EB-2 NIW
National importance in an NIW petition: which evidence supports it?
National importance is half of the first prong of Matter of Dhanasar. USCIS judges it by the potential prospective impact of the specific endeavor: implications for a field, a region or the public, jobs at a level significant for the region, effects in an economically depressed area. The importance of an occupation, an industry or one employer does not prove it. The evidence is a detailed description of the endeavor and a document for each effect it claims.

What does national importance mean under Matter of Dhanasar?
The potential prospective impact of the specific endeavor. It can come from national or global implications within a field or from substantial positive economic effects, such as significant potential to employ U.S. workers. Geography alone does not decide it.
Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), decided by the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on December 27, 2016, puts two requirements into the first prong: the proposed endeavor "has both substantial merit and national importance." The prong "focuses on the specific endeavor that the foreign national proposes to undertake." On the second requirement the AAO wrote: "In determining whether the proposed endeavor has national importance, we consider its potential prospective impact."
The AAO named two routes. An undertaking may have "national or even global implications within a particular field, such as those resulting from certain improved manufacturing processes or medical advances." The other route is economic: an endeavor that "has significant potential to employ U.S. workers or has other substantial positive economic effects, particularly in an economically depressed area."
Geography does not settle the question. The AAO wrote that "we do not evaluate prospective impact solely in geographic terms" and that "Even ventures and undertakings that have as their focus one geographic area of the United States may properly be considered to have national importance." The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, current as of October 27, 2026, gives officers the same instruction: they "should focus on the nature of the proposed endeavor, rather than only the geographic breadth of the endeavor."
The burden is the petitioner's. Officers decide whether the record shows substantial merit and national importance "by a preponderance of the evidence." The Policy Manual ends its examples with a sentence that sums up the test: an endeavor may reach national importance if it "has the significant potential to broadly enhance societal welfare," to add to culture or the arts, or "to contribute to the advancement of a valuable technology or field of study."
How does national importance differ from substantial merit?
Merit asks whether the work is valuable in its area. National importance asks how far its effects would reach. In Dhanasar the petitioner's teaching had merit and still failed the prong, while his research met both requirements.
Merit covers a wide range of areas. The Policy Manual names the areas where it may lie, "including, but not limited to, business, entrepreneurship, science, technology, culture, health, or education." Economic impact is optional at this step: Dhanasar holds that evidence of a potential economic impact "may be favorable but is not required," and that "endeavors related to research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge may qualify."
The petitioner in Dhanasar proposed two activities, research on propulsion systems and teaching. The AAO found that STEM teaching "has substantial merit in relation to U.S. educational interests," but the record did not establish that he "would be engaged in activities that would impact the field of STEM education more broadly." The research passed. One person with one set of degrees met the prong for the first activity and missed it for the second.
The Policy Manual turns that result into a rule for STEM cases. Proposed classroom teaching in STEM may have substantial merit, yet such activities, "by themselves, generally are not indicative of an impact in the field of STEM education more broadly, and therefore generally would not establish their national importance." A petition that proves the value of the work and stops there has answered half of the prong.
Why does the description of the endeavor decide the first prong?
Because officers assess what the person will do, not the job title. A list of the duties of an occupation gives them nothing to measure. Projects, goals and expected direct impacts give them the object of the analysis.
The Policy Manual says that the term "endeavor" is "more specific than the general occupation." Its example is engineering: the explanation "should describe the specific projects and goals, and the area of engineering in which the person will work, rather than simply listing the duties and responsibilities of an engineer." The petitioner should also "clearly lay out the potential direct impacts of the endeavor and whether the endeavor will be furthered through the course of the person's duties at a particular employer or some other way."
On national importance the instruction is direct: "the officer's analysis focuses on what the person will be doing rather than the specific job title or occupational classification." The officer looks for "substance that explains and substantiates how working in the proposed endeavor meets the national importance standard."
On March 28, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an electromechanical engineer who works on cold plasma applications (In Re: 30044608). It agreed with the Director of the Nebraska Service Center that "his specific proposed endeavor is unduly vague." The author of two letters in the record called the petitioner "a world expert" in the technology, yet "he does not describe how the Petitioner will effectuate his proposed endeavor or what the endeavor's scale will be."
A description that an officer can test answers five questions.
- Which projects will you carry out in the coming years, and what is the goal of each?
- In which area of the field does the work sit?
- Where will the work be done: at a named employer, in your own company or in a research group?
- Which direct effects do you expect, and for whom?
- Who outside your employer or company would use the results?
Which arguments does USCIS not accept as proof of national importance?
The importance of a profession or an industry, a national shortage of workers, general statements about entrepreneurs and jobs, and benefits to one employer. The Policy Manual names each of them as insufficient when it stands alone.
The Policy Manual lists the arguments that fail and gives an example for each. A proposed endeavor to engage in classroom teaching, "without broader implications for a field or region," generally does not have national importance, and citing the general importance of the profession "would not alone be sufficient." The next sentence deals with labor shortages: "Proposing to work in an occupation with a national shortage or serve in a consulting capacity for others seeking to work in an occupation with a national shortage alone, is also insufficient."
Entrepreneurs get the same answer. The manual says that "assertions regarding the general importance of business owners or entrepreneurs for job creation or other economic benefits would not alone be sufficient." Its subsection on entrepreneurs takes a person seeking to start a car dealership: statements and evidence "regarding the importance of the relevant industry" do not satisfy "the national importance prong."
The size of the employer does not help: "Benefits to a specific employer alone, even an employer with a national footprint, are not sufficiently relevant to the question of whether a person's endeavor has national importance." The manual's example is "a software engineer adapting their employer's code for various clients." Such an engineer will have difficulty with this prong "absent additional broader impacts supported by specific evidence."
The AAO reads opinion letters the same way. On February 12, 2024 it dismissed the appeal of a chief executive officer whose endeavor was to lead a Florida designer and manufacturer of door and trim products and custom cabinetry (In Re: 28786067). The expert opinion in the record cited 2021 reports on residential construction, and the AAO found it "of little probative value": "Rather, his opinion is general in nature, concluding that, because the Petitioner's proposed endeavor is to work for a small business in a high demand industry, it has national importance."
Which evidence shows implications beyond one employer?
Evidence that people outside the company would use the result: interest in adopting or licensing a technology, a new manufacturing or operational process, an effect on what other companies develop, or public benefits such as health outcomes.
The Policy Manual frames the question in one sentence: the issue is whether "the person's own individual endeavor stands to have broader implications, such as for a field, a region, or the public at large." Two examples follow.
The first is a person developing a drug for a pharmaceutical company. That person may establish national importance through "the prospective public health benefits of the drug, instead of solely projecting the profits that will accrue to the employer." For a petition this means documents on the condition the drug treats, the number of patients and the trial results so far, placed ahead of revenue forecasts.
The second is a technology developed for use or sale by one company. Benefits "for the company or its clients alone" may not establish national importance. To prove broader public or commercial implications, the petitioner can submit evidence of "widespread interest in adoption or licensing of the technology, a novel and important manufacturing or operational process, or how the technology stands to impact the development of similar technology by other companies."
Each of the three items in that sentence has its own documents.
- Interest in adoption or licensing: letters of intent, licensing inquiries, pilot agreements and purchase orders from organizations other than the employer.
- A novel process: patents and patent applications, technical reports and comparisons with the methods the industry uses now.
- Effect on other companies' development: citations of the work, references in standards and trade publications, and later products that build on it.
Does the record agree with itself?
In the cold plasma case cited above, the letter's author called keeping the intellectual property proprietary or as trade secrets "an equally valid option" for the company. The AAO wrote: "His letter also suggests that much of the Petitioner's work might not extend beyond his current employer based on potential intellectual property issues." The AAO read the option of keeping the technology inside one company against the claim of a broader impact.
How do you document jobs and other economic effects?
With a forecast whose figures have sources and with official data on the region. USCIS measures job creation against the population and economic circumstances of the area, and general statements about benefits to the economy do not count.
Dhanasar names the economic route in one sentence: an endeavor that "has significant potential to employ U.S. workers or has other substantial positive economic effects, particularly in an economically depressed area." The Policy Manual adds the scale. The potential to employ U.S. workers is assessed "at a level that is significant with respect to the population and economic circumstances of the relevant region." By that measure the same number of jobs weighs more in a small county than in a large metropolitan area.
For start-ups the manual describes the combination that works. Evidence of revenue growth and of jobs created in the United States "may also support that the proposed endeavor, the petitioner's start-up entity, or both, have national importance when coupled with, for example, evidence that the current or proposed start-up entity is located in an economically depressed area that has benefited or will benefit from jobs created by the start-up entity or that the potential job creation will otherwise be at a significant level with respect to the population and economic circumstances of the relevant area."
The limit is stated just as plainly: "broad assertions regarding general benefits to the economy and potential to create jobs will not establish an entrepreneur's qualification for a national interest waiver." USCIS "would also welcome probative evidence to support how the person has anticipated relevant metrics such as market size and share, job creation, and revenue growth."
AAO decisions show what happens to forecasts without support. On December 12, 2024 (In Re: 34632904) the AAO reviewed a plan for a financial consulting business that projected 19 employees and revenue of $1.5 million in year five. It wrote: "Nonetheless, the plan does not explain how these forecasts were calculated, or adequately clarify how these projections will be realized, nor does the record contain evidence to support the business plan's financial projections." On July 25, 2023 (In Re: 27360942) it found "insufficient documentation to support the Petitioner's projections" of $4,000,000 in total revenue.
An economic argument that an officer can check has four parts.
- The forecast of jobs and revenue by year, with the calculation behind each figure.
- The source of every market figure: the name of the report or database, the year and the link.
- Official statistics on the area where the jobs will be: population, unemployment and income.
- Documents for what already exists: payroll records, contracts, leases and tax filings.
Where do the figures go in the petition?
Into the business plan and its appendices. How a plan carries these figures and what it cannot replace is covered in the guide The second Dhanasar prong: how do you show you are well positioned?.
What changes for STEM endeavors and critical and emerging technologies?
The test stays the same. The Policy Manual recognizes that many endeavors advancing STEM technologies and research have broad enough implications, and the petition still has to tie the field to U.S. competitiveness or national security with authoritative sources.
The manual says the analysis "is the same regardless of endeavor." Of research it says that many proposed endeavors that aim to advance STEM technologies and research, "whether in academic or industry settings," have "sufficiently broad potential implications" for national importance.
A footnote defines the term: "Critical and emerging technologies are those that are critical to U.S. national security, including military defense and the economy." Examples "may include, but are not limited to, certain critical areas of artificial intelligence or quantum information science," and USCIS reviews each endeavor case by case. To identify such a field, officers consider "governmental, academic, and other authoritative" sources and "all other evidence submitted by the petitioner."
A STEM area can matter for competitiveness or security in other circumstances as well, for example when the record proves that "an endeavor will help the United States to remain ahead of strategic competitors or current and potential adversaries." The petition therefore cites the government documents that name the technology: national strategies, agency research programs and funding announcements.
Dhanasar itself is the model. The AAO relied on "probative expert letters from individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry that describe the importance of hypersonic propulsion research as it relates to U.S. strategic interests" and on "media articles and other evidence documenting the interest of the House Committee on Armed Services." The letters and the articles also "discuss efforts and advances that other countries are currently making in the area of hypersonic propulsion systems."
What can a letter from a government agency add?
It is not required. A letter from an interested agency or a federally funded research center supports the first prong when it shows the agency's expertise in the endeavor and explains why the technology matters to the United States.
The Policy Manual has a subsection on this evidence: "While not required, letters from interested government agencies or quasi-governmental entities in the United States (for example federally-funded research and development centers) can be helpful evidence and, depending on the contents of the letters, can be relevant to all three prongs."
For the first prong such a letter is favorable if it establishes "that the agency or entity has expertise in the proposed endeavor and that the proposed STEM endeavor promises to advance a critical and emerging technology or is otherwise important for purposes of maintaining the United States' technological prominence." The sentence holds two conditions: the author's expertise in this endeavor and a statement about this endeavor. A letter about the field in general meets the second condition no better than a general expert opinion does.
The manual does not require such a letter. Grant records do part of the same work. In Dhanasar the AAO, weighing the second prong, noted that the petitioner "played a significant role in projects funded by grants" from NASA and the Air Force Research Laboratories, and wrote that the significance of his research was "corroborated by evidence of peer and government interest in his research, as well as by consistent government funding of the petitioner's research projects."
What can an independent expert letter prove about national importance?
That a specialist outside the petitioner's circle reads the endeavor the way the petition does and can explain, with sources, what it would change in the field. An opinion about the industry in general carries little weight.
In Dhanasar the letters that counted came from "individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry." The Policy Manual adds a practical note in a footnote: "Petitioners may submit evidence related to the credentials of experts who support a petition for officers to consider when assigning weight to the letter." The author's CV belongs in the record next to the letter.
The letter has to stay on the endeavor. In the 2024 decisions cited above the AAO set aside an opinion that was "general in nature" and letters that did not describe how the petitioner would carry out the endeavor or "what the endeavor's scale will be." In the part on national importance the author can state three things.
- The author restates the endeavor as the petition describes it, with the same projects, goals and place of work.
- The author explains what the endeavor would add to the methods the field uses now, with references.
- The author names who outside the petitioner's employer would use the results, as the record names them.
Where is this covered in more detail?
What a letter says on each prong is covered in the guide NIW expert letters: what should they say for each Dhanasar prong?. How USCIS weighs letters from people who have not worked with the petitioner is covered in Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?.
How does IAE help with the first prong?
IAE issues an expert opinion letter with the analysis set out under the three Dhanasar prongs, prepares or reviews a business plan in which every market figure has a source, and audits an NIW profile before filing.
An IAE expert opinion letter is written by an expert of the IAE registry under the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002). For EB-2 NIW it runs up to 15 pages, with the analysis set out under the three Dhanasar prongs. The expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked on the IAE status check page. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, and one round of factual edits is included.
An IAE business plan for a petition is drafted by the IAE Secretariat from your materials and open sources, and a registry expert in economics and management checks it, corrects it and signs it. Every market figure carries its source with the name, year and link, and the plan contains no figures without a source and no data you have not confirmed.
If you are not sure whether your description of the endeavor reaches national importance, the IAE EB-2 NIW profile audit answers that in writing before anything is ordered. A registry expert checks EB-2 eligibility and the three Dhanasar prongs, gives a conclusion on each prong and lists the missing evidence. The report comes within 5 business days.
Is this legal advice?
No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice; the case strategy belongs to a licensed immigration attorney. USCIS weighs the plan and each letter with the rest of the record and decides the petition, and neither IAE nor the expert takes part in that decision.
Sources
- Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), Interim Decision 3882
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability (current as of October 27, 2026)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 28786067, February 12, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 30044608, March 28, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 34632904, December 12, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 27360942, July 25, 2023
Read also
All guides
Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each
Matter of Dhanasar, an AAO precedent of December 27, 2016, sets the test USCIS applies to an EB-2 national interest waiver (NIW). The petitioner
NIW expert letters: what should they say for each Dhanasar prong?
USCIS decides an EB-2 national interest waiver under the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar, and the AAO weighs an expert letter under the prong it
The second Dhanasar prong: how do you show you are well positioned?
The second prong of Matter of Dhanasar asks whether the petitioner is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. The AAO weighs educationGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

