Expert report review · Fire origin and cause

Rebuttal fire expert: review of the opposing fire report

For subrogation, product liability, arson defense and coverage disputes in US courts: the review lists each hypothesis the opposing investigator considered, checks what data excluded the others and which NFPA 921 edition was applied, and traces every artifact to its examination. The signed review is issued within up to 5 business days once the format and cost are confirmed.

  • Review of the opposing report
  • Expert report on your questions
  • Up to 5 business days
up to 5

business days, rush 48 hours

What does the reviewer check?

Each point cites the rule, the guide or the court decision behind it and the page of the opposing report.

Request a quote

Untested ignition theory

In Columbia Grain (D. Idaho 2015) a smolder theory rested on education, training and experience, with no testing or studies. Under the 2000 note to Rule 702 an experience-based expert must explain how that experience leads to the conclusion.

  • Rule 702
  • Testing

Borrowed exclusion

In State v. Ordonez-Lima (N.J. Super. 2024) the court rejected reliance on another investigator's exclusion of the electrical cause, reached without metallurgical analysis, and barred the opinion that the fire was incendiary.

  • Electrical cause
  • Lab exam

Expectation bias

In United States v. Hernandez (10th Cir. 2024) the court read NFPA 921 to require reviewing all the data before reaching conclusions. An OSAC form approved in 2016 says bias caused by irrelevant data can lead to errors in origin and cause.

  • NFPA 921
  • Bias

How is a review used in court?

703bases of opinion

Review without a scene visit

An expert may rely on facts made known to him if experts in the field would reasonably rely on them. In Travelers v. Volunteers of America (E.D. Ky. 2012) a defense expert retained two years after the fire worked from photographs and was admitted.

705cross-examination

Data behind the opinion

An expert may state an opinion without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, but may be required to disclose them on cross-examination. The review lists the photographs, artifacts and witness accounts each opinion depends on.

26(b)(4)(D)consulting review

Review that stays with counsel

Facts known and opinions held by an expert retained for trial preparation who will not testify are ordinarily not discoverable, except under Rule 35(b) or on a showing of exceptional circumstances.

37(c)(1)undisclosed evidence

No new testing in rebuttal

Information not disclosed as Rule 26(a) or (e) requires cannot be used unless the failure was substantially justified or harmless. In Columbia Grain (D. Idaho 2015) smolder testing added in a rebuttal report was excluded.

Say in the request whether the scene and the removed artifacts still exist.

How do I order?

Three steps from request to document

Deadlines are confirmed at order and depend on the volume of materials. For cases with tight deadlines there is a 48‑hour rush.

Step 1

Request and materials

Send the report or the case materials and describe the task: what to check or examine. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day.

Step 2

Selection and confirmation

IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from the registry within one business day. You approve the candidate and the CV before work starts.

Step 3

Execution and delivery

The specialist prepares the document; the draft is checked for facts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days; the expert is verified in the registry by QR code.

Questions about reviewing a fire report

Review without a scene visit, new tests in rebuttal, deviations from NFPA 921.

Still have questions?

Write to the Association's Secretariat

Contact us

Yes, if fire experts would reasonably rely on the data, as Rule 703 requires. In Travelers v. Volunteers of America (E.D. Ky. Aug. 21, 2012) the defense expert was retained two years after the fire, did not interview witnesses or inspect the site, relied on the other side's photographs and was admitted; the objections went to weight.

Courts have refused it when the testing supports the expert's own earlier theory. In Columbia Grain (D. Idaho Oct. 30, 2015) the court held that rebuttal testimony cannot be used to advance new arguments or new evidence, that Rule 26(e) supplementation does not cover failures of omission, and excluded the smolder testing under Rule 37(c)(1).

No. In United States v. Hernandez (10th Cir. June 7, 2024) the court treated the 2017 edition of NFPA 921 as flexible recommendations and asked whether the deviations affected the admitted opinions. In Travelers the court quoted the guide: deviations are not necessarily wrong or inferior but need to be justified.

No. A review, an examination and a specialist opinion are independent expert opinions. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; legal questions are for your attorney.

Members of the public IAE registry with the relevant specialization: professors, doctors of science, holders of international certifications. The candidate and the CV are agreed with you before work starts.

Enter the Member ID from the document on the status check page or scan the QR code: the category, specialization, attestation date and record status open.

Request

Request a review

Review of the opposing reportDeposition questionsNot sure

Hello, I am Sergei Tkach, Executive Director of IAE. Describe the case and the questions for the expert: within one business day we will reply with the right document, an available expert, the time frame and the fee.

Case details

How did you hear about IAE?

We reply within 1 business day.

Other report reviews

Choose the field to see what the reviewer checks and how a review is used in court.

Request a quote

Construction expert report review

An engineer reviews the opposing construction expert's report: causation, testing, the data considered and the repair estimate.

  • Rebuttal
  • Rule 702

Handwriting report review

A reviewer tests the opposing handwriting examiner's report against the examiner's file, the originals and ANSI/ASB Standard 070.

  • Review
  • Rebuttal

Questioned document report review

A reviewer tests the opposing examiner's report on alterations, ink and dating against ASB 011, ASB 035 and the SWGDOC ink standard.

  • Review
  • Ink

Medical report review

A physician in the relevant specialty checks the opposing medical expert report against the chart and Rule 702.

  • Rebuttal
  • Rule 702

Custody evaluation review

A psychologist reviews the opposing evaluation against the court order, the court rules for evaluators and the 2022 APA guidelines.

  • Work product review
  • APA 2022

Accident reconstruction report review

An engineer checks the opposing reconstruction: inputs, reaction times, calculations, tests and simulations, and opinions that go past engineering.

  • Rebuttal
  • Rule 702

Forensic linguistics report review

A linguist reviews the opposing linguist's report: the texts considered, the method, and whether the conclusions go beyond the data.

  • Rebuttal
  • Rule 702

Opposing survey review

A land surveyor reviews the opposing survey: record research, monuments, measurements and the reasoning behind the line.

  • Rebuttal
  • Rule 702

Impression and toolmark report review

An examiner reviews the opposing footwear, tire or toolmark report: documentation, class and subclass marks, test marks, verification and the wording of the conclusion.

  • Toolmarks
  • ULTR

Product defect report review

A specialist checks the opposing defect report: what was inspected and tested, which causes were ruled out and how the goods were valued.

  • Review
  • Rebuttal

Forensic accounting review

An accountant rebuilds the opposing damages or solvency report from the record and writes a rebuttal within the court's schedule.

  • Rebuttal
  • Damages model

Valuation rebuttal and appraisal review

An appraiser recomputes the opposing valuation step by step and prepares a rebuttal report or questions for cross-examination.

  • Rebuttal
  • USPAP review

Digital forensics report review

A reviewer checks whether another examiner could repeat the opposing work on messages, files or device data from the report alone.

  • Hash values
  • Rebuttal

Forensic audio report review

An examiner reviews the opposing audio report: the file and its hash, the tests run, the voice exemplars and the wording of the conclusion.

  • Rebuttal
  • SWGDE

Patent expert report review

A technical expert checks the opposing report on infringement or validity against the claim construction, the contentions and the evidence cited for each element.

  • Claim construction
  • Rebuttal