Expert report review
One-sided custody evaluation: what may a psychologist who saw only one parent conclude, and how is the report reviewed?
A psychologist who evaluated only one parent may describe that parent, but under the 2022 APA custody guidelines should not compare the parents or recommend decision-making, caregiving or parenting time. The APA Ethics Code limits opinions about a person the psychologist never examined. In California, rule 5.220 lets a court-appointed evaluator make a custody or visitation recommendation only for a party who has been evaluated. A review of a one-sided report measures each conclusion against these limits.

What is a one-sided custody evaluation?
An evaluation in which a psychologist retained by one parent or that parent's attorney examines that parent, and sometimes the child, while the other parent takes no part. The court did not appoint this evaluator.
Family courts order custody evaluations from evaluators they appoint. California Rules of Court rule 5.220 governs both court-connected and private child custody evaluators appointed under Family Code section 3111, and rule 5.220(c)(1) defines a child custody evaluator as a court-appointed investigator as defined in Family Code section 3110. The rule does not address a psychologist whom one parent hires directly.
The 2022 APA Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings, adopted as association policy in February 2022, draw the same line in the commentary to Guideline 7. Court-ordered evaluations are controlled by the court, which may restrict further distribution of the report. "Non-court-ordered evaluations may be controlled by the examinees." The parent who pays for a private evaluation decides whether the court ever sees it.
A one-sided report reaches the other parent in one of two ways. The retaining parent attaches it to a motion or a trial brief, or discloses the psychologist as an expert witness. In both cases the other parent's attorney receives a document about a family that the psychologist saw in part.
What may a psychologist conclude after evaluating only one parent?
Conclusions about the parent who was evaluated. Guideline 19 says that when only one parent is evaluated, psychologists avoid comparing the parents and refrain from recommendations on decision-making, caregiving or parenting time.
Guideline 19 asks psychologists to collect sufficient data to address the scope of the evaluation. Its commentary recognizes that in some referrals psychologists may be asked to evaluate only one parent. In those cases they are to avoid comparing the parents and to refrain from making recommendations on decision-making, caregiving or parenting time.
A one-parent evaluation can still answer narrower questions. It can describe the evaluated parent's functioning, that parent's test results, the interaction between that parent and the child during an observation, and any treatment needs. It cannot support a statement that this parent is the better custodian, because the second half of the comparison was never assessed.
Guideline 10 asks psychologists to construct an evidence-based, multimethod and multitrait assessment format. A reviewer reads the methods section of a one-sided report with that guideline open. Interviews of one parent, tests of one parent and an observation in one home cover one of the two households.
Can the report describe the parent who was never examined?
Only with stated limits. Under Standard 9.01(b) of the APA Ethics Code, opinions about a person's psychological characteristics follow an adequate examination; when one was not practical, the psychologist documents the efforts and limits the conclusions.
Standard 9.01(b) of the APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct says that psychologists provide opinions of the psychological characteristics of individuals only after they have conducted an examination of the individuals adequate to support their statements or conclusions. When such an examination is not practical after reasonable efforts, psychologists document the efforts they made and the result, clarify the probable impact of their limited information on the reliability and validity of their opinions, and limit the nature and extent of their conclusions or recommendations. The code took effect on June 1, 2003; the amendments effective in 2010 and 2017 changed the Introduction and Applicability and Standards 1.02, 1.03 and 3.04, and left Standard 9.01 as adopted in 2002.
Standard 9.01(c) covers record reviews. When psychologists conduct a record review or provide consultation and an individual examination is not warranted or necessary for the opinion, they explain this and the sources of information on which they based their conclusions and recommendations.
Statements about the absent parent in a one-sided report come from the retaining parent's interview, from messages that parent selected, or from the child's remarks during a visit that parent arranged. The reviewer marks each such statement and checks whether the report names its source and states the limit that Standard 9.01(b) requires. A report that diagnoses or characterizes a parent the psychologist never met, with no such disclosure, departs from the Ethics Code on its face.
What do California's rules say about recommendations for a party who was not evaluated?
Rule 5.220 lets court-appointed evaluators recommend custody or visitation only for a party who has been evaluated, and bars recommendations about a party not evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional.
Two subdivisions of rule 5.220 state the limit. Under subdivision (f)(3) the evaluator must only make a custody or visitation recommendation for a party who has been evaluated. Under subdivision (j)(3) the evaluator must not offer any recommendations about a party unless that party has been evaluated directly or in consultation with another qualified neutral professional. Subdivision (j)(1) adds the duty to maintain objectivity, provide and gather balanced information for both parties, and control for bias.
These rules bind evaluators appointed under Family Code section 3111. A psychologist hired by one parent falls outside their text, but a California judge who reads a private report next to a court-appointed evaluation knows the standard the appointed evaluator works under. The reviewer uses rule 5.220 as a measuring line: a court-appointed evaluator could not have made the recommendation that the private report makes.
Rule 5.220(e)(1) also lists what an evaluator explains to the parties in writing: the purpose of the evaluation, the procedures used and the time required, the scope and distribution of the report, the limits on confidentiality, and the cost and payment responsibility. A private report that is silent on these points sends the reviewer to ask for the engagement letter.
Can a parent bring a private psychologist when the court has appointed an evaluator?
In California, yes. Evidence Code section 733 lets any party produce other expert evidence on the same matter as a court-appointed expert, and the party calling that expert pays the expert's fees.
Evidence Code section 733 provides that nothing in the article on court-appointed experts prevents any party from producing other expert evidence on the same fact or matter mentioned in section 730. Where a party calls other expert witnesses, their fees are paid by the party calling them, and only ordinary witness fees are taxed as costs in the action.
The same section lets the other parent answer a one-sided report with a psychologist of its own. That psychologist can testify, or can work as a consultant who reviews the report and the underlying data and prepares questions for cross-examination.
Pennsylvania's custody rule takes a different route. Rule 1915.8(a) of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure lets the court order the child or any party to submit to and fully participate in an evaluation by an appropriate expert, on its own motion, on a party's motion or by agreement, and the order addresses the allocation of the costs, including insurance coverage. Under Rule 1915.8(b), a report that a party obtains and intends to introduce at trial must be delivered at least thirty days before trial, and the evaluator is subject to cross-examination by all counsel without regard to who obtains or pays for the evaluation.
Rule 1915.8(b) also states that no report is filed of record or considered evidence unless and until admitted by the court.
What does a reviewer check first in a one-sided report?
Who retained the psychologist, what question the psychologist was asked, what the parents were told about the purpose, which documents and people the psychologist relied on, and whether the other parent was invited.
Guideline 3 asks psychologists to identify the stated purpose of a custody evaluation before accepting a referral. In a one-sided evaluation the referral question comes from one parent or that parent's attorney. The reviewer compares the question with the conclusions. A referral to assess one parent's parenting capacity does not produce a comparison of two parents.
Guideline 7 asks psychologists to strive to obtain informed consent when this is both feasible and appropriate, and, where consent is not obtained, to strive to notify the referral source. The reviewer looks for the consent statement, what it says about the purpose and the intended use of the report, and who consented to the child's participation.
Then the reviewer lists the sources. A one-sided file holds interview notes with one parent, that parent's test protocols, an observation of that parent with the child, school or medical records the parent provided, and calls with people the parent named. Each item gets a note on who chose it. Collateral contacts chosen by one parent do not replace an interview with the other.
How does the reviewer test the data behind each opinion?
By tracing each opinion back to a test score, an interview passage, an observation or a document, and by noting which opinions rest only on the retaining parent's account.
The reviewer works from the report and, where counsel can obtain them, the psychologist's notes and test data. An opinion about the evaluated parent's mood that rests on test scores and an interview is one kind of statement. An opinion that the child fears the other parent, based on the child's words during a session the retaining parent scheduled, is another, and the reviewer records the conditions under which those words were obtained.
Guideline 19 frames the question as sufficiency of data for the scope of the evaluation. The reviewer asks whether the scope stated in the report matches the data collected. If the stated scope is one parent's functioning, the data may be sufficient. If the report goes on to address the child's best interests between two households, the data on the second household are missing.
Test results get a separate check. The reviewer confirms which tests were given, to whom, and whether the report carries the evaluated parent's scores over to the other parent by inference. Scores describe the person who took the test.
Will the court exclude a one-sided report or give it less weight?
That depends on the state's evidence rules and on the judge. Pennsylvania Rule 1915.8(b) treats no evaluation report as evidence until the court admits it, and Rule 702 asks whether an opinion rests on sufficient facts or data.
Custody cases are heard in state courts, and each state applies its own evidence rules. Federal Rule of Evidence 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case. Where a state court applies a rule with this wording, the sufficiency of data in a one-parent report is the first question.
The committee note to the 2023 amendment of Rule 702 says that some challenges to expert testimony raise matters of weight rather than admissibility, and that once the court finds the requirements met, any attack by the opponent goes only to the weight of the evidence. A review prepares both lines: the opinions that lack a sufficient basis, for a motion, and the limits of the remaining opinions, for cross-examination and argument.
Pennsylvania Rule 1915.8(b) puts the gate into the custody rule itself: no report is considered evidence unless and until admitted by the court, and the evaluator is subject to cross-examination by all counsel. The reviewer's list of points becomes the outline for that cross-examination.
What does the attorney receive from the review?
A written review that ties each point to a page of the one-sided report and to a guideline, an ethics standard or a court rule, with a list of documents to request and questions for the psychologist.
The review sorts the statements in the one-sided report into three groups: findings about the evaluated parent that the data support, findings that the data support in part, and statements about the absent parent or about custody that Guideline 19 and Standard 9.01(b) leave without a basis.
For each point the reviewer writes what the report says and on which page, what the guideline or rule requires, and what is missing. The reviewer also lists documents to request from the other side, such as the engagement letter, the consent form, interview notes and test data, and questions about who scheduled the child's sessions and who supplied each collateral contact.
The reviewer does not evaluate the family and gives no custody recommendation. Standard 9.01(c) applies to the reviewer too: a record review says that no examination was done and names the sources used.
What does IAE do when the other side files a one-sided custody evaluation?
A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a work product review of the other side's psychological report against the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA custody guidelines. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days.
The IAE review is for parents and family law attorneys who have received a custody evaluation or the other side's psychological report. The psychologist reads the report and the underlying data, checks them against the court order where there is one, the court rules for evaluators and the APA custody guidelines, and writes where the report follows them and where it does not.
IAE agrees the review questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued within 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Registry members passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. The reviewer does not examine the family and does not recommend which parent should have custody. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- American Psychological Association, Guidelines for Child Custody Evaluations in Family Law Proceedings (2022), Guidelines 3, 7, 10, 19
- APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (2002, amended effective June 1, 2010 and January 1, 2017), Standard 9.01 Bases for Assessments
- California Rules of Court, rule 5.220, Court-ordered child custody evaluations
- California Evidence Code section 733
- Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 1915.8, Physical and Mental Examination of Persons
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Capacity to sign a contract or deed: how is the opposing expert's opinion on mental capacity reviewed?
An expert opinion that a person lacked the mental capacity to sign a contract or deed is written after the signing, in some cases years later
Sexual abuse allegations in a custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check?
When a parent alleges that a child was sexually abused, a California custody evaluation must follow Family Code section 3118: the evaluator consults
Move-away custody evaluation: what does a reviewing psychologist check when a parent wants to relocate with the child?
In a California move-away case the court asks whether relocating the child would cause detriment and then weighs factors the state Supreme CourtExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

