Examinations

Can a voice recording prove a verbal agreement in court, and what does the recording have to show?

In California all contracts may be oral, except those that a statute requires to be in writing: that is Civil Code section 1622. A recording is evidence of what each side said, and the other party's own words are not hearsay under Rule 801(d)(2). Statutes of frauds ask for a writing signed by the party to be charged, and a court admits a recording only on evidence that it is what the offering party claims.

A small recorder sits between two coffee cups as two people talk, seen only from behind

Is a verbal agreement binding without a written contract?

Yes, unless a statute requires a writing for that kind of contract. The lists are set by state law: for example California Civil Code section 1624, New York General Obligations Law section 5-701 and UCC section 2-201.

California Civil Code section 1622 reads: "All contracts may be oral, except such as are specially required by statute to be in writing." The exceptions are collected in section 1624(a). A contract on that list is invalid unless it, "or some note or memorandum thereof", is in writing and subscribed by the party to be charged or that party's agent.

The California list has seven items. Among them are an agreement that by its terms is not to be performed within a year of its making, a special promise to answer for the debt of another, a lease for more than one year, a sale of real property, an agreement that is not to be performed during the lifetime of the promisor and a lender's commitment to loan more than $100,000 that is not primarily for personal, family or household purposes.

New York General Obligations Law section 5-701(a) uses the word void: "Every agreement, promise or undertaking is void, unless it or some note or memorandum thereof be in writing, and subscribed by the party to be charged therewith", if it falls into a listed class, the first of which is an agreement that "By its terms is not to be performed within one year from the making thereof."

For goods the rule is in section 2-201 of the Uniform Commercial Code. A contract for the sale of goods for the price of $500 or more is not enforceable unless there is "some writing sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made between the parties" that is "signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought". An agreement that is on none of these lists, such as a sale of a used item for less than $500 or a job to be finished within the year, can be proved without a writing, and a recording can be the main evidence of it.

Does a recording count as the writing that a statute of frauds requires?

The statutes speak of a writing subscribed or signed by the party to be charged. California and New York name a recorded telephone call as sufficient evidence only for qualified financial contracts between parties that are not natural persons.

California Civil Code section 1624(b) lifts the one-year rule for a "qualified financial contract": foreign exchange, commodity, swap, option and similar transactions in which "each party thereto is other than a natural person". Such a contract "is not invalid for lack of a note, memorandum, or other writing" if there is sufficient evidence that it was made. Paragraph (b)(3)(A) counts as such evidence "an electronic communication (including, without limitation, the recording of a telephone call" or the written text produced by computer retrieval).

New York has the same exception in General Obligations Law section 5-701(b). There is sufficient evidence of a qualified financial contract if there is evidence of electronic communication, "including, without limitation, the recording of a telephone call", that is admissible under the laws of the state and "sufficient to indicate that in such communication a contract was made". Both statutes name the recorded call in one exception, for qualified financial contracts between parties other than natural persons. The general clause of each statute speaks of a writing.

Federal law treats sound as a possible signature, but only on a record. Under 15 U.S.C. 7006(5) an electronic signature is "an electronic sound, symbol, or process, attached to or logically associated with a contract or other record" and "executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the record." Under section 7001(a) a signature, contract or record may not be denied legal effect "solely because it is in electronic form". Section 7001(c)(6), in the subsection on consumer disclosures, adds that "An oral communication or a recording of an oral communication shall not qualify as an electronic record" for that subsection, "except as otherwise provided under applicable law".

The UCC has its own exception for admissions. Under section 2-201(3)(b) a contract without a writing is enforceable if the party against whom enforcement is sought "admits in his pleading, testimony or otherwise in court that a contract for sale was made", and then only for the quantity admitted. The text speaks of an admission in court. A statement on a recording made before the lawsuit was not made in court; it is evidence, and the rules below decide whether the court hears it.

Is the other party's recorded statement hearsay?

Not when it is offered against that party. Rule 801(d)(2) takes an opposing party's own statement, and statements of its authorized persons, agents and employees, out of the definition of hearsay.

Rule 801(c) of the Federal Rules of Evidence defines hearsay as a statement that the declarant does not make while testifying at the current trial or hearing and that a party offers "to prove the truth of the matter asserted in the statement." The committee note to subdivision (c) takes the words of the agreement itself out of that definition: "If the significance of an offered statement lies solely in the fact that it was made, no issue is raised as to the truth of anything asserted, and the statement is not hearsay." The note excludes the whole category of "verbal acts", in which "the statement itself affects the legal rights of the parties". A recorded offer and its acceptance are played for the fact that they were spoken. A recorded remark about a past fact, such as "you already paid me half", is played for its truth, and for that kind of statement the next rule decides.

Rule 801(d)(2) takes a statement out of the definition of hearsay when the speaker is the opposing party. A statement offered against an opposing party is not hearsay if it "was made by the party in an individual or representative capacity", was made by a person whom the party authorized to make a statement on the subject, or "was made by the party's agent or employee on a matter within the scope of that relationship and while it existed". The committee note explains that such statements come in as "the result of the adversary system rather than satisfaction of the conditions of the hearsay rule".

Two limits follow from the text. For an agent or employee the statement "must be considered but does not by itself establish" the authority or the relationship, so a recorded manager who says he may approve the deal does not prove by those words alone that he had the power to bind the company. And paragraph (d)(2) covers statements offered against the party who made them; it does not cover the words of the party who made the recording and now offers it.

How is a recording of the agreement authenticated?

The party offering it must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the recording is what the party claims it is. Rule 901(b) lists the usual ways: a witness with knowledge, voice identification and evidence about the call.

The standard is Rule 901(a): "the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is." The examples in Rule 901(b) are illustrations, not a complete list. A participant in the conversation is a witness with knowledge under example (1) and can testify that the recording is the conversation it is claimed to be.

For a telephone conversation, example (6) accepts evidence that a call was made to the number assigned at the time to a particular person, if "circumstances, including self-identification, show that the person answering was the one called". For a business, the call must have been made to the business and must have "related to business reasonably transacted over the telephone."

Example (9) covers the device: "Evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result." Example (4) lets the content speak: the distinctive characteristics of the item, "taken together with all the circumstances". Under that example the amount, the date and a detail known only to the two parties, heard in the conversation itself, are evidence of what the recording is.

Who can say whose voice is on the recording?

Any witness who has heard the voice under circumstances that connect it with the speaker, under Rule 901(b)(5). An acoustic comparison by an examiner is expert testimony and has to meet Rule 702.

Rule 901(b)(5) admits "An opinion identifying a person's voice", whether heard firsthand or through a recording, based on hearing the voice at any time under circumstances that connect it with the alleged speaker. The committee note states that "aural voice identification is not a subject of expert testimony" and that "the requisite familiarity may be acquired either before or after the particular speaking".

The party who made the recording can give that identification. The dispute starts when the other party denies the voice or says that the speaker was someone else in the household or the office. Then the question becomes technical: whether the speech on the recording and known samples of the person's speech came from one speaker.

An examiner who answers it testifies under Rule 702. The party offering the examiner must show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods and applies them reliably to the recording. Each retained expert provides a report prepared and signed by the witness with all opinions, their basis and the facts or data considered, under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Does the court need the original file?

To prove the content of a recording, Rule 1002 requires the original unless the rules or a federal statute provide otherwise. SWGDE defines the original recording as the first manifestation of the sound in a recoverable stored format.

The committee note to Rule 1002 limits the rule to cases where the contents are what is being proved. A party who offers the recording to prove the words of the agreement is proving its content.

For forensic work the definition comes from the SWGDE Best Practices for Digital Audio Authentication, document 15-a-001, version 1.3 of September 20, 2018. The original recording is "the first manifestation of sound in a recoverable stored format." Section 3.1 adds: "Transcoded or re-encoded versions of an original recording are not original recordings." A verified duplicate of the original media may be used only where the original is not obtainable or no longer exists.

The same section explains the cost of a converted copy. A decoded copy may still contain useful information, but file format analysis regarding the original format becomes impossible. The file as the phone or recorder first saved it, kept on the device, is therefore the item to preserve.

Can the other side demand the rest of the conversation?

Yes. Under Rule 106, when a party introduces part of a statement, the adverse party may require the introduction, at that time, of any other part that in fairness ought to be considered with it.

Since the 2023 amendment the rule states that the adverse party may do so "over a hearsay objection." The committee note explains that when fairness requires completion, "that completing statement is admissible over a hearsay objection": a party who creates a misleading impression with an excerpt may not block the correction on hearsay grounds.

The amendment also extended the rule to "cover all statements, including oral statements that have not been recorded." If the recording starts after the parties had already discussed a condition of the deal, the other side may offer admissible evidence of that earlier talk. A clip that holds only the sentence "fine, I agree" invites that response.

Does it matter how the recording was made?

Yes. Under 18 U.S.C. 2511(2)(d) a private person may record a communication to which he or she is a party, unless the purpose is a criminal or tortious act. State laws add their own conditions.

The federal text says that it "shall not be unlawful under this chapter for a person not acting under color of law to intercept" a communication "where such person is a party to the communication" or where one of the parties has given prior consent, "unless such communication is intercepted for the purpose of committing any criminal or tortious act".

The words "under this chapter" confine that permission to the federal wiretap chapter. State statutes on recording apply in addition, and which state's law governs a call between two states is a legal question for the party's attorney. An examiner does not answer it; the examiner's questions concern the file.

Can you get a recording that the other side made of you?

In a federal civil case, yes. Under Rule 26(b)(3)(C) any party or other person may obtain his or her own previous statement about the action, including a recording, on request and without a special showing.

Rule 26(b)(3)(C) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure defines a previous statement as a written statement that the person has signed or otherwise adopted or approved, or a contemporaneous stenographic, mechanical, electrical or other recording, or a transcription of it, "that recites substantially verbatim the person's oral statement". If the request is refused, the person may move for a court order.

Rule 34(a)(1)(A) is the general tool. Its list of documents and electronically stored information names "sound recordings", and a party may ask to inspect, copy, test or sample them. The request must describe each item "with reasonable particularity", and the response is due within 30 days after service. Electronically stored information is produced in the form in which it is "ordinarily maintained" or in a "reasonably usable" form, so a request can ask for the audio file itself instead of a transcript.

What does a forensic examiner check when the recording is disputed?

Whether the file is consistent with an original recording, whether it has discontinuities or alterations, whose voice it carries and what was said. SWGDE requires several analyses, and no single one may be relied on alone.

Under section 3.1 of the SWGDE document the examiner first asks whether the submitted exhibit is the purported original, and requests it if it is not. The examiner also asks for the make, model and serial number of the recording device and whether the equipment is available for test recordings.

The listed analyses begin with critical listening to the unprocessed recording. File format and file structure are then examined, and the structure "should be compared with exemplar recordings" made from the submitted recorder or other test recordings; if the original device is not available, the document tells the examiner to use a device of the same make and model. Waveform and spectrographic analyses look at specific places in the audio. Section 4.1 says of all of them: "nor shall any single analysis be relied upon solely."

Section 5.2 lists three possible results: the recording is consistent with an original, the examination is inconclusive, or the recording is inconsistent with an original. Discontinuities and alterations are reported with an explanation of their cause. Under section 5.2.1 conclusions should not be stated in absolutes.

For a recorded agreement the questions to the examiner can also cover three items: a comparison of the disputed voice with known recordings of the person, whether the recording runs without stops across the passage that contains the terms, and a transcript that marks speakers, time codes and unintelligible passages.

What does IAE do when a recorded agreement is disputed?

IAE prepares an expert report on the client's questions about the recording: the speaker, the integrity of the file and the words spoken, or a review of the opposing audio examiner's report, in up to 5 business days.

The audio and voice page of IAE lists three kinds of work. In a voice comparison the examiner compares the questioned voice with known recordings by pitch, formants, speech rate and pronunciation and states the limits of the comparison in the report. In an authenticity check the examiner looks for breaks in background noise, metadata that does not match the device, signs of re-recording and gaps in the chain of copies. The transcript marks speakers, time codes and unintelligible passages against the original file.

The client sends the recording or the case materials and describes the task: what to check or examine. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and a 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm: whether the agreement is enforceable and whether the recording was lawfully made are questions for the client's attorney. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member