Examinations
What can you ask a forensic document examiner, and what should you send with the document?
A forensic document examiner answers questions about how a document was made and what was done to it afterwards: whether an entry was added, a page replaced, a stamp impression made by a given stamp. ANSI/ASB Standard 011 (2022) lists the examinations of the field. What the examiner can conclude depends on the wording of the question and on what arrives with it: the original, known impressions and the device, as Standards 035 and 117 describe.

Which questions can a forensic document examiner answer?
Questions about the source of handwriting and of machine-produced documents, alterations and obliterations, indentations, inks, paper and writing instruments, damaged documents, and the age and production history of a document.
ANSI/ASB Standard 011, Scope of Expertise in Forensic Document Examination, first edition 2022, sets out the list in sections 4.2.1 and 4.2.2. It covers the source of writing and the comparison of handwriting, numerals, signs and signatures, including electronically captured ones. It covers the source of machine-produced documents and the classification of output of typewriters, fax machines, copiers, printers and other imaging devices, and the devices themselves where appropriate.
The same sections include the detection of alterations and obliterations and the decipherment or restoration of altered, obliterated or erased areas; the visualization, decipherment and preservation of indentations; the examination and comparison of inks, paper and writing instruments; and the preservation and restoration of damaged, charred, liquid-soaked, torn or shredded documents.
The older SWGDOC Standard for Scope of Work of Forensic Document Examiners, version 2013-1, states the purpose of all this work in section 3.1: to establish genuineness or nongenuineness, to expose forgery or to reveal alterations, additions or deletions, to identify or eliminate persons as the source of handwriting, and to identify or eliminate the source of typewriting or other impressions and marks.
Which questions are outside the examiner's field?
Questions about the writer's personality or character. Standard 011 states that forensic document examination does not involve the study of handwriting for personality assessment.
Section 4.1 of Standard 011 excludes personality profiling and judgments about a writer's character. The SWGDOC scope standard says the same in its section 4.1: the work "does not involve a study of handwriting in an attempt to create a personality profile", and it does not involve calligraphic or engrossing skills.
Standard 011 draws the same line for the people who do the work. Under section 4.4.1 personality profiling or character assessment based on handwriting is not a foundation for competence in the field. Under section 4.4.3 other experience, such as calligraphy, penmanship, fraud investigation, law enforcement or banking, does not constitute expertise or training in forensic document examination.
A request that asks whether the writer is dishonest or what kind of person wrote a note is therefore addressed to the wrong specialist. A request that asks whether two entries were written with the same ink, or whether a page was substituted, is within the list above.
How should a question about alterations be worded?
Name the entry or page in dispute and the kind of change suspected: addition, deletion, obliteration or substitution. Ask also whether the original entry can be read.
ANSI/ASB Standard 035, Standard for the Examination of Documents for Alterations, first edition 2020, groups alterations in its foreword into four kinds: "an addition, deletion, obliteration, or substitution of information." Section 4.4.4(e) adds cutting and pasting and the insertion or omission of pages or entries. A question built on those words tells the examiner where to look: was the figure in line 4 overwritten, was page 3 produced with pages 1, 2 and 4, was the paragraph above the signature printed in the same pass as the body of the contract.
The answer has a built-in limit, and the question should allow for it. Section 4.3.8 states: "The absence of observed physical characteristics does not support a definite determination that the document is unaltered." Some alterations leave no observable physical characteristics. A question worded "is the document unaltered?" asks for a conclusion the standard does not permit; "are there characteristics of alteration in the amount clause?" asks for one it does.
The standard also expects the report to deal with innocent explanations. Under section 4.7.2(f) the report addresses apparent alterations that may come from software, hardware or user variations during normal production of the document. Tell the examiner how the document was produced, if that is known: the program, the printer, whether pages were reprinted before signing.
What should a request about a stamp impression include?
The original impression, the stamp that is said to have made it, the ink pad for a hand stamp, and known impressions made close in time to the questioned one. ANSI/ASB Standard 117 lists each of them.
ANSI/ASB Standard 117, Standard for Examination of Stamping Devices and Stamp Impressions, first edition 2020, prefers the original: "Examination of the original stamp impression is preferable" (section 4.5.10.1). A reproduction is usable only if its details are clear enough for comparison.
When known impressions are submitted, the examiner "shall request the stamp that produced the known impressions" (section 4.5.7). For a hand stamp the ink pad should be requested as well (section 4.5.11.3). With the device in hand the examiner makes test impressions on a substrate similar to that of the questioned document, with similar ink: a first-generation impression and then a second, third and fourth without reinking, at varied angle and pressure (section 4.5.11.6).
Time matters. A note to section 4.5.13.3 says: "A lack of contemporaneous stamp impressions can adversely affect the accuracy of the examination results." Wear and damage accumulate on a stamp, and the standard lists contemporaneousness as a comparability factor (section 4.5.13.2). Impressions made close in time to the questioned one are therefore the comparison material the standard points to.
The possible answers are fixed in section 4.6.2: identification, elimination, a qualified opinion or no conclusion. An identification requires agreement in class characteristics and in randomly acquired characteristics such as wear, damage and inking defects, and the possibility of a duplicate stamp has to be eliminated.
Can you ask when the document was made?
Yes, as a bounded question. Standard 011 includes comparing document elements with reference collections to determine age, production history or authenticity, and notes that dating and sequence requests can require more than one type of examination.
Section 4.2.2 of Standard 011 places dating inside the field in a specific form: typewriting, printing, paper, watermarks and ink are compared with an appropriate reference collection to determine age, production history or authenticity. Section 4.2.3 adds that requests about the sequence of preparation and the dating of documents "can require more than one type of document examination." The SWGDOC scope standard lists the same subject in section 4.2.1.4: date, source, preparation sequence, alterations or additions and relationships between documents.
A request of this kind can be worded against a reference point. Could this form, this typeface or this printing process have existed on the date the document bears. Was the stamp impression applied before or after the signature that crosses it. Were pages 1 and 2 printed on the same device as the signature page.
Some of those examinations take material out of the document. Standard 035 requires the examiner to obtain and record the requesting party's permission before destructive testing (section 4.6.3), so a request about dating states whether sampling is authorized.
Does the examiner need the original document?
The original is preferred. Standard 035 says that images and copying processes can mask physical characteristics of a document, and the examiner should request the original if it was not submitted.
The wording of section 4.3.2 is categorical: "The examination of the original item(s) is always preferable". The reason given is that "images and copying processes can mask physical characteristics of a document." Standard 011 lists indentations, inks and paper among the things examined, and these are physical features of the sheet.
Without the original the work continues with a recorded limitation. Under section 4.3.3 the examiner uses the best available evidence to assess the quality of the significant details, and section 4.3.1 treats a non-original submission as a limitation to be noted. The Questioned Documents section of the Virginia Department of Forensic Science gives the same instruction to its submitters: "Whenever possible the original documents, questioned and known, should be submitted." Photocopies can be examined when the original is lost or destroyed.
If only a copy exists, section 4.3.3 has the examiner work with the best available evidence, so the earliest and clearest copy is the one to send.
How should the document be handled before it reaches the examiner?
Leave it as it is and send it for document examination before any chemical or destructive processing. Fingerprint processing can make ink run and can destroy indented writing.
Section 4.3.4 of Standard 035 sets the order: "Document examinations should be conducted prior to any destructive processing", and gives latent print, DNA and ink chemistry work as examples. Standard 117 repeats the point for stamps in section 4.4.3: prior storage, handling, testing or chemical processing may hinder observation.
The Virginia laboratory explains the reason in plain terms. Latent print processing can make ink run or vanish and can destroy indented writing, so incoming cases are screened and routed to the document section first, and the non-destructive tests done there do not harm a later latent print examination.
Destructive steps need consent. Under section 4.6.1 of Standard 035 destructive methods should be performed after non-destructive methods have been exhausted, and under section 4.6.3 the examiner obtains and records permission from the requesting party before destructive testing. Images are captured before and after any destructive change (section 4.3.6), and material removed from the item is preserved separately (section 4.3.7). In litigation the other side has an interest in that permission, and the attorney decides how to obtain it.
What comparison material should come with the document?
Material of the same kind and period as the questioned item, with a source that can be proved: the stamp and its earlier impressions, writing of the same type, or other output of the same machine.
For stamp impressions the list is in the section above: the device, the pad and impressions made near the date in question. For handwriting the Virginia laboratory states the rule of comparability. Known samples must match the questioned material in type, hand printing with hand printing and cursive with cursive, and should contain the same characters and character combinations. Their source must be provable and admissible in court.
The last condition has a rule behind it. Rule 901(b)(3) of the Federal Rules of Evidence accepts as authentication "A comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness or the trier of fact." A specimen whose origin is itself disputed does not carry the comparison.
For printed documents Standard 011 includes the source of machine-produced documents and the devices themselves where appropriate. When the question is whether a page came from a given printer, the request can therefore include other documents known to come off that device and the device itself.
How do the original and the samples reach the examiner in a lawsuit?
Through a request under Rule 34 to produce documents and tangible things for inspection, copying, testing or sampling. A nonparty that holds the original is reached under Rule 45.
Rule 34(a)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure covers designated documents and "any designated tangible things" in the responding party's possession, custody or control, and permits the requesting party to inspect, copy, test or sample them. The request must describe each item "with reasonable particularity" and specify a reasonable time, place and manner for the inspection. The response is due within 30 days after service.
A request for document examination can name the original, the stamp, the pad and the comparison documents as separate items. Standard 035 puts non-destructive methods first (section 4.6.1) and requires the examiner to obtain and record the requesting party's permission before destructive testing (section 4.6.3), so a request for sampling of ink or paper is a separate decision for the attorney.
Under Rule 34(c) a nonparty, such as a bank, a notary or a former employer that holds the original or the stamp, may be compelled to produce documents and tangible things as provided in Rule 45.
What will the answer look like?
A report that states the purpose, the examinations conducted, the observations, the conclusions, the limitations and the methods. In federal court it also has to meet Rule 26(a)(2)(B).
Section 4.7.1 of Standard 035 requires reports that are complete and thorough and that state the purpose, the examinations conducted, the observations, the conclusions, the limitations and the methods. For stamps, Standard 117 requires the bases for conclusions to be documented and summarized in the report.
A testifying expert's report in a federal civil case also contains the items of Rule 26(a)(2)(B): a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the witness's qualifications with publications of the previous 10 years, prior testimony of the previous four years and the compensation. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(C) communications that identify facts, data or assumptions which the attorney provided and the examiner considered or relied on are open to discovery.
Under Rule 702 the party offering the examiner must show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion is based on sufficient facts or data and is a reliable application of reliable methods. The first of those conditions, sufficient facts or data, depends on what was submitted: the original or a copy, the known impressions, the device.
What does IAE do when a document needs forensic examination?
An examiner from the IAE registry prepares a report on the client's questions about the document, or a review of the opposing examiner's report, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE forensic document examination page lists the questions the examiner answers: whether a page was inserted or replaced, an entry erased or overwritten, a stamp impression made by the stamp in question, and how the document was printed. Erasures, additions, overwriting and inserted or substituted pages are examined under ANSI/ASB Standard 035 (2020), printing processes are classified under Standard 011 (2022), and stamp impressions are compared with known impressions and the stamp under Standard 117 (2020).
IAE frames the questions around the document and the part of it in dispute, and confirms the questions and the handling of the original with the client before work starts. Send the case materials and describe the task through the form on the contact page. You approve the examiner and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Registry members passed the collegial attestation of the council under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID in the report can be checked by QR code. The examiner confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome, and materials are not passed to third parties without your consent. The court weighs the report with the other evidence; neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- ANSI/ASB Standard 011, Scope of Expertise in Forensic Document Examination, 1st Ed., 2022 (AAFS Standards Board)
- ANSI/ASB Standard 035, Standard for the Examination of Documents for Alterations, 1st Ed., 2020 (AAFS Standards Board)
- ANSI/ASB Standard 117, Standard for Examination of Stamping Devices and Stamp Impressions, 1st Ed., 2020 (AAFS Standards Board)
- SWGDOC Standard for Scope of Work of Forensic Document Examiners, ver. 2013-1 (NIST)
- Virginia Department of Forensic Science, Questioned Documents section
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 901, Authenticating or Identifying Evidence (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 34 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Burned, soaked or torn: what can a document examiner recover from a damaged document?
A document that went through a fire, a flood or a shredder is often still readable in part. Forensic document examiners work with charred
Same pen or a different pen: what can a document examiner tell from the ink?
A document examiner can often show that two entries were written with different inks, and that settles that two pens were used. The reverse is
Indented writing: can an examiner read what was written on the sheet above?
Writing presses into the sheets underneath, and a document examiner can often make those invisible indentations readable with low-angle lightExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

