EB-2 NIW

NIW expert letters: what should they say for each Dhanasar prong?

USCIS decides an EB-2 national interest waiver under the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar, and the AAO weighs an expert letter under the prong it addresses. For the first prong the author describes the specific proposed endeavor, for the second the applicant's record, plan and progress, for the third facts the author can confirm. In 2024 the AAO gave little probative value to NIW letters that did not address the specific endeavor.

A woman of about 35, a public health researcher, sorts papers with colored tabs into three stacks at a desk by a window

Which letters did the AAO rely on in Matter of Dhanasar?

On the first prong the AAO relied on letters from people in senior positions in academia, government and industry. On the second it relied on detailed letters about government interest, read together with the grant records.

Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016) was decided on December 27, 2016. The applicant proposed hypersonic technology research and also planned to support teaching in STEM disciplines. What each prong requires is covered in the guide Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each.

On national importance the AAO wrote: "The petitioner submitted probative expert letters from individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry that describe the importance of hypersonic propulsion research as it relates to U.S. strategic interests." The AAO read them together with media articles on the interest of the House Committee on Armed Services; the letters and the articles "discuss efforts and advances that other countries are currently making in the area of hypersonic propulsion systems."

On the second prong: "The petitioner submitted detailed expert letters describing U.S. Government interest and investment in his research, and the record includes documentation that the petitioner played a significant role in projects funded by grants" from NASA and the Air Force Research Laboratories. In the next sentence the AAO tied the letters to those records: "Thus, the significance of the petitioner's research in his field is corroborated by evidence of peer and government interest in his research, as well as by consistent government funding of the petitioner's research projects."

For the teaching part of the endeavor the AAO found no national importance. "He submits letters favorably attesting to his teaching abilities at the university level and evidence of his participation in mentorship programs for middle school students." STEM teaching had substantial merit, but "the record does not indicate by a preponderance of the evidence that the petitioner would be engaged in activities that would impact the field of STEM education more broadly."

What can the letter say about the first prong?

It can describe the specific proposed endeavor as the petition does and explain, with sources, its potential impact beyond the applicant's employer. In 2024 the AAO gave little weight to letters about the industry or the applicant instead.

In Dhanasar the AAO wrote: "The first prong, substantial merit and national importance, focuses on the specific endeavor that the foreign national proposes to undertake." On national importance: "In determining whether the proposed endeavor has national importance, we consider its potential prospective impact."

On February 12, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of a chief executive officer whose proposed endeavor was to lead a Florida designer and manufacturer of door and trim products and custom cabinetry (In Re: 28786067). The expert opinion letter in the record cited 2021 reports on residential construction in the United States. The AAO found that "the advisory opinion is of little probative value" because it did not meaningfully address the details of the specific endeavor: "Rather, his opinion is general in nature, concluding that, because the Petitioner's proposed endeavor is to work for a small business in a high demand industry, it has national importance."

The same record held recommendation letters from former employers "praising the Petitioner's education, experience, past success, personal qualities, and the results he achieved." The AAO wrote: "However, these qualities relate to the second prong of the Dhanasar framework." In a letter, the applicant's qualities go into the part on the second prong.

On March 28, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an electromechanical engineer who works on cold plasma applications (In Re: 30044608). The AAO agreed with the Director of the Nebraska Service Center that "his specific proposed endeavor is unduly vague." The author of two letters in the record wrote that the applicant had become "a world expert" in the technology, yet "he does not describe how the Petitioner will effectuate his proposed endeavor or what the endeavor's scale will be."

The details the author gave "are not in harmony with the Petitioner's statement regarding his proposed endeavor." The AAO then wrote, citing the USCIS Policy Manual: "In determining national importance, the officer's analysis should focus on what the beneficiary will be doing rather than the specific occupational classification." The author had also called keeping the intellectual property proprietary or as trade secrets "an equally valid option" for the company, and the AAO wrote: "His letter also suggests that much of the Petitioner's work might not extend beyond his current employer based on potential intellectual property issues."

In the part on the first prong the author can state three things.

  • The author restates the proposed endeavor as the petition and the plan describe it, with the same projects, goals and place of work.
  • The author explains what the endeavor would add to the methods now used in the field.
  • The author names who outside the applicant's employer would use the results, such as hospitals, utilities, agencies or other research groups, as the record names them.

What can the letter say about the second prong?

It can describe the applicant's education and skills, record of success, plan, progress and the interest of users or funders. Each statement names a result, its date and the document that records it.

Dhanasar lists the factors for this prong, "including, but not limited to": education, skills, knowledge and record of success, a plan for future activities, progress towards the endeavor and the interest of customers, users, investors or others.

For each result the letter says what happened, when and in which exhibit, and the author adds what the result meant for the field, for example which groups adopted a method.

In the February 2024 case the AAO decision records a note by the Acting Director of the Texas Service Center: the recommendation and support letters "claim that the Petitioner has influenced the field," but "the letters do not provide specific examples."

A footnote to Dhanasar deals with the applicant's role in grants. The director of the university's research center was listed as lead principal investigator on all grants for the center's research, yet "the record establishes that the petitioner initiated or is the primary award contact on several funded grant proposals and that he is the only listed researcher on many of the grants." A letter that names the applicant's role in a grant points to the record where that role appears.

On the plan, an author with experience in the field can say whether the applicant's skills match the tasks and milestones the plan sets. On progress and interest, the author states what the documents record, such as a pilot, a contract, a grant award or a letter of intent, each with its date.

What can the letter say about the third prong?

USCIS weighs the balance itself. The author can give facts for the Dhanasar factors: how specialized the work is, who has funded it and which dates in the field make it urgent, each with a source.

Under Dhanasar, USCIS may weigh whether a job offer or a labor certification would be impractical, whether the United States would benefit from the applicant's contributions "even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available" and whether the national interest in those contributions is urgent enough to forgo the labor certification process.

For the applicant in Dhanasar the AAO used facts already in the record. He "holds three graduate degrees in fields tied to the proposed endeavor," and "research on hypersonic propulsion holds significant implications for U.S. national security and competitiveness." Government agencies, including NASA and the DOD, "have found his work on this topic to be promising and useful." The AAO concluded: "Because of his record of successful research in an area that furthers U.S. interests, we find that this petitioner offers contributions of such value that, on balance, they would benefit the United States even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available."

An author can add facts of the same kind. Whether the balance favors a waiver is the officer's finding, and the letter does not state it.

  • The author can state how many groups or companies in the United States work on the same problem, with the source of that count.
  • The author can name the agencies, companies or foundations that funded the applicant's work, with dates and the award documents.
  • The author can name a date in the field that makes the work time-sensitive, such as a program deadline or a compliance date in a regulation, with the document that sets it.

What should the letter not say?

It should not state legal conclusions, forecast results without support in the record, confirm facts the author has not checked or contradict the petition. Under Matter of Caron, such an opinion may be given less weight.

In both 2024 decisions the AAO set out the rule from Matter of Caron International: "As a matter of discretion, we may use opinion statements submitted by the Petitioner as advisory." An opinion that is "not in accord with other information in the record" may be rejected or given less weight. The AAO added: "We are ultimately responsible for making the final determination regarding an individual's eligibility for the benefit sought; the submission of expert opinion letters is not presumptive evidence of eligibility."

A sentence stating that the applicant meets a prong or qualifies for a national interest waiver states the determination USCIS keeps for itself.

Dhanasar does not ask for a forecast of success. The AAO recognized that forecasting "may present challenges to petitioners and USCIS officers" and does not require applicants to show that their endeavors are "more likely than not to ultimately succeed." What the AAO does require: "petitioners must establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that they are well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor." A figure about the future, such as jobs or revenue in the fifth year, comes from the applicant's plan, and the letter names the plan as its source.

In footnote 8 of Dhanasar the AAO wrote that it considers the quality of the evidence, "including relevance, probative value, and credibility." The applicant's role in a project, the number of users of a product or the amount of a grant is a fact the author takes from a document or knows firsthand. The letter lists the documents the author reviewed, and a fact the author has not checked stays out of the letter.

Which documents should back each statement in the letter?

Every factual statement points to an exhibit: the plan for the endeavor, published sources for figures, publication and citation records, patents, grant awards, contracts and dated letters from users or funders.

Before the author signs, the applicant or the attorney writes an exhibit number next to each factual statement in the draft, and a statement without an exhibit goes back to the author with a question.

  • On the first prong, the description of the proposed endeavor matches the petition and the business or research plan in the names of projects, goals and place of work.
  • On the first prong, a figure about the size of a problem cites a published source with its title, publisher and year, and that source is in the exhibits.
  • On the first prong, a statement that hospitals, utilities, agencies or companies would use the results points to their letters, contracts or published programs.
  • On the second prong, a statement about publications, citations or patents points to the publication list, a citation report with the database and the date of the search, or the patent with its number.
  • On the second prong, a statement about the applicant's role in a grant, about progress or about the interest of others points to a dated award letter, contract, pilot report or letter of intent.
  • On the third prong, a statement about funding history or urgency points to award documents or to the program or regulation that sets the date.

How does the author show the basis of the opinion?

The letter states the author's position, field and years of work, how the author learned of the applicant's work and which documents the author reviewed. The author's CV is attached to the letter.

The AAO described the letters in Dhanasar as written by "individuals who establish their own expertise in aerospace, describe the petitioner's research in detail and attest to his expertise in the field of hypersonic propulsion systems." In a letter the author's expertise comes first: the position held, the years in the field and the publications, patents or projects that qualify the author to judge the endeavor. The CV attached to the letter lists the same facts.

Next the letter says how the author knows the applicant's work. An author who worked with the applicant knows the role from inside the project. In the March 2024 case both letters referred to work with the applicant over the "past 18 months"; the AAO found that they did not specifically address the proposed endeavor. An author who never worked with the applicant knows the work from documents and from the field, and lists those documents with their dates. Which facts each kind of author can confirm is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?

How does IAE prepare an NIW letter by prong?

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents, with the analysis under the three Dhanasar prongs. A registry expert in the subject area checks every statement, edits the text and signs as the author.

An IAE expert opinion letter for EB-2 NIW runs up to 15 pages. The analysis follows the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar: the substantial merit and national importance of the endeavor, the applicant's position to advance it and the balance of interests in favor of waiving labor certification. The author may decline the order and leaves out any conclusion the author does not consider supported by the documents.

The author's CV and a declaration of independence are attached to the letter. In the declaration the author states that there is no personal, financial or professional tie to the applicant; the rules are set out in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002). The author's status can be checked in the public Expert Registry by QR code or by the number in the letter.

The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, and one round of factual edits is included. The author's conclusions remain the author's own.

Is an IAE letter legal advice?

No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice; case strategy requires a licensed immigration attorney. IAE does not promise that a letter will meet any prong. USCIS weighs the letter together with the other evidence and decides the petition.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree