Expert report review

Rule 35 psychological examination: what does the plaintiff's reviewing psychologist check?

When a plaintiff claims emotional distress, the defense can ask the court to order a psychological examination under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 35. The order sets the time, place, manner, conditions and scope, and the examiner then writes a report with findings, diagnoses, conclusions and test results. A psychologist on the plaintiff's side reviews that report against the order, the test data and the ethics rules for psychological assessment.

A psychologist seen over the shoulder sits with test forms and a stopwatch, the face out of view

When can the defense obtain a psychological examination of the plaintiff?

When the plaintiff's mental condition is in controversy and the defense shows good cause. In Schlagenhauf v. Holder the Supreme Court required an affirmative showing, not conclusory allegations in the pleadings.

Under Rule 35(a)(1), the court where the action is pending may order a party whose mental or physical condition is in controversy to submit to an examination by a suitably licensed or certified examiner. Under Rule 35(a)(2)(A), the order may be made only on motion for good cause and on notice to all parties and to the person to be examined.

In Schlagenhauf v. Holder, 379 U.S. 104, decided November 23, 1964, Justice Goldberg wrote for the Court that both requirements are not met "by mere conclusory allegations of the pleadings" or "by mere relevance to the case" and that they "require an affirmative showing by the movant." A plaintiff in a negligence action who asserts mental or physical injury "places that mental or physical injury clearly in controversy." The Court held that the record could not support the order for four examinations of the defendant, in internal medicine, ophthalmology, neurology and psychiatry, and remanded the case.

Courts look at what the plaintiff actually claims. In Gattegno v. PricewaterhouseCoopers, No. 3:00CV1399 (D. Conn., October 2001), the plaintiff alleged ongoing mental injury in every count and a separate count of negligent infliction of emotional distress. Magistrate Judge Holly B. Fitzsimmons granted the examination and wrote that whether the plaintiff believed she had alleged a "garden-variety" claim was "not significant." In Stuff v. Simmons, No. 49A02-0505-CV-416 (Ind. Ct. App., December 12, 2005), the court reversed an order compelling a neuropsychological examination under Indiana Trial Rule 35. A routine claim for emotional distress damages did not put the plaintiff's mental condition in controversy, and an examining physician's opinion that she magnified her symptoms did not show good cause.

California sets the line by statute. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 2032.320(b) and (c), the court may not order a mental examination of a personal injury plaintiff who stipulates that no claim is made for mental and emotional distress over and above that usually associated with the physical injuries and that no expert testimony on that distress will be offered, unless exceptional circumstances are shown. In Doyle v. Superior Court, 50 Cal.App.4th 1878, decided in 1996, the Court of Appeal held that an allegation of past emotional distress did not place the plaintiff's mental condition in controversy.

What must the order for the examination specify?

The time, place, manner, conditions and scope of the examination and the person or persons who will perform it (Rule 35(a)(2)(B)). In California the order also names the diagnostic tests and procedures.

Rule 35(a)(2)(B) requires the order to specify these items. The committee note to the 1991 amendment explains that Congress changed the rule in 1988 to authorize mental examinations by licensed clinical psychologists, that the word "suitably" before licensed or certified was a new requirement, and that the court may assess the examiner's credentials, especially for "examinations by persons having narrow qualifications."

The terms come before the examination. In Winslow v. Montana Rail Link, 2001 MT 269, decided December 18, 2001, the Supreme Court of Montana held that a pleaded tort claim for emotional distress satisfied good cause for a psychiatric examination, and sent the case back for an order specifying the "time, place, manner, conditions and scope" of the examination before it took place.

Section 2032.320(d) of the California Code of Civil Procedure adds the "diagnostic tests and procedures" to the list. In Doyle the defense disclosure said the psychologist would give "the MMPI and other standard projective tests," and only a later letter named the Rorschach, the Thematic Apperception Test and the Rotter Incomplete Sentences test.

In Mills v. Cabell County Board of Education, No. 3:22-cv-00592 (S.D.W. Va., December 22, 2023), Magistrate Judge Cheryl A. Eifert ordered an examination of a mother who claimed serious emotional distress after the alleged mistreatment of her non-verbal son at school. The examiner was a licensed clinical and forensic psychologist, and the plan covered a records review, a face-to-face interview, in-person psychological testing and collateral interviews if appropriate, with testing spread over two days. The reviewer reads the report against such an order and lists every procedure that the order did not cover.

Can the plaintiff's side observe or record the examination?

Federal courts decide it in the conditions of each order, with different results. California gives both the examiner and the examinee the right to make an audio recording of a mental examination.

Section 2032.530(a) of the California Code of Civil Procedure reads: "The examiner and examinee shall have the right to record a mental examination by audio technology." Under subdivision (b), the section leaves unchanged the existing case law on the presence of the examinee's attorney or other persons.

In Matchett v. Nelson-Hughes, Civil No. 2022-43 (D.V.I., amended order of May 6, 2024), the plaintiff claimed short-term memory loss and trouble concentrating after a fall. Magistrate Judge Ruth Miller ordered: "Plaintiff's neuropsychological examination shall be videorecorded." She found recording "the best means to promote" objectivity and reliability and limited the recording to counsel, their staff and experts, with no use outside the case.

In Meza v. Wacker Neuson Sales Americas, No. 2:18-cv-0574 (D. Ariz., September 12, 2018), Judge H. Russel Holland ruled the other way for an examination by a clinical neuropsychologist: "The IME proceedings shall not be recorded." The plaintiff's guardian could attend the clinical interview and the questionnaires but "may not be present during the administration of psychological testing."

For the reviewer, a recording settles what was asked, in what words and how long each part took. Without one, the review compares the report with the examiner's notes and test forms and with the plaintiff's own account of the day.

What must the examiner's report contain?

Under Rule 35(b)(2), the examiner's findings in writing and in detail, including diagnoses, conclusions and the results of any tests. The party that moved for the examination delivers it on request, with like reports of earlier examinations.

Under Rule 35(b)(1), the party that moved for the examination must, on request, give the requester a copy of the examiner's report together with like reports of all earlier examinations of the same condition. The requester may be the party against whom the order was issued or the person examined. Rule 35(b)(2) requires a detailed written report setting out "the examiner's findings, including diagnoses, conclusions" and the results of any tests.

If the report is not delivered, Rule 35(b)(5) lets the court order delivery on just terms and exclude the examiner's testimony at trial. Rule 35(b)(6) applies the subdivision to examinations made by agreement, unless the agreement states otherwise, and keeps other routes open: it does not preclude obtaining an examiner's report or deposing an examiner under other rules. The committee note to the 1970 amendment says that Rule 35(b) "is not preemptive."

California's version is longer. Under section 2032.610, the examinee's side may demand a detailed written report setting out the history, the examinations, the findings, including the results of all tests made, the diagnoses, prognoses and conclusions, and copies of reports of all earlier examinations of the same condition. The reports are due "within 30 days after service of the demand, or within 15 days of trial, whichever is earlier," and the work-product protection for the examiner's writings, reports and testimony is waived.

A report that names a diagnosis without the test results it rests on, or lists tests without their scores, leaves out items that Rule 35(b)(2) names. The reviewer records each such gap with the page of the report.

What does the plaintiff give up by requesting the report?

Privilege over other examinations of the same condition. Under Rule 35(b)(4), by requesting and obtaining the report or by deposing the examiner, the examinee waives privilege for testimony about all such examinations.

Rule 35(b)(4) states the waiver: by requesting and obtaining the examiner's report, or by deposing the examiner, the party examined waives any privilege it may have in that action or any other action involving the same controversy concerning testimony about all examinations of the same condition.

The exchange runs both ways. Under Rule 35(b)(3), after delivering the report, the party that moved for the examination may request from the other side like reports of all earlier or later examinations of the same condition, unless it proves it could not obtain them.

The plaintiff's side therefore takes stock before it sends the request. A psychologist who examined the plaintiff for the plaintiff's own case produces reports of the same condition. A reviewing psychologist who only reads the defense report and file and does not examine the plaintiff is in a different position: under Rule 26(b)(4)(D), facts known and opinions held by a consulting expert who is not expected to testify are ordinarily not discoverable, except as provided in Rule 35(b) or on a showing of exceptional circumstances.

Whether a given report falls under the waiver is a legal question for counsel. The reviewer's part is to state in the review which records were examined and to keep the review limited to the defense examiner's work.

How does the reviewing psychologist get the test data?

Through the examinee's release or a court order. Under the APA Ethics Code, psychologists give test data, including raw scores and responses, to persons named in a release and otherwise only as law or a court order requires.

Standard 9.04 of the APA Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (adopted in 2002, amended in 2010) defines the term: "The term test data refers to raw and scaled scores, client/patient responses to test questions or stimuli," and "psychologists' notes and recordings concerning client/patient statements and behavior during an examination."

Under 9.04(a), "pursuant to a client/patient release, psychologists provide test data to the client/patient or other persons" named in the release, and they may withhold it to protect the client or others from substantial harm. Under 9.04(b), "in the absence of a client/patient release, psychologists provide test data only as required by law or court order."

Test materials are a separate category. Standard 9.11 defines them as "manuals, instruments, protocols, and test questions or stimuli" and asks psychologists to make reasonable efforts to maintain their integrity and security. A request that names the plaintiff's psychologist as the recipient of the test data and keeps the test materials out of general circulation follows both 9.04 and 9.11. The Matchett order used such a condition for the video, limiting it to counsel, their staff and experts.

With the scores and the response sheets the reviewer can rescore the tests and check the examiner's arithmetic and norms. With the report alone the reviewer checks only whether the conclusions follow from the scores the report itself states.

What does the reviewing psychologist check in the examiner's report?

Whether the procedures match the order, whether each conclusion rests on data the report sets out, whether the tests were valid for the person tested, and whether the interpretation accounts for the purpose and setting of the examination.

The first check is the order. Each interview, test and collateral contact in the report is compared with the time, manner, conditions and scope that the order set under Rule 35(a)(2)(B), and in California with the tests and procedures named under section 2032.320(d).

The tests come next. Standard 9.02(b) of the APA Ethics Code asks psychologists to use instruments "whose validity and reliability have been established for use with members of the population tested" and, when they have not been established, to "describe the strengths and limitations of test results and interpretation." The reviewer checks the age, language and background of the plaintiff against the norms of each test named in the report.

Interpretation is the third check. Under Standard 9.06, psychologists interpreting results take into account "the purpose of the assessment as well as the various test factors, test-taking abilities, and other characteristics of the person being assessed, such as situational, personal, linguistic, and cultural differences," and indicate significant limitations of their interpretations. The reviewer checks whether the report states the purpose of the examination and the situation in which it took place, an examination requested by the opposing party in a lawsuit, and how the examiner took them into account.

The last check is the link between data and opinion. Rule 702 requires testimony "based on sufficient facts or data" that "is the product of reliable principles and methods," applied reliably to the case, and Rule 703 lets an expert rely on facts or data of a kind that experts in the field would reasonably rely on. A statement that the plaintiff exaggerates symptoms, with no score or observation cited for it, is the kind of conclusion the reviewer marks first. In Stuff v. Simmons the court held that such an opinion from an examining physician did not show good cause for a mental examination.

Is the Rule 35 report the only disclosure the examiner makes?

No. Rule 35(b)(6) keeps the other discovery rules open, and an examiner retained to testify writes the report that Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires and can be deposed after it is provided.

Rule 35(b)(6) says that the subdivision does not preclude obtaining an examiner's report or deposing an examiner under other rules. The 1970 committee note names Rule 34 and Rule 26(b)(3) or (4) as routes for discovering unprivileged reports.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a written report "prepared and signed by the witness" from a witness "retained or specially employed to provide expert testimony in the case." That report lists all opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, cases with trial or deposition testimony from the previous 4 years and the compensation.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A), a party may depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and where a report is required the deposition takes place only after the report is provided. The review written from the Rule 35 report and the test data becomes the outline for that deposition.

The Rule 35 report and the Rule 26 report can differ. The reviewer compares them line by line: diagnoses, test results, conclusions and the facts listed as considered. A conclusion that appears only in the later report, or a test result that changed between them, is a point for counsel.

What does IAE do when a party needs a review of a Rule 35 psychological examination?

A psychologist from the IAE registry writes a review of the opposing psychologist's evaluation or an expert report on the client's questions. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The forensic psychological evaluation page covers child custody and parenting time, decision-making capacity in contract and will disputes, and emotional distress claims in civil cases. On emotional distress it states the federal rule: when a party's mental condition is in controversy, the court may order an examination under FRCP 35, and the examiner's report sets out findings, diagnoses, conclusions and test results.

The review checks the opposing report against the APA Specialty Guidelines for Forensic Psychology: corroboration from more than one source (9.02), instruments with established validity and reliability (10.02) and stated limits for persons not examined (9.03). IAE frames the questions from the pleadings, the records and the opposing evaluator's report and confirms them with the client before work starts.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome.

Materials go through the contact form and are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member