Expert report review

Review of the opposing document examiner's report or a second examination: which comes first?

A review reads the opposing examiner's report and file; a second examination tests the document again. In most disputes the review comes first: it removes no ink from the page, it can stay confidential under Rule 26(b)(4)(D), and it tells counsel what a retest would have to answer. A second examination needs the original under Rule 34 and, for ink dating, enough ink left on the page to sample.

A hand pauses between a closed report and an original document under a loupe

What is the difference between a review and a second examination?

A review checks the other examiner's work: the report, the notes, the images and the reasoning. A second examination repeats the work on the evidence itself and produces an independent result that can support or contradict the first.

The forensic science lexicon of the Organization of Scientific Area Committees, published by NIST, defines verification as "The subsequent independent examination by another trained and competent examiner," which either supports or refutes the original examiner's conclusions. The entry notes that some laboratories require the original items to be examined. A second examination for a party follows the same idea: a new examiner looks at the evidence and reaches a result of his or her own.

A review does something narrower. The reviewer reads what the first examiner received, what was done to it, what was recorded and how the conclusion was worded. The review answers whether the report holds together on its own record. It does not produce a new finding about the signature, the page or the ink.

The two are often confused because both end in a written opinion that disagrees with the first report. The difference matters for what each one needs. A review needs the report and the file. A second examination needs the questioned document, the comparison material, a laboratory and, for any chemical test, permission to remove part of the document.

Why can a second examination on different material not be compared with the first?

Because conclusions depend on the evidence each examiner had. Ted M. Burkes of the FBI Laboratory and Ronald N. Morris wrote in 2013 that only reports based on exactly the same evidence can be compared with each other.

Ted M. Burkes of the FBI Laboratory and Ronald N. Morris presented "The Case of Different Documents and Different Conclusions" at the 2013 meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. In their case an FBI Laboratory examiner compared questioned signatures with the known writing of two men, Harrup and Helvey. A second examiner, contacted by Mr. Harrup's attorney, reached an inconclusive result; the abstract notes that "The documents submitted initially were photocopies of marginal quality."

The authors' point is stated in one sentence: "only reports based on exactly the same evidence can be compared with each other." They also describe a later comparison of five other documents that led to a probably wrote conclusion, reported orally: "A verbal conclusion was reported to the attorney and he did not want a written report."

For a party deciding between a review and a second examination, the lesson is practical. A second examination ordered on a different copy or different exemplars will produce a different report, and the other side will say that it answers a different question. A review identifies first what the original examiner had, so that any second examination can be run on the same items or on better ones, with the difference recorded.

Why does the review usually come first?

It costs no part of the document, it can be finished inside the rebuttal window, and it tells counsel whether a second examination could add anything. For ink dating it also shows how much ink is left.

A review works from paper the parties already have: the report, the notes and images produced in discovery, and copies of the document. Nothing is removed from the original, and the review can be done while the original remains in the other side's custody.

The review also sorts the problems by kind. Some flaws are in the reasoning: a conclusion worded more strongly than the observations allow, a threshold that the report never states, a comparison with entries that were not shown to be the same ink. Those can be presented through a rebuttal or cross-examination without any new test. Other flaws are in the evidence: the first examiner worked from a copy, used exemplars from the wrong period or never saw the original. Those may justify a second examination.

In ink dating the order matters more, because the test consumes the entry. In Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, the defense chemist Gerald M. LaPorte reported in his report of March 25, 2012 that there was "not enough ink available" from the initials on page 1 for further dating. A party that orders a second dating test before anyone has checked what remains may find that the entry it wanted tested is already gone.

Qualified opinions point to the same sequence. Jane A. Lewis, in a 2019 presentation to the American Academy of Forensic Sciences on reasons for qualified opinions, named the lack of contemporaneous known writing, the lack of known writing comparable to the questioned writing and poor clarity copies, and wrote that original questioned and known documents give the examiner the fullest information and that submitters should aim for good quality first-generation copies. A review that finds one of those gaps tells counsel what a second examination would need before it is worth ordering.

Can a review stay confidential?

Yes, while the reviewer is a consulting expert who will not testify. Rule 26(b)(4)(D) ordinarily bars discovery of such an expert's facts and opinions, with two exceptions, Rule 35(b) and exceptional circumstances.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D) a party ordinarily may not, by interrogatories or deposition, discover facts known or opinions held by an expert who has been retained or specially employed in anticipation of litigation or to prepare for trial and who is not expected to be called as a witness. The exceptions are the situation provided in Rule 35(b) and "exceptional circumstances under which it is impracticable for the party to obtain facts or opinions" on the same subject by other means.

A party that does obtain such discovery pays for it. Rule 26(b)(4)(E) requires the party seeking discovery, unless manifest injustice would result, to pay the expert a reasonable fee for time spent responding and, for discovery under (D), "a fair portion of the fees and expenses it reasonably incurred" in obtaining the expert's facts and opinions.

The status changes when the party decides to use the reviewer at trial. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any person who has been identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and if a written report is required, the deposition may be conducted only after the report is provided. A second examiner hired to test the original and testify is a testifying expert from the start, and that examiner's results will be disclosed.

The sequence therefore has a strategic side that the rules make visible. A confidential review lets counsel learn whether the first report has weaknesses before deciding whether to put a second examiner's results on the record.

Does a second examination fit inside the rebuttal deadline?

Often not without planning. A rebuttal is due 30 days after the other side's disclosure absent a stipulation or order, and the response to a Rule 34 request to test the original is due 30 days after service.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the default for rebuttal: evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party is due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure," absent a stipulation or a court order.

A second examination of the original usually runs through Rule 34. Under Rule 34(b)(2)(A) the responding party "must respond in writing within 30 days after being served," unless the parties stipulate or the court orders otherwise. If the request is served after the opposing report arrives, the response may come on the same day the rebuttal is due, before any testing has begun.

A review fits the default window because it uses what was produced with the report. A second examination fits it only if counsel arranges access early, agrees a protocol with the other side or asks the court for a schedule with dates for testing. A request served before expert disclosures, or a scheduling order that sets dates for inspection of the original, removes the conflict.

How does a party get the original for a second examination?

Through a Rule 34 request to inspect, copy, test or sample the document, which must specify a reasonable time, place and manner. Burden and intrusiveness of testing are handled by protective orders under Rule 26(c).

Rule 34(a)(1) lets a party request that another party produce and permit the requesting party or its representative to inspect, copy, test or sample designated items in the responding party's possession, custody or control. Under Rule 34(b)(1)(B) the request "must specify a reasonable time, place, and manner for the inspection and for performing the related acts."

The 2006 committee note added testing and sampling to the rule and said that concerns about "burden and intrusiveness" can be addressed under Rules 26(b)(2) and 26(c). Rule 26(c)(1) lets the court, for good cause, issue an order "specifying terms, including time and place," for the discovery, "prescribing a discovery method other than the one selected" by the requesting party, and designating the persons who may be present.

When the document is held by someone who is not a party, such as a bank, a notary or a former employer, Rule 34(c) applies: "As provided in Rule 45, a nonparty may be compelled to produce documents and tangible things or to permit an inspection."

The review supplies the content of the request. It names what the first examiner did not do and therefore what the second examiner needs: the original rather than a copy, specific pages, specific entries, comparison documents from the same period, and, for chemical tests, the number and location of samples.

What if the first examination used up the ink?

Then a second dating test of that entry may be impossible, and the dispute is decided on the first report and its review. Old extracts kept by the first laboratory rarely help.

The Ceglia record shows both sides of the problem. LaPorte's report states that the plaintiff "objected to the removal of additional ink plugs and the Court later resolved this issue, ordering the extraction of additional samples," and that he returned "on August 27, 2011, as authorized by the Court order."

The ink specialist on the plaintiff's side, Speckin, took ten vials of ink and four of paper on July 25, 2011, and gave no dating opinion. In his deposition he said his remaining samples were "probably discarded after a year" and explained why old extracts are of limited use: "After a year of sitting out of the document in a vial, any value would be very minimized." Ink dating on such samples, in his words, "would be very questionable."

When a second dating test is no longer possible, the review carries the challenge. It sets out what the first examiner measured, which threshold was applied, what the report says about the ink's condition and storage, and how many samples were taken by whom. Those points go to the court on admissibility under Rule 702 and to the trier of fact on weight.

If a second examination is done, can both reports go to the jury?

Yes, if each meets Rule 702. The 2000 committee note says that a finding that one expert is reliable does not mean that contradictory expert testimony is unreliable.

The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 states: "When a trial court, applying this amendment, rules that an expert's testimony is reliable, this does not necessarily mean that contradictory expert testimony is unreliable." The amendment "is broad enough to permit testimony that is the product of competing principles or methods in the same field of expertise."

Each report is tested on its own record. Since the 2023 amendment the proponent must show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data and is the product of reliable principles and methods. A second examination that was run on a better original or on proper exemplars answers those questions with its own data; a review answers them by pointing to the gaps in the first report.

What does IAE do when a party is deciding between a review and a second examination?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing examiner's report and, where needed, a report on the party's own questions. The format is confirmed within one business day; the document is issued in up to 5 business days.

The IAE page for questioned documents lists the work for federal and state cases: whether a page was inserted or replaced, an entry erased or overwritten, a stamp impression made by the stamp in question, and how the document was printed, prepared as a report on the client's questions or as a review of the opposing examiner's report. The review page names the review of the opposing examiner's report, the signed PDF in up to 5 business days and a 48-hour rush.

The reviewer reads the opposing report and the produced file against ANSI/ASB Standards 011 and 035, the SWGDOC ink comparison standard and Rule 26(a)(2)(B). The page states that the other side's examiner can test a party's original through a Rule 34 request and that Standard 035 requires recorded permission and images before and after any destructive test. The questions and the handling of any original are agreed with the client before work starts.

The client sends the report and the materials and describes the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Specialists are members of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member