommendations. If the order asked only for findings, a recommendation in the summary is outside the scope.
Can the evaluator report one parent's allegations as fact?
Not when the allegations are disputed. Credibility findings belong to the judge, and Rule 5.220(f) requires the report to include information that does not support its conclusions and to describe the limits of the evaluation.
Tippins wrote that evaluators should not adopt one side's disputed allegations as fact, because judges make the credibility findings, and that evaluators can report conclusions in the alternative: if the court finds the allegation true, one conclusion follows, and if it does not, another.
Rule 5.220(f) lists what every California evaluation must contain. The evaluator summarizes the data sources and the time spent, includes information that does not support the conclusions reached, describes limitations caused by unobtainable information, and makes recommendations only about parties who were evaluated.
APA Guideline 19 asks psychologists to gather enough data to address the scope of the evaluation and to support their conclusions. A disputed incident described only from one parent's interview, with no record, witness or other source named, has one source behind it, and the review says so.
The reviewer builds a table of the key facts in the report with the source the report names for each. Facts with a single interested source, and conclusions that depend on them, go into the review as a separate group.
What does IAE do when a party needs a custody evaluation reviewed?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation or an expert report on the client's questions. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The forensic psychological evaluation and review page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. Under the 2022 APA custody guidelines, the evaluator combines several methods, standardized measures and observation of parent-child interaction (Guidelines 10, 17, 18), and the review checks the opposing report against the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02) and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03).
IAE frames the questions from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirms them before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, verifiable by Member ID or QR code. Materials go through the contact form or to info@iaexperts.com and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- American Psychological Association, Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings, adopted as association policy in February 2022 (copy of the APA document)
- California Rules of Court, rule 5.220, Court-ordered child custody evaluations (amended effective January 1, 2023)
- Timothy M. Tippins, Raising the Bar for Custody Evaluations, Law Journal Newsletters, April 14, 2011
- American Psychological Association, Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology (Guidelines 9.02, 9.03, 10.02)
Read also
All articles
Capacity to sign a contract or deed: how is the opposing expert's opinion on mental capacity reviewed?
An expert opinion that a person lacked the mental capacity to sign a contract or deed is written after the signing, in some cases years later
Sexual abuse allegations in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?
When a parent alleges that a child was sexually abused, a California custody evaluation must follow Family Code section 3118: the evaluator consults
Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?
In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme CourtExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

