Expert witnesses

Securities litigation damages expert: what must loss causation and the 90-day lookback show?

In a private securities fraud action the plaintiff must prove that the defendant's misstatement caused the loss, and damages may not exceed the gap between the price the plaintiff paid or received and the mean trading price over the 90 days after the truth reached the market. Both rules are in 15 U.S.C. 78u-4, added by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. A damages expert works inside these two limits.

An economist from behind studies a hand-drawn price line on a blank sheet

What does a damages expert do in a securities fraud case?

The expert connects the price of the security to the misstatement and its correction, and computes damages within the statutory cap. The plaintiff carries the burden of proving loss causation under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(b)(4).

Section 78u-4 is part of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 as codified in chapter 2B of title 15. It was added by Pub. L. 104-67 of December 22, 1995, and amended in 1998 and 2010. Two of its provisions decide what a damages expert has to establish. Subsection (b)(4) puts on the plaintiff the burden of proving that the defendant's act or omission "caused the loss for which the plaintiff seeks to recover damages." Subsection (e) caps the award with a formula based on market prices after the corrective disclosure.

The expert therefore works with dated prices. The inputs are the price the plaintiff paid or received, the date on which the information correcting the misstatement was disseminated to the market, and the daily closing prices for the 90 days that followed. Each of those inputs is a point the other side can contest.

What does the PSLRA say about loss causation?

In any private action under the Exchange Act, the plaintiff has the burden of proving that the act or omission alleged to violate the Act caused the loss for which the plaintiff seeks damages.

The full text of 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(b)(4) reads: "In any private action arising under this chapter, the plaintiff shall have the burden of proving that the act or omission of the defendant alleged to violate this chapter caused the loss for which the plaintiff seeks to recover damages."

The provision sits in subsection (b), which also sets the pleading rules for these cases. Under (b)(1), the complaint "shall specify each statement alleged to have been misleading" and "the reason or reasons why the statement is misleading"; if an allegation is made on information and belief, the complaint "shall state with particularity all facts on which that belief is formed." Under (b)(2), it must state facts "giving rise to a strong inference that the defendant acted with the required state of mind."

Loss causation is a separate element from the misstatement and from the defendant's state of mind. A complaint can identify a false statement and plead scienter and still fail if it does not connect the statement to the loss.

What did the Supreme Court decide in Dura Pharmaceuticals v. Broudo?

That an inflated purchase price does not by itself constitute or proximately cause the economic loss a plaintiff must prove. Justice Breyer wrote for a unanimous Court, which reversed the Ninth Circuit on April 19, 2005.

The plaintiffs bought Dura stock on the public market between April 15, 1997, and February 24, 1998. They alleged that Dura made false statements about its drug profits and about the expected FDA approval of a new asthmatic spray device. On February 24, 1998, Dura announced lower-than-expected earnings, and the next day the share price fell to about $21 from about $39. In November 1998, Dura announced that the FDA would not approve the spray device. The next day the price fell temporarily, and within a week it had almost fully recovered.

The District Court dismissed the claim about the spray device for failure to allege loss causation adequately. The Ninth Circuit reversed, holding that loss causation is shown if "the price on the date of purchase was inflated because of the misrepresentation."

The Supreme Court heard argument on January 12, 2005, and decided the case on April 19, 2005; it is reported at 544 U.S. 336. The Court held the complaint legally insufficient, reversed the judgment of the Ninth Circuit and remanded the case.

Which elements must a securities fraud plaintiff prove?

Six, as the Court listed them in Dura: a material misrepresentation or omission, scienter, a connection with the purchase or sale of a security, reliance, economic loss and loss causation.

The private action in Dura arose under section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, 15 U.S.C. 78j(b), and under SEC Rule 10b-5, which forbids, among other things, the making of any "untrue statement of a material fact" or the omission of any material fact.

In Dura the Court listed the elements of a private action under these provisions: a material misrepresentation or omission; scienter, a wrongful state of mind; a connection with the purchase or sale of a security; reliance, which in fraud-on-the-market cases is often called transaction causation; economic loss; and loss causation, a causal connection between the misrepresentation and the loss.

The last two elements are where the damages expert works. The opinion cites the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, 109 Stat. 737, and its loss causation provision, 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(b)(4).

Why is an inflated purchase price not a loss by itself?

At the moment of purchase the plaintiff holds a share of equivalent value and has suffered no loss. A later lower price may have other causes, so the plaintiff must connect the loss to the misrepresentation.

The Court wrote that "an inflated purchase price will not itself constitute or proximately cause the relevant economic loss." At the moment of the transaction "the plaintiff has suffered no loss," because the inflated price is offset by ownership of a share of equivalent value. "[T]he logical link between the inflated share purchase price and any later economic loss is not invariably strong."

Two situations break the link. "[I]f, say, the purchaser sells the shares quickly before the relevant truth begins to leak out, the misrepresentation will not have led to any loss." And a lower price at a later sale may result not from the earlier misrepresentation but from "changed economic circumstances, changed investor expectations, new industry-specific or firm-specific facts, conditions, or other events." Given "the tangle of factors affecting price," logic alone permits only the conclusion that the purchase price may play a role in a later loss.

The Court added: "To 'touch upon' a loss is not to cause a loss, and it is the latter that the law requires." The securities statutes make private actions available "not to provide investors with broad insurance against market losses," but to protect investors against losses that misrepresentations actually cause. The alternative causes the Court named are the ones a damages model has to answer.

What must the complaint say about loss and causation after Dura?

It must give the defendant some indication of the loss and of the causal connection the plaintiff has in mind. The Dura complaint alleged only an inflated purchase price, and the Court held that insufficient.

The Court applied Rule 8(a)(2), which requires only "a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief." The statement still has to give the defendant "fair notice of what the plaintiff's claim is and the grounds upon which it rests." The only loss the Dura complaint alleged was the inflated purchase price, and the complaint did not otherwise identify the loss or the causal connection.

In the Court's view, a plaintiff who has suffered an economic loss should not find it burdensome "to provide a defendant with some indication of the loss and the causal connection that the plaintiff has in mind." The opinion cited the 1995 conference report's criticism of "abusive" practices and quoted Blue Chip Stamps on a plaintiff "with a largely groundless claim to simply take up the time of a number of other people."

The Court limited its ruling: "We need not, and do not, consider other proximate cause or loss-related questions."

How does the 90-day lookback cap damages?

Damages may not exceed the difference between the plaintiff's purchase or sale price and the mean trading price of the security during the 90 days that begin when the corrective information is disseminated to the market.

15 U.S.C. 78u-4(e)(1) provides that "the award of damages to the plaintiff shall not exceed the difference between the purchase or sale price paid or received, as appropriate, by the plaintiff for the subject security and the mean trading price of that security during the 90-day period beginning on the date on which the information correcting the misstatement or omission that is the basis for the action is disseminated to the market."

An example of a calculation under the (e)(1) formula, with figures chosen only for illustration: for a share bought at $50, with a mean trading price of $38 over the 90 days, damages may not exceed the difference between the two, $12 per share. If the price recovers during the 90 days, the mean rises and the cap falls.

The cap is a ceiling. The plaintiff still has to prove under (b)(4) how much of the loss the misstatement caused, and the expert's number can be lower than the cap.

The start date is the dissemination of the information "correcting the misstatement or omission that is the basis for the action." Which announcement corrected which statement is a question of fact.

How is the mean trading price calculated?

As an average of the daily trading price of the security, determined as of the close of the market each day during the 90-day period. The statute fixes the closing price as the daily input.

Under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(e)(3), the mean trading price "shall be an average of the daily trading price of that security, determined as of the close of the market each day during the 90-day period referred to in paragraph (1)."

The statute takes the closing price of each day of the period, so intraday prices do not enter the average.

What if the investor sold before the 90 days ran out?

Then the cap uses the mean trading price from the day after the corrective disclosure until the day the plaintiff sold or repurchased the security, under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(e)(2).

Subsection (e)(2) provides that "if the plaintiff sells or repurchases the subject security prior to the expiration of the 90-day period described in paragraph (1), the plaintiff's damages shall not exceed the difference between the purchase or sale price paid or received, as appropriate, by the plaintiff for the security and the mean trading price of the security during the period beginning immediately after dissemination of information correcting the misstatement or omission and ending on the date on which the plaintiff sells or repurchases the security."

In a class action, investors who held through the full 90 days share one mean, and each investor who sold earlier has a mean for his or her own window, so the cap depends on each investor's trading record.

When can the damages expert get discovery in a PSLRA case?

Usually after the motion to dismiss is decided. All discovery is stayed while a motion to dismiss is pending, unless the court finds that particularized discovery is necessary to preserve evidence or to prevent undue prejudice.

Under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(b)(3)(B), "all discovery and other proceedings shall be stayed during the pendency of any motion to dismiss, unless the court finds upon the motion of any party that particularized discovery is necessary to preserve evidence or to prevent undue prejudice to that party."

Until the stay ends, what the expert can use is public: the company's filings and announcements and the market prices. The complaint has to identify the statements, the reasons they were misleading and the facts behind the inference of scienter under (b)(1) and (b)(2), and it has to plead a loss caused by the misstatement.

Why does the loss estimate matter when the court picks the lead plaintiff?

Because the PSLRA presumes that the lead plaintiff should be the person or group with the largest financial interest in the relief sought by the class, if that movant also satisfies Rule 23.

Under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(a)(3)(B)(iii)(I), the presumption favors the person or group of persons that has either filed the complaint or made a motion in response to the notice, "has the largest financial interest in the relief sought by the class," and otherwise satisfies Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

The timetable is short. Under (a)(3)(A)(i), the plaintiff publishes notice "Not later than 20 days after the date on which the complaint is filed," and class members may move to serve as lead plaintiff not later than 60 days after the notice is published. Under (a)(3)(B)(i), the court considers the motions and appoints the lead plaintiff not later than 90 days after the notice. The financial interest of each movant has to be shown inside that window.

How is a damages award split among defendants?

By percentage of responsibility, unless the jury specifically finds that a defendant knowingly committed a violation. Only a knowing violator is jointly and severally liable under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(f).

Under 15 U.S.C. 78u-4(f), a covered person "shall be liable for damages jointly and severally only if the trier of fact specifically determines that such covered person knowingly committed a violation of the securities laws." Other covered persons are liable only for the portion of the judgment that corresponds to their percentage of responsibility, "measured as a percentage of the total fault of all persons who caused or contributed to the loss."

Subsection (d) adds a question for the jury. On a defendant's request, the court submits a written interrogatory on that defendant's state of mind at the time of the alleged violation.

Under (f)(3), the court instructs the jury to answer special interrogatories on each covered person's responsibility, or makes findings itself if there is no jury. In determining the percentage, the trier of fact considers the nature of each person's conduct and "the nature and extent of the causal relationship between the conduct of each such person" and the plaintiff's damages.

How does IAE find a securities damages expert?

In the IAE request, choose the case type Commercial dispute and name the calculation, for example loss causation and damages under section 78u-4(e). Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.

The commercial litigation expert witness page lists the specialties IAE searches for in commercial disputes: damages, forensic accounting, business valuation, solvency, securities, insurance claims handling and industry specialists. Among the points a court checks, the page names Rule 702 in its form since December 1, 2023, the six parts of a Rule 26(a)(2)(B) report and the protection of counsel communications under Rule 26(b)(4)(C).

The request form asks for the field of expertise, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel for the conflict check. In the short description, name the security, the class period, the dates of the alleged corrective disclosures and the stage of the case. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years.

Candidate names and CVs come after the search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option, and the expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case