Examinations

Can you be forced to give a handwriting sample?

Yes. A grand jury or a criminal court can order a person to give handwriting exemplars, and a witness who refuses can be held in civil contempt. Federal courts follow Gilbert v. California (1967), which treats a handwriting sample, unlike the content of what is written, as an identifying physical characteristic outside the Fifth Amendment. The Justice Department's manual adds that a person may be made to copy specific language.

A hand writes on a blank card at a counsel table while another hand steadies it

Why is a handwriting sample not protected by the Fifth Amendment?

Because the Supreme Court held in Gilbert v. California in 1967 that a handwriting exemplar, as opposed to the content of what is written, is an identifying physical characteristic outside the privilege against self-incrimination.

The Third Circuit quoted Gilbert in 1987: "[a] mere handwriting exemplar, in contrast to the content of what is written," "like the voice or body itself, is an identifying physical characteristic". A New York trial court quoted the end of the same sentence in 1978: it "is an identifying physical characteristic outside [the Fifth Amendment's] protection." The privilege covers testimony and communications.

The Third Circuit placed Gilbert in a line of Supreme Court cases. It cited Schmerber v. California (1966) for the rule that the privilege protects testimonial or communicative evidence, and Fisher v. United States (1976) for the point that producing evidence under a subpoena can have communicative aspects, while the privilege covers only testimonial, incriminating communications.

Before Gilbert some courts drew a line between passive cooperation, such as fingerprints and photographs, and active cooperation, such as speaking or writing. People v. Rinaldi, decided by a New York county court on July 21, 1970, noted that line and read Gilbert as holding that "to require a handwriting exemplar did not impair a defendant's privilege against self incrimination".

Can a grand jury order a witness to give handwriting samples?

Yes. In United States v. Doe (1968) the Second Circuit upheld an order to fill out FBI handwriting forms against a witness who refused and was held in civil contempt. The Third Circuit reached the same result in 1987.

Edmund J. Devlin appeared before a grand jury in the District of Connecticut that was investigating the theft of postal money orders. The foreman ordered him to provide exemplars on FBI forms. Four forms called for the months, the alphabet, the numbers zero through eighteen and signatures. A fifth form looked like a money order, carried a printed notice that it was a handwriting sample form and not a negotiable instrument, and required the names of ten payees and the signature "George Strouch".

"Devlin refused to obey the foreman's order." Before Chief Judge Timbers he argued that the fifth form violated the Fifth Amendment and that all the forms violated his right to counsel and due process. The district court held him in civil contempt and committed him for 30 days, or until he gave the exemplars or the grand jury was discharged, whichever came first, and stayed the sentence pending appeal.

Judge Friendly wrote for the Second Circuit on December 9, 1968. The counsel argument was foreclosed by Gilbert. On due process, the court held that the standard for eyewitness identification did not apply: "Expert comparison of handwriting exemplars bears scant resemblance to eyewitness identification." On the fifth form, it relied on United States v. Wade and treated handwriting, like voice, as an identifying physical characteristic.

Can you be made to write specific words?

Yes. The Justice Department's Criminal Resource Manual says that an accused or subpoenaed person may be compelled to duplicate specific language, citing United States v. Doe, where the witness had to copy payee names and a signature onto a form.

Section 255 of the Criminal Resource Manual is short. Its first sentence reads: "An accused or subpoenaed person may be compelled to duplicate specific language." The citation is United States v. Doe, 405 F.2d 436, 438 (2d Cir. 1968). The second sentence says that a court may order a person to give a sample in an unusual form, such as writing with a backhand or backward slant, and cites the 1987 Third Circuit decision.

In the Third Circuit case the second subpoena directed the witness to furnish exemplars "in the amount, style, and wording as directed." The witness himself offered to provide "normal handwriting in the amount, style, and wording as directed". The dispute was over the style, not over the words.

Can a court order you to write in a style you do not normally use?

Yes. In 1987 the Third Circuit upheld civil contempt against a grand jury witness who refused to write exemplars with a backhand slant, holding that neither the act nor the sample was testimonial.

A federal grand jury in Newark, New Jersey, was investigating possible labor racketeering under 29 U.S.C. § 186, mail fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1341 and extortion under 18 U.S.C. § 1951. Handwritten documents were part of the inquiry. On July 31, 1986, the witness gave exemplars to the FBI Document Laboratory, and the examiner then asked for more to determine who wrote other documents. A second subpoena followed on September 19, 1986, and on November 5 the witness was told to write in a backhand slant.

The witness argued that a "normal" backslant, which was not his usual style, would communicate how he disguises his writing and so would be testimonial. The majority disagreed: "The mere fact that a style of writing is one which a witness would not normally display does not transform the sample" into testimony. It held: "We find that neither the act of producing a backhand exemplar nor the exemplar itself is testimonial evidence." The only directly comparable authority it found was an Eighth Circuit decision of 1985, reported at 755 F.2d 685, which had upheld compelled backslant exemplars.

Judge Becker dissented. In his view, "the subpoena which the government seeks to enforce in this case compels the defendant to reveal his thoughts."

What happens if you refuse to give a handwriting sample?

A witness who disobeys a court order to give exemplars can be held in civil contempt. Devlin was committed for up to 30 days unless he complied, and the Newark order rested on 28 U.S.C. § 1826(a).

The Newark witness was held in civil contempt on December 10, 1986, under 28 U.S.C. § 1826(a), for refusing without just cause to comply, and the Third Circuit affirmed. In Doe, the commitment was to last 30 days or until Devlin gave the exemplars or the grand jury was discharged, whichever came first.

State courts use the same tool. In Rinaldi the New York court found the procedure authorized while the defendant is before the court and the only compulsion is a possible contempt citation for violating a court order.

Can the prosecution get an order after charges are filed?

Yes. In Ruggirello the Sixth Circuit in 1972 affirmed a conviction after a pretrial order based on an affidavit that the authorship of documents was material, and New York courts granted motions for exemplars after indictment in 1970 and 1978.

Louis A. Ruggirello was charged with understating his income for three years. Before trial the government moved for an order requiring him to give handwriting samples, with an affidavit stating that it held documents whose authorship was material to the case. His counsel conceded at the hearing that the court had authority under Gilbert. He did not object at trial when the samples were introduced in evidence, and on appeal he argued that the order violated his Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights. In 1972 the Sixth Circuit found "no merit in this or any other claim of error" and affirmed the conviction.

In re Sutz, decided by the New York Supreme Court on September 12, 1978, involved two defendants indicted for grand larceny in an alleged insurance fraud scheme. Seized file cards held instructions they allegedly gave to codefendants and employees. The defendants objected that no statute authorized an order for exemplars. Judge Goldfluss granted the motion and noted that "there is a marked difference between a prearrest and postarrest application for handwriting exemplars".

In Rinaldi the defendants were indicted under Penal Law § 215.40 for tampering with physical evidence: affidavits allegedly prepared as false evidence and submitted to the Appellate Division. The District Attorney moved for exemplars to compare with the signatures on those affidavits, and the court directed each defendant to furnish them in the form requested.

Do you have a right to a lawyer when giving the sample?

Not under the Sixth Amendment before a grand jury, the Second Circuit held in 1968, relying on Gilbert. A New York court in 1970 still let counsel attend, because the exemplars might become the subject of cross-examination at trial.

Devlin's argument that the forms violated his right to counsel was rejected as foreclosed by Gilbert v. California. The Second Circuit did not require a lawyer to be present when a grand jury witness fills out handwriting forms.

The Rinaldi court took a different practical step. After granting the motion, it wrote that "the defendants are entitled to have their counsel present at such time," because the exemplars might be the subject of cross-examination at trial.

Are there limits on compelled handwriting samples?

Yes. New York courts required findings before ordering samples and warned against force and harassment. A 1997 review of the case law reports that Georgia's law permitting compelled samples was struck down in 1979.

In Sutz the court made three findings before it issued the order: a prima facie connection between the investigation and the handwritten documents, the defendants' control over or access to the instruments used to make the writings, and probable cause to believe that the same persons wrote or authorized the documents. Reasonableness and constitutional validity, the court said, must be decided before the order issues.

The Rinaldi court stressed that prerequisites are needed to prevent abuses such as force or harassment. It cited Mackell v. Palermo, a Queens County decision that allowed an order to shave a defendant for a lineup but added that "the court had no authority to so order merely because the prosecution suspected him of having committed some crime."

D. L. Hammond reviewed the law in 1997 in the International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners. According to the abstract, the federal rulings he surveyed span the years 1903-1982, federal law on compelled samples is firmly established, and military courts also allow compulsion, having reached that position several years after the federal courts. Georgia and Nevada were the two states whose law diverged: Georgia's law permitting compelled samples was struck down in 1979, and Nevada's law was thought to be similar.

Why does the examiner need samples written on request?

Because writing collected from old documents may not cover the questioned text. In the Newark case the FBI examiner asked for more exemplars after the first set, and the 1968 forms covered months, letters, numbers and signatures.

Hammond's abstract opens with the premise that forensic handwriting analysis depends on sufficient, properly collected writing samples. Some suspects hand them over willingly, and otherwise investigators turn to federal and state law to obtain them.

Requested exemplars let the examiner choose the words, the letters and the form. The FBI forms in Doe asked for the months, the alphabet, the numbers zero through eighteen, signatures and a copy of a money order with ten payee names. In the Newark case the first exemplars did not answer every question, so the FBI examiner asked for a second set to determine the authorship of other documents, and the subpoena left the amount, style and wording to the government's direction.

Exemplars written on request are also open to challenge. The Rinaldi court let counsel attend because the samples could be the subject of cross-examination at trial, and the Third Circuit case turned on a witness who said a requested style would reveal how he disguises his writing.

What does IAE do when a case turns on requested handwriting samples?

An IAE examiner compares the questioned signature or writing with known writing, including requested exemplars, and prepares a report on your questions or a review of the opposing examiner's report in up to 5 business days.

The IAE handwriting page lists the questions the examiner answers: whether the person named on a will, contract or check signed it, and whether the signature shows signs of simulation or tracing. Under ANSI/ASB Standard 070 (2022) the examiner checks whether questioned and known writing are originals and comparable, then weighs similarities and differences together. Standard 070 (6.3.8) has the examiner look for slow writing, guide lines and unnatural similarity between questioned signatures.

On known writing the page asks for originals of the same type and from about the same period as the questioned item. It notes that Standard 070 records that a lack of contemporaneous writing can hamper the assessment of dissimilarities and that specimens collected only by a stakeholder may not show the writer's full range of variation. Under 28 U.S.C. § 1731, admitted or proved handwriting is admissible for comparison, and Rule 901(b)(3) permits comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert or the trier of fact.

Send the questioned document or its best copy, the known writing and any requested exemplars with a note on when and how each was taken, and your questions, through the Request a quote button on the service page. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and, within one business day, the format, the cost, the deadline and the examiner from the registry. You approve the candidate and the CV before work starts, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the report can be checked by QR code. The examiner confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. The court weighs the report with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member