RFE
An expert opinion for H-1B: how do you show the position requires a degree?
An H-1B position is a specialty occupation only if it requires a U.S. bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, and meets one of four regulatory criteria. An expert opinion carries weight when it ties each duty of this position to the knowledge of a specific degree field. USCIS may give an opinion little weight when it repeats the employer's job description or conflicts with other evidence.

What is a specialty occupation under the rule in force since January 17, 2025?
A job that requires a U.S. bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, as a minimum for entry. A general degree without further specialization does not qualify it.
The definition sits in 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(ii). A specialty occupation is "an occupation which requires theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge" and "which requires the attainment of a bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, as a minimum for entry into the occupation in the United States."
The final rule Modernizing H-1B Requirements, 89 FR 103054, published on December 18, 2024 and effective January 17, 2025, added three sentences to that definition. "A position is not a specialty occupation if attainment of a general degree, without further specialization, is sufficient to qualify for the position." "A position may allow for a range of qualifying degree fields, provided that each of those fields is directly related to the duties of the position." "Directly related means there is a logical connection between the required degree, or its equivalent, and the duties of the position."
These sentences set the questions an expert opinion has to answer. Which degree fields does the position accept? What links each of them to the duties? Would someone with a general degree be able to do the work? The quotations follow the eCFR edition of October 23, 2026.
Which of the four criteria does the position have to meet?
At least one: the degree is normally the minimum for the occupation, for parallel positions in the industry, or for this employer, or the duties are so specialized and complex that they need it.
Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(A), a position that meets the definition must also satisfy "at least one of the following criteria." Each criterion uses the same phrase, a U.S. baccalaureate or higher degree "in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent":
- (1) the degree "is normally the minimum requirement for entry into the particular occupation";
- (2) the degree "is normally required to perform job duties in parallel positions among similar organizations in the employer's industry in the United States";
- (3) "the employer, or third party if the beneficiary will be staffed to that third party, normally requires" the degree "to perform the job duties of the position";
- (4) "the specific duties of the proffered position are so specialized, complex, or unique that the knowledge required to perform them is normally associated with" the degree.
Where does an expert opinion fit?
The first criterion is usually argued from the Occupational Outlook Handbook and similar sources. The third rests on the employer's own hiring records. An expert opinion carries most weight under the second and the fourth: an expert can describe the practice of similar organizations in the industry and explain why these particular duties need the knowledge of a degree field. A good opinion names the criteria it addresses instead of asserting that the position qualifies under all of them.
What does "normally does not mean always" change for the evidence?
The petitioner does not have to show that every worker in the occupation holds the degree. A standard or regular pattern is enough, and the regulation now says so in words.
Paragraph (h)(4)(iii)(A)(5) of 8 CFR 214.2 states that "normally means conforming to a type, standard, or regular pattern" and that "Normally does not mean always." DHS explained in the preamble to the 2024 final rule that it was "clarifying that 'normally' does not mean 'always' within the criteria for a specialty occupation."
The same reading appears in Innova Solutions, Inc. v. Baran, No. 19-16849 (9th Cir. Dec. 16, 2020). USCIS had denied an H-1B petition for a computer programmer. The Ninth Circuit held that USCIS failed to consider the Handbook's statement of the "typical level of education that most workers need to enter this occupation," wrote "Normally does not mean always," and reversed and remanded.
For an expert opinion this means two things. The opinion should describe the pattern in the industry with sources: hiring requirements, job postings, professional standards. It should not claim that no one ever enters the occupation without the degree, because that is not the test and the claim is easy to disprove.
How much weight does USCIS give an expert opinion?
USCIS may treat it as an advisory opinion. It is not required to accept an opinion that conflicts with other information or is questionable, so the weight comes from the analysis.
The rule comes from Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm. 1988). Its headnote says the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities" and other sources submitted as expert testimony. Where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept it and may give it less weight.
Immigration attorney Cyrus D. Mehta reviewed H-1B denials in 2017 and listed the reasons officers gave for discounting professors' opinions: the opinion was not based on objective evidence, did not rely on a study of the employer's organization, was based largely on the job description the employer furnished, did not relate its conclusions to concrete aspects of the business and cited no research material.
Each of those reasons points to a missing step in the opinion, not to the expert's rank. A professor's title does not replace an analysis of the employer, the duties and the industry.
What should an H-1B expert opinion contain?
The duties of this position broken into tasks with their share of time, the knowledge each task requires, the degree fields that teach it, evidence of industry practice and the basis for each conclusion.
Start from the employer, not from the job title. The opinion describes the business, the team the worker joins and the products or projects involved, and it says which documents the expert reviewed: the petition letter, the organization chart, project documents, the employer's past hiring for the role.
Then the duties. Each main duty gets its share of working time, the tools and methods used and the decisions the worker makes. For each duty the opinion explains which theoretical knowledge it needs and where a specific degree program teaches it. This is the part officers look for under the fourth criterion.
Then the industry. If the opinion addresses the second criterion, it cites job postings from similar organizations, professional standards or surveys, with dates and links, and explains why those organizations are comparable in size, field and type of work.
Last, the expert. The opinion states the expert's degrees, positions and experience with hiring or training for such roles, how the expert knows the industry practice described, and that the expert has no connection to the employer or the worker. Conclusions stay within that expertise.
Can an expert also evaluate the worker's experience as equal to a degree?
Only certain evaluators count. One route is a college official with authority to grant credit for experience under such a program; another is USCIS's own determination under the three-for-one rule.
The routes are listed in 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(D). The first is "an evaluation from an official who has authority to grant college-level credit for training and/or experience in the specialty at an accredited college or university which has a program for granting such credit based on an individual's training and/or work experience." A credentials evaluation service may evaluate education, not experience.
Under paragraph (D)(5), USCIS itself may find equivalence: "three years of specialized training and/or work experience must be demonstrated for each year of college-level training the alien lacks." The worker must also show recognition of expertise, for example "recognition of expertise in the specialty occupation by at least two recognized authorities in the same specialty occupation."
A recognized authority is "a person or an organization with expertise in a particular field, special skills or knowledge in that field, and the expertise to render the type of opinion requested" (8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(ii)). The IAE article on the three-for-one rule covers this route in more detail. An opinion on the position and an evaluation of the worker answer different questions and are better kept as separate documents.
Who should write the opinion?
A person with expertise in the field of the position and in the practice of the industry, usually a professor in a related program or a senior practitioner who has hired for such roles, with no tie to the employer.
The officer asks two things about the author: does this person know the field well enough to say which knowledge the duties require, and does this person know how similar organizations hire? A professor who teaches the relevant courses answers the first; a practitioner who has led such teams answers the second. Some opinions need both kinds of experience.
Independence matters as much as rank. An expert who works for the employer, owns part of it or is related to the worker gives the officer a reason to apply Matter of Caron International and discount the opinion.
How does IAE prepare an H-1B expert opinion?
A registry expert in the field signs an opinion on letterhead with the analysis under the specialty occupation criteria. IAE prepares the draft from your documents, and the expert checks, corrects and signs it.
For an IAE expert opinion letter you send the worker's CV, a description of the position and the draft petition. The IAE Secretariat prepares the draft, the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The draft goes to the employer and the attorney before signing, and one round of factual edits is included. The expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked on the IAE status check page. The standard timeline is 10 business days, or 5 for urgent cases.
If the petition has already received a request for evidence on specialty occupation, the IAE RFE response service prepares the opinion against the officer's specific objections. The IAE article on specialty occupation RFEs lists the objections officers raise most often.
Is this legal advice?
No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice; the case strategy belongs to a licensed immigration attorney. USCIS weighs each letter with the rest of the record and decides the petition, and neither IAE nor the expert takes part in that decision.
Sources
- 8 CFR 214.2, Special requirements for admission, extension, and maintenance of status (eCFR edition of October 23, 2026)
- DHS, Modernizing H-1B Requirements, Providing Flexibility in the F-1 Program, and Program Improvements Affecting Other Nonimmigrant Workers, final rule, 89 FR 103054 (December 18, 2024)
- Innova Solutions, Inc. v. Baran, No. 19-16849 (9th Cir. December 16, 2020)
- Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm. 1988), Interim Decision 3085
- Cyrus D. Mehta, The Government's "Nasty" Treatment of Expert Opinions in Support of H-1B Visa Petitions (2017)
Read also
All guides
How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
USCIS treats an expert letter as one piece of evidence. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use such a letter as an advisory opinion
An RFE says your letters are not independent: how should you respond?
When an RFE says the letters are not independent, the officer may be questioning the authors' ties to the applicant, missing documents behind
Reviewing an expert letter before filing: what should you check?
A finished expert letter is checked before filing on four points: the author and how the author knows the work, the exhibit behind each factGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

