EB-2 NIW

The second Dhanasar prong: how do you show you are well positioned?

The second prong of Matter of Dhanasar asks whether the petitioner is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. The AAO weighs education and record of success, a model or plan, progress already made and the interest of customers, users or investors. A business plan answers one of these factors. In three AAO appeals of 2023 and 2024 the record held a plan with forecasts, and the AAO still found the prong unmet.

A woman of about 40 with dark hair tied back checks a signed lease against a printed cash flow table at the counter of an unopened cafe in morning sun

What does the second prong ask you to prove?

That you, the person, are well positioned to advance the specific endeavor described under the first prong. The AAO weighs four factors and does not require proof that the endeavor will more likely than not succeed.

A founder who has described the company under the first prong, or a researcher who has described a research program, reaches the next question: why this person? Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), decided by the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on December 27, 2016, sets the second prong on page 889: the petitioner proves "that the foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor." On page 890 the AAO lists what it considers, "including, but not limited to": "the individual's education, skills, knowledge and record of success in related or similar efforts; a model or plan for future activities; any progress towards achieving the proposed endeavor; and the interest of potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities or individuals."

The AAO did not ask for a forecast of success. It recognized that forecasting "may present challenges to petitioners and USCIS officers" and that many innovations and entrepreneurial endeavors "may ultimately fail, in whole or in part," even with "an intelligent plan and competent execution." Petitioners do not have to show that their endeavors are "more likely than not to ultimately succeed." The burden stays with them all the same: "But notwithstanding this inherent uncertainty, in order to merit a national interest waiver, petitioners must establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that they are well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor."

The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 restates the four factors, and two of them name the person more directly than Dhanasar does. The plan factor reads: "Evidence of a detailed proposal or plan that the person developed, or played a significant role in developing, for future activities related to the proposed endeavor." The interest factor reads: "The interest or support garnered by the person from potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities or persons." Interest in the market as a whole is not interest garnered by the person. A plan prepared with a consultant fits the wording when the activities, their order and the figures are the petitioner's own decisions and the plan says so.

The chapter then sets the proof for the prong: "The petitioner should submit evidence to document the person's past achievements, explain how those achievements relate to the proposed endeavor or provide evidence of progress towards achieving the endeavor, and corroborate projections related to the proposed endeavor." In the next paragraph it adds: "However, unsubstantiated claims would not meet the petitioner's burden of proof." The regulation says where this evidence goes. Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(ii), the petitioner submits Form ETA-750B "as well as evidence to support the claim that such exemption would be in the national interest." How the three prongs fit together is covered in the guide Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each.

Which documents answer each of the four factors?

Degrees, employer letters and dated results answer the record factor, and the plan answers the second. Registrations, contracts and pilots dated before filing answer progress; investment, letters of intent and customer correspondence answer interest.

Most NIW files are assembled by document type: diplomas in one tab, letters in another, the business plan at the end. The second prong is read by factor. The Policy Manual gives a list of evidence for the prong and warns: "This list is not meant to be a checklist or to indicate that any one type of evidence is either required or sufficient to establish eligibility." After the list it says that in each case officers "must consider the totality of circumstances." When the exhibits are sorted under the four Dhanasar factors before filing, an empty factor is visible while there is still time to fill it.

Education, skills, knowledge and record of success

Diplomas, licenses and employer letters with dates and duties prove education and skills. A record of success is a result with a date and a document: a product released, a company's revenue in the years the petitioner ran it, a method adopted by others, a patent licensed. For entrepreneurs the Policy Manual gives two examples: "successfully leading prior start-up entities or having a combination of relevant degrees and experience to equip the petitioner to advance the proposed endeavor." For a patent it asks the petitioner to document "how the petitioner contributed to the development of the intellectual property and how it has or may be used internally or externally."

The record is read against the endeavor as proposed. In an appeal decided on September 13, 2023, the AAO found that the petitioner "has sufficient education, skills, and knowledge of the medical supply market in Brazil," and wrote that the record "does not establish that he has a record of success in the U.S. medical devices industry, a significant part of his proposed endeavor."

A model or plan for future activities

For a founder the plan is usually a business plan. The Policy Manual's list of evidence names "A plan describing how the person intends to continue the proposed work in the United States." After the list the chapter adds: "Business plans or other similar descriptions of the person's plans, while useful in explaining the person's objectives, should be supported by other independent evidence." The words "other similar descriptions" cover a researcher's research program or a consultant's description of planned engagements.

A petitioner who will work for someone else has a different kind of plan. Footnote 78 of the chapter says USCIS considers "a job offer or communications with prospective employers, while not required, relevant" to the capacity in which the person will carry out the endeavor and to the feasibility of the plan.

Progress towards achieving the endeavor

Progress is what has already happened, with a date before the petition was filed. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), a petitioner "must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication." A company registered in the state of operation, a signed lease, a license application, a first contract, a pilot with a named customer, a prototype test report, a grant award and a first hire each count with their dates. A contract signed after filing does not prove progress as of filing, and one AAO decision below turned partly on that.

Interest of customers, users, investors and others

Interest is proved by people and organizations outside the petitioner's company. The Policy Manual lists "Correspondence from prospective or potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities" and "Evidence that the person has received investment from U.S. investors, such as venture capital firms, angel investors, or start-up accelerators, and that the amounts are appropriate to the relevant endeavor." Letters of intent, purchase orders, pilot agreements, grant awards and user counts exported from the product's own analytics with the export date belong here. Each document names the organization, the person who signed it and the date.

Does a researcher prove the second prong the same way as a founder?

The four factors are the same. A researcher usually proves them with publications, grants and a role in funded projects; a founder with the company, its ownership, customers and investors, which the Policy Manual treats in a separate subsection.

Dhanasar himself was a researcher, and the decision does not mention a business plan. The AAO concluded: "The petitioner's education, experience, and expertise in his field, the significance of his role in research projects, as well as the sustained interest of and funding from government entities such as NASA and AFRL, position him well to continue to advance his proposed endeavor of hypersonic technology research." The sentence names his role in the projects and funding that continued over time.

For a researcher, the plan is the research program: the questions, the methods, the laboratory or employer where the work continues and the funding. Publications and citations belong to the record of success, and the Policy Manual lists citation history among the evidence for this prong. Files without them are covered in the article Do you need publications or citations for an NIW?

A founder works through a company, and the Policy Manual has a separate subsection, "Specific Evidentiary Considerations for Entrepreneurs." It describes an entity in which the petitioner "typically possesses (or will possess) an ownership interest" and "maintains (or will maintain) an active and central role." Officers may consider that "there is no single way in which an entrepreneurial venture entity must be structured." Footnote 101 explains that this subsection, because it discusses self-petitions by entrepreneurs, does not distinguish between petitioner and person "as they are one and the same."

Ownership and role are proved by the company's own documents: the certificate of formation, the operating agreement or stock ledger, and the resolution or minutes that appoint the petitioner. The Policy Manual names the petitioner's "appointment as an officer (or similar position of authority)" as evidence of an active and central role in the operations of the entity.

Which evidence does the Policy Manual name for entrepreneurs?

Ownership and role, degrees and experience, outside investment or a binding commitment to invest, incubator or accelerator admission, awards or grants, intellectual property, published material, growth in revenue and jobs, and letters from third parties.

At an early stage a founder often has more paper than results: an LLC, a pitch deck, several calls with customers. The subsection for entrepreneurs groups its evidence under nine headings, and several items describe validation by someone outside the company.

  • Investment counts in three forms: "An investment, binding commitment to invest, or other evidence" of an outside investor's future intent to invest. Such investment, "consistent with industry standards, may provide independent validation."
  • The amount is weighed against the endeavor: "Because different endeavors have different capital needs, USCIS also considers the amount of capital that would be appropriate to advance the endeavor in determining whether the petitioner has secured sufficient investments."
  • Officers "may consider evidence of an entrepreneur's admission into an incubator or accelerator as an endorsement of the petitioner's proposed plan or past track record," and petitioners may submit evidence of the past success of the incubator.
  • Awards and grants are treated like outside investment: this evidence "may provide independent validation."
  • Intellectual property counts when documents explain why it is significant to the field or endeavor and how the petitioner contributed to its development.
  • Published material about the petitioner, the company or both has its own heading in the subsection.
  • Growth in revenue and in jobs created in the United States counts together with "the petitioner's contribution to such growth."
  • Letters may come from "relevant government entities, outside investors, or established business associations" with knowledge of the petitioner's research, products or services, or of the petitioner's knowledge, skills or experience.

How does the subsection weigh projections?

Its last paragraph begins with two sentences on proof: "Evidence establishing the petitioner's past entrepreneurial achievements and that corroborates projections of future work in the national interest are favorable factors. Claims lacking corroborating evidence are not sufficient to meet the petitioner's burden of proof." The paragraph before it repeats the rule of Dhanasar: petitioners are "not required to establish that the proposed endeavor is more likely than not to ultimately succeed." A projection counts in the founder's favor when documents in the record back it, and a projection without them does not meet the burden of proof.

What can a business plan show for the second prong?

It is the model or plan Dhanasar names: what the petitioner will do, in what order, with what money and which people. With exhibits attached, it also connects past results, progress and outside interest to the future work.

An entrepreneur who orders a business plan for an NIW often expects it to carry the whole second prong. It answers one factor of four directly. The Policy Manual says: "Business plans or other similar descriptions of the person's plans, while useful in explaining the person's objectives, should be supported by other independent evidence." Each statement in the plan points to that evidence.

The Policy Manual's version of the factor also asks whose plan it is: one "that the person developed, or played a significant role in developing." In an appeal decided on July 25, 2023, the petitioner proposed a veterinary sonography business. The plan identified a target audience and ways to reach it on social media. The AAO found that a social media marketing plan was not "a model for the actual activities that the Petitioner has developed or played a significant role in developing to advance their proposed endeavor." It added: "The business plan instead only placed heavy emphasis on what the Petitioner had done in their past and their qualifications to continue the same activities in the future."

A plan written for the second prong describes the future work and the petitioner's part in it. It covers the points below, each with an exhibit number where a document exists.

  • The plan lists the activities of the endeavor in order, with target dates for the first contracts, the product release, each hire and any second location.
  • The plan states the petitioner's own role: the title, the decisions the petitioner makes, the work the petitioner does personally and the work assigned to staff or contractors.
  • The plan names the steps already taken by the filing date, such as the registration, the lease, a license application, a first customer or a pilot, and cites the exhibit for each.
  • The plan names the customers, users, investors or agencies that have expressed interest, and the document from each of them.
  • The plan itemizes start-up costs, names the source of each amount of funding and compares the total with what the endeavor needs.
  • The plan lists the licenses and permits the activity requires in the state where it will run and the date by which each will be obtained.
  • The financial model lists each assumption with its source.

What can a business plan not replace?

Evidence of what has already happened. In the AAO appeals below, each record held a plan with forecasts, and the prong failed on unexplained figures, missing steps, an absent license and no documented interest from clients or agencies.

A plan is a document about the future, and the second prong is decided on the record as of filing. In three non-precedent AAO decisions published on uscis.gov, the record held a business plan with forecasts, and the AAO found the second prong unmet.

A veterinary sonography business, decided on July 25, 2023

This is the case cited above, in which the plan described the past instead of the future work (In Re: 27360942). The endeavor anticipated, in the AAO's words, "a highly aggressive growth strategy which will eventually employ 250 people." At first the operations were to be housed "in a single-family residence." The AAO wrote that "it is unclear in the record how any veterinary sonography services could legally be provided from the single-family home." Under the first prong it had already found "insufficient documentation to support the Petitioner's projections" of $4,000,000 in total revenue. It concluded that the petitioner had not shown with "material, relevant, and probative evidence" a position to advance the endeavor.

A medical device consultancy, decided on September 13, 2023

The petitioner planned a company providing sales and consulting services between U.S. and Brazilian medical device businesses (In Re: 28425355). The AAO wrote: "The record also contains a business plan, complete with financial and personnel forecasts." The plan put his investment at $20,000 and projected first-year payroll, operating and marketing costs of $385,708, $97,940 and $5,800 against estimated revenue of $552,905. In the paragraph before, the AAO had written that the record did not contain "an adequate business plan for future activities" or sufficient evidence of progress.

The reasons were specific. "The Petitioner did not, however, elaborate on these projections or adequately explain how they were calculated." Because the plan "does not itemize or account for initial start-up costs which are typically incurred by a new business," it was not apparent that $20,000 "would be sufficient to cover those costs and enable the company to commence revenue-generating activity." On progress, "the Petitioner offers no details as to the specific steps he had taken to advance his endeavor as of the date this petition was filed." A consultancy agreement in the record was executed in September 2022, "nearly two years after the instant petition was filed" and the AAO did not count it, citing 8 C.F.R. 103.2(b).

An architecture firm, decided on May 6, 2024

The petitioner, an architect, proposed her own firm offering architectural work and interior design in Florida (In Re: 27693833). Her response to the request for evidence included "a detailed business plan" with "a personnel plan and financial projections for a five-year period": 15 full-time employees in two Florida offices, net profit of $202,593 and total revenue of $1.8 million within five years.

The AAO noted that the plan "does not describe the Petitioner's plans for obtaining a license to practice her profession in Florida," that the record held no evidence of steps to register the business, and that the plan "does not discuss the Petitioner's planned involvement with urban planning projects," which were part of the endeavor she described. The record also lacked evidence of interest from public administration or agencies involved in urban planning. The AAO found the second prong unmet and wrote that further discussion of the third prong "would serve no meaningful purpose."

Where should the figures in the plan come from?

From documents the officer can check: contracts and quotes for prices and costs, letters of intent for volumes, government statistics for markets and wages, bank and investment records for funding. Each assumption names its source.

Founders often build the financial model last and fill it with round targets. The AAO decisions read it for its basis. The Policy Manual asks the petitioner to "corroborate projections related to the proposed endeavor" and the September 2023 decision faulted a petitioner who did not "adequately explain how they were calculated."

The same objection appears under the first prong. On December 12, 2024 (In Re: 34632904), the AAO reviewed a plan for a financial consulting business that projected 19 employees in year five, payroll of $311,000 in year one and $1.1 million in year five, and revenue of $455,000 in year one and $1.5 million in year five. It wrote: "Nonetheless, the plan does not explain how these forecasts were calculated, or adequately clarify how these projections will be realized, nor does the record contain evidence to support the business plan's financial projections." It added that "the lack of supporting details detracts from probative value" of the plan.

Before filing, each figure in the model can be checked against its source in seven steps.

  • Revenue is price times volume: the price comes from a current price list, quotes or signed contracts, and the volume from letters of intent, pilots or the petitioner's sales record in a previous company.
  • Start-up costs are itemized line by line, including registration, licenses, deposits, equipment, insurance and first marketing, because the September 2023 plan was faulted for leaving them out.
  • Funding names the source of each amount, with bank statements, an investment agreement or a binding commitment to invest, and the total is compared with the capital the endeavor needs.
  • Payroll lists each position with a wage taken from a named wage survey and its year, and each hire is tied to a revenue milestone.
  • Market size and growth come from government statistics or published studies cited with title, publisher, year and link.
  • Premises and licenses match the activity and the state, which were the gaps in the July 2023 and May 2024 decisions.
  • The same figures appear in the petition letter, the plan and any expert letter.

How does an NIW plan differ from an E-2, L-1A or EB-5 plan?

E-2, L-1A new office and EB-5 plans answer tests written into regulations: no marginal enterprise, a managerial or executive position within a year, ten jobs within two years. For NIW the plan is evidence for the second prong.

Many founders already have a plan written for another visa, and each of those plans answers its own rule. Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15), "an enterprise may not be marginal." A marginal enterprise lacks "the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living for the treaty investor and his or her family" (see The E-2 marginal enterprise test). Under 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(v)(C), an L-1A new office petition proves that the U.S. operation, "within one year of the approval of the petition, will support an executive or managerial position" (see L-1A new office business plan). Under 8 CFR 204.6(j)(4)(i)(B), an EB-5 file holds a copy of "a comprehensive business plan" showing the need for "not fewer than ten (10) qualifying employees" within the next two years, and Matter of Ho, 22 I&N Dec. 206 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998) says the plan "should contain sales, cost, and income projections and detail the bases therefor" and adds: "Most importantly, the business plan must be credible" (see EB-5 business plan under Matter of Ho). Paragraph (k) of 8 CFR 204.5 does not mention a business plan, and the entrepreneur subsection of the Policy Manual names revenue growth and job creation as relevant metrics without a minimum number. An NIW plan is read for the person: the petitioner's role, the steps taken by filing and the outside interest already secured. A plan reused from an E-2 or L-1A file needs that part written anew for the second prong.

How can an expert letter address the second prong?

As a third-party review of the plan and the record: an expert in the field compares the petitioner's past results with the plan's tasks, and the plan's costs, timeline and hiring with the field. The officer decides the prong.

A founder's work rarely goes through journal peer review, and the Policy Manual accepts other reviewers. It says entrepreneurs "may operate in a variety of high-tech or cutting-edge industries that have their own industry or technology experts that provide various forms of peer review." It adds that "the merits of the entrepreneur's business, business plan, product, or technology may undergo various forms of review by third parties, such as prospective investors, retailers, or other industry experts." Letters and statements from "relevant third-party reviewers" may have probative value for the second prong. Footnote 103 lets petitioners submit evidence of the experts' credentials "for officers to consider when assigning weight to the letter."

For letters in general the chapter sets a standard: "Letters may be persuasive when they are from experts in the person's field who have first-hand knowledge of the person's achievements, describe those achievements, provide specific examples of how the person is well positioned to advance the person's endeavor, and are supported by other independent evidence."

For the second prong the expert reads the plan with its exhibits and writes about facts the expert can compare with the field. The letter cites the page of the plan and the exhibit for each statement.

  • The expert names the petitioner's past results that bear on the tasks in the plan, with dates and exhibit numbers.
  • The expert compares the plan's start-up costs, timeline and hiring with businesses or projects of the same type and names the source of the comparison.
  • The expert states what the documents record about progress and outside interest, such as a pilot, a contract or an investment, with dates.
  • The expert states the author's own position and how the author came to know the petitioner's work.

What does the letter leave out?

A finding that the petitioner is well positioned, because the officer makes it. The letter also does not repeat the plan's revenue figures as the expert's own forecast. How to build a letter under all three prongs is covered in the guide NIW expert letters: what should they say for each Dhanasar prong?, and how officers weigh letters in general in How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?

How does IAE help with the second prong?

IAE prepares a business plan signed by a registry expert in economics and management, reviews an existing plan, issues an expert opinion letter under the IAE Impartiality Policy and audits an NIW profile against the three Dhanasar prongs.

An IAE business plan for a petition is drafted by the IAE Secretariat from your materials and open sources, and a registry expert in economics and management checks it against 15 points, corrects it and signs it. The plan runs 25-35 pages with a five-year financial model in Excel. Every market figure carries its source with the name, year and link, and the plan contains no figures without a source and no data you have not confirmed. For an NIW petition the plan covers the requirement in three places: the summary, the petitioner's role and the appendices with documents. The section for the category states the entrepreneur's role and the significance of the enterprise as facts, with no legal conclusions. The plan takes 7 business days, or 4 in rush mode, counted from payment and a complete set of documents.

If you already have a plan, a registry expert reviews it against the same checklist in 3 business days. You receive a table of the 15 points marked met, partly met or not met with the page of the plan, the three main risks, and a conclusion to file, revise or redo, with edits listed by priority.

An IAE expert opinion letter is written by an expert of the IAE registry under the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002). For EB-2 NIW it runs up to 15 pages, with the analysis set out under the three Dhanasar prongs. The expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked on the IAE status check page. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, and one round of factual edits is included.

If you are not sure which factor of the second prong your record leaves empty, the IAE EB-2 NIW profile audit answers that in writing before anything is ordered. A registry expert checks EB-2 eligibility and the three Dhanasar prongs, gives a conclusion on each prong and lists the missing evidence. The report comes within 5 business days.

Is this legal advice?

No. IAE provides an independent expert opinion, is not a law firm and gives no legal advice; the case strategy belongs to a licensed immigration attorney. USCIS weighs the plan and each letter with the rest of the record and decides the petition, and neither IAE nor the expert takes part in that decision.

Sources

All guides

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree