EB-1A

Original contributions of major significance in EB-1A: how do you prove them?

Criterion (v) of the EB-1A regulation asks for original contributions of major significance in the field. USCIS decides two things: whether the work is original and whether it has major significance. Under the USCIS Policy Manual, funding, a patent or a publication does not necessarily prove the second on its own. In Amin v. Mayorkas the Fifth Circuit upheld USCIS, which found that a letter about another company's use of the applicant's design did not show widespread replication.

A researcher at a window-lit desk marks citing papers in a printed report next to a folder with a patent and a license

What does 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v) require?

Evidence of the person's original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic or business-related contributions of major significance in the field. USCIS first decides whether the contributions are original and then whether they have major significance to the field.

The EB-1A regulation lists ten types of evidence in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). Unless the person has a one-time achievement, a major internationally recognized award, the petition must meet "at least three of the following." The fifth type reads: "Evidence of the alien's original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field" (8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v)). Business is on the list, so a founder's product is judged under the same words as a laboratory result.

The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 splits the criterion into two determinations. "First, USCIS determines whether the person has made original contributions in the field. Second, USCIS determines whether the original contributions are of major significance to the field." In the Policy Manual's words, the analysis "focuses on whether the person's original work constitutes major, significant contributions to the field."

Both determinations belong to step one of the two-step review. At that step the officer weighs quality only "to the extent the criterion has qualitative requirements," and criterion (v) has one in its text: major significance. The two steps are covered in the guide The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough.

Why is an original result not enough?

Originality and significance are separate findings. Under the Policy Manual, funding, a patent or a publication does not necessarily establish major significance on its own. The petitioner has to prove what others in the field did with the work.

The Policy Manual says that evidence that the person's work "was funded, patented, or published" may point to originality but "will not necessarily establish, on its own, that the work is of major significance to the field." The AAO put the rule in one sentence in a non-precedent decision of August 2, 2023: "Contributions do not necessarily have major significance just because they are original." The petitioner, the AAO wrote, must submit evidence of their importance, "such as their generation of widespread commentary, notice from others working in the field, or citations" (In Re: 27572282).

In another non-precedent decision, of July 24, 2023, the AAO dismissed the appeal of a postdoctoral researcher in molecular biology (In Re: 27437533). The AAO listed what a petitioner may prove: that the contributions "have been widely implemented throughout the field, have remarkably impacted or influenced the field, or have otherwise risen to a level of major significance."

In Kazarian v. USCIS the petitioner filed letters in which physics professors attested to his contributions in the field. The AAO found that his contributions were not major. In 2010 the Ninth Circuit called that analysis "consistent with the relevant regulatory language" and left the finding in place.

When do citations prove major significance?

When other evidence explains them. The Policy Manual pairs citations high relative to others' work in the field with widespread commentary on the work's importance. In July 2023 the AAO held that counts and percentile rankings alone fall short.

The Policy Manual gives one example for research: "published research that has provoked widespread commentary on its importance from others working in the field, and documentation that it has been highly cited relative to others' work in that field, may be probative of the significance of the person's contributions to the field of endeavor." The sentence joins two kinds of evidence: what other authors wrote about the work and how often they cited it.

In the July 2023 decision the petitioner filed percentile rankings that placed two of his articles in the top 10% and two others in the top 20%. Four articles had appeared in journals ranked high by impact factor. The AAO wrote that "Highly cited publications alone are not sufficient under 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(v) absent evidence that they were of 'major significance,'" because a citation ranking "does not provide sufficient context to determine the impact or importance of a given researcher's work in the field." In the AAO's reading, an impact factor describes the journal as a whole.

The AAO then described a better comparison: "A more appropriate analysis, for example, would be to compare the Petitioner's citations for individual articles to other similarly, highly cited articles that the field views as having been of major significance, as well as factoring in other corroborating evidence." The AAO added: "While the record indicates that other researchers have built upon the Petitioner's research, the evidence does not establish that the field views the Petitioner's work as a contribution of major significance."

The August 2023 decision came out the other way. Since 2017, the 34 published articles of a physician who researches rare diseases had drawn more than 120 citations from researchers. A German professor of nuclear medicine and a doctor at a hospital described clinical uses of her findings. The professor wrote that her treatment protocols for rare infections improve the chances of successful treatment and that radiologists use her PET-scan findings in the differential diagnosis of periaortitis. The AAO found the criterion met. More than 40,000 downloads of her articles, the AAO accepted, were not probative.

Which evidence proves that others in the field used the work?

Records made outside the applicant's own employer: licenses, sales by another company, adoption by another lab or firm, and letters from those users. In Amin v. Mayorkas, evidence of impact inside his own companies did not meet the criterion.

The Fifth Circuit decided Amin v. Mayorkas on January 24, 2022 (No. 21-20212). Amin, a chemical engineer, named three accomplishments: work on the world's first portable sulfur-forming units, the first modularized well pads in the Alberta Oil Sands and a "walking" drill rig. For the sulfur units he filed a letter by a former Enersul executive, who wrote that the innovation answered an industry need and earned Amin a promotion. USCIS gave that letter little weight "because it did not explain the design's impact beyond Enersul."

For the well pads, a project manager at the China National Offshore Oil Corporation wrote that the company "utilized Mr. Amin's design and adopted similar strategies to build modules in China" but had so far not reached the same efficiency. The court called this letter "Amin's best evidence because it addresses the impact of his work beyond his own employer." USCIS still found it insufficient because "it did not show widespread replication of the design," and the court upheld that finding: "Amin cites no case where an invention that was not adopted by even one industry actor met this standard." On the drill rig, "Amin's evidence does not show that anyone beyond his company used (or even attempted to use) the rig design."

On patents the Policy Manual says that evidence "that the person developed a patented technology that has attracted significant attention or commercialization may establish the significance of the person's original contribution to the field." A pending patent needs more: "If a patent remains pending, USCIS generally requires additional supporting evidence to document the originality of the person's contribution, such as detailed reference letters."

Documents that record use of the work outside the applicant's employer include the following.

  • A license agreement or royalty statement names the licensee, the licensed patent or software and the date.
  • Sales or deployment figures for a product built on the work come from the company that sells it and state the period they cover.
  • A standard, product manual or clinical protocol of another organization names the method or cites the patent.
  • A citing paper describes how its authors used or extended the result, and the passage is marked in the exhibit.
  • A letter by a user outside the applicant's employer states what that organization adopted, when, at what scale and with what result.

What must a letter about the contribution say?

What the contribution is, who outside the applicant's circle used it, with what result, and how the author knows this. The Policy Manual asks for specific letters whose statements are corroborated by documents in the record.

Under criterion (v) the Policy Manual says that detailed letters by experts in the field may provide valuable context, "particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance." Such letters "should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field and should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."

The section on letters of support adds that letters "should explain in specific terms why the witnesses believe the beneficiary to be of the caliber of a person with extraordinary ability." The officer considers "the relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness." The author's tie to the applicant is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?

In the July 2023 decision the recommendation letters praised the petitioner, but "the authors do not provide specific examples of contributions that are indicative of major significance." The AAO also noted that "some letters hypothesize on the effect of the Petitioner's research at some undetermined time in the future."

The Enersul letter in Amin did not explain the design's impact beyond Enersul. A letter by a user of the work names the organization outside the applicant's employer that applied the result, the date it started, the volume and the change in cost, yield, accuracy or time, and it cites the exhibit that records the change.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter on a contribution?

For an IAE expert opinion letter, the secretariat prepares a draft from the applicant's documents, and a registry expert in the subject area checks it, makes changes and signs it. For EB-1A the expert assesses the contribution, originality and recognition against the level of the field, with the analysis set out under the regulatory criteria. The expert's CV and a declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code.

IAE is not a law firm. The letter does not guarantee approval: USCIS weighs it together with the rest of the record and decides the petition.

What happens to the contribution at the final merits step?

The officer weighs it again with the whole record and decides whether the person has sustained acclaim and stands at the very top of the field. A met criterion (v) does not decide that question.

In the August 2023 decision the AAO found criterion (v) met and still did not approve the petition. It wrote: "Because we decline to make this final merits determination in the first instance, we will remand the matter."

Among the Policy Manual's examples for the second step is a total rate of citations that is high relative to others in the field, such as a high h-index for the field. The same section says: "While a person may be stronger in one particular evidentiary area than in others, the totality of the evidence must establish that the person is extraordinary."

In Amin, USCIS found three criteria met on its second review: judging the work of others, leadership roles and a relatively high salary. Criterion (v) was not among them. At the final merits step, in the Fifth Circuit's words, "the agency credited Amin's contribution to his employers but found evidence of his impact on the field lacking."

How do you assemble the evidence for criterion (v) before filing?

Describe each contribution in one sentence, then attach proof of originality, records of use outside your employer and a letter tied to those records. A contribution supported only by letters or by citation counts is a gap.

The work takes six steps.

  • Write each contribution as one sentence that names the result, the year and the field, and give each contribution its own group of exhibits.
  • Attach the document that fixes originality and its date, such as the article, the patent or application, or the first contract.
  • Collect records of use by organizations outside your employer, such as licenses, sales by a licensee, standards or protocols that name the method, and citing papers with the passage on the use marked.
  • Compare the citations of each article with similarly highly cited articles that the field treats as major, as the AAO suggested in July 2023, instead of relying on a percentile or an impact factor alone.
  • Ask each letter author to describe use that has already happened, with dates, figures and the name of the organization, and to state how the author knows these facts.
  • Check every sentence of every letter against an exhibit, and remove statements about future effect that no document supports.

What if you are not sure the contributions meet the criterion?

The IAE profile audit answers that in writing. An IAE expert checks the record against the EB-1A criteria of 8 CFR 204.5(h). For each criterion the report says whether it is met, partly met or not met and names the documents behind the conclusion. The audit costs $350 for one category, and the report comes within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment. It gives no legal advice and no forecast of the USCIS decision.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree