Expert report review

How should a fire origin and cause report use witness statements?

A fire investigator works with two kinds of data: what the scene shows and what people saw before, during and after the fire. The 2017 edition of NFPA 921, as quoted by the Tenth Circuit in 2024, treats witness observations as data for finding the origin and requires the investigator to collect data that can support or refute them. A reviewer of the opposing report checks which accounts the investigator used, which he set aside, and why.

An investigator speaks with a neighbor on a porch at dusk, a burned house soft behind them

Are witness observations data for finding a fire's origin?

Yes. The 2017 edition of NFPA 921, as quoted by the Tenth Circuit in United States v. Hernandez, calls observations by witnesses data that can be used in determining the origin, before, during and after the fire.

United States v. Hernandez, No. 23-7024, was decided by the Tenth Circuit on June 7, 2024, in an opinion by Judge Bacharach. A fire destroyed a mobile home in eastern Oklahoma and killed the defendant's mother and grandmother. The mother told emergency responders that he "had doused her with gasoline and lit her on fire." He was convicted of two counts of second-degree murder and one count of arson in Indian Country, and the court of appeals affirmed.

The fire investigator at trial, Gene Wheat, testified that the 2017 edition of NFPA 921, Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations, was in effect when the fire occurred, and the court quoted that edition. Section 18.3.3.15 says that "Observations by witnesses are data that can be used in the context of determining the origin" and that "Such witnesses can provide knowledge of conditions prior to, during, and after the fire event." Section 18.2.5 says that "Witness statements, the investigator's expertise, and firefighting procedures play important roles in the determination of the fire origin." Section 19.3.1.6 says information "should be sought from persons having knowledge (such as occupants)."

The guide also accepts that one observation can carry an origin opinion. As quoted by the court, sections 18.2.1.2 and 19.2.1 say that in some instances a single item, such as a credible eyewitness to the ignition, may be the basis for a determination of origin. Section 18.8.3 adds that where the cause is very difficult or impossible to determine, "a witness may be found who saw the fire in its incipient stage and can provide the investigator with an area of fire origin." In each passage the witness is a source of data, and the next question is how the investigator tested it.

Does the investigator have to test what witnesses say?

Yes. NFPA 921 section 18.3.3.15, quoted in Hernandez, requires the investigator to conduct as thorough an investigation as possible to collect data that can support or refute the witness statements.

The full requirement, as the Tenth Circuit quoted it, is to "conduct as thorough an investigation as possible to collect data that can support or refute the witness statements." A report that repeats an account and builds on it, with no physical data compared against it, has skipped that step.

In Hernandez the court looked at what Wheat did besides interviewing people. He examined fire patterns, fire dynamics, fire damage, fuel systems and electrical systems; the court wrote that "Mr. Wheat examined all these sources of information except arc mapping." The court also referred to the accelerant found on the mother's body. On that record it held that the district court "didn't exceed its discretion by allowing Mr. Wheat to rely in part on the witness statements."

A reviewer applies the same test to the opposing report. For each account the investigator used, the review lists what the witness reported (a time, a place where smoke or flame was first seen, a sound, an action), the physical data in the report that support or contradict it, and the page where the investigator made the comparison. Accounts that the report uses without any comparison are listed as untested, together with the opinion that depends on them.

Is starting with witness interviews a sign of expectation bias?

Not by itself. In Hernandez the Tenth Circuit held that NFPA 921 does not prohibit investigators from starting with witness statements, and that the trial court could reject criticism of that sequence.

Citing NFPA 921 sections 4.3.8 and 4.3.9, the court described expectation bias as a fire investigator's arrival at a conclusion before considering all the relevant data. Wheat "began investigating by interviewing witnesses, including the victims and Mr. Hernandez himself." Hernandez told him that he had been "cleaning with some gasoline and smoking a cigarette and it had ignited." On appeal Hernandez faulted Wheat "for starting with witness statements, arguing that he strayed from the scientific method."

The defense expert testified that investigators risk bias when they start with witnesses and that Wheat had "relied totally" on Hernandez's criminal history; later the same expert said only that Wheat "may" have harbored bias. The court answered that "the guidelines themselves don't prohibit investigators from starting with witness statements" and held that "the district court could reasonably reject criticism of Mr. Wheat's decision to start with witness interviews." It described the 2017 guide as providing "flexible recommendations, not strict requirements" and reviewed the ruling for abuse of discretion.

The court also noted that Hernandez did not explain how the claimed deviations from NFPA 921 could have affected Wheat's opinions. A review that says only "the investigator started with interviews" gives a judge nothing to act on. A review that names the account, the physical data the investigator skipped and the opinion that changes without that account gives the court a specific gap to measure.

What if the opposing expert discounts the eyewitnesses?

In Travelers v. Volunteers of America the court admitted an expert who discounted eyewitnesses and left his reasons for the jury. The 2023 note to Rule 702 makes the sufficiency of the basis a question for the judge.

Travelers Casualty Insurance Co. of America v. Volunteers of America of Kentucky, Inc., No. 5:10-301-KKC, was decided by Judge Karen K. Caldwell of the Eastern District of Kentucky on August 21, 2012. Travelers, suing on behalf of Johnny Palumbo II, doing business as Brookview Apartments, relied on Captain Ward, who "spoke to numerous witnesses and concluded that the fire started in the trashcan next to Sellers's bed." The defense expert, Robert Russell, "did not interview any witnesses or perform a first person inspection of the site," and relied in part on statements that the defendant Dena Sellers gave to the plaintiff's experts that she saw the fire above the patio door when she woke up.

Travelers argued that Russell's opinion was contradicted by witness statements and did not adequately explain Lieutenant Hayden's testimony. The court found that "Russell discounts much of the eyewitness testimony for various reasons" and held that the argument "goes to the weight of the testimony, not its admissibility." It wrote: "It is up to the jury to evaluate his reasons for discounting such testimony," and called the objections "excellent material for cross-examination" that were insufficient to exclude him.

Travelers was decided before the 2023 amendment to Rule 702. The committee note to that amendment says that many courts had held that the sufficiency of an expert's basis and the application of the method are questions of weight, and calls those rulings an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a). A reviewer in a current case therefore frames discounted eyewitness accounts as a question under Rule 702(b): with those accounts set aside, does the opinion still rest on sufficient facts or data, and has the proponent shown that it is more likely than not?

Can an expert rely on interviews someone else conducted?

Yes, under Rule 703, if experts in the field would reasonably rely on that kind of information. In Travelers the court admitted experts who used another investigator's interviews, eyewitness accounts and depositions without interviewing the witnesses themselves.

Rule 703 of the Federal Rules of Evidence lets an expert base an opinion on facts or data in the case that the expert "has been made aware of or personally observed." If experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on those kinds of facts or data, they need not be admissible for the opinion to be admitted. Inadmissible facts or data may be disclosed to the jury by the proponent only if their probative value in helping the jury evaluate the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect.

In Travelers, the plaintiff's expert James Thomas spoke to Captain Ward, obtained his report and then spoke to Sellers, who "said that she did not remember if she smoked in bed that night." The defense argued that Thomas "simply adopted Ward's opinion." The court answered that "An expert is free to rely on another expert's opinion in formulating their own opinion." A third expert, Frederick Franklin, worked from "eyewitness accounts, depositions and the data collected by Captain Ward and James Thomas"; the defense pointed out that he "did not conduct witness interviews or speak with any LFD firefighters." The court denied the motion to exclude all three.

For each account, the review traces the path it took to the opposing expert: who heard it first, when, whether it was recorded or summarized, and how many people passed it on before it reached the report. An account that reached the expert as a summary of someone else's summary is listed with that path, so the court can see how far the opinion sits from the witness's own words.

How can an interview taint a fire investigation?

In American Modern Home v. Thomas, a federal court excluded an insurer's investigator who sat through an interview in which the fire marshal used lies and threats to seek a confession and said the fire was not accidental.

American Modern Home Insurance Co. v. Thomas, No. 4:16 CV 215 CDP, was decided by Judge Catherine D. Perry of the Eastern District of Missouri on September 17, 2018. The fire occurred in Aaron and Aimee Thomas's apartment on January 3, 2014, and the insurer contended that it was intentionally set by or at the direction of the Thomases. Dan Bruno, the Fire Marshal of the West County EMS and Fire Protection District, and John Nordyke, the cause and origin expert hired by American Modern, jointly conducted a recorded interview of Aimee Thomas on January 23.

The court found that "Nordyke acquiesced in Dan Bruno's admitted method of lying and making threats to Aimee to coerce a confession," and that "Bruno repeatedly stated in Nordyke's presence during the January 23 interview that they knew the fire was not accidental." It wrote that it also appeared that Nordyke "engaged in conduct that would lead to bias in and/or taint of the investigation" in direct contravention of NFPA 921.

The court's first ground for exclusion was method. Nordyke "admittedly conducted no tests to rule out any hypotheses other than his poured-ignitable-liquid hypothesis," while NFPA 921 requires that hypotheses of fire cause and origin be carefully examined against empirical data. "For several reasons, including those set out above," the court found his opinion "unreliable in the circumstances of this case" and excluded his report and testimony on cause and origin. Bruno's own origin and cause opinion was admitted, because he "systematically evaluated the evidence against these hypotheses."

Can a fire investigator say what a person's behavior meant?

Not as an expert, according to American Modern Home v. Thomas. The fire marshal could describe what he saw a person do, but could not give opinions on emotional responses, motivations or veracity.

The court wrote: "I agree with the Thomases, however, that Bruno is not qualified to render an opinion on the meaning of a person's emotional responses, motivations, or veracity." It allowed that "Bruno can testify as a lay witness to factual descriptions of a person's conduct," and did not permit testimony on how he believed any person felt based on that conduct. The court relied on Daubert's statement that knowledge under Rule 702 "connotes more than subjective belief or unsupported speculation."

If the opposing report describes how an insured or a witness behaved during an interview, as calm, nervous, evasive or tearful, the reviewer marks each such passage and checks whether the report uses it to support the cause opinion. Under the reasoning in American Modern, the investigator may report the observed conduct as a fact; the inference about what the conduct meant is outside fire investigation.

Is there a standard method for weighing eyewitness information?

Not in NFPA 921, according to a research needs form of OSAC's Fire and Explosion Investigation Subcommittee, which says the guide outlines no specific process for using eyewitness information.

The Organization of Scientific Area Committees for Forensic Science (OSAC) publishes research needs identified by its subcommittees on the NIST website. The form titled "Witness Information for Fire & Explosion Scenes," version 2 dated January 13, 2020 and approved on March 10, 2021, states: "There is no specific process outlined within NFPA 921 for use of eyewitness information."

The form says that "Training is common on how to conduct such interviews, but uncommon on how to accurately use the information," and that "Research is required to develop protocols or techniques for collecting, extracting, and analyzing data." It adds that "Specific guidance is needed to understand how witnesses react to and perceive fire events" and that "Guidance is also needed on how witnesses interpret and report their observations."

Without a prescribed process in the guide, the opposing report has to state its own: which accounts were collected, by whom and when, how they were weighed against each other, and which physical data tested them. Rule 702(c) and (d) ask whether the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods reliably applied. A report that is silent on how it used witness information gives the reviewer an unexplained step to point to.

Which interview records can the other side obtain?

The facts or data the expert considered must be disclosed with the report. Statements taken in anticipation of litigation are work product, but any person can obtain his or her own previous statement on request.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires a retained expert's report to contain "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming" the opinions. Interview notes, recordings and transcripts that the expert considered fall under that requirement. Rule 26(b)(4)(C)(ii) also makes discoverable the communications in which the party's attorney identified facts or data that the expert considered.

Statements that an insurer's investigator or counsel took before the lawsuit may be work product. Under Rule 26(b)(3)(A), documents prepared in anticipation of litigation by or for a party or its representative, including its insurer or agent, are ordinarily not discoverable, but they may be discovered if the requesting party shows substantial need and cannot obtain their substantial equivalent by other means without undue hardship. If the court orders discovery, Rule 26(b)(3)(B) protects the mental impressions, conclusions, opinions and legal theories of the attorney or other representative.

Rule 26(b)(3)(C) sets a separate rule for a witness's own words. Any party or other person may, on request and without the required showing, obtain the person's own previous statement about the action or its subject matter. A previous statement is a written statement the person signed or otherwise adopted or approved, or a contemporaneous recording or its transcription that recites the oral statement substantially verbatim. The reviewer compares the summary in the opposing report with the recording or signed statement, line by line.

What does the review say about witness evidence in the opposing report?

It lists every account the investigator used or set aside, with its source, date and form of record, the physical data that support or refute it, and the opinion that changes if the account falls away.

The review starts with a table of people: occupants, neighbors, passers-by, the first-arriving firefighters, the insured. For each, it records who interviewed the person, on what date, whether the interview was recorded, and whether the opposing expert spoke to the person or read someone else's notes. The disputes in Hernandez, Travelers and American Modern concerned those facts: an investigator who started with interviews, an expert who never interviewed anyone, and what was said in the room during an interview.

The second table lists observations: the time a person noticed smoke or flame, where it was seen, what the doors and windows looked like, what was moved or opened before and during firefighting. Each observation is matched to the fire patterns, the timeline and the artifacts in the report. Where two accounts conflict, the review records whether the investigator explained the choice by physical data or chose without explanation.

The last part ties each gap to an opinion. If the origin rests on one eyewitness, the review says so and lists the burn patterns the investigator did not compare. If the investigator set an eyewitness aside, the review states the reasons given and whether data support them. The client's attorney decides how to use the review: in a deposition outline, a Rule 702 motion or a rebuttal report.

What does IAE do when the opposing fire report rests on witness accounts?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing investigator's report or an origin and cause expert report on the client's questions for US cases. The investigator works from the scene record, photos, removed artifacts and witness accounts.

The IAE fire origin and cause page describes the review for subrogation, product liability, arson defense and coverage disputes. The reviewer lists each hypothesis the opposing investigator considered and checks what data excluded the others, checks which NFPA 921 edition was applied, and traces each artifact to its examination: whether wiring, appliances and debris were photographed in place before removal, logged and examined at a joint lab exam with all interested parties notified.

A review answers six questions about the opposing report: whether the method fits the object and the questions and was followed at every stage; whether all objects, materials and questions were examined; whether the conclusions follow from the examination; whether the expert's education, specialty and experience match the subject; whether the report meets the form and procedure of the jurisdiction; and whether the report can be relied on.

The client sends the opposing report with its exhibits, the interview recordings and statements in the file, and states whether the fire scene still exists. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed document is issued within up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member