Expert report review

Family violence screening in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?

In California a finding that a parent perpetrated domestic violence within the previous five years creates a rebuttable presumption against giving that parent sole or joint custody, and the court may not base that finding solely on a custody evaluator's conclusions. A reviewing psychologist therefore checks how the evaluation screened for violence, whether the evaluator holds the training that rule 5.230 requires, and which facts the report gathered for the questions the court must decide.

Two armchairs sit at uneven angles beside a face-down questionnaire and a tissue box

Why does a review start with the family violence screening?

Because a finding of domestic violence changes the legal test for custody in California, and the evaluation is often where the facts about violence are first collected and organized for the court.

Family Code section 3044(a) applies "upon a finding by the court that a party seeking custody of a child has perpetrated domestic violence" within the previous five years. The finding creates a rebuttable presumption that awarding that party sole or joint physical or legal custody is detrimental to the best interest of the child. The presumption "may only be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence."

The finding belongs to the court. Section 3044(e) adds that the court "may not base its findings solely on conclusions reached by a child custody evaluator" and "shall consider any relevant, admissible evidence submitted by the parties."

The evaluator still shapes what the court sees. The evaluation collects police records, interviews and observations, and the report describes them. If the screening was thin, the record on the question that sets the legal test for custody is thin as well. That is why a work product review usually opens with the screening: what was asked, of whom, when, with what records in hand, and how the answers were used.

Must the evaluator screen even when no one has alleged violence?

Yes, under the 2022 APA custody guidelines. Guideline 15 asks psychologists to screen across all types of cases, including those with no allegations or judicial findings of intimate partner violence.

The American Psychological Association adopted its Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings as association policy in February 2022, and they are scheduled to expire 10 years from that date. Guideline 15 reads: "Psychologists endeavor to conduct appropriate screening for family violence, child maltreatment, intimate partner violence, and resultant trauma."

The text of the guideline extends the screening to every case. Psychologists "strive to implement screening across all types of cases," including "those in which no allegations or judicial findings of intimate partner violence have been made." The screening is also meant to continue: it is "ideally an ongoing process throughout the custody evaluation, rather than a one-time event."

For the reviewer this gives two questions that can be answered from the file. Was there any screening in a case where neither parent raised violence at intake? And if a parent, a child or a collateral source raised it later, did the evaluator return to the subject, or does the report treat the intake answers as the final word?

The guidelines are professional aspirations, not court rules, and the APA text uses the words "endeavor" and "strive." A review cites them as the standard the profession set for itself and says where the evaluation met it and where it did not.

What is the screening meant to find?

Physical or sexual abuse, child abuse including alienating behaviors, intimate partner abuse, and power imbalance or coercion and control by family members or caregivers. The findings feed into the assessment and recommendations.

Guideline 15 lists the targets: psychologists "strive to identify potential physical or sexual abuse, child abuse including alienating behaviors," and "intimate partner abuse, power imbalance or coercion and control behaviors on the part of family members or caregivers." Coercion and control are named next to physical abuse, so a screening limited to questions about hitting covers part of the list.

The guideline then says what to do with the results: psychologists are to "utilize these findings, as appropriate, in their assessment processes and recommendations." A reviewer looks for that link in the report. If the screening section records concerns and the analysis section never mentions them, the evaluation collected information and did not use it.

Screening can also trigger duties outside the case. Psychologists "inform the appropriate authorities of newly uncovered incidents" that "invoke mandatory reporting obligations, which may vary by jurisdiction." When the file shows a disclosure that would have required a report under the law of the state, the reviewer checks whether a report was made and whether the evaluation says so.

The review does not decide whether violence occurred. It states what the screening covered, what it missed and whether the conclusions take its results into account.

Which facts does the evaluation need if the Family Code 3044 presumption may apply?

The facts on the statutory factors for rebutting the presumption: treatment and counseling programs, parenting classes, probation or parole, protective orders, further acts of violence and firearm restrictions.

Under section 3044(c), a person has perpetrated domestic violence when the court finds that the person intentionally or recklessly caused or attempted to cause bodily injury or sexual assault, among other conduct listed in the statute. To overcome the presumption, the perpetrator must show under subdivision (b)(1) that giving custody to the perpetrator is in the best interest of the child. The preference for frequent and continuing contact with both parents "may not be used to rebut the presumption, in whole or in part."

Subdivision (b)(2) lists seven additional factors, and the court weighs whether, on balance, they support the legislative findings in Section 3020. The factors are whether the perpetrator has completed a batterer's treatment program, whether the perpetrator has completed alcohol or drug abuse counseling and a parenting class where the court finds them appropriate, whether the perpetrator is on probation or parole and has complied with its terms, whether the perpetrator is restrained by a protective or restraining order and has complied with it, whether the perpetrator has committed further acts of domestic violence, and whether the court has found the perpetrator to be a restrained person in possession or control of a firearm or ammunition.

Each factor corresponds to records that exist or do not exist: program completion letters, probation reports, restraining orders and proofs of service, police reports of later incidents. A reviewer compares that list with the documents the evaluator reviewed. Rule 5.220(e)(2)(A) of the California Rules of Court has the evaluator review "pertinent documents related to custody, including local police records." An evaluation that reaches a conclusion on safety without the restraining order file or the criminal case record has left a gap that the court will have to fill from other evidence.

Under subdivision (f)(2), a court that finds the presumption overcome must state its reasons "in writing or on the record." Subdivision (f)(1) records the Legislature's intent, with reference to Jaime G. v. H.L. (2018), that the court make specific findings on each factor in subdivision (b). The court can only state those reasons from facts in the record, and the review shows which of them the evaluation supplies.

Can the court rely on the evaluator's conclusion that violence did or did not occur?

Not by itself. Section 3044(e) bars the court from basing a domestic violence finding solely on a custody evaluator's conclusions and requires it to consider the parties' relevant, admissible evidence.

The current text of section 3044, operative January 1, 2026 under subdivision (i), keeps this rule in subdivision (e). The court decides whether violence occurred on the parties' relevant and admissible evidence, and the evaluator's conclusions are one part of that evidence.

That limit shapes how a review reads the report. Sentences such as "the father is a perpetrator of domestic violence" or "no domestic violence occurred in this family" state the court's finding in the evaluator's words. The reviewer separates them from the evaluator's data: what each parent reported, what the records show, what the child said, what the evaluator observed. The data can support the court's finding. The conclusion cannot replace it.

The same distinction matters in the other direction. An evaluation that dismisses a parent's account because no criminal case was filed has used one fact as a test for the whole question. Guideline 15 asks for screening in cases "in which no allegations or judicial findings of intimate partner violence have been made," so the absence of a court record is a reason to look further.

Was the evaluator trained in domestic violence as rule 5.230 requires?

Rule 5.230 requires basic training, 16 hours of advanced training within 12 months and 4 hours of update training each year. Absent a local rule, the evaluator attaches the certificates of completion to each evaluation report.

Rule 5.230 of the California Rules of Court states its purpose as "domestic violence training for all court-appointed persons who evaluate or investigate child custody matters." It covers persons appointed as child custody investigators under Family Code section 3110 or Evidence Code section 730, and "persons who are professional staff or trainees in a child custody or visitation evaluation or investigation." No person may be a court-appointed investigator under Family Code section 3111(d) or Evidence Code section 730 unless the person has completed domestic violence training.

The training has three layers. Persons covered complete basic training in domestic violence issues "as described in Family Code section 1816." Then "Sixteen hours of advanced training must be completed within a 12-month period": 12 hours of instruction and 4 hours of "community resource networking intended to acquaint the evaluator with domestic violence resources." After that, "Four hours of update training are required each year after the year in which the advanced training is completed." Under rule 5.230(e)(1)(E), eligible providers "Distribute a certificate of completion to each person who has completed the training."

The proof sits in the report. Under subdivision (f), absent a local rule, evaluators must attach copies of their certificates of completion to each evaluation report. Rule 5.225(e) provides that before appointment evaluators "must comply with the basic and advanced domestic violence training requirements described in rule 5.230," and under rule 5.225(l)(1)(B) a private evaluator files the declaration of qualifications on form FL-326 "no later than 10 days after notification of each appointment and before any work on each child custody evaluation has begun."

The reviewer checks three items: the certificates of completion attached to the report, the FL-326 declaration and its filing date. A missing certificate or a declaration filed after the evaluation started is a fact the attorney can put to the court without any opinion from the reviewer.

What does the required training cover, and how does the reviewer use that list?

The advanced curriculum includes structuring the evaluation, the governing law, resources and interventions, and the specific problems of assessment in domestic violence cases. The reviewer uses the same topics as a checklist for the report.

Rule 5.230(d)(1)(A) sets the content of the 12 hours of instruction. It covers, among other topics, "The appropriate structuring of the child custody evaluation process," "The relevant sections of local, state, and federal law or rules" and "The unique issues in family and psychological assessment in domestic violence cases."

The last topic is broken down in the rule. It includes the effects of exposure to domestic violence and psychological trauma on children, the relationship of gender, class, race, culture and sexual orientation to domestic violence, the uses and limitations of psychological testing, the influence of alcohol and drug use on the incidence of domestic violence, obtaining collateral information, safe and enforceable parenting plans, and "The importance of discouraging participants in child custody matters from blaming victims of domestic violence." The annual update includes "an update of current social science research and theory."

The list gives the reviewer concrete questions. Does the report rely on a personality test score to decide whether a parent is violent, without addressing the limits of testing? Does it treat a parent's substance use as a separate issue or connect it to risk? Does it record collateral sources, and which ones? Does the parenting plan it recommends address exchanges of the child, contact between the parents and what happens after a violation? A review that answers these questions page by page gives the attorney material for cross-examination drawn from the evaluator's own required training.

How should the evaluator interview and observe the family when violence is alleged?

Rule 5.220 has the evaluator interview the parents jointly or separately unless contraindicated in cases involving domestic violence, and observe parent-child interaction unless contraindicated to protect the child.

Rule 5.220(e)(2) sets the procedures. The evaluator reviews "pertinent documents related to custody, including local police records"; observes "parent-child interaction (unless contraindicated to protect the best interest of the child)"; interviews the parents jointly or separately "unless contraindicated in cases involving domestic violence," assessing among other things the "History of child abuse, domestic violence, substance abuse, and psychiatric illness"; and interviews the child and parents together or separately "unless contraindicated to protect the best interest of the child."

The evaluator's general duties point the same way. Under rule 5.220(d)(2), the evaluator must "Consider the health, safety, welfare, and best interest of the child within the scope and purpose of the evaluation" and "Strive to minimize the potential for psychological trauma to children during the evaluation process." Guideline 15 adds that psychologists "consider how the methods of assessment and communication to the parties may impact safety" and "are prepared to seek court guidance as needed."

A reviewer reads the procedures section for the order and format of contacts. Were the parents interviewed together after one of them reported violence? Was the child observed with the parent the child said was violent, and if so, why did the evaluator find the observation safe? Did the evaluator ask the court for guidance on any of these choices? The rule does not require a separate interview in every case. It requires the evaluator to decide, and the report should show that a decision was made.

What has NIJ-funded research found about custody evaluators in domestic violence cases?

A study supported by the National Institute of Justice reviewed 69 contested custody cases with domestic violence allegations and found that the evaluator's assessment of ongoing risk best predicted whether the parenting plan was safe.

The National Institute of Justice published an article on October 1, 2017, on the need for mandatory domestic violence training for court-appointed custody evaluators. It describes research by Michael Davis, Ph.D., and the New York Legal Assistance Group, supported by NIJ grant number 2007-WG-BX-0001. The researchers reviewed 69 cases of contested custody involving domestic violence allegations and interviewed 15 of the custody evaluators.

According to the article, the best predictor of a safe parenting plan was the evaluator's assessment of ongoing risk, and that assessment depended on the evaluators' beliefs about the underlying causes of domestic violence. Evaluators who used the power and control model recommended arrangements that were safer for victimized parents and children. The article states that many evaluators lack adequate domestic violence training and recommends screening all court-appointed evaluators for knowledge of domestic violence.

For a review, the study points to the part of the report where beliefs about violence become visible: the evaluator's explanation of why violence happened and whether it will recur. A reviewer reads that explanation against the data the evaluator collected and against the training topics in rule 5.230, and asks whether the risk assessment is stated, on what it rests and how it connects to the recommended plan.

Can the reviewer say whether abuse happened or which parent should have custody?

No. The reviewer has examined no one, and rule 5.220(j)(3) bars recommendations about a party unless that party was evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional.

Rule 5.220(j)(3) directs evaluators to "Not offer any recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional." A reviewing psychologist who reads the file evaluates no party, so the review contains no custody recommendation and no finding about violence.

What the review does contain is a description of the evaluation measured against the rules and guidelines: which screening was done and when, which records were reviewed, whether the training certificates and the FL-326 declaration are in the file, how the interviews and observations were arranged and whether the conclusions follow from the data. Under section 3044(e) the court weighs the evaluator's conclusions with the parties' other evidence, and the review is part of that evidence.

The limit also protects the review. A reviewer who wrote that the mother was abused or that the father is safe would be offering the same kind of conclusion that section 3044(e) keeps the court from adopting on an evaluator's word alone, without even the interviews the evaluator conducted. The review keeps to what can be checked on paper: dates, documents, procedures, the reasoning between data and conclusions, and the gaps.

How is the review used in a California custody case?

It supplies questions for the cross-examination of the evaluator, which each local court must arrange through expeditious and cost-effective procedures, and documented points for the parent's briefs on the 3044 factors.

Rule 5.220(k) provides that "Each local court must develop procedures for expeditious and cost-effective cross-examination of evaluators," and lists videoconferences, telephone conferences, audio or video examination and the scheduling of appearances among the means to consider. A review written before the hearing turns the evaluation's gaps into questions: which police records were reviewed, why the parents were interviewed together, where the training certificates are, how the risk assessment was reached.

The same points serve the briefs on the presumption. Where section 3044(b)(2) lists a factor and the evaluation contains nothing about it, the parent's attorney can show the court that the evaluation does not answer the question and point to the records that do.

The documents behind the review go to the court with it. A list of the records the evaluator reviewed, compared with the list of records that exist, shows the court what was missing. Copies of the certificates of completion, or a note that none were attached, and the filing date of the FL-326 declaration answer the training questions without argument.

Whether the reviewing psychologist testifies or stays a consultant is a decision for the parent's attorney. The review itself is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials.

What does IAE do when a parent needs the family violence screening in a custody evaluation reviewed?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review that measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.

IAE describes the review for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. A psychologist from the IAE registry measures the evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines and writes the work product review. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody.

IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

The specialist confirms in the document that they have no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member