Examinations
Piercing the corporate veil: what does a forensic accountant trace, and which test does the court apply?
A creditor who pierces the corporate veil collects a company's debt from its owner. The test depends on state law: Delaware asks whether the owner and the company operated as a single economic entity and whether the result carries an element of injustice or unfairness; Florida requires improper conduct. In both, the proof comes from the company's books. In NetJets v. LHC Communications the ledger showed more than $4.5 million of the owner's personal expenses paid by the company.

What does piercing the corporate veil mean?
A court disregards the separate existence of a corporation or an LLC and holds its owner liable for the company's debts. Each state sets its own test, and the creditor carries the burden of proof.
A corporation or a limited liability company is a separate person, and its owner is not ordinarily liable for its debts. Veil piercing, also called the alter ego doctrine, is the exception. A creditor who wins a judgment against an empty company asks the court to reach the owner who controlled it.
In NetJets Aviation, Inc. v. LHC Communications, LLC, decided by the Second Circuit on August 8, 2008, the company was a Delaware LLC and the court applied the Delaware alter ego standard. In Dania Jai-Alai Palace, Inc. v. Sykes, decided by the Florida Supreme Court on May 3, 1984, the court applied Florida's rule. The two tests differ, and the facts a forensic accountant has to establish differ with them.
What do courts look for under the Delaware alter ego test?
Two things: that the owner and the company operated as a single economic entity, and an element of injustice or unfairness. Courts weigh capitalization, solvency, records, formalities, siphoning and whether the company was a facade.
In NetJets the Second Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Kearse, framed the Delaware test as a two-part inquiry: whether the owner and the entity "operated as a single economic entity," and whether there was an "element of injustice or unfairness" running through the case. For the first part, courts consider whether the entity was adequately capitalized, whether it was solvent, whether dividends were paid, whether records were kept, whether officers and directors functioned properly, whether other formalities were observed, whether the dominant owner siphoned the entity's funds, and whether the entity was simply a facade for the owner.
No single factor decides the question. Fraud is not required, but the injustice must be more than the breach of contract that created the debt. Because an LLC needs fewer formalities than a corporation, the court gave less weight to missing formalities for LHC.
Most of these factors are measured in money. Capitalization, solvency, dividends and siphoning are questions about the balance sheet and the flow of cash between the company and its owner. That is where a forensic accountant does the work.
How does the Florida test differ?
Florida requires improper conduct. The Florida Supreme Court held in Dania Jai-Alai that the veil may not be pierced unless the corporation was organized or employed to mislead creditors or to work a fraud upon them.
Dania Jai-Alai Palace ran a jai-alai fronton; its valet parking was operated by a sister company, Carrousel Concessions, and both were wholly owned by Saturday Corporation. In December 1977 a Carrousel attendant's foot slipped off the brake onto the accelerator, and the car crushed a patron, Gladys Sykes. A jury returned a $775,000 verdict against all three corporations.
The Florida Supreme Court held that the "corporate veil may not be pierced absent a showing of improper conduct" and quoted its earlier rule that the veil will not be penetrated "unless it is shown that the corporation was organized or employed to mislead creditors or to work a fraud upon them." It criticized the reasoning of a district court of appeal decision, Vantage View, that had allowed piercing on "the mere instrumentality doctrine alone, without improper conduct," and quashed the ruling against the parent company, Saturday. The plaintiff's counsel had stipulated that "there was no wrongdoing or fraud involving Saturday."
For the accountant, Florida changes the question. Control and commingling still have to be shown, but the case turns on evidence that the company was used to mislead creditors or to defraud them: transfers out of the company when its debts came due, payments that left creditors unpaid, records that hid where the money went.
What does a forensic accountant trace in an alter ego case?
The flow of money between the company, its owner and the owner's other companies: how the company was funded, what it paid for the owner, what the owner took out and when, and how the books recorded each transfer.
The NetJets record shows the work. LHC Communications, a Delaware LLC whose sole member was Laurence S. Zimmerman, signed a lease for a 12.5 percent interest in an airplane and a management agreement with NetJets on August 1, 1999. LHC terminated the agreements in July 2000, leaving a balance of $440,840.39; after a $100,000 deposit was applied, $340,840.39 remained unpaid. LHC ceased operations in 2001. The district court entered judgment against LHC and dismissed the claims against Zimmerman.
The evidence on appeal came from LHC's financial records, its general ledger and deposition testimony. LHC was started with capitalization of no more than $20,100. Zimmerman added money as needed and withdrew it at will: between January 2000 and June 2002 about 60 transfers went into LHC from Zimmerman and about 60 went back out to him, and about two dozen transactions ran between LHC and Zimmerman's other companies.
A tracing schedule of this kind lists every transfer with its date, amount, counterparty, the account it moved through and the ledger entry that recorded it. The schedule makes the pattern visible and lets the court check it against the source records. The IAE article on tracing commingled funds covers the tracing rules themselves.
How are personal expenses paid by the company documented?
Payment by payment, with the payee, the date, the amount and the owner's connection to each. In NetJets the company paid more than $4.5 million to third parties for the owner's personal expenses.
The Second Circuit listed the payments. LHC wired a total of $2 million to Salomon Smith Barney on May 15 and 16, 2000 to meet margin calls or reduce the margin debt on Zimmerman's personal brokerage accounts, and sent checks totaling $2 million on August 22 and October 6, 2000 to PaineWebber, another firm where Zimmerman personally had brokerage accounts. It paid about $70,000 between December 2000 and July 2001 to Fox Lair, a Zimmerman company that owned a Park Avenue apartment, about $350,000 for a Bentley titled in Zimmerman's name and $110,000 to the holder of a mortgage on his personal property.
The use of the airplane was tested the same way. Of about 40 LHC flights, Zimmerman acknowledged about 6 as vacations, and at least as many again appeared unrelated to LHC's business.
Each line in such a list has to be tied to a document: the bank debit, the invoice or statement of the payee, the title or the account that shows whose benefit it was. A payment that the books record as a business expense but that bought the owner's car is the kind of fact a court weighs under the siphoning and facade factors.
How does the accountant show that the owner took money out when creditors went unpaid?
By matching the owner's withdrawals against the company's receipts and debts over time. In NetJets the owner withdrew a $675,000 client payment, and more, on the day it arrived, in the month LHC terminated its NetJets agreements.
A client payment of $675,000 reached LHC on July 9, 2000, and Zimmerman withdrew that amount and more the same day. From July 2000 through 2001 he withdrew about $750,000 more than he deposited. In total, by the court's count, what Zimmerman and his companies took out of LHC exceeded what they put in by some $3 million, not counting money put into LHC for investments in another company, Bazillion.
The timing matters for both parts of the Delaware test. Withdrawals while a debt to a creditor is outstanding go to siphoning and solvency, and they are the facts a court looks at when it asks whether the owner's conduct carried an element of injustice beyond the breach itself.
A net-flow schedule by month, with the company's unpaid debts on the same timeline, puts these facts in one place. It answers the question the court will ask: when the company could not pay, where did its money go?
Were the owner's deposits loans or capital?
The books called them loans, but there were no written agreements or repayment terms. In NetJets the court noted that if the deposits were capital, the withdrawals may well have been prohibited under Delaware LLC law.
Zimmerman's deposits were recorded as loans, without written agreements or repayment terms. A witness testified that this let Zimmerman withdraw the money without tax consequences. The Second Circuit observed that if the deposits were in substance capital contributions, the withdrawals may well have been prohibited by section 18-607(a) of the Delaware LLC Act, given that LHC ceased operating and was unable to pay its debt to NetJets.
The classification is an accounting question with legal consequences. The accountant compares the entries with the documents behind them: notes, interest, maturity dates, repayment history, and whether an outside lender would have lent on those terms. The same factors appear in the IAE article on debt recharacterization.
Who decides the alter ego question, and what is the accountant's report for?
The factfinder decides. In NetJets the evidence was ample to permit a reasonable factfinder to find complete domination, so the Second Circuit vacated the dismissal of the claims against the owner and remanded.
The Second Circuit held that the evidence was "ample to permit a reasonable factfinder" to find that Zimmerman completely dominated LHC, and that a reasonable factfinder could also find an element of injustice or unfairness. Summary judgment for Zimmerman was therefore improper. The court also refused summary judgment for NetJets: whether LHC was Zimmerman's alter ego remained a question for the factfinder after trial.
The accountant's report puts those facts in a form the factfinder can use and the court can test. Under Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence the proponent must establish that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied. Under Rule 703 the accountant may rely on the kinds of facts or data that experts in the field would reasonably rely on. Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the report to state every opinion with its basis and reasons and to list the facts or data considered and the exhibits.
The opinion stops at the financial facts. Whether the owner and the company operated as a single economic entity, and whether the facts amount to injustice or improper conduct, are conclusions for the court and the jury. The accountant shows what the money did.
What does IAE do in a veil piercing or alter ego case?
A forensic accountant from the IAE registry writes an expert report on your questions or a review of the opposing expert's report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic accounting service covers lost profits and other damages, solvency on the date of a transfer, and tracing of funds in commercial, bankruptcy and partnership disputes. The expert traces funds between accounts through bank statements and ledgers, and under FRE 1006 the court may admit a summary chart of voluminous records. The questions are framed from the ledgers, tax returns and bank statements in the record and confirmed before work starts.
For an alter ego case, send the judgment or the claim against the company, its general ledger and bank statements for the period, the owner's and related companies' accounts if you have them, the formation and capitalization documents and any loan papers, and the opposing report if there is one. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and you approve the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID in the document can be checked by QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. Neither IAE nor the specialist guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- NetJets Aviation, Inc. v. LHC Communications, LLC, No. 06-3340-cv, 537 F.3d 168 (2d Cir. Aug. 8, 2008) (CourtListener)
- Dania Jai-Alai Palace, Inc. v. Sykes, 450 So. 2d 1114 (Fla. 1984) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 703, Bases of an Expert (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Preference claim in bankruptcy: how does a forensic accountant test the ordinary course and new value defenses?
A vendor paid in the 90 days before its customer's bankruptcy can be sued for the money under 11 U.S.C. 547. The defenses are arithmetic. In Sparrer
Ponzi scheme clawbacks: how does a forensic accountant calculate who is a net winner and how much must be returned?
When a Ponzi scheme collapses, the receiver or trustee sues investors who took out more than they put in. The figure in each claim comes from
Forensic accountant in a divorce: how are hidden income and assets found under Florida law?
In a Florida divorce each spouse must serve a financial affidavit, three years of tax returns, twelve months of bank and brokerage statementsExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

