Expert witnesses
Toy injury expert witness: small parts, age grading and ASTM F963 in a children's product case
A toy injury case usually turns on a short list of questions: was the toy meant for a child under three, did any part fit inside the federal small parts cylinder, did the toy meet ASTM F963, and was it tested and certified before sale. Each question belongs to a different expert. A 2021 federal ruling in a choking death case also marks what those experts may not tell the jury.

Which experts does a toy injury case need?
Usually an engineer who tests the toy and its parts, a human factors specialist on the age the toy was meant for, a product safety compliance specialist on testing and certification, and a physician on how the injury happened.
Schmidt v. International Playthings LLC, No. 1:19-cv-00933, in the US District Court for the District of New Mexico, arose from the death of a 2-year-old. According to the autopsy described in the record, the child choked on the toy pacifier from a Calico Critters Yellow Labrador Twins set, a flocked toy with a baby bottle and a pacifier. The plaintiffs' experts included Dennis Brickman, P.E., an engineer, and Joseph Mohorovic, C.P.S.M., a product safety specialist. The record also contains an age determination report by Carol Pollack-Nelson, Ph.D., a human factors psychologist whose CV lists earlier work at the Consumer Product Safety Commission on age determination.
That line-up follows the questions. The engineer tests whether the toy or a part that comes off it fits in the small parts cylinder, before and after the use and abuse tests. The human factors specialist addresses the age the toy is intended for, using the factors the regulation lists. The compliance specialist reads the test reports, the children's product certificate and the labels. The medical expert connects the part to the injury.
Defense counsel needs the same disciplines, together with a specialist who can explain the production tests and the age grading the company performed. Under Rule 702 each opinion must fall within the knowledge, skill, experience, training or education of the witness who gives it, so one generalist rarely covers all four questions.
What does the federal small parts rule require?
Toys intended for children under 3 must not be, or release under use and abuse testing, a part that fits entirely within the small parts cylinder of 16 CFR 1501.4 in any orientation without being compressed.
16 CFR 1500.18(a)(9) bans any toy or other article intended for use by children under 3 years of age that presents a choking, aspiration or ingestion hazard because of small parts, as determined under part 1501, and was introduced into interstate commerce after January 1, 1980. Under 16 CFR 1501.2(a), part 1501 applies to toys and other articles intended for use by children under 3 years (36 months) of age, and the examples include stuffed, plush and flocked animals and other figures, teethers, crib gyms, blocks and dolls.
16 CFR 1501.4(a) provides that no such article, and no part separated from it during testing, may be small enough to fit entirely within a cylinder with the dimensions shown in Figure 1 of the section, and that the English dimensions shall be used. Under section 1501.4(b), the article is placed in the cylinder without being compressed. If it fits entirely in any orientation, it fails. If it does not, it is put through the use and abuse tests of 16 CFR 1500.51 and 1500.52, excluding the bite tests, and each piece that comes off, other than paper, fabric, yarn, fuzz, elastic and string, goes into the cylinder in turn.
The engineer's report records every step: the cylinder used and its calibration, the orientation of each attempt, the use and abuse tests applied, the forces and the photographs. An opposing reviewer looks first at whether the use and abuse tests were run on new exemplars or on the incident toy, and at whether the pieces tested were the ones that came off in the test or ones found later.
How is the age a toy is intended for decided?
Under 16 CFR 1501.2(b) by the manufacturer's stated intent if reasonable, the advertising, promotion and marketing, and whether the article is commonly recognized as intended for children under 3. A 3+ label alone did not settle it in Schmidt.
16 CFR 1501.2(b) lists the factors: the manufacturer's stated intent, such as on a label, if it is a reasonable one; the advertising, promotion and marketing of the article; and whether the article is commonly recognized as being intended for children under 3. Toys intended solely for children three and older fall outside part 1501.
In Schmidt, the age determination report by Dr. Pollack-Nelson concluded that the product is clearly marketed and advertised for ages 3 years or older and is not marketed to children younger than 3 years. The court, in its memorandum opinion of April 29, 2021, by Judge James O. Browning, read the regulation differently for flocked toys. It found section 1501.2 ambiguous because its plain language can be interpreted reasonably in two ways, considered the legislative history and concluded that flocked toys are categorically intended for children under three. On that reading, the 3+ label on the package did not take the toy outside part 1501.
For other toys the factors still decide. An age grading opinion looks at the label, the box art and the photographs of children on it, the size and weight of the toy, the play pattern it invites, where retailers shelved it and how it was advertised. The expert shows the material behind each factor so that the court and the jury can weigh it.
Which mandatory toy safety standard applies?
ASTM F963. Congress made F963-07 a consumer product safety standard 180 days after August 14, 2008 under 15 U.S.C. 2056b, and 16 CFR 1250.2 now requires toys to meet the applicable provisions of ASTM F963-23.
Under 15 U.S.C. 2056b(a), beginning 180 days after August 14, 2008, the provisions of ASTM International Standard F963-07 became consumer product safety standards issued by the Commission under section 2058, with listed exclusions such as section 4.2 and Annex 4 and provisions that restate existing mandatory bans or FDA rules.
The Commission updates the standard by rule. 16 CFR 1250.1 establishes a consumer product safety standard for toys. Under 16 CFR 1250.2(a), each toy must comply with all applicable provisions of ASTM F963-23, incorporated by reference. Section 1250.2(b) excludes section 4.2 and Annex 5, and any provision of F963 that restates or incorporates an existing mandatory standard or ban or an FDA regulation or statute. The rule was published at 89 FR 3351 on January 18, 2024 and amended at 90 FR 57855 on December 12, 2025.
The edition matters. A toy made years before the incident was subject to the edition in force when it was made or imported, and an expert who tests it against the current edition must explain why. The reviewer of an F963 opinion checks the edition, each section relied on and whether the test followed that section's procedure.
Was the toy tested and certified before it was sold?
Under 15 U.S.C. 2063(a)(2) a children's product subject to a children's product safety rule must be tested by an accredited third party conformity assessment body, and the manufacturer issues a certificate based on that testing.
15 U.S.C. 2063(a)(2) requires the manufacturer of a children's product subject to a children's product safety rule, and a private labeler where the product bears a private label, to have the product tested by a third party conformity assessment body accredited under paragraph (3) before importing it or distributing it in commerce. The manufacturer submits the product or samples identical in all material respects. Based on that testing, it issues a certificate that the product complies, either separately for each applicable rule or in one certificate listing each rule.
Under section 2063(f)(2)(A), a third party conformity assessment body is one that is not owned, managed or controlled by the manufacturer or private labeler of the product it assesses, with an exception in subparagraph (D) for firewalled bodies the Commission accredits by order.
In discovery the compliance expert asks for the certificate, the laboratory reports behind it, the samples tested and the production lot they came from. Points such an opinion can raise: a certificate that names a rule the laboratory did not test, a test on a prototype that differs from the production toy, or a report dated after the toy was sold.
Can an expert testify that the toy violated federal regulations?
Not about what the regulation means. In Schmidt the court barred the plaintiffs' experts from interpreting the federal regulatory scheme, holding that it is for the court to decide what the law is, but allowed factual testimony for negligence.
In Schmidt, Epoch Everlasting Play, LLC, the US distributor of the toy, moved under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 to strike or limit the testimony of Brickman and Mohorovic. It argued that both experts testified that the toy was banned by federal regulations because the miniature figurines are flocked toy animals, and that whether the toy was banned would be a judicial determination. The plaintiffs answered that expert testimony on regulations is allowed where the regulatory scheme is complex and beyond the common understanding of a typical juror, and that the experts had tested the toy and concluded it was intended for use by children under three.
The court granted the motion in part and denied it in part. The experts may not testify about their interpretations of the federal regulatory scheme banning hazardous toys, because it is for the Court and not for the jury to decide what the law is. Because the court concluded as a matter of law that the toy was intended for use by children under three, the experts also could not testify to the three section 1501.2(b) factors. They may testify to facts regarding the complaint's other counts, including negligence. The court denied Epoch Everlasting's motion for partial summary judgment on the negligence per se count.
The working rule for a report follows from that ruling. The expert states facts and test results: which part came off, at what force, whether it fit the cylinder, what the label and marketing said. The meaning of the regulation, and whether the facts amount to a violation, is argued by counsel to the court.
What evidence should be preserved after a toy injury?
The toy and every part of it, the packaging and inserts, the receipt and listing, exemplars from the same lot, and the medical and autopsy records. Testing of the incident toy waits for a protocol agreed with the other side.
Items to keep and, where needed, request:
The incident toy is evidence that can be changed by testing. Use and abuse tests on it can break off new pieces and make it impossible to show which piece came off in the incident. The engineer runs those tests on exemplars from the same production lot and examines the incident toy without force, under a protocol agreed with the other side, with photographs and video of each step.
- The toy, every detached part and any part recovered during medical treatment.
- The box, inserts, warnings and instructions, and the online listing or store photograph if the toy was bought there.
- The receipt, the order confirmation and the lot or date code on the toy or box.
- Unopened exemplars of the same toy, preferably from the same lot.
- Medical records, emergency response records and, in a death case, the autopsy report.
- From the manufacturer, in discovery: the children's product certificate, laboratory reports, age grading documents and complaint records.
How does IAE find an expert for a toy injury case?
In the request choose Product liability and name the toy, its maker, the part involved and the injury. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, rates and prior testimony.
The product liability expert witness page covers defects in vehicles, medical devices, consumer products and industrial equipment and lists 8 specialties, among them product design, failure analysis, human factors, and warnings and instructions. IAE chooses the specialty by the question the firm needs answered, so the request should say whether the dispute is about small parts testing, age grading, warnings or certification.
The request form asks for the field, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel.
Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm; case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- 16 CFR 1500.18, Banned toys and other banned articles intended for use by children (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 16 CFR 1501.2, Scope (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 16 CFR 1501.4, Size requirements and test procedure (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 15 U.S.C. 2056b, Mandatory toy safety standards (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 16 CFR 1250.1, Scope (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 16 CFR 1250.2, Requirements for toy safety (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 15 U.S.C. 2063, Product certification and labeling (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Schmidt v. International Playthings LLC, No. 1:19-cv-00933 JB/SCY (D.N.M. Apr. 29, 2021), memorandum opinion and order, Justia
- Schmidt v. International Playthings LLC, Document 172, exhibit (age determination report), Justia
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
State of the art defense in product liability: what must the manufacturer's expert prove about the technology available when the product was made?
The state of the art defense asks what a manufacturer could have known and built on the day the product left its hands, not on the day of the injury
Machine guarding expert witness: what does the engineer examine when a worker is hurt by an unguarded machine?
When a worker is hurt at the point of operation of a machine, the case usually turns on the guard: how the machine was designed to keep hands out
General vs specific causation: which experts does a drug or toxic exposure case need?
In a drug or toxic exposure case the plaintiff proves causation twice. General causation asks whether the substance can cause this kind of injuryExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

