Journal

EB-1B scholarly articles: what does "scholarly journals with international circulation" require?

An EB-1B petition for an outstanding professor or researcher can count the researcher's articles only if they appeared in scholarly journals with international circulation in the academic field. That is one of six criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(i), and at least two must be met. In four AAO decisions from 2021 and 2024 the articles passed this step, and each appeal was lost at the final merits stage.

A librarian seen from behind packs bound journals into an open mail crate

What does the EB-1B scholarly articles criterion say?

Criterion (F) of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i) asks for evidence of the researcher's authorship of scholarly books or articles, in scholarly journals with international circulation, in the academic field. It is one of six criteria, and two are required.

The regulation requires evidence that the professor or researcher "is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the petition." That evidence "shall consist of at least two of the following": major prizes or awards, membership in associations that require outstanding achievements, published material by others about the researcher's work, participation as a judge of the work of others, original scientific or scholarly research contributions, and authorship.

The authorship criterion reads in full: "(F) Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly books or articles (in scholarly journals with international circulation) in the academic field." Three limits sit in that sentence. The work must be scholarly, journal articles must appear in scholarly journals with international circulation, and the publications must be in the academic field named in the petition.

The regulation defines an academic field as "a body of specialized knowledge offered for study at an accredited United States university or institution of higher education." A petition that names the field too broadly or too narrowly changes which articles count under criterion (F) and which awards and memberships count under the other five.

What else does an EB-1B petition need besides the articles?

At least three years of teaching or research in the academic field and a qualifying job offer from a US university, institution of higher learning or private research employer. The employer files the I-140; no labor certification is required.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(i)(1), a United States employer that wants to employ an outstanding professor or researcher files the I-140 petition. The petition includes evidence of at least three years of experience in teaching or research in the academic field, in letters from current or former employers with the writer's name, address and title and a specific description of the duties (204.5(i)(3)(iii)).

Experience gained while working on an advanced degree counts only if the degree was obtained and either the researcher had full responsibility for the classes taught or the research toward the degree "has been recognized within the academic field as outstanding."

The offer of employment comes in a letter from a US university or institution of higher learning offering a tenured or tenure-track teaching position or a permanent research position, or from a department, division or institute of a private employer offering a permanent research position. A private employer must show that it employs at least three persons full-time in research positions and has documented accomplishments in an academic field (204.5(i)(3)(iv)). Permanent means tenured, tenure-track or for a term of indefinite or unlimited duration with an ordinary expectation of continued employment.

How does the EB-1B article criterion differ from the EB-1A one?

EB-1A accepts scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media. EB-1B names scholarly journals with international circulation and adds scholarly books, both in the academic field.

The EB-1A criterion at 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) reads: "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media." The EB-1B criterion at 204.5(i)(3)(i)(F) covers "scholarly books or articles (in scholarly journals with international circulation) in the academic field."

The two texts differ in three places. EB-1B counts books as well as articles. EB-1A refers to the field, EB-1B to the academic field, which the regulation ties to a body of knowledge taught at an accredited US university or institution of higher education. And EB-1A describes the outlet as a professional or major trade publication or other major media, while EB-1B describes it as a scholarly journal with international circulation.

EB-1B also needs an employer's petition and two of its six criteria. Both lists contain an article criterion, so the same publications can be presented in either category, with the evidence matched to the wording of each.

What does the regulation say about international circulation?

Only the phrase itself, in parentheses after "scholarly journals". The regulation gives no definition, and in the four AAO decisions cited here the AAO accepted the articles without discussing circulation.

Paragraph (i)(2) of 8 CFR 204.5 defines "academic field" and "permanent" but not "international circulation". In the decisions of August 18, 2021 (laser physics), October 4, 2021 (artificial intelligence), March 4, 2024 (sociology) and March 22, 2024 (computer vision and machine learning), the AAO found that the beneficiary's authorship of scholarly articles met the initial evidence requirement and did not analyze circulation.

University immigration offices set their own document standards. The EB-1B factsheet of IFSIS, the immigration office for faculty and scholars at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, states that the office generally only includes publications in journals "ranked in the top 20 by Google Scholar" or "ranked in the first quartile (Q1) by Scimago", and that publications in obscure, unranked or unindexed journals do not help an EB-1B petition.

For an author the practical record for each article is the journal's name, publisher, editorial board, peer review procedure, where it is indexed and where it is read. Those documents answer the parenthetical phrase in the regulation, and they are also the starting point for the citation evidence the AAO weighs at the next step.

Why is meeting the article criterion not enough?

Because the AAO applies a two-step review. Meeting two criteria is only the first step; at the final merits stage the evidence as a whole must show that the researcher is internationally recognized as outstanding.

In the March 4, 2024 decision the AAO wrote that meeting the criteria "is only the first step" and that "the successful submission of evidence meeting at least two criteria does not, in and of itself, establish eligibility." It then conducts "a final merits determination to decide whether the evidence in its totality shows" international recognition. The decision cites Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), for the two-step process.

The October 4, 2021 decision notes that USCIS "has confirmed the applicability of this two-step analysis" to outstanding professors and researchers and cites the USCIS Policy Manual, volume 6, part F, chapter 3, section B. In its words, outstanding professors and researchers "should stand apart in the academic community" through "eminence and distinction based on international recognition."

In all four decisions cited here the beneficiary met at least two criteria and the appeal was dismissed. The articles counted at step one, and the question at step two was what they showed about the researcher's standing.

How does the AAO weigh citations and journal rankings?

As evidence of influence, measured against others in the field. The AAO has held that publication in a highly ranked journal is not enough by itself and that raw citation counts need comparative statistics.

The August 18, 2021 decision states: "Publication in a highly ranked journal in-and-of-itself is insufficient" to show international recognition. The AAO explained that a high ranking or impact factor describes the citation rate of the publication as a whole, and the March 22, 2024 decision adds that a high ranking "does not, however, show the influence of any particular author".

For citations the AAO asks for comparison. The 2021 decision refers to the lack of "comparative statistical evidence indicating how often others in the Beneficiary's field are cited," and the 2024 decisions use the phrase "Without statistical evidence or other objective metrics comparing the number of citations." In the March 4, 2024 decision the AAO also noted that the petitioner had not submitted evidence of the ranking of the journals relative to other publications.

The March 4, 2024 decision states that "the citation history or other evidence of the influence of the Beneficiary's books or articles can be an indicator" of international recognition, and the March 22, 2024 decision says the same of articles. A petition file therefore pairs each article with its citation count, the source of the count and a comparison with researchers in the same field and career stage.

Do conference papers count?

They can sit in the record, but the AAO has refused to treat a highly ranked conference or a presentation as proof by itself. In 2021 it asked for evidence of the impact of the presented research.

In the October 4, 2021 decision, concerning a researcher in artificial intelligence, the AAO found it was not established that "publication in a conference proceeding with a high ranking alone is sufficient." It added: "A high CORE ranking does not, however, show the influence of any particular author."

The August 18, 2021 decision dealt with conference presentations by a laser physicist and held that "without documenting the impact of his presented research, such participation is not sufficient." The same decision found that the petitioner had not shown "the international stature" of an LLE publication that reports on the scientific work of the beneficiary's own laboratory.

Criterion (F) names scholarly books and articles in scholarly journals. A conference paper published in proceedings enters the record as an article, and its weight at the final merits stage depends on the same evidence of influence as a journal article.

Why does the AAO say authorship is inherent to research work?

Because professors and researchers publish as part of their jobs. The AAO therefore looks for evidence that the publications influenced the field, beyond the fact that they exist.

The October 4, 2021 and March 22, 2024 decisions both begin the discussion of articles with the same clause: "As authoring scholarly articles is often inherent to the work of professors and researchers," the citation history or other evidence of influence can indicate international recognition.

The August 18, 2021 decision cites the Policy Manual for the point that authorship "should be evaluated to determine whether they were indicative" of international recognition. A list of publications answers criterion (F); evidence of what others did with the work answers the final merits question.

What standard of proof applies to an EB-1B petition?

Preponderance of the evidence. The petitioner must show that eligibility is more likely than not, and the AAO looks at whether the researcher stands apart in the academic field through outstanding achievement.

The March 22, 2024 decision places the burden of proof on the petitioner, who must establish eligibility by a preponderance of the evidence. Its footnote explains that a petitioner must show that what it claims is "more likely than not" or "probably" true.

The same decision concluded that "the Petitioner has not shown that he stands apart in the academic field through outstanding achievement and international recognition." The March 4, 2024 decision describes the purpose of the regulation as establishing "a beneficiary's international recognition," and asks whether the achievements are enough to establish such recognition.

What if the criteria do not readily apply to the field?

The petitioner may submit comparable evidence. Under 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(ii), if the standards of the six criteria do not readily apply, other evidence may establish the researcher's eligibility.

The text reads: "If the standards in paragraph (i)(3)(i) of this section do not readily apply, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." The petitioner explains why a criterion does not fit the field and what the substitute evidence shows.

USCIS Policy Alert PA-2022-12 of March 23, 2022 updated the appendices to Policy Manual volume 6, part F, chapters 2 and 3. For an outstanding professor or researcher it states that published material about the person's work "need not be a printed article; rather, a petitioner may submit more varied forms of evidence." That guidance concerns criterion (C), material written by others; the alert does not address criterion (F) on the researcher's own articles.

How does IAE Review handle manuscripts?

IAE Review is a peer-reviewed open-access journal. Each manuscript goes through double-anonymous review by at least two independent reviewers, and the initial editorial decision comes within 7 business days.

IAE Review is the peer-reviewed journal of the International Association of Experts, published in open access under the CC BY 4.0 licence. Articles appear as soon as they are ready, without fixed issues, and each has a permanent page and PDFs in English and Russian. The journal is interdisciplinary and has eight sections: six OECD fields of science, Expert examination and assessment, and Professional practice and standards.

Every manuscript goes to at least two independent reviewers under double-anonymous review: authors and reviewers do not know each other. The initial decision, to send for review or decline, comes within 7 business days, and the decision after peer review within 60 calendar days of submission; revisions requested by reviewers extend the term. The procedure is set out in the editorial policy.

Manuscripts in Russian or English go through the submission form as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX, with an abstract and 5 to 8 keywords in both languages. IAE membership is not required and does not affect editorial decisions. Whether an article meets criterion (F), and what weight it carries at the final merits stage, is decided by USCIS.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Journal

Want to publish in IAE Review?

Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

Manuscript

Received

Initial decision within 7 business days

Article typeOriginal research
Reviewers2, double-anonymous
DOI10.68034 via Crossref