Examinations
Seller failed to disclose defects in the house: what can the buyer prove with an expert?
A buyer who finds a defect after closing has a claim against the seller only for what the seller knew and did not disclose. In Florida, Johnson v. Davis (1985) requires a seller to disclose known facts that materially affect the value of the home and are not readily observable. The buyer also has to link the damage to a condition that existed before the sale, and that link comes from an expert.

What does a buyer have to prove when the seller did not disclose a defect?
That the seller knew of a defect materially affecting the value of the home, that the buyer could not readily observe it and did not know of it, that the seller kept silent, and what the defect costs.
In Florida the elements come from Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625, decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on October 31, 1985. The court held that "where the seller of a home knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer, the seller is under a duty to disclose them to the buyer."
Each element is a separate question of fact. Knowledge concerns the seller. Materiality and visibility concern the defect itself: what it was, how far it reached, whether a buyer walking through the house could see it. Damages concern money, the cost of the repair. The defect, its extent and the cost of repair are questions for an engineer or another qualified expert.
New Jersey applies a similar rule. In Rogers v. Conti, an unpublished decision of May 5, 2023, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court of New Jersey cited Strawn v. Canuso for the rule that sellers must disclose "on-site defective conditions" that are "known to them and unknown and not readily observable by the buyer."
When is a seller required to disclose a defect?
When the seller knows of it, it materially affects the value of the home, and the buyer neither knows of it nor can readily observe it. Florida also requires a written flood disclosure on residential sales.
In Johnson the defect was a leaking roof. The Davises agreed to buy the Johnsons' three-year-old home for $310,000 and paid a $5,000 deposit. Before paying a further $26,000, Mrs. Davis saw buckling plaster and stains on the ceiling. Mr. Johnson told her that a window problem had been corrected and that the stains came from wallpaper glue and from beams that had been moved. After the Johnsons moved out, heavy rain brought water into the house through the window frame, the ceiling, the light fixtures and the kitchen.
The court rejected caveat emptor as a defense: "One should not be able to stand behind the impervious shield of caveat emptor and take advantage of another's ignorance." It approved the return of the $26,000 deposit on the ground of fraudulent misrepresentation and of the $5,000 deposit with interest on the ground of fraudulent concealment, because the Johnsons knew of earlier roof problems and did not disclose them. Chief Justice Boyd dissented and wrote that a duty to disclose should come from the legislature.
The Florida Legislature later added a written disclosure for one condition. Section 689.302 of the Florida Statutes, created by chapter 2024-215, requires a seller of residential real property to complete and provide a flood disclosure "at or before the time the sales contract is executed." As amended by chapter 2025-166, the form asks whether the seller has knowledge of flooding that damaged the property during the seller's ownership, whether the seller has filed a claim with an insurance provider relating to flood damage on the property, including a claim with the National Flood Insurance Program, and whether the seller has received assistance for flood damage to the property, including assistance from the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
Does the buyer have to prove that the seller actually knew?
In Florida, yes. In Jensen v. Bailey (2011) the Second District Court of Appeal held that the buyer must prove the seller's actual knowledge and reversed a judgment based on what the sellers should have known.
The Jensens sold their St. Petersburg house to Gene and Cynthia Bailey under a June 2005 contract, and the sale closed in July 2005. On the disclosure statement the Jensens checked "NO" to the question whether any improvements had been built in violation of building codes or without necessary permits. Three remodeling jobs, in the master bath, the kitchen and a bedroom where French doors were installed, had been done without permits. Experts testified at trial that the work was done improperly, did not meet the codes in effect when it was done and would need reconstruction to meet newer, stricter codes.
The trial court found no evidence that the Jensens actually knew about the missing permits or the improper work, held them liable because they should have known and entered judgment for $33,370 in damages plus $13,787.31 in prejudgment interest. The Second District reversed on November 30, 2011, in case No. 2D10-939: "the buyer must prove the seller's actual knowledge of an undisclosed material defect." It quoted an earlier decision, Slitor v. Elias: "Johnson does not convert a seller of a house into a guarantor of the condition of the house."
In Jensen the experts proved the defects and the need for reconstruction, and the buyer still lost on knowledge. In the other cases discussed here, knowledge came from documents and statements: in Johnson, from the seller's own explanations of the stains; in Rogers, from the insurance claim the seller's son filed after an earlier leak.
What if the buyer could have found the defect before closing?
Then the seller may have had no duty. In Nelson v. Wiggs (1997) a Florida appeals court found no duty to disclose seasonal flooding that a buyer could learn of through diligent attention, including public records.
After Hurricane Andrew destroyed their home in 1992, the Nelsons bought Helen Wiggs' house in the East Everglades, an area that floods seasonally. The house stood on raised ground and had never flooded. The Nelsons bought and closed during the dry season. The trial court found that they never asked about flooding, that Ms. Wiggs made no statements about it, that they obtained no inspections and that they did not talk to the neighbors.
The Third District Court of Appeal affirmed the denial of rescission on August 13, 1997, in Nelson v. Wiggs, 699 So. 2d 258. The majority read "not readily observable" in Johnson as wider than what a buyer can see: the question was whether the facts were known only to the seller or could be learned through diligent attention. Dade County's flood regulations and public records made the information available to any buyer, and Mr. Nelson, an air conditioning, heating and refrigeration contractor, had reviewed the original permits and plans at the county building department before closing. Judge Sorondo dissented, writing that in the dry season the flooding was not readily observable.
An expert who examines the house after closing therefore answers two questions about visibility. Could the defect be seen in the condition the house was in when the buyer looked at it? Was it recorded anywhere the buyer could check, such as permits? The listing photographs and the buyer's inspection report record what the house looked like before closing.
Why did the home inspection not find the defect?
A home inspection is a limited visual examination of readily accessible systems. Florida's statute defines it that way, so a defect hidden behind a finished wall or a repaired surface lies outside what the inspector examines.
Section 468.8311(4) of the Florida Statutes defines home inspection services as "a limited visual examination of the following readily accessible installed systems and components of a home: the structure, electrical system, HVAC system, roof covering, plumbing system, interior components, exterior components, and site conditions that affect the structure, for the purposes of providing a written professional opinion of the condition of the home."
In Rogers v. Conti the buyers' professional inspection disclosed no issues, and three days after closing they found mold behind some walls. The Appellate Division decided the appeal on two other points: what the sellers knew and whether the mold could be tied to an earlier leak.
An expert retained for litigation is not limited to a visual walk-through. Under section 90.702 of the Florida Statutes the testimony has to rest on sufficient facts or data and on reliable principles and methods reliably applied to the facts of the case, so the expert examines what the opinion depends on, including concealed areas when the opinion concerns them.
What does an expert establish in a nondisclosure case?
What the defect is, how far it extends, whether it could be seen before closing, whether an earlier repair covered it, when the damage began relative to the sale, and what the repair costs.
In Johnson the dispute about the roof was a dispute between experts. The sellers' roofers said that repairs costing less than $1,000 would make the roof watertight. The buyers' roofers said that the roof was inherently defective and needed a new roof costing about $15,000.
The expert's tasks follow the elements of the claim. For materiality, the expert describes the defect and its extent and prices the repair. For visibility, the expert compares the condition found with what the listing photographs and the inspection report record. For timing, the expert relates the damage and any earlier repair to the closing date. For code questions, as in Jensen, the expert compares the work with the code in force when it was done.
Section 90.702 of the Florida Statutes lets a qualified expert give an opinion if "(1) The testimony is based upon sufficient facts or data; (2) The testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and (3) The witness has applied the principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case." An opinion about when a leak began rests on the materials the expert examined. An expert who never saw the damaged area before it was repaired has fewer facts to work from.
Why do these claims fail on causation?
The buyer must tie the damage to the condition the seller knew about. In Rogers v. Conti the buyers' expert report was ruled a net opinion, and they could not prove that the mold came from an earlier leak.
The house in Rogers was in an age-restricted community and was sold "as is" by an elderly owner who had moved out at least a year earlier; her son handled the sale as attorney-in-fact. About a year before the listing, a leak arose in the hallway bathroom. The son found it within 24 hours and filed an insurance claim, and the repair included new sheetrock and an antimicrobial treatment of the area. The disclosure form did not mention the leak, and the sellers stated that they were unaware of "any leaks, backups, or other problems relating to any of the plumbing systems and fixtures."
Three days after closing, the buyers found mold behind some walls and asked to rescind. The sellers stopped the deed from being recorded, returned the proceeds to escrow and offered to make the buyers whole, including the broker's commission. The buyers insisted on completing the sale and sued for breach of contract, civil conspiracy, intentional common law fraud, consumer fraud and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing.
The trial court in Mercer County held that the buyers' expert report was a net opinion and granted summary judgment. On appeal the buyers did not challenge the net opinion ruling and argued that lay testimony was enough. The Appellate Division affirmed in docket No. A-0739-21. It quoted Reynolds v. Gonzalez, "A mere possibility of . . . causation is not enough," and concluded that "plaintiffs cannot prove the alleged mold condition was caused by the water leak." It also noted that the disclosure statement "asked questions about the present condition of the property, not any prior occurrences."
What happens if the buyer repairs the damage before the seller's side sees it?
The physical evidence can be lost. In Rogers the buyers refused to let the sellers inspect the alleged mold and completely renovated the area, eliminating the evidence that either side's expert could have examined.
The Appellate Division recorded these facts in its account of the case. After the renovation, the condition behind the walls could no longer be examined, and the question whether the mold came from the leak repaired a year before the sale had to be answered without it.
An engineer's opinion about the source of water or mold depends on the materials that were wet or damaged. When those materials are removed and discarded, the expert works from photographs and descriptions, and the other side can argue that the opinion does not rest on sufficient facts or data under the state's expert testimony rule, such as section 90.702 in Florida.
Before demolition, the record that an expert later relies on is made at the house: photographs and video of the opened areas with measurements, samples of affected materials with notes of where each was taken, moisture readings, and written notice to the seller with an opportunity to inspect. In Rogers the sellers had asked to see the mold and were refused.
Does an as-is clause defeat a claim for a hidden defect?
In Rogers the court read as is to mean the property in its present state and still examined the duty to disclose known defects. The buyers lost on causation: they could not tie the mold to the leak.
The Appellate Division quoted an earlier New Jersey decision for the meaning of the term: under an "as is" sale the buyer takes the property "in its present state or condition." It then applied the rule that sellers must disclose known defects that the buyer cannot readily observe. The trial judge had called the suggestion that the sellers knew of a mold condition "pure speculation."
In Johnson the Supreme Court of Florida wrote that "The doctrine of caveat emptor does not exempt a seller from responsibility for the statements and representations" a seller makes to induce a buyer to act, where those statements amount to fraud. The court tied the return of the larger deposit to Mr. Johnson's statement that there were no roof problems, made after the first deposit was paid.
How far an as-is clause reaches depends on the wording of the contract and on the case law of the state, and that is a question for the buyer's attorney. The clause does not change the physical facts in the expert's report: what the defect was, when it began and whether it could be seen.
What does IAE do when a buyer finds a hidden defect after closing?
IAE prepares an expert report on the questions agreed with the client about water intrusion, defects and code, scope and cost, or a review of the opposing construction expert's report, in up to 5 business days.
On the construction defects page the expert answers three groups of questions. Water intrusion: under ASTM E2128-26 the expert first checks whether the water came from the roof, plumbing or condensation, then tests the wall. Defects and code: the expert documents cracks, deflection, settlement and failed finishes and compares the work with the plans, the specifications and the code edition in force at permit. Scope and cost: the expert lists each damaged element, measures quantities on site or from photos and prices the repair line by line, with defect repair kept apart from upgrades.
The expert works from the documents, the photos and the site inspection record, and IAE confirms the questions with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush for tight deadlines.
Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and states in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the other evidence. Neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), Supreme Court of Florida, No. 65330 (Syfert)
- Jensen v. Bailey, No. 2D10-939 (Fla. 2d DCA Nov. 30, 2011) (FindLaw Caselaw)
- Nelson v. Wiggs, 699 So. 2d 258 (Fla. 3d DCA Aug. 13, 1997), No. 96-3328 (Hall Approved)
- Rogers v. Conti, No. A-0739-21 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. May 5, 2023), unpublished (New Jersey Courts)
- Florida Statutes, section 468.8311, Definitions (home inspection services), 2025 edition (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes, section 90.702, Testimony by experts, 2024 edition (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes, section 689.302, flood disclosure in residential real property sales, as amended by chapter 2025-166 (Florida Senate)
Read also
All articles
A neighbor's grading or paving sends water onto my property: who is responsible, and how does an expert prove the drainage change?
Whether a neighbor answers for water that runs onto your land depends on the surface water rule of the state. California asks whether each owner
Roof leaking after a roof replacement: how does an expert prove that the roofer's work caused it?
A roof that leaks a few weeks after it was replaced does not prove by itself that the roofer did bad work. The owner has to show where the water
Construction next door damaged my house: how does an expert tie the cracks to the neighboring work?
When excavation, pile driving or underpinning next door is followed by new cracks, tilting floors or sticking doors, the owner has to prove thatExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

