Expert report review

Questions for the opposing document examiner: what to ask at deposition about ink, dating and alterations?

The opposing document examiner can be deposed once the written report has been served. In an ink, dating or alteration case the useful questions come from three places: the report, the examiner's file and the standard the examiner says was followed. A review of the report before the deposition turns each gap into a question about what was tested, on which original, with what permission, and how firmly the result may be worded.

A blank notepad and a fountain pen sit beside an ink vial and a face-down page under a lamp

When can the opposing document examiner be deposed?

After the examiner's written report is provided. Rule 26(b)(4)(A) permits the deposition of any expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and the party taking it pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time.

Rule 26(b)(4)(A) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure states: "A party may depose any person who has been identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial." If Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a report from the expert, "the deposition may be conducted only after the report is provided."

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E)(i), unless manifest injustice would result, the party seeking discovery must pay the expert a reasonable fee for time spent responding to discovery under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) or (D). The time the examiner spends at the deposition is therefore paid by the side asking the questions, and a short, prepared list costs less than a long one built at the table.

The examiner's file and a review of the report by your own examiner come first; the list of questions follows from them.

What should be in hand before the deposition?

The report with all six parts required by Rule 26(a)(2)(B), the examiner's notes, images and test records, and a review of the report by your own examiner. Each question should cite a page of one of them.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) lists what the report must contain: a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them; the facts or data considered in forming them; any exhibits that will be used to summarize or support them; the witness's qualifications, including publications from the previous 10 years; a list of cases in which the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition during the previous 4 years; and a statement of the compensation for the study and testimony.

The report alone is rarely enough for an ink or alteration case. The images of each examination, the record of which tests were run on which entries and the description of the samples taken sit in the examiner's file. Drafts of the report are protected by Rule 26(b)(4)(B), but the facts and data considered are listed in the report itself, and the file behind them is requested before the deposition.

A reviewer reads the report and the file against the standard the examiner names. In ink work that is usually the SWGDOC Standard for Test Methods for Forensic Writing Ink Comparison (version 2013-1); for alterations, ANSI/ASB Standard 035, Standard for the Examination of Documents for Alterations, first edition 2020.

Which questions test what the examiner actually examined?

Ask which item was examined, original or copy, when and from whom it was received, its condition on arrival, and which entries were tested. An opinion about an original that the examiner never saw is an opinion about an image.

The first block of questions fixes the object. ANSI/ASB Standard 070 makes the same point for handwriting in section 6.3.2: the examiner shall determine whether the questioned writing is original, and if the original is not submitted, shall evaluate the quality of the reproduction. A copy cannot show the type of writing instrument, and ink comparison needs the ink itself.

Questions that fit this block are these.

  • Which document did you examine: the original, a photocopy or a scan?
  • When and from whom did you receive it, and in what condition?
  • Which entries, signatures or pages did you examine, and which ones did you not examine?
  • Where was the document stored between the questioned date and your examination, and what do you know about that storage?
  • Did anyone else handle or test the document before you, and did you receive their records?

How do you question an ink comparison?

Through the test sequence and the meaning of a match. Under the SWGDOC standard a match means the inks could not be distinguished at the level of analysis used; it does not prove one pen or one batch.

The SWGDOC ink standard sets the order of work. Nondestructive optical examinations come first: visible light with magnification to determine whether the ink is ballpoint or non-ballpoint, its condition and color (section 7.1), long-wave and short-wave ultraviolet light with recorded fluorescence (7.2), and infrared examination with recorded infrared luminescence (7.3). Chemical examinations, which are partly destructive, follow: spot and solubility tests (7.6) and thin layer chromatography (7.7).

The standard limits what any result means. Section 4.3 states that contemporary ink rarely has sufficient individuality to show common origin below the level of the manufacturing batch. Section 9.3.1 permits calling samples a match "at that level of analysis"; section 9.3.2 adds that a match does not rule out samples from different manufacturing batches or from different writing or marking instruments. Under 9.3.3 a report must never call two samples identical or the same ink.

A difference has its own threshold. Section 9.2.1 permits a conclusion of no common origin on significant, reproducible, inexplicable differences, and 9.2.2 requires the examiner to account for batch-to-batch variation and interfering factors. Questions follow directly: which tests were run on each entry, which ones separated the inks, whether the result was reproduced, and what other explanation was considered.

The weight of a match also depends on how common the formula is. Section 4.6.1 describes an ink library as samples of ink formulas from known sources, and section 4.7 says a match carries more weight when the rarity of the formula is known. Ask whether a library was used, whose, and what it showed about the formula.

What should be asked about ink dating?

Which method was used and where its procedure is published, because the SWGDOC ink comparison standard places ink dating outside its scope. A dating opinion has to rest on another documented method.

Section 1.2 of the SWGDOC ink standard excludes identifying the manufacturer or the time of manufacture of a formula and states that "performing ink dating examinations are beyond the scope of this standard." Section 4.1 lists four questions an examiner may be asked, among them whether dated entries are consistent with their dates and whether an ink is as old as claimed, and section 4.2 says the standard fully answers only the first of the four, the comparison of formulas.

An examiner who gives an age opinion therefore names a different method. The deposition fixes which one, where it is published, how it was validated, on which entries and controls it was run, and which conditions of storage it assumes. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) requires the basis and reasons for every opinion, so a dating conclusion without a stated method is a gap in the report itself.

Two further questions matter when the result is an interval. What does the method treat as a reference: other entries on the same document, documents of known date, or published data? And what would the result have been for an entry made on the stated date and kept in the stated way?

How are destructive tests questioned?

By counting what was removed and checking the permission and the images. Thin layer chromatography under the SWGDOC standard usually takes 7 to 10 plugs of ink from a line, or about 1 cm of line.

Section 7.7.2.1 of the SWGDOC ink standard states that "usually 7 to 10 plugs of ink from a line are sufficient" for thin layer chromatography; a scalpel can remove about 1 cm of line instead, and limited writing may require single-plug microsampling (7.7.2.5). Section 7.7.2.4 calls for an equal amount of paper from a clean area as a blank. Extraction uses about 3 to 5 microliters of solvent, pyridine for ballpoint inks and ethanol and water for non-ballpoint inks (7.7.3.1).

Each figure becomes a question. How many plugs were taken from each entry and where? Was a paper blank taken? Which solvent was used? Were the comparison samples extracted with the same solvent? What was photographed before and after sampling, and how much of each entry remains for another examiner?

The last question has practical weight. Sampling removes ink that a second examination may need, and the answer tells counsel whether a second test on the same entries is still possible.

Which questions test an alteration opinion?

Ask what was compared with what: the disputed entry with the surrounding entries, page with page, and which tests separated them. A match between entries does not prove they were written at one sitting or with one pen.

The first question on the SWGDOC list in section 4.1 is whether an ink is the same, in formula, as the ink on other parts of the same document. That is the question in most addition cases: was the added line written with the same ink as the rest? A difference reported under section 9.2.1 supports a second instrument; a match under 9.3.1 is consistent with one ink and does not exclude a second pen of the same formula.

For cut-and-paste and duplication, section 6.3.3 of Standard 070 requires the examiner to examine questioned writing for duplication by electronic or other means, and section 6.5.6.1 calls for evaluating exact replication among multiple writings. Ask which items were superimposed, at what magnification and with what result.

Questions about the method of each finding come next: which light sources and filters were used, as section 7.5 of the ink standard recommends a range of them because ink reactions vary by wavelength, and which observation led to each conclusion.

How firmly may the examiner word the conclusion?

No more firmly than the tests support. The SWGDOC standard bans calling inks identical, and Standard 070 requires a conclusion to rest on a combination of characteristics after alternative interpretations are considered.

Section 4.8.1 of the SWGDOC ink standard offers the wording "inability to distinguish the ink samples at this level of analysis." A report or an answer at deposition that calls two inks "the same" goes beyond section 9.3.3, and the transcript records it.

For handwriting and duplication, section 6.8.1 of Standard 070 states that a conclusion is not based solely upon any one characteristic, but on the combination of characteristics, and section 6.7 states that the examiner shall consider alternative interpretations. Ask which alternatives the examiner considered and why each was rejected.

Can you ask what counsel told the examiner?

Yes, within three exceptions to the protection of attorney-expert communications: compensation, facts or data counsel provided and the expert considered, and assumptions counsel provided and the expert relied on.

Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects communications between a party's attorney and a reporting expert, except to the extent that they relate to compensation for the expert's study or testimony, identify facts or data that the attorney provided and that the expert considered in forming the opinions, or identify assumptions that the attorney provided and that the expert relied on.

In a dating case the assumptions can concern time and storage: the date the document was said to be signed, where it was kept, what other documents came from the same period. Ask what the examiner was told on each point and by whom, and whether the opinion changes if an assumption is wrong.

How are the answers used after the deposition?

In a rebuttal report on the same subject, due within 30 days of the other side's disclosure absent another order, and at trial, where Rule 705 lets counsel require the facts behind the opinion on cross-examination.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the default for rebuttal: evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party is disclosed within 30 days after that disclosure, unless a stipulation or court order sets another time. Admissions at deposition about untested entries, untested alternatives or wording beyond the standard give the rebuttal report its subject.

Rule 705 of the Federal Rules of Evidence states that, unless the court orders otherwise, an expert may state an opinion and give the reasons for it without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, "But the expert may be required to disclose those facts or data on cross-examination." The deposition transcript fixes those facts in advance.

What does IAE do when counsel prepares to depose the opposing document examiner?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing examiner's report for federal and state cases, with each point tied to a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule, in up to 5 business days.

The IAE review page for questioned documents is written for attorneys facing the other side's report on alterations, substituted pages, ink or dating. The reviewer reads the report and the produced file against ANSI/ASB Standards 011 and 035, the SWGDOC ink comparison standard and Rule 26(a)(2)(B), and each point of the review cites a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule. The page lists the checks used above: destructive testing and its records, notes detailed enough for an independent review, and the wording of an ink match.

Send the opposing report, the produced file and the deposition date through the form on the contact page. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and, within one business day, the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from the registry; you approve the reviewer and the CV before work starts. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The reviewer confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. Neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member