Examinations

Forged signature on a will: what can a handwriting examiner establish?

A will is disputed after the testator has died, so the examiner cannot ask the testator for new handwriting samples. The comparison rests on signatures the testator left during life, preferably from the last months and from custodians with no stake in the estate. ANSI/ASB Standard 070 lists age, illness and medication among the factors that change writing, and the examiner has to separate those changes from signs of simulation.

An old will on thick paper, a magnifying glass over the signature at the bottom, a fountain pen and an envelope nearby

Who has to prove that the signature on a will is forged?

That depends on the state. In California the proponents of a will carry the burden of proving due execution. In Pennsylvania the party who alleges forgery must prove it by clear, direct, precise and convincing evidence.

California Probate Code § 6110 lists what a valid will needs: a writing, the testator's signature (or a signature in the testator's name by another person in the testator's presence and at the testator's direction), and the signatures of at least two witnesses who were present at the same time and understood that the instrument was the testator's will. Under § 8252(a), at trial "the proponents of the will have the burden of proof of due execution."

Contestants in California carry the burden on the other grounds listed in § 8252(a): lack of intent or capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, mistake and revocation. Section 6110(c)(2) lets a court treat a will that was not witnessed as paragraph (1) requires as valid if the proponent shows by clear and convincing evidence that the testator, when signing it, intended it to be a will. That rule still presupposes the testator's own signature.

Pennsylvania places the burden on the other side. In In re Estate of Grigg, 2024 PA Super 211, decided on September 16, 2024, the Superior Court applied the rule of In re Cline's Estate: the party relying on forgery to defeat a will must prove it, and the proof must be clear, direct, precise and convincing. Each state has its own probate law, and the law of the state where the will is offered decides which side loses if the handwriting evidence is evenly balanced.

What evidence besides a handwriting examiner can prove who signed a will?

The attesting witnesses, people who know the testator's handwriting, and the judge or jury comparing the signature with genuine writing. California Evidence Code §§ 1416 and 1417 allow both routes beside expert comparison.

Under § 6110(c)(1) the two witnesses must have seen the testator sign or heard the testator acknowledge the signature or the will. Their testimony about the signing goes straight to the question. If no subscribing witness is available, Probate Code § 8221 lets the court admit a will that conforms to the law on its face on proof of the testator's handwriting together with proof of one witness's handwriting, a writing in the will signed by all subscribing witnesses, or an affidavit of a person with personal knowledge of the execution.

Evidence Code § 1416 admits the opinion of a nonexpert who has personal knowledge of the handwriting: a person who saw the testator write, who saw writing the testator acted on, or who received the testator's letters in reply to his or her own. Under § 1417 the judge or jury may compare the questioned signature with handwriting that the opposing party admitted or treated as genuine, or that is otherwise proved genuine to the court's satisfaction. Section 1418 lets an expert make the same comparison with the same kind of known writing.

The handwriting examiner is one witness among these. In Grigg, discussed below, no subscribing witness saw the signing, and the case turned on the credibility of the only person who said he had.

Why can't the examiner get new handwriting samples from the testator?

Because the testator is dead. ANSI/ASB Standard 070 recognizes known writing produced in the normal course of business and writing produced at request, and only the first kind exists after death. Its source and date then become the main questions.

Standard 070, approved by the Academy Standards Board (ASB) in April 2022 and by ANSI in October 2022, says in section 6.4.3(c) that known specimens "may include both those written in the normal course of business and those that were written specifically at request for comparison purposes." A living writer can be asked to produce samples under conditions that match the questioned document. A deceased testator leaves only what was written during life.

The same section warns that specimens collected only by a stakeholder may not show the writer's full range of variation. In a will contest both sides are stakeholders. Signatures kept by a bank, a hospital or a government office come from a custodian with no interest in the estate.

Section 6.4.3(b) deals with known writing that is internally inconsistent. If the set suggests more than one writer, the examiner contacts the submitter for authentication, and if the issue stays unresolved, discontinues work on the affected group. If a check signed in the testator's name by a caregiver sits among the exemplars, this rule applies to it. California Evidence Code § 1418 adds a legal filter: the expert compares the will only with writing the opposing party admitted or treated as genuine, or with writing proved genuine to the court's satisfaction.

Where can a family find known signatures of a deceased testator?

With custodians who had no stake in the will: banks, government offices, employers and hospitals. Federal hospital rules require signed consent forms in the medical record, and the executor or administrator can request the chart under HIPAA.

For a will signed during a last illness, the hospital chart holds signatures from the same weeks. Under 42 CFR 482.24(c)(4)(v), a hospital medical record must contain "properly executed informed consent forms for procedures and treatments specified by the medical staff," and § 482.24(b)(1) requires hospitals to keep records for at least 5 years. A consent form signed in the same weeks as the will records how the testator signed while ill.

Access to the chart runs through the estate. Guidance from the Department of Health and Human Services describes the personal representative of a deceased individual as "an executor, administrator, or other person who has authority under applicable State or other law to act on behalf of the decedent." The same guidance says a decedent's health information stays protected "for 50 years following the date of death," and that a provider may disclose relevant information to family members involved in the person's care unless that conflicts with a preference the decedent expressed.

Other usual exemplars are signed checks and bank signature cards, leases and deeds, tax returns, employment papers and personal letters. Each one goes to the examiner with its date and its source. Standard 070 lists writings that are not contemporaneous among the features limiting comparability (6.5.2.1), and when the known writing is not comparable, the examiner "shall request additional known writing per laboratory policy" (6.5.2.3).

How do age and illness change a testator's signature?

Signatures slow and lose pressure. In a 2014 study of 42 healthy writers aged 60 to 91, stroke duration and dysfluency grew with age while velocity and pen pressure fell. Illness, medication and a hospital bed add other changes.

M. P. Caligiuri, C. Kim and K. M. Landy published the study in the Journal of Forensic Sciences in July 2014 (vol. 59, no. 4, pp. 1020-1024). In 42 healthy subjects, "vertical stroke duration and dysfluency increased with age," "vertical stroke amplitude and velocity decreased with age" and "pen pressure decreased with age." Male writers showed stronger age effects than female writers, especially in pen pressure and stroke dysfluency.

The authors wrote that examiners must often consider whether the available exemplars capture the natural effects of aging on the writer. That is the reason to look first for signatures from the testator's last years.

Standard 070 lists the factors that the examiner weighs when distortion appears in questioned or known writing (6.5.4): "age; illness or injury; medication, drugs or alcohol (intoxication or withdrawal); awkward writing position," the writing instrument and surface, cold or heat, fatigue, haste or carelessness, nervousness, the nature of the document and use of the unaccustomed hand. The standard adds that "attempts to disguise should be considered."

Several of these signs look like signs of forgery. The note to section 6.3.7 names "tremor" and "poor line quality" as indicators of distortion, and the note to section 6.3.6 lists "lifts, stops, and hesitations of the writing instrument" and "unnatural tremor" as indicators of slow writing. Section 6.3.8 then has the examiner decide whether slow writing points to an attempt to simulate or trace. Genuine signatures from the period of illness let the examiner check whether the tremor in the will is the testator's own.

What changes when the whole will is in the testator's handwriting?

The examiner gets more writing to compare. In California a holographic will is valid without witnesses if the signature and the material provisions are in the testator's handwriting, and it may be proved like any other writing.

Probate Code § 6111(a) makes a will that does not meet § 6110 "valid as a holographic will, whether or not witnessed," if the signature and the material provisions are in the testator's handwriting. Under § 6111(c) a statement of intent may be handwritten or part of a commercially printed form will. Section 8222 states: "A holographic will may be proved in the same manner as other writings." No attesting witness is required for such a will.

Section 6111(b) adds two rules for undated holographic wills. If the missing date leaves doubt whether the holographic will or an inconsistent will controls, the holographic will is invalid to the extent of the inconsistency unless it is shown to have been executed after the other will. If the testator lacked capacity to make a will at any time when the will might have been executed, the will is invalid unless it is shown to have been executed while the testator had that capacity.

For the examiner, a handwritten will means text, numerals and a signature. Standard 070 has the examiner separate known writing into groups by type, such as hand printing, cursive, numerals, symbols and signatures (6.4.3(a)), and treats text content as one of the features limiting comparability (6.5.2.1). The known writing should therefore include the testator's cursive text and numbers, for example handwritten letters, notes and filled-in checks, along with signatures.

What can the examiner conclude about the signature on a will?

Whether the evidence supports a signature by the testator or by another writer, together with the limits of the material. Standard 070 requires competing propositions, alternative interpretations and a conclusion based on a combination of characteristics.

Under the note to section 6.2.4, the scope may be written as "two or more mutually exclusive competing hypotheses and propositions for each set of comparisons." For a will the basic pair is that the testator wrote the signature or that another person wrote it. Sub-hypotheses can follow: a genuine signature distorted by illness, a freehand simulation, a tracing over a genuine model.

Section 6.7 states: "The examiner shall consider alternative interpretations." Under section 6.8.1, "a conclusion is not based solely upon any one characteristic, but rather on the combination of characteristics within the set of writing in conjunction with any limitations that may be present." A tremor alone, or one unusual letter form, cannot carry an opinion that the will is forged.

Limitations go into the record. Section 4.2 says "limitations should be noted and recorded," and section 4.2.1 names among their sources non-original documents, the condition of the items, the quantity, complexity or comparability of the writing, and absent or insufficient characteristics. If only a photocopy of the will survives, or the estate can offer five exemplars written ten years apart, the report says so.

Where tracing is suspected, section 6.5.6 has the examiner determine whether the model is among the submitted writings and notes that "overlay comparisons have been found to be an effective method of evaluation." A questioned signature that matches a genuine one in the file almost line for line marks that genuine signature as a possible model.

How did a Pennsylvania court weigh two examiners in a 2024 will case?

In In re Estate of Grigg the orphans' court accepted the contestants' examiner, found the signature on a January 5, 2022 will forged and declared the will of no legal effect. The Superior Court affirmed on September 16, 2024.

Dorothy Grigg died on February 1, 2022, at age 81, of a pulmonary embolism and COVID-19. Four of her children petitioned the Register of Wills of Cambria County for letters of administration, as if she had left no will. Her husband Charles Grigg and her son Ronald Grigg objected, relied on a will dated January 5, 2022 and asked that Ronald be appointed to administer the estate under it. The Orphans' Court took up the dispute.

Each side called a handwriting examiner: Khody Detwiler for the petitioners and Michelle Dresbold for the respondents. The orphans' court found that Detwiler's testimony was "clear, direct, precise, and conveys" that the signature "is not, in fact, the signature of Dorothy Grigg," and relied on his "extensive education and experience."

No subscribing witness saw the signing. Ronald, a former attorney, testified that he drafted the will and watched his mother sign it. The court did not find him credible and noted that he and his sister Sharon had testified "opposite" about their mother's health. The Superior Court held that "evidence which is uncontradicted is not necessarily to be accepted as true." The rule of Cline's Estate, under which the opinion evidence of experts in forgery cases "is of little weight" and cannot prevail against "positive evidence of actual facts by witnesses whom the Chancellor considers credible," did not help the proponents, because the court had not believed their only eyewitness.

The published opinion does not say which exemplars the examiners used or whether either of them examined the original will.

What does IAE do when the signature on a will is disputed?

An IAE examiner prepares a report on whether the person named in the will signed it and whether the signature shows signs of simulation or tracing. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days.

The IAE handwriting and signature service covers wills, contracts and checks in federal and state cases. Under Standard 070 the examiner checks whether questioned and known writing are originals and comparable, then weighs similarities and differences together. For simulation and tracing the examiner looks for slow writing, guide lines and unnatural similarity between questioned signatures. The questions are framed around the questioned signature or entry and the known writing the client has.

The client sends the will or its best copy, the known signatures with their sources and dates and a description of the task. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, can be verified by Member ID or QR code and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. Neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member