Examinations

Is an insult in a private message or group chat defamation?

An insult sent only to the person insulted is not defamation, because nobody else received it. A text or a chat message becomes a published statement once it reaches a third person who can understand it, and Texas and Illinois appellate courts have let defamation claims over texts and private emails to one or two recipients go forward. The message must still state a false fact, and statements to police or social workers can be privileged.

A cafe table holds two cups and a phone face down, a third chair pulled slightly out

Is an insult in a private message defamation?

Not if the message went only to the person insulted. Defamation requires publication to a third party, and a statement made directly to the defamed person has not been published to anyone else.

Illinois states the elements this way in Project44, Inc. v. FourKites, Inc., 2022 IL App (1st) 210575, decided on November 22, 2022: "To establish defamation, the plaintiff must show that (1) the defendant made a false statement about the plaintiff," "(2) the defendant published that false statement to a third party," "and (3) the published statement damaged the plaintiff's reputation."

The Court of Appeals of Texas at Dallas applied the same element in Gautreaux v. May, No. 05-22-00616-CV, a memorandum opinion of September 6, 2023. Publication, it said, means communication to a third person who is "capable of understanding their defamatory import," and a defendant who communicates the statement directly to the person it concerns "has not published the matter to a third person."

The court went through the messages one by one and asked who received each of them. A message that reached only the person it concerned fails on this element, whatever it says.

What counts as publication of a text or chat message?

Delivery to at least one person other than the one defamed who can understand the message. A text that apparently went by mistake to a plaintiff's father and private emails to a company's directors have been treated as published.

Gautreaux v. May involved five text messages, one email chain and one voicemail. One of the texts accused the plaintiffs of corporate sabotage, theft of investors and intellectual property, fraud and wiping company computers. Another went, apparently by mistake, to David May, the father of one of the plaintiffs. For two statements the court wrote: "There is no question that these two statements were communicated to third persons", and named David May and a representative of Oil Patch as the recipients.

On texts sent to other plaintiffs or to a party's attorney the court left the question open: "We need not decide this issue, however." It affirmed the denial of the defendants' motion to dismiss under the Texas Citizens Participation Act, holding that the plaintiffs made a prima facie case of defamation per se and business disparagement.

In Project44 the complaint alleged two anonymous emails sent through Gmail accounts: the first went to two directors of the company who were not its employees, the second to its new chief financial officer. Between them the emails accused the company of accounting improprieties, compared it to Theranos and called it a Ponzi scheme. The trial court dismissed the complaint; the appellate court reversed and held that "the complaint adequately alleges publication." The Supreme Court of Illinois affirmed on March 21, 2024, in 2024 IL 129227, holding that communication of a defamatory statement about a corporation to members of its executive leadership team "establishes the publication element".

The court relied on comments to section 577 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts. Comment e reads: "the communication to a servant or agent of the person defamed is a publication." Comment i treats a communication by one agent to another agent of the same principal, within the scope of employment, as a publication by the first agent and, in the comment's words, "also by the principal".

Is a message in a group chat published to everyone in the group?

Each member who receives the message and is not the person defamed is a third person under the definition courts apply. The membership of the group is evidence of who received the message.

Under the Gautreaux definition, publication needs one third person capable of understanding the statement. A chat of five people, the sender and the person insulted among them, delivers the message to three third persons; a chat of the sender and the person insulted alone delivers it to none.

The membership list is therefore evidence. A screenshot of the message without the list of participants leaves open who read it. The export of the chat, the group settings and the testimony of members who saw the message can answer that question.

Privilege is a separate question. In Project44 the Illinois court reversed the dismissal on publication and wrote in paragraph 53: "We express no opinion on the application of qualified privilege to this matter."

Can a single text to one other person be defamation?

Yes. In Waller v. Waller (2020) a Texas appellate court held that a petition adequately pleaded defamation where one allegation was a text to one person saying that the plaintiff had been stealing.

Waller v. Waller, No. 12-19-00226-CV, was decided by the Court of Appeals of Texas at Tyler on June 5, 2020. Among the alleged statements was a text message that Susan Waller sent to Rhonda Parsons: "I guess you heard Bill's been stealing." The petition also alleged Facebook postings, private Facebook messages and conversations with prospective buyers.

The court held that the petition pleaded defamation against Susan and Alicia: "These paragraphs fairly succinctly allege that Susan and Alicia told numerous people that Bill is a thief." It held that the trial court erred in striking those allegations and reversed the summary judgment on defamation and conspiracy against them. On the social media communications it noted that "the recipients of social media communications, much like the general public, have no direct interest in the litigation," and held that the judicial privilege was not shown on the face of the petition, declining to extend it to social media communications.

Publication does not depend on the size of the audience: under the Gautreaux definition one third person is enough.

Are messages to police, social workers or hospital staff protected?

Often by a qualified privilege. In a recent Ohio federal case, statements to police, social workers and hospital staff were privileged, and the claim failed because actual malice was not plausibly pleaded.

Greer v. Harreld, No. 2:24-cv-1237, was decided in the Southern District of Ohio by Chief Judge Sarah D. Morrison. Steven Greer alleged that his siblings defamed him while he cared for their father, who had dementia. The statements were made to police, social workers, hospital and nursing home staff, funeral home staff and an aunt.

For the statements to police, social workers and staff the court applied a qualified privilege and found that Greer had not plausibly pleaded actual malice. Other statements failed because the complaint did not say who said what, when or to whom, or because the speakers were not defendants. The defamation claim was dismissed in full.

A private channel does not decide the case either way. A text to a stranger about a theft can be actionable, as in Waller; a message to a caseworker about a family member can be privileged, as in Greer.

Does calling someone "crazy" in a chat state a fact?

When it names an impression and no checkable fact. Courts treat words like "crazy" as opinion, while accusations of theft or fraud in a text can support a claim of defamation per se.

In Greer the court treated "not a real doctor" as non-actionable figurative opinion and quoted an earlier ruling on "mentally unstable" and "crazy": "A statement that someone is "crazy" is an expression of opinion that generally does not subject one to liability." In Gautreaux, texts that accused named people of theft of intellectual property and fraud supported a prima facie case of defamation per se, and in Waller "Bill's been stealing" was pleaded as defamation.

What if the sender says the messages are fake?

The party offering the messages must authenticate them. Federal Rule of Evidence 901 lets that be done by a witness with knowledge, by comparison with authenticated writing and by the distinctive characteristics of the messages.

Rule 901(a) requires "evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is." Rule 901(b)(1) accepts "Testimony that an item is what it is claimed to be", for example from the recipient who saw the message arrive. Rule 901(b)(4) accepts "The appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns, or other distinctive characteristics of the item" "taken together with all the circumstances."

Rule 901(b)(3) provides for "A comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact." The advisory committee note to Example (4) adds that "Language patterns may indicate authenticity or its opposite." A forensic linguist compares the disputed messages with messages the sender admits writing: spelling habits, punctuation, abbreviations, greetings and word choice.

A digital forensics examiner works on the device and the account: export files, timestamps, phone numbers and the participants of the chat. The two kinds of evidence answer different questions, and in a dispute over a group chat both may be needed.

What does a linguist establish about a chat message?

Who the message refers to, what it asserts, which parts state facts and which state evaluations, how replies and earlier messages shape its meaning and, if authorship is disputed, how its language compares with known writing.

Chat messages are short and refer back to earlier ones. The linguist identifies the person referred to by name, nickname, pronoun, a reply to a specific message or a mention, and reads the message with the thread around it. In Gautreaux the accusations named the people concerned; in a group chat the same accusation can be made by replying to someone's photo.

The linguist then separates the propositions: "Bill's been stealing" asserts conduct that records can confirm or refute, while "crazy" states an impression. Emojis, quotation marks and capital letters are part of the text and are described with the words.

In a federal case the written report follows Rule 26(a)(2)(B): "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them," "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them," exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, prior testimony from the previous 4 years and compensation. The list of facts or data names the exported chat and the known writing used for comparison. Whether the message is defamatory is decided by the court.

What does IAE prepare when an insult in a chat is claimed to be defamation?

An IAE linguist prepares a report on the client's questions or a review of the opposing linguist's report for a federal or state case, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE forensic linguistics page lists the questions: whether a post states a fact or an opinion, how a disputed contract clause reads, whether two marks look and sound alike, who wrote an anonymous message. For defamation the linguist separates statements that can be checked against facts from evaluations, reading each sentence in the context of the whole article, post or message thread. Questioned emails or messages are compared with known writing of each candidate author; under FRE 901(b)(3) an expert witness may compare an item with an authenticated specimen.

The secretariat confirms receipt of the materials the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to sue over a message is a question for the client's attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member