Examinations
Graphologist or forensic document examiner: what is the difference, and which one can testify about a signature?
A graphologist reads handwriting to describe a person's character. A forensic document examiner compares a questioned signature or entry with known writing to decide who wrote it, under a published procedure, ANSI/ASB Standard 070. Two US associations of document examiners, ASQDE and AFDE, say the fields are unrelated, a 1989 meta-analysis found graphologists' predictions from neutral texts near zero, and a New York court excluded handwriting testimony about a surgeon's physical condition.

What is the difference between a graphologist and a forensic document examiner?
The purpose. A graphologist examines handwriting to assess personality. A forensic document examiner compares two bodies of handwriting to determine authorship, and that is the question in a forged signature case.
The American Society of Questioned Document Examiners (ASQDE) states the difference in a position paper titled "Graphology and Forensic Document Examination." A graphologist "examines handwriting for purposes of personality assessment", which the paper calls a "clairvoyant-type determination." A forensic document examiner "examines and compares two bodies of handwriting for the determination of authorship." The paper compares the two fields to astronomy and astrology and says that graphology, as practiced in North America, has no place in forensic document examination.
The Association of Forensic Document Examiners (AFDE) gives the same answer in its published questions and answers: "A Graphoanalyst and a graphologist both evaluate personality based on observations made from handwriting." It adds that "These fields are not related to forensic document examination" and that training in them "is not considered to be training for forensic evaluation of handwriting." The AFDE calls forensic document examination "a branch of the forensic sciences."
The titles overlap. In the Michigan will case described below, a graphologist also called himself a handwriting analyst and a document evaluator. The method described in the report separates the two fields; the title does not.
What does a forensic document examiner do with a disputed signature?
The examiner follows the steps of ANSI/ASB Standard 070: checks whether the writing is original and natural, collects comparable known writing, weighs similarities and differences together and considers other explanations before concluding.
Standard 070, approved by the Academy Standards Board in April 2022 and by ANSI in October 2022, sets out procedures "used by forensic document examiners", including evaluation of the sufficiency of the material. Under section 6.3.2 the examiner determines whether the questioned writing is original writing. Section 6.3.6 looks for features of slow writing, such as lifts, stops and hesitations of the writing instrument, and section 6.3.7 for distortion: poor line quality, excessive angularity, unusual size, tremor. Section 6.3.8 covers indicia of simulation and tracing, including guide lines and unnatural similarity between several questioned items.
The known writing is examined in the same way and compared for comparability: section 6.5.2 names type of writing and lack of contemporaneousness among the features that limit it. Section 6.7 states that "The examiner shall consider alternative interpretations", and section 6.8.1 that a conclusion is not based solely upon any one characteristic, but on the combination of characteristics.
Nothing in the standard concerns character, mood or personality. The examiner's question is whether this person wrote this signature, and the evidence is the comparison of two bodies of writing.
Can handwriting reveal personality, and what does the research say?
The evidence is weak. A 1989 meta-analysis of 17 studies found low validity for graphologists, psychologists without graphology training did better, and with neutral texts the graphologists' validity was near zero.
Efrat Neter and Gershon Ben-Shakhar pooled 17 studies in "The predictive validity of graphological inferences: A meta-analytic approach" (Personality and Individual Differences, 1989, volume 10, issue 7, pages 737 to 745). In those studies 63 graphologists and 51 non-graphologists evaluated 1,223 handwriting samples.
For samples with meaningful content, correlations between the judges' inferences and a general criterion lay between 0.136 and 0.206 for all judges, and between 0.153 and 0.177 for graphologists alone. Psychologists with no knowledge of graphology outperformed the graphologists on all dimensions. In the few cases where neutral scripts were used, the validities of the graphologists were near zero, and the authors suggest that what validity there is may come from the content of the text, not from the handwriting.
A 1994 article in the Journal of Forensic Identification (volume 44, No. 3, pages 276 to 290), abstracted by the National Criminal Justice Reference Service, describes the premises of graphology: that handwriting reveals a human trait or personality and that changes in handwriting follow changes in personality. A forensic comparison rests on a different premise: that a writer's habits repeat within a range of variation and can be compared with another writer's habits.
Will a court accept a graphologist as a handwriting expert?
It can, if nobody objects to the method. In a 1996 Michigan will contest a graphologist testified about the signature, the will was admitted, and the appeal failed because the objection had attacked his qualifications, not his technique.
In the estate of Marie Laveck (Michigan Court of Appeals, docket No. 179630, unpublished per curiam opinion of December 20, 1996), Robert Haskins described himself as a graphologist, a handwriting analyst, a document evaluator and a stress reduction and personality assessment consultant. He did not apply forgery indicia and relied instead on his background in graphology, basing his opinion in part on indications from the shape of the letters. He testified that the purported signature and the known signatures were both made by "a person with problems around the stomach."
The probate court overruled the objection to his qualifications as an expert and admitted the will. The Court of Appeals noted that no specific objection was registered as to the technique or methodology, and wrote that neither the Michigan Supreme Court nor the Court of Appeals had addressed whether graphology is an area of recognized scientific knowledge. Had the issue been preserved by a motion in limine or by a timely and specific objection, the trial court could have conducted a Davis-Frye hearing. It was not preserved, and the judgment was affirmed.
The practical lesson is procedural. A challenge to a graphologist is a challenge to the method, made before trial and in writing, and it asks the court to rule on whether the method is accepted for determining authorship.
Can a handwriting expert testify about a person's health or state of mind?
Not as a diagnosis. In Cameron v. Knapp a New York court excluded a handwriting expert who would have testified from chart entries that a surgeon had shaky hands, holding him not competent to give a medical opinion.
In Cameron v. Knapp, 137 Misc. 2d 373 (N.Y. Sup. Ct., October 19, 1987), Justice David B. Saxe dealt with a malpractice plaintiff who offered a handwriting expert to testify that the surgeon's chart entries were written by a person with shaky hands, as proof of the surgeon's physical condition. The court held that "a handwriting expert is not competent to testify to an individual's physical or mental condition based on a sample of that individual's handwriting" and excluded the testimony.
Under the Frye test, the court added, the plaintiff had not shown that handwriting analysis is generally accepted as reliable for judging a surgeon's fitness, and the court found no judicial opinions holding that it is. Discussing an earlier case, Daniels v. Cummins, the court wrote that the expert there had "leaped into an occult and pseudoscientific pursuit known as graphology."
A document examiner does record tremor, poor line quality and other signs of distortion, because section 6.3.7 of Standard 070 requires it. The examiner uses them to judge whether the writing is natural or simulated, not to diagnose an illness.
How is a forensic document examiner trained?
By supervised training in the procedures and instruments, either as an apprentice in a laboratory or over several years of structured study, usually followed by certification. A course in graphology is not that training.
The AFDE describes two paths. Examiners employed in law enforcement agencies normally train in-house as apprentices, and the training lasts until the person is competent to render forensic opinions. Private-sector candidates usually find a mentor and may study part-time for several years. A degree from an accredited college or university is described as a start.
Certification boards differ, according to the AFDE, in their prerequisites, their testing procedures and whether the board is accredited by the Forensic Specialties Accreditation Board. Section 4.1 of Standard 070 requires that its procedures be used by a forensic document examiner trained in the procedures and instruments, and section 1 states that the standard cannot replace knowledge, skills or abilities acquired through task-specific education, training, research and experience.
The ASQDE paper adds a point about testing. Proficiency studies have been conducted on examiners whose training meets published standards; the paper says not one has been conducted on graphologists who practice forensic examination without meeting them.
What does a court require of a handwriting witness?
Testimony based on sufficient facts or data and on reliable methods reliably applied. Courts have limited even certified examiners, admitting comparisons of similarities and differences while excluding the opinion on who wrote the entry.
In Barnett v. American Heritage Life Insurance Co., No. 06-2171 (W.D. Tenn., November 19, 2007), Magistrate Judge Tu M. Pham applied Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence to a forensic document examiner with a bachelor's degree in forensic science, certified by the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners since 1982. The court found him qualified, then excluded his testimony as to authorship, including his opinion that there were "indications" that Angelina Barnett wrote the questioned beneficiary entries, because the plaintiffs had not shown support for the principle of uniqueness of handwriting.
The same order permitted him to testify to the mechanics and characteristics of handwriting, his methodology and his comparison of similarities and dissimilarities, finding that testimony relevant and reliable.
How do you check whether the other side's handwriting witness is a graphologist?
Read the report and the CV for the method. Personality terms, missing known writing, no mention of the original and no reference to Standard 070 or comparable procedures point to graphology, not document examination.
The report itself usually answers the question. A document examination report names the questioned items and the known writing, says whether originals were examined, describes the comparison and states a conclusion on a recognized scale. A graphological report describes traits. These questions sort the two.
- Where, for how long and under whose supervision was the witness trained in forensic document examination?
- Does the witness hold certification from a board, and is that board accredited by the Forensic Specialties Accreditation Board?
- Is the witness a member of a graphology or graphoanalysis society, and has the witness written personality analyses for clients?
- Which questioned items and which known writing were examined, and were they originals?
- Which procedure did the witness follow, and does the report address the steps of Standard 070, such as comparability of the known writing and alternative interpretations?
- Has the witness taken proficiency tests in handwriting comparison, and with what results?
What does IAE do when a signature is disputed?
An examiner from the IAE registry prepares a report on your questions about a questioned signature or entry, or a review of the opposing examiner's report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE handwriting page covers whether the person named on a will, contract or check signed it, and whether the signature shows signs of simulation or tracing. Under ANSI/ASB Standard 070 (2022) the examiner checks whether questioned and known writing are originals and comparable, then weighs similarities and differences in combination; section 6.3.8 has the examiner look for slow writing, guide lines and unnatural similarity between questioned signatures. Rule 901(b)(3) permits comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert or the trier of fact.
Send the questioned document or its best available copy, the known writing with a note on the source and date of each item, and the questions, through the form on the contact page; the service page has a "Request a quote" button. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and, within one business day, the format, the cost, the deadline and the examiner from the registry. You approve the candidate and the CV before work starts, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the report can be checked by QR code. The examiner confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. The court weighs the report with the other evidence; neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, Graphology and Forensic Document Examination
- Association of Forensic Document Examiners, Frequently Asked Questions
- ANSI/ASB Standard 070, Standard for Examination of Handwritten Items, First Edition 2022
- Neter E., Ben-Shakhar G., The predictive validity of graphological inferences: A meta-analytic approach, Personality and Individual Differences, 1989, 10(7), 737-745
- NCJRS abstract, Journal of Forensic Identification, 1994, vol. 44, No. 3, pp. 276-290 (questioned document examination and graphology)
- Estate of Marie Laveck, Deceased, Michigan Court of Appeals, No. 179630, December 20, 1996, unpublished per curiam opinion (Justia)
- Cameron v. Knapp, 137 Misc. 2d 373 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. 1987)
- Barnett v. American Heritage Life Insurance Co., No. 06-2171 (W.D. Tenn. Nov. 19, 2007), order on motion to exclude
Read also
All articles
Can a notarized signature be challenged as forged, and what does the handwriting examiner have to show?
A notary's stamp does not make a signature unchallengeable, but it changes the proof. In New York a certificate of acknowledgment raises
Block capitals: can a handwriting expert identify who hand printed a note or a form?
Anonymous notes, address labels and filled-in forms are often written in block capitals, and the writer may expect capitals to hide his or her
Signed on a signature pad: can a handwriting expert examine an electronic handwritten signature?
A signature written with a stylus on a pad or tablet is still handwriting, and a handwriting examiner can compare it with known signatures. The imageExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

