Expert witnesses
Can an expert witness be paid a contingency fee under state ethics rules and federal law?
The ethics rules for lawyers in California, Texas, New York, Massachusetts and Florida let a lawyer pay an expert witness a reasonable fee for professional services and forbid pay that depends on the testimony or on the result of the case. The District of Columbia is the exception: its comment permits an expert's fee conditioned on recovery if the fee is not a percentage of the recovery. Federal criminal law sets a separate limit.

Can an expert witness be paid a contingency fee?
In most U.S. jurisdictions, no. Ethics rules permit a reasonable fee for an expert's professional services and forbid compensation contingent on the testimony or the outcome. The District of Columbia permits a fee conditioned on recovery.
The comment to Rule 3.4 of the North Dakota Rules of Professional Conduct gives the general rule in two sentences. It is not improper to pay a witness's expenses or to compensate an expert witness on terms permitted by law. Then: "The common law rule in most jurisdictions is that it is improper to pay an occurrence witness any fee for testifying and that it is improper to pay an expert witness a contingent fee." The comment to North Carolina's Rule 3.4 uses the same words, and the North Carolina State Bar quoted them in 2022 Formal Ethics Opinion 5.
In those two states the rule text is short. Paragraph (b) forbids a lawyer to "offer an inducement to a witness that is prohibited by law." The ban on contingent expert fees comes from the common law that the comment describes. California, Texas, New York, Massachusetts and Florida wrote the ban into the text of the rule and added an express exception for an expert's reasonable fee.
These rules bind lawyers. In Formal Ethics Opinion 5 the North Carolina State Bar wrote that the contract entered into by the client and the public insurance adjuster "is not governed by the Rules of Professional Conduct." Courts and bar committees therefore ask who agreed to the fee, when it was agreed, and whether the lawyer took part. The cases below turn on those three facts.
Which state rules forbid contingent fees for expert witnesses?
California Rule 3.4(d), Texas Rule 3.04(b), New York Rule 3.4(b) and Massachusetts Rule 3.4(g) bar compensation contingent on the testimony or the outcome. Florida Rule 4-3.4(b) permits only a reasonable, noncontingent fee for an expert.
California Rule 3.4(d) forbids a lawyer to "directly or indirectly pay, offer to pay, or acquiesce in the payment of compensation to a witness contingent upon the content of the witness's testimony or the outcome of the case." Except where prohibited by law, the lawyer may advance, guarantee or acquiesce in the payment of expenses reasonably incurred by a witness in attending or testifying, reasonable compensation for loss of time, and "a reasonable fee for the professional services of an expert witness."
Texas Rule 3.04(b), in the text effective January 31, 2022 published by the Texas courts, has the same three exceptions and two extra words. A lawyer may not pay, offer to pay, or acquiesce in the offer or payment of compensation "to a witness or other entity contingent upon the content of the testimony of the witness or the outcome of the case." The words "other entity" reach a company that employs the expert. The Texas opinion on that point is discussed below.
New York Rule 3.4(b), as the New York State Bar Association quotes it in Ethics Opinion 962 of March 18, 2013, bars compensation "contingent upon the witness's testimony or the outcome of the matter." It permits "a reasonable fee for the professional services of an expert witness and reasonable related expenses." Any witness may receive reasonable compensation for loss of time spent attending, testifying, "preparing to testify or otherwise assisting counsel."
Massachusetts puts the ban in Rule 3.4(g). Comment [5] states: "Compensation of a witness may not be based on the content of the witness's testimony or the result in the proceeding." After a sentence on compensation for lost time and expenses, the comment adds: "A lawyer may pay a reasonable fee for the professional services of an expert witness."
Florida reaches the same result through the wording of the exception. Rule 4-3.4(b) of the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar, in the 2014 text that the Florida Supreme Court quoted in footnote 1 of Trial Practices, Inc. v. Hahn Loeser & Parks, LLP (December 28, 2018), forbids a lawyer to "offer an inducement to a witness, except a lawyer may pay" a witness reasonable expenses of attending or testifying, "a reasonable, noncontingent fee for professional services of an expert witness;" and reasonable compensation "for the time spent preparing for, attending, or testifying at proceedings." The expert fee clause reads the same in the pre-2014 text, which the court applied to the 2011 trial in that case.
Why do the rules ban outcome-based fees for experts?
To keep false testimony out of court. In 1977 the Second Circuit upheld New York's former DR 7-109(C), writing that perjured expert testimony is particularly difficult for a juror to detect.
Carl E. Person represented ten plaintiffs in the Nabcor antitrust action. He wanted to retain experts in accounting, franchising, financing and economics on a contingent fee basis and argued that his clients could not otherwise afford adequate expert testimony. New York's Disciplinary Rule 7-109(C) said that a lawyer shall not "pay, offer to pay, or acquiesce in the payment of compensation to a witness contingent upon the content of his testimony or the outcome of the case." It allowed "a reasonable fee for the professional services of an expert witness."
The Eastern District of New York granted summary judgment for Person and declared the rule unconstitutional as applied to contingent expert fees. It found the treatment of contingent payment as improper "too irrational to survive Fourteenth Amendment analysis." The Second Circuit reversed and dismissed the complaint in Person v. Association of the Bar of the City of New York, 554 F.2d 534 (2d Cir. 1977). Judge J. Joseph Smith wrote the opinion for a panel with Chief Judge Kaufman and Judge Mulligan.
The court applied rational-basis review. It wrote that the rule "was promulgated to insure that judicial proceedings in New York were free of false testimony" and that "perjured expert testimony is particularly difficult for a juror to detect." On Person's arguments, it said: "We are not convinced, however, that there is no danger of the inducement of false expert testimony." It added: "New York may tackle a problem one step at a time." Person's points about cross-examination and experts' indirect stakes, the court said, "may indicate the desirability of legislative change."
The Alabama State Bar's 1997 opinion places DR 7-109 in the "old Model Code of Professional Responsibility." New York's current Rule 3.4(b), quoted above, keeps the ban on compensation contingent on the testimony or the outcome.
Does any jurisdiction allow an expert fee that depends on winning?
The District of Columbia does, within a limit. Comment [8] to D.C. Rule 3.4 lets an expert's fee depend on the outcome, provided the fee, while conditioned on recovery, is not a percentage of the recovery.
D.C. Rule 3.4(b) forbids a lawyer to falsify evidence, to counsel or assist a witness to testify falsely, "or offer an inducement to a witness that is prohibited by law." Comment [8] turns to payments. It is not improper to pay a witness's expenses or to compensate a witness for loss of time spent "in preparing to testify, in attending, or in testifying."
The comment then departs from every state rule quoted above: "A fee for the services of a witness who will be proffered as an expert may be made contingent on the outcome of the litigation, provided, however, that the fee, while conditioned on recovery, shall not be a percentage of the recovery."
The comment separates two arrangements. A fixed sum that the expert receives only if the client recovers fits within it. A share of the award does not. In California, Texas, New York, Massachusetts and Florida both arrangements fall under the ban, because in each the payment depends on the outcome of the case.
Can the contingent fee go to a consulting service or the expert's employer?
Not where the rule reaches other entities. Texas Opinion 553 found it a violation to use as an expert an employee of a company with a contingent fee interest, and Florida Opinion 98-1 rejected a contingency-fee medical-legal consulting service.
The Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas decided Opinion 553 in August 2004. A property tax consulting company had a contingent fee contract with a property owner covering the subject of the lawsuit and paid the litigation expenses, including expert witness fees. One of its employees, a licensed real estate appraiser, was to testify as the expert.
The committee wrote that "[t]he payment of a contingent fee to an entity that is the employer of an expert witness clearly comes within the prohibition of Rule 3.04(b)." Its conclusion reads: "It is a violation of the Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct for a lawyer to use in a case as an expert witness an employee of a business entity that has a contingent fee interest in the outcome of the case."
Florida answered a similar question about consulting services in Ethics Opinion 98-1 of March 27, 1998. A medical-legal consulting service offered a malpractice lawyer a physician who would review the records and then serve as the expert, with the service paid a contingency fee. The opinion reads Rule 4-3.4(b) as a rule that "prohibits the payment of a contingency fee for the services of an expert witness" and concludes: "It is impermissible for an attorney to enter into an arrangement with a medical-legal consulting service" of that kind.
Opinion 98-1 quotes a committee member's statement in Pennsylvania Informal Opinion 95-79 about a consultant entitled to a share of the recovery: "let us not forget MFRI's interest in the outcome of the litigation--15% of the recovery." The Florida opinion also cites bar opinions from Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, the District of Columbia, Tennessee, South Carolina, New Jersey, Texas, Illinois and Pennsylvania, and ABA Formal Opinion 87-354.
What if the client agreed to pay the witness a percentage before the lawsuit?
In October 2022 a Texas federal court refused to strike a public adjuster paid 10% of the insurance settlement, and the North Carolina State Bar allowed a lawyer to call a percentage-paid adjuster as an expert.
In Arthur v. Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co., No. SA-21-CV-00602-FB (W.D. Tex.), Adam and Colleen Arthur claimed wind and hail damage to the metal roof of their San Antonio home from a May 27, 2020 storm. They had hired public adjuster Logan Rodgers for "10% of RCV (Replacement Cost Value) of total insurance settlement" and designated him "as a non-retained expert" on, among other things, the cost of repairs. Liberty Mutual moved to strike him, arguing that the fee agreement gave him a stake in the outcome and made him biased.
On October 24, 2022, Magistrate Judge Elizabeth S. Chestney denied the motion. She read Rule 3.04 as a bar on an attorney's offer to compensate a witness contingent upon the outcome of the case and wrote: "There is no such agreement in this case." The agreement was "between Plaintiffs (not Plaintiffs' attorneys) and Rodgers," it predated the litigation by about a year, and "Rodgers did not enter into an agreement to provide testimony in exchange for proceeds of this litigation." Bias was left for trial: "Liberty Mutual may attempt to discredit Rodgers at trial by cross examining him on any bias."
The North Carolina State Bar adopted 2022 Formal Ethics Opinion 5 on October 21, 2022. A homeowner whose property suffered hail damage hired a licensed public adjuster for a percentage of the insurance proceeds and later hired a lawyer for trial. Assuming the court qualifies the adjuster as an expert, the lawyer may call him, the opinion concludes. The lawyer is not "offer[ing] an inducement to a witness that is prohibited by law," because "the statute permits the client to pay the public adjuster a contingency fee." The opinion relies on N.C. Gen. Stat. 58-33A-60(d), which caps adjuster fees at ten percent in a catastrophic incident.
In both matters the client signed the fee agreement with the witness, and the lawyer did not. Neither decision covers an expert that a lawyer retains for the lawsuit itself.
Does federal criminal law limit what a witness may be paid?
Yes. 18 U.S.C. 201(c) punishes giving or receiving anything of value for testimony, with up to two years in prison, but subsection (d) exempts a reasonable expert fee for preparing the opinion and testifying.
Section 201(c)(2) of title 18 reaches whoever "directly or indirectly, gives, offers, or promises anything of value to any person, for or because of the testimony under oath or affirmation given or to be given by such person as a witness upon a trial, hearing, or other proceeding." It covers testimony before any court, any committee of Congress, and any federal agency, commission or officer authorized to hear evidence or take testimony. Section 201(c)(3) covers the witness who demands, seeks, receives or accepts the payment.
The penalty is a fine, imprisonment for not more than two years, or both.
Subsection (d) lists what stays lawful: witness fees provided by law, and payment by the party that calls the witness of "the reasonable cost of travel and subsistence incurred and the reasonable value of time lost in attendance," or, "in the case of expert witnesses, a reasonable fee for time spent in the preparation of such opinion, and in appearing and testifying." The statute measures the lawful expert fee by the time spent preparing the opinion and testifying.
How does the other side learn how the expert is paid?
From the expert report and from discovery. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(vi) requires a statement of the compensation for the study and testimony, and communications about compensation are not protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(C)(i).
In federal court the written report of a retained expert must include "a statement of the compensation to be paid for the study and testimony in the case" (Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(vi) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure). The other side has the fee terms before the deposition begins.
Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects most communications between counsel and a retained expert. The protection does not extend to communications that "relate to compensation for the expert's study or testimony." Messages between counsel and the expert about payment can therefore be requested in discovery and used in cross-examination.
The deposition has its own payment rule. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E), unless manifest injustice would result, the court must require the party seeking discovery to "pay the expert a reasonable fee for time spent in responding to discovery." In Arthur, the court named cross-examination as the way to test a witness whose fee may create bias.
What fee terms may a lawyer agree with an expert?
A reasonable fee for professional services and reasonable expenses. The Alabama State Bar's 1997 opinion calls for a reasonable and customary fee that does not depend on the outcome and covers only time actually spent.
The Disciplinary Commission of the Alabama State Bar answered the question in opinion 1997-02 of October 29, 1997: "An attorney may pay an expert witness a reasonable and customary fee for preparing and providing expert testimony." The fee may not be contingent on the outcome. A fact witness may be reimbursed actual expenses, including lost time or income, but may not be paid for testimony.
The opinion also covers an expert who knows facts of the case. Such a witness may be paid the usual fee for the expert work. The lawyer should not pay more than that fee or for more time than the expert actually spent, because the excess could look like payment for factual testimony.
The opinion quotes Rule 1.8(e)(1), which lets a lawyer "advance court costs and expenses of litigation, the repayment of which may be contingent on the outcome of the matter." A lawyer working on a contingent fee may therefore pay the expert's invoices and be repaid by the client only if the client recovers. The expert's own fee still may not depend on the outcome.
Payments to fact witnesses have narrower limits. In Trial Practices, the Florida Supreme Court held that rule 4-3.4(b) permits a party to pay a fact witness for assistance with case and discovery preparation that is directly related to the witness preparing for, attending, or testifying at proceedings.
How does IAE handle expert fees when it searches for an expert?
IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs and hourly rates within 5 business days for a $2,000 search fee paid in advance. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony.
The request form on the expert witnesses page asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check, and a short description of the case. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline.
Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, the lists that Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Candidate names and CVs come after the search fee is paid. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee.
The fee rule is printed in the pricing block of the page: the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option at +$100 per hour, with one invoice from IAE: a retainer, monthly invoices, ACH or wire transfer within 15 days, and the search fee credited to the first invoice. The witness search agreement and the expert witness agreement are published in advance. IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- North Dakota Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 3.4 Fairness to Opposing Party and Counsel, with comment (North Dakota Supreme Court)
- North Carolina State Bar, 2022 Formal Ethics Opinion 5: Client Paying Public Adjuster-Witness a Contingency Fee (October 21, 2022)
- State Bar of California, Rules of Professional Conduct, chapter 3, rule 3.4
- Texas Disciplinary Rules of Professional Conduct, effective January 31, 2022, Rule 3.04 (Texas Judicial Branch, txcourts.gov)
- New York State Bar Association, Committee on Professional Ethics, Opinion 962 (March 18, 2013)
- Massachusetts Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 3.4 (Mass.gov, Supreme Judicial Court rules)
- Trial Practices, Inc. v. Hahn Loeser & Parks, LLP, No. SC17-2058 (Fla. Dec. 28, 2018) (Justia copy of the court's PDF)
- Person v. Association of the Bar of the City of New York, 554 F.2d 534 (2d Cir. 1977) (Justia)
- D.C. Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 3.4 Fairness to Opposing Party and Counsel, with comments (D.C. Bar)
- Texas Center for Legal Ethics, Professional Ethics Committee Opinion 553 (August 2004)
- Professional Ethics Committee for the State Bar of Texas, Opinion 553 (August 2004) (University of Houston Law Center copy)
- The Florida Bar, Professional Ethics Committee, Ethics Opinion 98-1 (March 27, 1998)
- Arthur v. Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co., No. SA-21-CV-00602-FB (W.D. Tex. Oct. 24, 2022), order (Justia copy)
- 18 U.S.C. 201, Bribery of public officials and witnesses (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Alabama State Bar, Disciplinary Commission, opinion 1997-02 (October 29, 1997)
Read also
All articles
Does an expert witness have to be licensed in the state where the case is tried?
Federal Rule of Evidence 702 qualifies an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education and says nothing about a license. State
What happens if your expert witness dies or withdraws before trial?
When a disclosed expert dies, falls ill or withdraws after the disclosure deadline, the party has to ask the court to change the scheduling order
Can you subpoena an expert who has not been retained, and what must you pay?
An expert who was never hired can be subpoenaed, but Rule 45(d)(3)(B)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lets the court quash a subpoenaExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

