Expert report review

When does a custody evaluator have a conflict of interest?

A custody evaluator who once treated a parent, plans to become the family's parenting coordinator or has ties to one side's lawyer holds more than one role in the case. The 2022 APA custody guidelines ask psychologists to avoid such conflicts, and the 2022 AFCC guidelines ask evaluators to disclose them in writing. A reviewing psychologist checks the report and the file for these relationships and for what was disclosed.

Two closed appointment books and two face-down family photos sit on a quiet desk

What counts as a conflict of interest for a custody evaluator?

Any personal, scientific, professional, legal, financial or other interest or relationship that could impair the evaluator's objectivity. The APA and AFCC guidelines focus on multiple relationships, where the evaluator holds another role with a person in the case.

Guideline 12 of the APA Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings, adopted as association policy in February 2022, reads: "Psychologists aspire to avoid conflicts of interest and multiple relationships." Its application section asks psychologists to refrain from serving as a custody evaluator when "personal, scientific, professional, legal, financial, or other interests or relationships" could impair their objectivity or expose others to harm.

The rationale is stated in the same guideline. Real or apparent conflicts "may increase the likelihood of unfairness, undermine the court's confidence" in the evaluator's opinions, and can "potentially harm all parties involved." The commentary defines a multiple relationship as one in which the psychologist is in a professional role with someone and also has another relationship with that person, or with someone closely associated with or related to that person.

The AFCC Guidelines for Parenting Plan Evaluations in Family Law, approved by the AFCC Board of Directors on May 11, 2022, use a narrower definition. Under Guideline 3.1(c), "Conflicts of Interests" refer to "multiple relationships that could compromise an evaluator's independence, objectivity, competence, and effectiveness."

Can a parent's or child's therapist evaluate the family?

The APA guidelines treat it as a conflict. The commentary to Guideline 12 lists conducting custody evaluations with current or prior psychotherapy clients, and Guideline 19 asks treating psychologists to refrain from custody recommendations.

The commentary to APA Guideline 12 gives as an example of a conflict "Conducting child custody evaluations with one's current or prior psychotherapy clients/patients." The word prior matters for the review: a course of therapy that ended years before the appointment still falls within the example.

The same commentary covers the reverse direction: "conducting psychotherapy with one's current or prior child custody examinees." A psychologist who evaluated the family and then begins treating the child or one of the parents is in the situation the commentary describes.

A treating clinician who is not the evaluator can still be a witness. Guideline 19 says that "treating psychologists, whose roles differ from those of custody evaluators," endeavor to refrain from offering recommendations on custody, parenting time or decision making. When a therapist's letter or testimony ends with a recommendation about which parent should have the child, the reviewer notes that the guideline asks treating psychologists not to give one.

The commentary also names the relationship with someone "closely associated with or related to" the person. The reviewer applies that wording to earlier treatment of a parent's new partner or of a parent's sibling and records it with its dates.

Can the evaluator later become the family's parenting coordinator?

The APA commentary says that a custody evaluator who becomes the parenting coordinator may also have a conflict of interest. A parenting coordinator works with the family after the order, and courts limit what a coordinator may decide.

The commentary to Guideline 12 states that a custody evaluator's move into the role of parenting coordinator "may also be a conflict of interest."

The District of Columbia Court of Appeals described how the two roles fit together in Jordan v. Jordan, Nos. 09-FM-1152, 09-FM-1337 and 10-FM-375, decided March 10, 2011. The court-appointed custody evaluator, Dr. William B. Zuckerman, recommended joint custody and the appointment of a parenting coordinator. The trial court appointed a different person, Ms. Roberta Eisen, as parenting coordinator under Superior Court Domestic Relations Rule 53, over the mother's objection.

The Court of Appeals held that Rule 53 authorized the appointment, but limited the delegated authority to day-to-day issues: "[A] trial court may not abdicate its responsibility to decide the core issues of custody and visitation." Read as a whole, the court said, the order was "a permissible exercise of the court's authority under Rule 53."

When the same psychologist evaluates the family and then acts as coordinator, the reviewer checks two things in the record: whether the dual role was disclosed before the appointment, and whether the evaluator's recommendations named himself or herself, or a colleague from the same practice, for the later role.

What must an evaluator disclose before accepting the case?

Under AFCC Guideline 3.3, any role conflicts or potential role conflicts with the parties, attorneys or judicial officers, and, before accepting an appointment with multiple relationships, a written disclosure followed by a written waiver.

AFCC Guideline 3.3(a) says that "Evaluators should disclose any role conflicts or potential role conflicts with the parties, attorneys or judicial officers" involved in the case. The guideline reaches beyond the family: a professional or social tie to one side's lawyer or to the judge falls within it.

Guideline 3.3(b) sets the form. Before accepting an appointment that involves multiple relationships, the evaluator should give "a reasonably detailed written disclosure of current, prior, or anticipated relationships" and obtain a written waiver. Under Guideline 3.2(a) the relationships counted are those evaluators "currently have, have had, or expect to have" with those involved in the litigation, so a planned later role counts as well as a past one.

The APA guidelines address the case where a second role cannot be avoided. The commentary to Guideline 12 asks psychologists to disclose their dual roles, clarify role expectations and explain how confidentiality may be affected.

The AFCC guidelines use the word should throughout. The Foreword explains that "should" means the guideline is "highly desirable, strongly recommended, and should be followed unless the evaluator can articulate good reasons for deviating." A reviewer who finds an undisclosed relationship therefore also looks for any explanation the evaluator gave for proceeding.

When should an evaluator decline the appointment?

When the conflict is significant. AFCC Guideline 3.2(a) says evaluators should decline cases with a significant conflict of interest arising from multiple relationships, and APA Guideline 12 asks psychologists to refrain from serving when an interest could impair objectivity.

AFCC Guideline 3.2(a) reads: "Evaluators should decline cases where there is a significant conflict of interest arising from multiple relationships." Guideline 3.2(b) gives evaluators "the right to refuse to be involved in an evaluation when multiple roles are involved."

The APA wording in Guideline 12 is that psychologists refrain from serving as a child custody evaluator when interests or relationships could impair their objectivity. Guideline 11 adds a working rule for the evaluator: "Psychologists are encouraged to be skeptical of their own objectivity."

Neither text sets a time limit after which a past relationship stops counting. The reviewer records the facts the report and the file give: what the earlier relationship was, when it began and ended, whether it involved treatment, and whether the evaluator addressed it in the report.

Can the evaluator give a parent advice during the evaluation?

Not as a rule. AFCC Guideline 3.4 asks evaluators to refrain from therapeutic advice or intervention until the analyses have been completed, unless there is a credible risk of imminent harm.

Guideline 3.4 says evaluators should "refrain from offering therapeutic advice or intervention during an evaluation until the analyses have been completed," unless there is a credible risk of imminent harm. Advice to one parent in the middle of the evaluation is a second role taken on inside the first.

The reviewer reads the session notes and correspondence in the file for advice, instructions or referrals given to one parent before the analyses were completed, and lists each with its date and the page of the file.

How does a reviewer find a role conflict in the evaluation file?

By reading the report's account of sources and contacts against the file: intake forms, session notes, correspondence, billing records and any disclosure or waiver. Each earlier relationship is listed with its dates and with the guideline it touches.

The reviewer starts with the list of sources and contacts in the report, then compares it with the file: who referred the family, who paid, which collateral sources were called, and whether the evaluator's name appears in records that predate the appointment, such as therapy notes or an earlier evaluation of the same child.

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 703 an expert may base an opinion on facts or data in the case that the expert has been made aware of or personally observed. The reviewer's opinion rests on the same file, so the review lists the documents read and the pages relied on.

Guideline 23 of the APA custody guidelines asks psychologists to describe persons evaluated or consulted, "and the work of other professionals, in a respectful and appropriate manner." The review names facts and the guideline each fact touches. It does not characterize the evaluator's motives.

AFCC Guideline 10.4 asks evaluators who rely on formal assessment data of earlier evaluations to examine "the qualifications of the previous evaluator." The reviewer applies the same check in the other direction: when the evaluator relied on an earlier assessment, the review records who performed it and whether that person had a prior role with the family.

Does a conflict make the evaluation inadmissible?

Not automatically. The APA guidelines are aspirational and the AFCC guidelines are recommendations. The court decides whether to admit the report, what weight to give it and whether to order another evaluation.

The introduction to the APA custody guidelines says that "Guidelines are aspirational in intent" and that they "are not intended to be mandatory or exhaustive." The AFCC Foreword defines should as a strong recommendation that the evaluator may depart from with good reasons. Neither text, by itself, removes an evaluation from the case.

In federal court, Rule 702 as amended in 2023 admits expert testimony only if the proponent shows the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and on reliable principles and methods reliably applied. The 2023 committee note says that "Some challenges to expert testimony will raise matters of weight rather than admissibility." In a state court the attorney identifies the state rule, and the reviewer reads the review against it.

A review gives the attorney material for each route: an objection to the appointment if the relationship is known early, cross-examination of the evaluator on the relationship and on the missing disclosure, and a request that the court weigh the report in light of the guidelines or order a further evaluation by someone without the conflict.

Must the reviewing psychologist be free of conflicts too?

Yes. A reviewer who treated the child or a parent, or who has ties to the evaluator, holds the kind of second role the guidelines describe. A testifying reviewer in federal court also discloses prior testimony and compensation.

The APA custody guidelines state that they "are not intended for psychologists functioning either in a consultant role" in custody litigation. The reasons Guideline 12 gives for avoiding multiple relationships still apply to a consultant: a reviewer who treated a family member cannot give an independent account of another psychologist's evaluation of that family.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, facts known and opinions held by an expert retained only to consult are ordinarily not discoverable, except under Rule 35(b) or on a showing of exceptional circumstances. If the reviewer becomes a testifying expert, the written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) lists the cases in which the reviewer testified in the previous four years and states the compensation to be paid for the study and testimony.

The reviewer also stays within the review. AFCC Guideline 11.1(b) asks evaluators to refrain from "offering opinions regarding parenting plans when they have not evaluated all of the parties." A reviewer who has examined no one comments on method, data and compliance with the order and the guidelines, and makes no recommendation about custody.

What does IAE do when a party suspects a conflict in a custody evaluation?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review that measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA guidelines, including any prior relationship with the family.

The review is for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. The reviewer reads the report and the underlying data, checks them against the court order, the rules for evaluators and the APA custody guidelines, and writes where the evaluation follows them and where it does not. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.

IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member