Expert report review

Review of the opposing forensic document examiner's report: what does the reviewer check?

A review of the other side's questioned document report compares what the examiner did with what the field's standards require: ANSI/ASB Standard 011 on the scope of the work, ANSI/ASB Standard 035 on alterations, originals, notes, destructive tests and report contents, and SWGDOC terminology for conclusions. Each gap the reviewer finds is tied to a section of a standard and to a page of the report.

An examiner under a desk lamp compares report pages with ultraviolet photographs of a document

Is the opinion within the scope of forensic document examination?

ANSI/ASB Standard 011 lists what document examiners do, from handwriting and machine-produced documents to ink, paper and writing instruments, and says that dating and sequence questions can require more than one type of examination.

ANSI/ASB Standard 011, Scope of Expertise in Forensic Document Examination, first edition 2022, was approved by the ASB in December 2018 and by ANSI in August 2022. Section 4.2.2 includes "the examination and comparison of ink, paper, and writing instruments" and the comparison of such elements "with an appropriate standard reference collection to determine age, production history, or authenticity."

Section 4.2.3 says that analytical requests "such as the sequence of preparation, dating of documents, and counterfeit recognition" may require more than one type of examination, and that "A complete forensic examination of documents shall involve the assessment of all of the elements" of the document. A report that dates a contract from a single type of examination should explain why no other examination was needed, and the reviewer checks whether it does.

Section 4.1 sets an outer boundary: forensic document examination "does not involve the study of handwriting for personality assessment." An opinion about the signer's personality drawn from the writing falls outside the field.

Did the examiner work from the original document?

Standard 035 says examination of the original is always preferable, because images and copying can mask physical characteristics. Without the original, the examiner uses the best available evidence and states the limits.

Section 4.3.2 of ANSI/ASB Standard 035, Standard for the Examination of Documents for Alterations, first edition 2020, reads: "The examination of the original item(s) is always preferable," because "images and copying processes can mask physical characteristics of a document." The examiner should request originals if they were not submitted. Under section 4.3.3, if originals are unavailable, the examiner uses the best available evidence to assess significant details.

Section 4.3.8 adds that some alterations may not be detectable in non-original documents. A report that examined a scan, a fax or a photocopy and still gives an unqualified opinion has not applied this section.

The reviewer checks the report's description of the item: original or copy, its condition on receipt, and whether a request for the original was made. Under Rule 34(a)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a party may request that another party produce designated documents and permit the requesting party "to inspect, copy, test, or sample" them, so the absence of the original can be raised in discovery before the review is finished.

Are the examiner's notes detailed enough for an independent review?

Standard 035 requires the examiner to record procedures contemporaneously and with enough detail for an independent review. If the produced file does not let a second examiner retrace the work, that is a finding in itself.

Section 4.3.6 of Standard 035 says the examiner "shall contemporaneously record the procedures performed to allow for an independent review." Section 4.4.3 repeats the requirement for results: "The results and accompanying notes should have sufficient detail to allow for an independent review."

Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) and (iii) require the report to list the facts or data considered and the exhibits. Standard 035 names images among the matters an alteration report addresses (section 4.7.2(e)) and requires images before and after any destructive technique (section 4.6.5). The reviewer asks for those images and for the notes behind each observation in the report.

Rule 26(b)(4)(C) protects communications between counsel and a reporting expert, with three exceptions: compensation, facts or data the attorney provided and the expert considered, and assumptions the attorney provided and the expert relied on. Facts or assumptions about the document supplied by counsel, for example that it was backdated, fall within the exceptions if the examiner considered or relied on them.

Was destructive testing authorized and recorded?

Under Standard 035, destructive examinations come only after non-destructive methods are exhausted, with permission obtained and recorded beforehand and images taken before and after. The reviewer checks all three records.

Section 4.6.1 defines destructive examinations as "those that damage or otherwise change the item" and says they "should be performed after non-destructive methods have been exhausted." All findings are recorded in the case notes. Under section 4.5.13 the examiner determines the need for destructive examinations.

Section 4.6.3: "Prior to destructive testing, obtain and record permission from the responsible party requesting the examination." Section 4.6.5: "The item shall be imaged before and after the use of destructive techniques." A report that mentions sampling of ink lines without a record of permission and without before-and-after images leaves the reviewer unable to confirm what was removed and from where.

In litigation the permission question is also a discovery question. Rule 34(b)(1)(B) requires a request to specify "a reasonable time, place, and manner for the inspection and for performing the related acts," and the 2006 committee note says that burden and intrusiveness raised by requests to test or sample can be addressed under Rules 26(b)(2) and 26(c). Testing that went beyond the agreed protocol is a point for the review and for counsel.

Does the report contain what Standard 035 requires?

Section 4.7 requires the purpose, the examinations, observations, conclusions, limitations and sources of uncertainty, and the methods used, and lists six matters the conclusions address, including whether altered entries were decipherable.

Under section 4.7.1, "The report shall contain the stated purpose of the examination(s)," the examinations conducted, the observations, the conclusions or opinions, "limitations and sources of uncertainty (as applicable)," and the methods used.

Section 4.7.2 lists what the conclusions address, as appropriate: whether characteristics indicative of alterations were observed; whether any of the altered entries were decipherable; the text or description of altered and original entries; the method or sequence of alterations; images of alterations and original entries; and apparent alterations that can actually be the result of software, hardware or user affected variations.

The reviewer turns this list into a table: six rows, each marked as addressed, partly addressed or missing, with the page of the report. A missing row is not automatically an error, because the standard says "as appropriate," so the review explains why the omitted item mattered in this case.

Does a finding of no alteration prove that the document is genuine?

No. Standard 035 section 4.3.8 says the absence of observed physical characteristics does not support a definite determination that the document is unaltered.

The full sentence in section 4.3.8 reads: "The absence of observed physical characteristics does not support a definite determination that the document is unaltered." A report that converts "no signs of alteration found" into "the document is authentic" or "the document was not altered" overstates its result.

The same section notes that some alterations may not be detectable in non-original documents. If the examination was done on a copy, a negative result covers only what the copy could show.

The reviewer also checks which methods produced the negative result. Section 4.7.1 requires the report to state the methods used; a negative finding covers only the methods that produced it, and the review lists the methods the report names.

Could software or equipment explain an apparent alteration?

Standard 035 requires the report to address, where relevant, apparent alterations that can actually result from software, hardware or user affected variations. The reviewer checks whether the examiner considered that explanation before calling a page altered.

Item (f) of section 4.7.2 covers "apparent alterations in documents that can actually be the result of software, hardware, or user affected variations." The standard names three sources of a difference that looks like an alteration but is not one: the software used to prepare the document, the hardware used to print or copy it, and variations introduced by the user.

A reviewer asks whether the examiner collected exemplars from the devices the parties say were used, whether page-to-page differences were compared with differences within a single print run, and whether the report states the alternative and the reason for rejecting it.

Rule 702(d) requires that the opinion apply the method reliably to the facts of the case. The 2023 committee note says "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded from a reliable application" of the expert's basis and methodology. An alteration opinion that never addresses item (f) has not shown that it stays within those bounds.

Is the conclusion worded on a recognized scale?

SWGDOC published a nine-level terminology for document examiners' conclusions, with identification and elimination at the ends, and says examiners may apply it to other examinations within their work. "Possible" and "could have" have no place in it.

The SWGDOC Standard Terminology for Expressing Conclusions of Forensic Document Examiners (ver. 2013-2) runs from identification through strong probability, probable and indications to no conclusion, and then through indications did not, probably did not and strong probability did not to elimination. Section 3.5 says the text deals with handwriting and that forensic document examiners "may apply this terminology to other examinations within the scope of their work."

Section 4.2.1 says the terms "possible" and "could have" "have no place in expert opinions on handwriting." A report on a stamp impression or a page substitution that uses "could have been altered" gives the court no level of confidence to weigh.

The 2023 committee note to Rule 702 adds that forensic experts "should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty" if the methodology is subjective. The reviewer reads the conclusion level against the limitations the examiner recorded and states which limitation caps it.

How does the review reach the court?

As a confidential consulting memo, as a rebuttal report served within 30 days of the opposing disclosure, or through cross-examination and a Rule 702 motion built on its points.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D), facts known and opinions held by an expert retained in anticipation of litigation who is not expected to testify are ordinarily not discoverable. Counsel can obtain the review first and decide later whether to designate the reviewer. A testifying reviewer serves a report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B); evidence intended solely to contradict or rebut the opposing expert on the same subject is due within 30 days after that disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), absent a stipulation or court order.

Rule 705 lets the cross-examiner require the examiner to disclose the facts or data underlying the opinion. Rule 703 lets an expert rely on facts or data that experts in the field would reasonably rely on, even if they are not admissible. The review tells counsel which notes, images and test records to ask for.

Since December 1, 2023, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and a reliable method reliably applied. The committee note calls rulings that treated the sufficiency of the basis and the application of the method as questions of weight "an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."

What does IAE do when a party needs a review of a document examiner's report?

IAE prepares reviews of the opposing examiner's report on alterations, substituted pages, stamp impressions and printing process for federal and state cases. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The review checks whether each opinion comes with its basis and the facts or data considered, as Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires, and whether the examiner followed Standard 035, including the treatment of apparent alterations caused by software, hardware or normal production variation. It answers the six questions IAE uses for every expert report: method, completeness, soundness of conclusions, the expert's competence, form and procedure, and whether the report can be relied on.

The client sends the opposing report, the produced file and what is available of the document. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The questions and the handling of any original are agreed before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Specialists are members of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. Each confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member